Implementing Regulation for National Spatial Plan

Overview

The National Spatial Plan essentially serves as a regulatory map of Indonesia, governing which areas are available for what purposes. It is now governed by, and formulated under the auspices of: (1) Law No. 26 of 2007 on Spatial Planning (‘Spatial Planning Law’); (2) Government Regulation No. 15 of 2010 on the Implementation of Spatial Planning (‘Implementing Regulation’). The previous regulation on the subject, Law No. 24 of 1992 on Spatial Planning, has been repealed and replaced.

 

Formulating the Spatial Plan is a complex process, involving many different state agencies (e.g., Ministry of Forestry, Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources) and many different ‘levels’ of the state, from the regent/mayor to executives in the central government. It requires a careful inventory of available land, and comprehensive data collection about the characteristics of that land. Meanwhile, the Spatial Plan must consider socio-cultural factors of societies in each area, as well as the economic development in those areas and the nation as a whole. It is a fine balancing act, weighing tensions between various regulatory interests at every point of formulation.

 

In previous times, the Spatial Plan - which is used as the basis for licensing of certain activities such as mining, forestry, construction, and energy resource extraction - has often been understood differently by different state institutions, from Ministries to different levels of government. In a common scenario, one state agency assumes an area is intended for purpose ‘X,’ another assumes the area is intended for purpose ‘Y’; the first agency issues a license on the basis of ‘X,’ the second revokes it on the basis of ‘Y’. That basic scenario (i.e., a disunity of state understanding) is made possible by lacking Spatial Plan regulation. In short, it has caused a host of problems, and created an uncertain regulatory ‘terrain’ for economic development.

 

This Spatial Planning Law merely provides a broad framework for the implementation of spatial planning. Its various topics include: division of authority between state agencies and levels of government; mandating citizen participation; supervision of activities; dispute settlement; general principles governing the process (e.g., public interest, legal certainty, integration); and so on.

 

This inquiry briefly highlights key aspects of the Implementing Regulation, and is guided by two core questions. First, how does the regulation effect state control over the utilization of Indonesian space? Second, how does it implement the revised Spatial Planning Law’s objective, namely, to rectify the issue of coordination between different levels and agencies of the state?

 

Purpose

The Implementing Regulation explicitly states that its purpose is to regulate, implement, control, and supervise spatial planning. In effect, its purpose is to inform how the National Spatial Plan is to be formulated, to give legal basis to that process and the Plan itself, and to ensure that Indonesian ‘space’ is utilized in accordance with the National Spatial Plan.

 

Definition of Spatial Planning

Article 1 (1) of the Spatial Planning Law defines ‘space’ as including land, sea, and air in Indonesia, and where humans live and can perform activities. It follows that ‘spatial planning,’ defined in Article 1 (5) of the Law, is a system for utilization and control of Indonesian spaces.

 

General Breakdown of the National Spatial Plan

The entirety of the National Spatial Plan consists of the: National Spatial Plan, Provincial Spatial Plans, Regency Spatial Plans, and Municipality Spatial Plans. Going from the bottom up, each Plan builds upon the others, and collectively they form the National Spatial Plan. The National Spatial Plan literally serves as a regulatory map of the country.

 

Controlling the Utilization of Space

There are numerous methods for controlling the utilization of spaces across Indonesia. As provided in Chapter VI of the Implementing Regulation, the methods include: zoning, licensing, incentives, disincentives, and sanctions.

 

Zoning is particularly fundamental to the National Spatial Plan. It is the method by which areas of the country are regulated to allow certain activities and restrict others. For resource exploitation industries, this is a critical feature of the Spatial Plan; it elaborates where and what types of extractive activities can take place in every area of Indonesia.

 

Licensing is also particularly critical to utilization of land in legal accordance to the National Spatial Plan. By requiring different space utilization permits, licensing authorities may check that a proposed activity is congruent with the regulatory status of a particular area.

 

Incentives can be given by spatial planning by regulating a zone to be more ‘attractive’ to certain activities. Where the government wishes to promote development, for instance in remote or disaster-stricken areas, it may regulate a zone to have tax incentives for certain types of activities (e.g., infrastructure development, certain business activities), or loosen requirements for various types of space utilization licenses.

