Regulations for State Control and Maximal Use of Otherwise Neglected Lands
Overview
The issue of state seizure, control, and utilization of otherwise neglected lands has been revisited by two recently released regulations: (1) Government Regulation No.11 of 2010 on Control and Utilization of Neglected Lands (hereinafter, ‘the 2010 Government Regulation’), and; (2) Head of the National Land Agency Regulation No. 4 of 2010 on the Procedure to Control Neglected Lands (hereinafter, ‘the 2010 BPN Regulation’). The latter acts as an implementing regulation for the former, and both converge to serve one essential effect: land reform.
The regulations repeal and replace Government Regulation No. 36 of 1998 (hereinafter, ‘the 1998 Government Regulation’). Although that regulation addressed state re-control of neglected land, in short, its effect in reality was undermined by its vagueness, as this inquiry will elaborate. For one thing, it was not even clearly established what was meant by ‘neglected land’.
Evidencing the failure of the 1998 Government Regulation, the Head of the National Land Agency (‘BPN’), Joyo Winoto, estimates that the amount of neglected land in Indonesia exceeds 7.3 million acres; 133 times larger than the size of Singapore (Seputar Indonesia, 22 March 2010). Mr. Winoto expects that the recently-released twin regulations on neglected land will clarify the understanding of ‘neglected land,’ articulate a workable method for the state to re-control that land, and specify how the indwelling productive potential of the land will be liberated for the maximal public benefit.
This inquiry will briefly highlight key features of the two new regulations, firstly to assess the extent to which they respond to the issues underlying underutilization of land, and secondly to evaluate whether their contents actually correspond to claims that the effort will serve the wellbeing of Indonesian lower and middle-classes (who, like the land, are routinely neglected).
For a brief overview of the 2010 BPN Regulation, see ILB No. 1351 12/3/2010.
Purpose
Vast amounts of land are owned under certain ‘titles’ or ‘rights (and obligations) of ownership,’ but are not being used either in accordance with the utilization rights bestowed by their titles, or at all. That fact affects the lives of many Indonesian people, particularly large numbers of farmers who are able to cultivate the land but otherwise face a difficult living situation. The 2010 Government Regulation and its implementing 2010 BPN Regulation are intended to allow the state to re-control those lands in a well-managed, clear and standardized fashion, and later to use those lands towards the public benefit.
Types of Lands
Rectifying the semantic failure of the 1998 Government Regulation to establish what is meant by ‘neglected land,’ Article 2 of the 2010 Government Regulation elaborates the 6 types of land that collectively consist of the ‘neglected land jurisdiction’ of sorts for the government. The land title categories listed exactly correspond to those regulated in the ‘umbrella law,’ Law No. 5 of 1960 on [Lands], and they are: (1) Ownership Right, (2) Cultivation Right, (3) Right to Build, (4) Right to Use, (5) Right to Manage, and (6) any other land titles granted by a license, decision, or letter from any state authority. Considering the broad nature of the sixth category, the jurisdiction for state re-control of land is sizeable.
Exemption
Essentially, there are two exceptional situations in which a neglected piece of land may be spared from the governmental effort to re-control and utilize it, and they are provided by Article 3 (a) and (b) of the 2010 Government Regulation. In the first instance, title-holders of a Right to Build or Ownership Right may claim that the land was ‘unintentionally abandoned’ or ‘inadequately developed’: the Elucidation to the Article explains that this effectively refers to a case of insufficient funds being the reason for underutilization. In the second instance, the exempted title-holding party is the Indonesian state, which in this case can claim that the government was incapable of distributing funds from the State Budget to fully utilize the land, or correctly utilize it for the intended purpose.
Procedure for Determination of a Land as ‘Neglected’
In essence, the process in which a land is identified as ‘neglected’ is based upon the BPN’s assessment of a land inventory (i.e., extensive data), which it will collect. The Head of each BPN Regional Office is the government authority directly responsible for the neglected land identification process; the Central-level BPN only supervises in this respect.
