On 3 October 2009, the House of Representatives issued Law No. 32 of 2009 on Environment Protection and Management. Since then, the public has been divided into two categories: those in favor, such as environmental advocates, and those not in favor, such as resource extraction companies. The division is caused by the comparatively ‘stringent’ provisions of the Law, which place more restrictions and obligations on natural resource utilization than ever before.
The State Ministry of Environment has been particularly vocal in representing the government’s view that resource exploitation must be controlled, modest, and responsible to Indonesia’s long-term wellbeing. Those interests are reflected in the Law’s provisions around tightened licensing, advance environment-utilization financial deposits, and a rigorous sanction regime, amongst other things. Despite the pro-environmental fanfare, those same provisions have been contended by large segments of the resource extraction population, who have applied pressure in numerous ways to loosen those regulatory requirements.
Adherence to the Law’s provisions also pose an issue to public institutions, such as the Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources, ‘BP Migas,’ and state-owned Pertamina; these parties have asked for extensions to comply with the Law.
This Indonesian Law Digest will examine key features of the Law, and highlight the issues of implementation arising in the Indonesian context, particularly with respect to the Law’s impact on the private sector.
Purpose
According to the Preamble of Law No. 32 of 2009, the regulation repeals replaces its predecessor - Law No. 23 of 1997 - to provide more legal certainty around environmental utilization, and to better guarantee Indonesian people a healthy living environment. Other purposes, perhaps more tangential to the fundamental purpose, are also listed in Article 3 of the Law.
The Law in a Nutshell
Driven by the mandate of Article 28H (1) of the 1945 Indonesian Constitution, which guarantees to citizens the right to enjoy a good, healthy environment, the new Law is considerably more extensive than its predecessor. It broadly covers how the environment is to be protected and managed in the ideal sense, regulating planning, utilization, control, maintenance, and supervision of the environment, and meanwhile providing sanctions for cases of violation.
Planning
‘Planning’ refers to the requirement that the government collect natural resource-related data and information (see Article 6 (2) of the Law), and use that as the basis for the formulation of an Environment Protection and Management Plan. Known by its Indonesian-language acronym as the ‘RPPLH,’ the plan lays out environmental conditions, draws attention to problems, and details methods to address the problems. It will be used as a guideline underpinning the allowances made for resource exploitation (Article 12 (1)).
Methods to Maintain Environmental Integrity
To effectively ensure that natural resource exploitation is controlled, the three-fold mechanism set out by the Law includes: prevention, ‘overcoming,’ and recovery.
Prevention measures are highly differentiated, involving some 13 methods provided by the Law. The preventive measures include Environmental Impact Assessments, licensing, environmental regulations, audits, and other methods contained in Article 14 of the Law.
Overcoming damages to the environment, once it has taken place, involves pollution control, informing the public, alarming the public if the environmental damage becomes excessive, isolating the damage or pollution, and addressing the cause of the damage; further details can be found in Article 53 of the Law.
Meanwhile, environmental recovery includes remediation, rehabilitation, and restoration of the environment; details are provided in the Elucidation to Article 54 of the Law.
Environmental maintenance methods are illustrated in Article 57 of the Law, and regulatory tools include mandating an area to be a ‘conservation’ or ‘reservation’ area, thereby restricting activities in those areas.
Chapter VII of the Law specifically addresses pollution caused by dangerous, poisonous materials, and makes available sanctions - both administrative and criminal - for those who create associated issues for the environment.
Contended Provisions
Environmental License
As provided under the 1997 Law, prior any activity that could result in significant impacts to the environment (e.g., mining), the party wishing to use a particular area must submit a request to Environmental Impact Assessment Commission to conduct a study, appropriately known as the Environmental Impact Assessment or ‘Amdal,’ which assesses how certain areas will be utilized for certain activities, and tries to ascertain what the extent of environmental damage will be. Technically, an Amdal is the precondition for utilization of an area for environmentally-threatening activities, but that was not practiced consistently and substantial environmental degradation has been taking place as a result.
The drafters of the 2009 Law introduced the Environmental License to respond to that issue. Like the Amdal documents, Environmental Licenses are a pre-condition for the acquisition of business licenses from different Ministries: without it, no further licensed activities are possible.
Environmental Licenses can be issued by the Minister of Environment, governors, or mayors/regents. They can only be issued after receiving and reviewing an Amdal, or what is known as an ‘UKL-UPL’ recommendation, which is issued for activities with less significant risks to the environment. Thus, all business licenses for exploitation of natural resources require that the prospective business first have their activities carefully screened, first through the Amdal procedure, and then through the Environmental License procedure.
In the case that the Environmental License is revoked, the effect of revocation will extend to all licenses obtained as a subsequent result of the Environmental License, including all business licenses. Given that obtaining an Environmental License - and indeed all licenses after that - can be such an involved process, this particular provision has been particularly contested by business-doers.
Environmental Guarantee Funds
After an Environmental License is granted, one of the following obligations is for License-holders to make a deposit in a government-appointed bank. This ‘Guarantee Fund’ is meant to be used for environmental recovery purposes. However, the amount that must be deposited is yet unknown, and will be the subject of subsequent Government Regulation.