 

Disincentives can similarly be in the form of tax increases in a particular zone, or difficult licensing requirements. Other disincentives include space rehabilitation (e.g., reforestation), and other obligations contingent upon space utilization.

 

Sanctions are available to the state in many forms, ranging from written warnings, license revocation or cancellation, closure of the location, building demolition, and administrative fines.

 

Regulating Spatial Planning: Overview

For each respective ‘level’ of Spatial Plan - from municipal to central governmental levels -drafting of the Spatial Plan befalls to the relevant executive government. The draft will be submitted to the House of Representatives at each respective level of government to be discussed, and subsequently issued as a regulation. For example, the provincial governor is charged with supervising the draft Provincial Spatial Plan; the Provincial House of Representatives or ‘DPRD’ will disseminate the draft, and perhaps issue it as a Provincial Government Regulation.

 

Technical Procedure for Drafting Spatial Plans

Each level of government will formulate the draft according to a series five of stages:

1)

Preparation Stage. The method and financial plan will be determined by the relevant authority that is charged with the drafting process.

2)

Data Collection. This includes data on an area’s population, economic development, land utilization, and availability of infrastructure and facilities.

3)

Data Evaluation. At this point, collected data is disseminated by the drafting authority, informing future drafting decisions.

4)

Drafting of the Concept for the Spatial Plan. This literally includes mapping each subsection of every zone into subcomponent regulatory areas.

5)

Incorporation of the Draft Spatial Plan into a Draft Regulation. The Draft will be submitted to the relevant House of Representatives to be scrutinized, debated, and issued as a formal regulation.

 

Citizen Consultation

Article 65 of the Spatial Plan Law provides for extensive citizen participation in spatial planning and implementation - but only in a general manner, requiring further implementing regulation to specify further. The three general modes for citizen inclusion are: 1) formulation of the spatial plan; 2) utilization of spaces, and; 3) exercising control over the utilization of spaces. However, the Implementing Regulation does not actually specify how those roles for citizen inclusion take place in reality. In effect, the current prevailing regulation does not clearly include the public in spatial planning processes.

 

Spatial Plan Coordination: One Standardized National Spatial Plan?

Law No. 24 of 1992 on Spatial Planning evidently could not produce synchronization of spatial planning efforts across all levels of government. On the coordination front, it is still dubious whether the replacements will succeed where the predecessor failed.

 

Article 27 (2) (d) of the Implementing Regulation sets out that the drafting of the Provincial Spatial Plan shall take the Municipal and Regency Spatial Plans into consideration. However, the same paragraph also states that “…the [Provincial Spatial Plan] shall be based upon the National Spatial Plan”. However, Article 26 of the Implementing Regulation states that the formulation of the National Plan will be addressed in “different regulation” - which does not yet exist.

 

Thus, there is a tension in the formulation of Spatial Plans; do they build upon municipal- and regency-level spatial planning, or do they implement a broader National Spatial Plan formulated by the central government? The question thus raised is whether spatial planning, or revisions to existing spatial plans, are to be a top-down or bottom-up process; does it empower the central government, or does it empower locals? Is the issue of coordination ultimately resolved?

 

With 206 Articles, the Implementing Regulation may be extensive, but it leaves those essential questions to be answered by subsequent regulation. Until further regulation is released, the clarification of ambiguities around synchronization befalls to the National Spatial Planning Coordinating Board, which was established by Presidential Decree No. 4 of 2009.

 

Dispute Settlement

When there is a dispute arising from synchronization between different spatial plans, or an issue with the implementation of national and regional spatial plans, the settlement process will be managed by the National Spatial Planning Coordinating Board.

 

Forestry Controversy

One dispute that has created legal uncertainty in recent times was caused by Article 37 of the Spatial Planning Law, which revokes any license that is in violation of spatial planning. Indeed, it is stated in Article 73 of that Law that any government officials that issue licenses in violation of spatial planning will face criminal and administrative sanctions.

 

According to Law No. 41 of 1999 on Forestry, however, the Minister of Forestry is authorized to allocate ‘Protected’ and ‘Production’ Forestry Areas for certain types of activities, including some non-forestry activities. Some of those allocated areas have conflicted with the national spatial planning. What then, for the license-holders whose activities were previously approved by the Ministry of Forestry? Given the uncertainty caused by the Spatial Planning Law, the Minister of Forestry has been reluctant to issue licenses or allocate certain Forest Areas for various activities.