The inventory process is one subject of the implementing 2010 BPN Regulation. According to Article 5 (2) of that regulation, all land title-holders in the 6 categories listed previously must report both the type of land granted to them, and if the land is being used for its intended purpose to the BPN Regional Office. The BPN Regional Office will assess the provided information, and investigate any suspicions about dishonest information. Title-holders must comply with further requests for information by the BPN Regional Office.
On the basis of collected information, the Head of the BPN Regional Office will conclude whether land being investigated is neglected. If ‘neglected,’ the BPN will warn the title-holder that they must utilize the land correctly, fully, and shortly - or risk the land being controlled by the state.
Warning Notifications
As with the 1998 Government Regulation, 3 warnings will be issued to title-holders of ‘neglected land,’ but the timeframe for response is significantly shortened. Whereas previously, title-holders had nearly 3 years, they now have about 3 months. After the first warning is issued, title-holders have one month to respond meaningfully (i.e., use the land) before they are warned a second time: after another month they will be warned a third time; after another (third) month of neglecting the land, they will have effectively forfeited their rights to it.
Legal Consequences
According to Articles 19 and 20 of the 2010 BPN Regulation, after failing to comply with warnings, the Head of the BPN Regional Office will issue a Decision on the Determination of Neglected Land. In short, it (1) terminates any title-holder rights over the land(s), (2) terminates all legal associations entirely between the land and former title-holders, and (3) confirms that the lands are no longer the property of any title-holder besides the Indonesian state.
Landowners or title-holders must vacate the premises and ‘clear away’ all goods on the neglected lands within one month from a BPN Decision. Any expenses for that are to be borne by the title-holder. Any items on the neglected lands remaining after that one month will be regarded as state property.
Financial Reparation
Whereas Article 15 of the 1998 Government Regulation provides for financial ‘reparation’ to title-holders whose land is re-controlled by the state, neither that provision nor any with similar effect are contained in the current two 2010 regulations. Thus, no financial compensation will be afforded to any title-holders who have not optimally utilized their lands.
Maximizing the Use of Neglected Lands for Public Purposes
Given what some have alleged to be the ‘clandestine’ fashion in which the government drafted this regulation, more than a few elements of the public have voiced doubts about the extent to which the regulation is in fact ‘pro-public’. Before the regulations were released, Usep Setiawan, the Agrarian Reform Consortium’s National Council Chairperson, was concerned that the regulations might empower investor interests more than those of lower and middle-classes, for whom re-adjusted land distribution is perhaps more pertinent (Konsorsium Pembaharuan Agraria, 2009).
Article 15 of the 2010 Government Regulation takes on those concerns explicitly: neglected lands are designated for the prosperity of the people and the state, delivered through agrarian reform, strategic programs, and other pro-social programs. The Article’s Elucidation states that ‘Agrarian Reform’ involves distributing and redistributing neglected land for social interests, that ‘state strategic programs’ include development of such sectors as energy, public housing, and food security, and that other programs range from national defense to natural disaster relocation.
Enforcement Date
Government Regulation No.11 of 2010 has been in force since 22 January 2010. Head of the National Land Agency Regulation No. 4 of 2010 has been in force since 1 February 2010.
Conclusion
Taken together, the two 2010 regulations discussed in this inquiry are effectively a sanction upon any land title-holder who is identified to be neglecting their land, or the obligations befallen to a particular type of land. Considering that no incentives are provided for state re-control of neglected land, title-holders are almost predestined to fight the implementation of these regulations as much as possible. That said, the regulations are clear, and they are forceful; a great deal of arbitrary capacities are given to the BPN to exercise the regulatory mandate over a wide-ranging land jurisdiction. That arbitrary power does however disguise relatively lacking formal standards for the identification of ‘neglected land,’ inviting opportunities for both inconsistency and corruption. In sum, implementation of these regulations will be difficult.