Mining companies perceive this imposition to be costly. Moreover, some have claimed that Law No. 4 of 2009 on [Mining] obligates the same financial obligation by way of Reclamation and Mining Operation Closure deposits.
Environmental Quality Standard
Determination of whether or not environmental pollution is taking place is based upon Environmental Quality measurements, which measure water quality, waste-water substance evaluations, air quality, particulate emissions, and so on.
Article 20 (3) of the Law allows waste to be dumped into any Environmental Medium, but only if (1) the waste fulfills the Environmental Quality standard, and (2) there is approval from the relevant governmental authorities. Further details will be provided in subsequent Government and Ministerial Regulations. Thus, implementing regulation is required to elaborate these aspects of the law into reality.
According to the Oil and Natural Gas Increase Supervisory Team, created by the Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources to oversee the government-stimulated effort to increase commodity production over the next few years, many oil and gas companies will have difficulty implementing these aspects of the 2009 Law without substantial expenditure, which might hamper expansion of production.
Sanctions
The 2009 Law covers sanctions for various violations, both administrative and criminal. As provided in Article 76, administrative sanctions include written warnings, coercive actions (e.g., asset confiscation), frozen Environmental License, and revocation of license(s). Criminal sanctions cover many aspects of environmental violations, and range from criminal fines of up to IDR 15 billion, and imprisonment of decision-making executives for up to 15 years.
Interestingly, in Article 88, a person’s right to prove their innocence can be reserved if it is found that the individual has seriously threatened the environment with what is known as ‘B3 Waste’ - poisonous, hazardous, and environmentally-destructive waste. The provision lacks clarity, and will likely be the subject of further implementing regulation, but has the potential to act as a serious deterrent, as much as it has the potential for arbitrary abuse.
Conclusion
The 2009 Law is clearly not lacking of controversy. On the one hand, it appears to be serious about regulating the protection of the environment: it places substantially greater requirements on land utilization that has the potential to threaten the environment, and significantly expands the punitive possibilities in the event of violation of those requirements.
Not just the private sector, but also agencies such as the Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources, and BP Migas have shared in expressing their dismay with the regulatory extent of this Law. In light of the serious environmental degradation caused by looser regulation, and the failure of previous regulation to even take effect (e.g., Amdal pre-requisites), the Law is unlikely to be changed or amended: Last week (2/4), as quoted from Media Indonesia, Deputy Minister of Environment Hermien Rosita told reporters that there will be no amendment to the 2009 Law.
On 3 October 2009, the House of Representatives issued Law No. 32 of 2009 on Environment Protection and Management. Since then, the public has been divided into two categories: those in favor, such as environmental advocates, and those not in favor, such as resource extraction companies. The division is caused by the comparatively ‘stringent’ provisions of the Law, which place more restrictions and obligations on natural resource utilization than ever before.
The State Ministry of Environment has been particularly vocal in representing the government’s view that resource exploitation must be controlled, modest, and responsible to Indonesia’s long-term wellbeing. Those interests are reflected in the Law’s provisions around tightened licensing, advance environment-utilization financial deposits, and a rigorous sanction regime, amongst other things. Despite the pro-environmental fanfare, those same provisions have been contended by large segments of the resource extraction population, who have applied pressure in numerous ways to loosen those regulatory requirements.
Adherence to the Law’s provisions also pose an issue to public institutions, such as the Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources, ‘BP Migas,’ and state-owned Pertamina; these parties have asked for extensions to comply with the Law.
This Indonesian Law Digest will examine key features of the Law, and highlight the issues of implementation arising in the Indonesian context, particularly with respect to the Law’s impact on the private sector.
Purpose
According to the Preamble of Law No. 32 of 2009, the regulation repeals replaces its predecessor - Law No. 23 of 1997 - to provide more legal certainty around environmental utilization, and to better guarantee Indonesian people a healthy living environment. Other purposes, perhaps more tangential to the fundamental purpose, are also listed in Article 3 of the Law.
The Law in a Nutshell
Driven by the mandate of Article 28H (1) of the 1945 Indonesian Constitution, which guarantees to citizens the right to enjoy a good, healthy environment, the new Law is considerably more extensive than its predecessor. It broadly covers how the environment is to be protected and managed in the ideal sense, regulating planning, utilization, control, maintenance, and supervision of the environment, and meanwhile providing sanctions for cases of violation.
Planning
‘Planning’ refers to the requirement that the government collect natural resource-related data and information (see Article 6 (2) of the Law), and use that as the basis for the formulation of an Environment Protection and Management Plan. Known by its Indonesian-language acronym as the ‘RPPLH,’ the plan lays out environmental conditions, draws attention to problems, and details methods to address the problems. It will be used as a guideline underpinning the allowances made for resource exploitation (Article 12 (1)).
Methods to Maintain Environmental Integrity
To effectively ensure that natural resource exploitation is controlled, the three-fold mechanism set out by the Law includes: prevention, ‘overcoming,’ and recovery.