 

Article 31 of the Implementing Regulation addresses the dilemma: utilization of Forest Areas is to be governed by regulations relating to Forestry. In effect, licenses issued by the Ministry of Forestry, and Forest Area allocations made by the Minister of Forestry (e.g., for mining activities) are to remain legally valid. Future spatial planning is mandated to integrate Ministry of Forestry allocations and license areas into it.

 

Conclusion

Spatial Planning is the critical foundation for development in Indonesia, and its capacity to direct economic growth naturally gives reason for the government to hope that the Implementing Regulation (a) clarifies vague aspects of the Spatial Planning Law, and (b) closes loopholes that existed in the previous regulatory framework. In the view of this inquiry, overlapping regulatory areas caused by the failure of different state parties to coordinate effectively is indicative of regulatory failure; whether the problem persists is to be seen.

 

Implementation will be hampered by key provisions that refer to subsequent regulation: two examples discussed in this inquiry were how the final National Spatial Plan is actually formulated, and how citizens will be able to participate in each stage of planning.

 

Coordination remains a dubious issue. At one time, each ‘level’ of spatial planning is told to integrate with, and build upon each subsidiary ‘level’ of Spatial Plan, but in the same paragraphs, ‘lower-level’ Plans (e.g., Municipal Plans) are told to comply with ‘higher-level’ Plans (e.g., Provincial Plans). The question remains: Is it a top-down process (i.e., more or less dictated by the central government) or is it a bottom-up one, favoring locals in each area? Uncertainty remains, and the National Spatial Planning Coordinating Board established in 2009 will likely step into the breach to clarify understandings.

 

Chapter VI of the regulation on mechanisms for controlling the utilization of spaces is sufficiently clear, elaborating licenses, zoning, incentives, and sanctions. Meanwhile, the regulation specifies that Forestry regulations will prevail in cases of disjunction with spatial planning.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku

Overview

The National Spatial Plan essentially serves as a regulatory map of Indonesia, governing which areas are available for what purposes. It is now governed by, and formulated under the auspices of: (1) Law No. 26 of 2007 on Spatial Planning (‘Spatial Planning Law’); (2) Government Regulation No. 15 of 2010 on the Implementation of Spatial Planning (‘Implementing Regulation’). The previous regulation on the subject, Law No. 24 of 1992 on Spatial Planning, has been repealed and replaced.

 

Formulating the Spatial Plan is a complex process, involving many different state agencies (e.g., Ministry of Forestry, Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources) and many different ‘levels’ of the state, from the regent/mayor to executives in the central government. It requires a careful inventory of available land, and comprehensive data collection about the characteristics of that land. Meanwhile, the Spatial Plan must consider socio-cultural factors of societies in each area, as well as the economic development in those areas and the nation as a whole. It is a fine balancing act, weighing tensions between various regulatory interests at every point of formulation.

 

In previous times, the Spatial Plan - which is used as the basis for licensing of certain activities such as mining, forestry, construction, and energy resource extraction - has often been understood differently by different state institutions, from Ministries to different levels of government. In a common scenario, one state agency assumes an area is intended for purpose ‘X,’ another assumes the area is intended for purpose ‘Y’; the first agency issues a license on the basis of ‘X,’ the second revokes it on the basis of ‘Y’. That basic scenario (i.e., a disunity of state understanding) is made possible by lacking Spatial Plan regulation. In short, it has caused a host of problems, and created an uncertain regulatory ‘terrain’ for economic development.

 

This Spatial Planning Law merely provides a broad framework for the implementation of spatial planning. Its various topics include: division of authority between state agencies and levels of government; mandating citizen participation; supervision of activities; dispute settlement; general principles governing the process (e.g., public interest, legal certainty, integration); and so on.

 

This inquiry briefly highlights key aspects of the Implementing Regulation, and is guided by two core questions. First, how does the regulation effect state control over the utilization of Indonesian space? Second, how does it implement the revised Spatial Planning Law’s objective, namely, to rectify the issue of coordination between different levels and agencies of the state?