Prevention measures are highly differentiated, involving some 13 methods provided by the Law. The preventive measures include Environmental Impact Assessments, licensing, environmental regulations, audits, and other methods contained in Article 14 of the Law.
Overcoming damages to the environment, once it has taken place, involves pollution control, informing the public, alarming the public if the environmental damage becomes excessive, isolating the damage or pollution, and addressing the cause of the damage; further details can be found in Article 53 of the Law.
Meanwhile, environmental recovery includes remediation, rehabilitation, and restoration of the environment; details are provided in the Elucidation to Article 54 of the Law.
Environmental maintenance methods are illustrated in Article 57 of the Law, and regulatory tools include mandating an area to be a ‘conservation’ or ‘reservation’ area, thereby restricting activities in those areas.
Chapter VII of the Law specifically addresses pollution caused by dangerous, poisonous materials, and makes available sanctions - both administrative and criminal - for those who create associated issues for the environment.
Contended Provisions
Environmental License
As provided under the 1997 Law, prior any activity that could result in significant impacts to the environment (e.g., mining), the party wishing to use a particular area must submit a request to Environmental Impact Assessment Commission to conduct a study, appropriately known as the Environmental Impact Assessment or ‘Amdal,’ which assesses how certain areas will be utilized for certain activities, and tries to ascertain what the extent of environmental damage will be. Technically, an Amdal is the precondition for utilization of an area for environmentally-threatening activities, but that was not practiced consistently and substantial environmental degradation has been taking place as a result.
The drafters of the 2009 Law introduced the Environmental License to respond to that issue. Like the Amdal documents, Environmental Licenses are a pre-condition for the acquisition of business licenses from different Ministries: without it, no further licensed activities are possible.
Environmental Licenses can be issued by the Minister of Environment, governors, or mayors/regents. They can only be issued after receiving and reviewing an Amdal, or what is known as an ‘UKL-UPL’ recommendation, which is issued for activities with less significant risks to the environment. Thus, all business licenses for exploitation of natural resources require that the prospective business first have their activities carefully screened, first through the Amdal procedure, and then through the Environmental License procedure.
In the case that the Environmental License is revoked, the effect of revocation will extend to all licenses obtained as a subsequent result of the Environmental License, including all business licenses. Given that obtaining an Environmental License - and indeed all licenses after that - can be such an involved process, this particular provision has been particularly contested by business-doers.
Environmental Guarantee Funds
After an Environmental License is granted, one of the following obligations is for License-holders to make a deposit in a government-appointed bank. This ‘Guarantee Fund’ is meant to be used for environmental recovery purposes. However, the amount that must be deposited is yet unknown, and will be the subject of subsequent Government Regulation.
Mining companies perceive this imposition to be costly. Moreover, some have claimed that Law No. 4 of 2009 on [Mining] obligates the same financial obligation by way of Reclamation and Mining Operation Closure deposits.
Environmental Quality Standard
Determination of whether or not environmental pollution is taking place is based upon Environmental Quality measurements, which measure water quality, waste-water substance evaluations, air quality, particulate emissions, and so on.
Article 20 (3) of the Law allows waste to be dumped into any Environmental Medium, but only if (1) the waste fulfills the Environmental Quality standard, and (2) there is approval from the relevant governmental authorities. Further details will be provided in subsequent Government and Ministerial Regulations. Thus, implementing regulation is required to elaborate these aspects of the law into reality.
According to the Oil and Natural Gas Increase Supervisory Team, created by the Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources to oversee the government-stimulated effort to increase commodity production over the next few years, many oil and gas companies will have difficulty implementing these aspects of the 2009 Law without substantial expenditure, which might hamper expansion of production.
Sanctions
The 2009 Law covers sanctions for various violations, both administrative and criminal. As provided in Article 76, administrative sanctions include written warnings, coercive actions (e.g., asset confiscation), frozen Environmental License, and revocation of license(s). Criminal sanctions cover many aspects of environmental violations, and range from criminal fines of up to IDR 15 billion, and imprisonment of decision-making executives for up to 15 years.
Interestingly, in Article 88, a person’s right to prove their innocence can be reserved if it is found that the individual has seriously threatened the environment with what is known as ‘B3 Waste’ - poisonous, hazardous, and environmentally-destructive waste. The provision lacks clarity, and will likely be the subject of further implementing regulation, but has the potential to act as a serious deterrent, as much as it has the potential for arbitrary abuse.
Conclusion
The 2009 Law is clearly not lacking of controversy. On the one hand, it appears to be serious about regulating the protection of the environment: it places substantially greater requirements on land utilization that has the potential to threaten the environment, and significantly expands the punitive possibilities in the event of violation of those requirements.
Not just the private sector, but also agencies such as the Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources, and BP Migas have shared in expressing their dismay with the regulatory extent of this Law. In light of the serious environmental degradation caused by looser regulation, and the failure of previous regulation to even take effect (e.g., Amdal pre-requisites), the Law is unlikely to be changed or amended: Last week (2/4), as quoted from Media Indonesia, Deputy Minister of Environment Hermien Rosita told reporters that there will be no amendment to the 2009 Law.