 

Purpose

The Implementing Regulation explicitly states that its purpose is to regulate, implement, control, and supervise spatial planning. In effect, its purpose is to inform how the National Spatial Plan is to be formulated, to give legal basis to that process and the Plan itself, and to ensure that Indonesian ‘space’ is utilized in accordance with the National Spatial Plan.

 

Definition of Spatial Planning

Article 1 (1) of the Spatial Planning Law defines ‘space’ as including land, sea, and air in Indonesia, and where humans live and can perform activities. It follows that ‘spatial planning,’ defined in Article 1 (5) of the Law, is a system for utilization and control of Indonesian spaces.

 

General Breakdown of the National Spatial Plan

The entirety of the National Spatial Plan consists of the: National Spatial Plan, Provincial Spatial Plans, Regency Spatial Plans, and Municipality Spatial Plans. Going from the bottom up, each Plan builds upon the others, and collectively they form the National Spatial Plan. The National Spatial Plan literally serves as a regulatory map of the country.

 

Controlling the Utilization of Space

There are numerous methods for controlling the utilization of spaces across Indonesia. As provided in Chapter VI of the Implementing Regulation, the methods include: zoning, licensing, incentives, disincentives, and sanctions.

 

Zoning is particularly fundamental to the National Spatial Plan. It is the method by which areas of the country are regulated to allow certain activities and restrict others. For resource exploitation industries, this is a critical feature of the Spatial Plan; it elaborates where and what types of extractive activities can take place in every area of Indonesia.

 

Licensing is also particularly critical to utilization of land in legal accordance to the National Spatial Plan. By requiring different space utilization permits, licensing authorities may check that a proposed activity is congruent with the regulatory status of a particular area.

 

Incentives can be given by spatial planning by regulating a zone to be more ‘attractive’ to certain activities. Where the government wishes to promote development, for instance in remote or disaster-stricken areas, it may regulate a zone to have tax incentives for certain types of activities (e.g., infrastructure development, certain business activities), or loosen requirements for various types of space utilization licenses.

 

Disincentives can similarly be in the form of tax increases in a particular zone, or difficult licensing requirements. Other disincentives include space rehabilitation (e.g., reforestation), and other obligations contingent upon space utilization.

 

Sanctions are available to the state in many forms, ranging from written warnings, license revocation or cancellation, closure of the location, building demolition, and administrative fines.

 

Regulating Spatial Planning: Overview

For each respective ‘level’ of Spatial Plan - from municipal to central governmental levels -drafting of the Spatial Plan befalls to the relevant executive government. The draft will be submitted to the House of Representatives at each respective level of government to be discussed, and subsequently issued as a regulation. For example, the provincial governor is charged with supervising the draft Provincial Spatial Plan; the Provincial House of Representatives or ‘DPRD’ will disseminate the draft, and perhaps issue it as a Provincial Government Regulation.

 

Technical Procedure for Drafting Spatial Plans

Each level of government will formulate the draft according to a series five of stages:

1)

Preparation Stage. The method and financial plan will be determined by the relevant authority that is charged with the drafting process.

2)

Data Collection. This includes data on an area’s population, economic development, land utilization, and availability of infrastructure and facilities.

3)

Data Evaluation. At this point, collected data is disseminated by the drafting authority, informing future drafting decisions.

4)

Drafting of the Concept for the Spatial Plan. This literally includes mapping each subsection of every zone into subcomponent regulatory areas.

5)

Incorporation of the Draft Spatial Plan into a Draft Regulation. The Draft will be submitted to the relevant House of Representatives to be scrutinized, debated, and issued as a formal regulation.

 

Citizen Consultation

Article 65 of the Spatial Plan Law provides for extensive citizen participation in spatial planning and implementation - but only in a general manner, requiring further implementing regulation to specify further. The three general modes for citizen inclusion are: 1) formulation of the spatial plan; 2) utilization of spaces, and; 3) exercising control over the utilization of spaces. However, the Implementing Regulation does not actually specify how those roles for citizen inclusion take place in reality. In effect, the current prevailing regulation does not clearly include the public in spatial planning processes.

 

Spatial Plan Coordination: One Standardized National Spatial Plan?

Law No. 24 of 1992 on Spatial Planning evidently could not produce synchronization of spatial planning efforts across all levels of government. On the coordination front, it is still dubious whether the replacements will succeed where the predecessor failed.

 

Article 27 (2) (d) of the Implementing Regulation sets out that the drafting of the Provincial Spatial Plan shall take the Municipal and Regency Spatial Plans into consideration. However, the same paragraph also states that “…the [Provincial Spatial Plan] shall be based upon the National Spatial Plan”. However, Article 26 of the Implementing Regulation states that the formulation of the National Plan will be addressed in “different regulation” - which does not yet exist.

 

Thus, there is a tension in the formulation of Spatial Plans; do they build upon municipal- and regency-level spatial planning, or do they implement a broader National Spatial Plan formulated by the central government? The question thus raised is whether spatial planning, or revisions to existing spatial plans, are to be a top-down or bottom-up process; does it empower the central government, or does it empower locals? Is the issue of coordination ultimately resolved?

 

With 206 Articles, the Implementing Regulation may be extensive, but it leaves those essential questions to be answered by subsequent regulation. Until further regulation is released, the clarification of ambiguities around synchronization befalls to the National Spatial Planning Coordinating Board, which was established by Presidential Decree No. 4 of 2009.

 

Dispute Settlement

When there is a dispute arising from synchronization between different spatial plans, or an issue with the implementation of national and regional spatial plans, the settlement process will be managed by the National Spatial Planning Coordinating Board.

 

Forestry Controversy

One dispute that has created legal uncertainty in recent times was caused by Article 37 of the Spatial Planning Law, which revokes any license that is in violation of spatial planning. Indeed, it is stated in Article 73 of that Law that any government officials that issue licenses in violation of spatial planning will face criminal and administrative sanctions.

 

According to Law No. 41 of 1999 on Forestry, however, the Minister of Forestry is authorized to allocate ‘Protected’ and ‘Production’ Forestry Areas for certain types of activities, including some non-forestry activities. Some of those allocated areas have conflicted with the national spatial planning. What then, for the license-holders whose activities were previously approved by the Ministry of Forestry? Given the uncertainty caused by the Spatial Planning Law, the Minister of Forestry has been reluctant to issue licenses or allocate certain Forest Areas for various activities.

 

Article 31 of the Implementing Regulation addresses the dilemma: utilization of Forest Areas is to be governed by regulations relating to Forestry. In effect, licenses issued by the Ministry of Forestry, and Forest Area allocations made by the Minister of Forestry (e.g., for mining activities) are to remain legally valid. Future spatial planning is mandated to integrate Ministry of Forestry allocations and license areas into it.

 

Conclusion

Spatial Planning is the critical foundation for development in Indonesia, and its capacity to direct economic growth naturally gives reason for the government to hope that the Implementing Regulation (a) clarifies vague aspects of the Spatial Planning Law, and (b) closes loopholes that existed in the previous regulatory framework. In the view of this inquiry, overlapping regulatory areas caused by the failure of different state parties to coordinate effectively is indicative of regulatory failure; whether the problem persists is to be seen.

 

Implementation will be hampered by key provisions that refer to subsequent regulation: two examples discussed in this inquiry were how the final National Spatial Plan is actually formulated, and how citizens will be able to participate in each stage of planning.

 

Coordination remains a dubious issue. At one time, each ‘level’ of spatial planning is told to integrate with, and build upon each subsidiary ‘level’ of Spatial Plan, but in the same paragraphs, ‘lower-level’ Plans (e.g., Municipal Plans) are told to comply with ‘higher-level’ Plans (e.g., Provincial Plans). The question remains: Is it a top-down process (i.e., more or less dictated by the central government) or is it a bottom-up one, favoring locals in each area? Uncertainty remains, and the National Spatial Planning Coordinating Board established in 2009 will likely step into the breach to clarify understandings.

 

Chapter VI of the regulation on mechanisms for controlling the utilization of spaces is sufficiently clear, elaborating licenses, zoning, incentives, and sanctions. Meanwhile, the regulation specifies that Forestry regulations will prevail in cases of disjunction with spatial planning.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku
2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info