On the other hand, with an estimated 7.3 million acres or more of underutilized land, even a marginal modicum of success would likely have substantial positive effects for the lower and middle classes of Indonesia - the almost expressly-stated beneficiaries of this regulation. In addition to at least creating the opportunity for a substantial increase in social wellbeing due to improved land access (and thus, chances for meaningful livelihood), land reform tends to exercise very significant influences on both short- and long-term economic development.
The issue of state seizure, control, and utilization of otherwise neglected lands has been revisited by two recently released regulations: (1) Government Regulation No.11 of 2010 on Control and Utilization of Neglected Lands (hereinafter, ‘the 2010 Government Regulation’), and; (2) Head of the National Land Agency Regulation No. 4 of 2010 on the Procedure to Control Neglected Lands (hereinafter, ‘the 2010 BPN Regulation’). The latter acts as an implementing regulation for the former, and both converge to serve one essential effect: land reform.
The regulations repeal and replace Government Regulation No. 36 of 1998 (hereinafter, ‘the 1998 Government Regulation’). Although that regulation addressed state re-control of neglected land, in short, its effect in reality was undermined by its vagueness, as this inquiry will elaborate. For one thing, it was not even clearly established what was meant by ‘neglected land’.
Evidencing the failure of the 1998 Government Regulation, the Head of the National Land Agency (‘BPN’), Joyo Winoto, estimates that the amount of neglected land in Indonesia exceeds 7.3 million acres; 133 times larger than the size of Singapore (Seputar Indonesia, 22 March 2010). Mr. Winoto expects that the recently-released twin regulations on neglected land will clarify the understanding of ‘neglected land,’ articulate a workable method for the state to re-control that land, and specify how the indwelling productive potential of the land will be liberated for the maximal public benefit.
This inquiry will briefly highlight key features of the two new regulations, firstly to assess the extent to which they respond to the issues underlying underutilization of land, and secondly to evaluate whether their contents actually correspond to claims that the effort will serve the wellbeing of Indonesian lower and middle-classes (who, like the land, are routinely neglected).
For a brief overview of the 2010 BPN Regulation, see ILB No. 1351 12/3/2010.
Purpose
Vast amounts of land are owned under certain ‘titles’ or ‘rights (and obligations) of ownership,’ but are not being used either in accordance with the utilization rights bestowed by their titles, or at all. That fact affects the lives of many Indonesian people, particularly large numbers of farmers who are able to cultivate the land but otherwise face a difficult living situation. The 2010 Government Regulation and its implementing 2010 BPN Regulation are intended to allow the state to re-control those lands in a well-managed, clear and standardized fashion, and later to use those lands towards the public benefit.
Types of Lands
Rectifying the semantic failure of the 1998 Government Regulation to establish what is meant by ‘neglected land,’ Article 2 of the 2010 Government Regulation elaborates the 6 types of land that collectively consist of the ‘neglected land jurisdiction’ of sorts for the government. The land title categories listed exactly correspond to those regulated in the ‘umbrella law,’ Law No. 5 of 1960 on [Lands], and they are: (1) Ownership Right, (2) Cultivation Right, (3) Right to Build, (4) Right to Use, (5) Right to Manage, and (6) any other land titles granted by a license, decision, or letter from any state authority. Considering the broad nature of the sixth category, the jurisdiction for state re-control of land is sizeable.
Exemption
Essentially, there are two exceptional situations in which a neglected piece of land may be spared from the governmental effort to re-control and utilize it, and they are provided by Article 3 (a) and (b) of the 2010 Government Regulation. In the first instance, title-holders of a Right to Build or Ownership Right may claim that the land was ‘unintentionally abandoned’ or ‘inadequately developed’: the Elucidation to the Article explains that this effectively refers to a case of insufficient funds being the reason for underutilization. In the second instance, the exempted title-holding party is the Indonesian state, which in this case can claim that the government was incapable of distributing funds from the State Budget to fully utilize the land, or correctly utilize it for the intended purpose.
Procedure for Determination of a Land as ‘Neglected’
In essence, the process in which a land is identified as ‘neglected’ is based upon the BPN’s assessment of a land inventory (i.e., extensive data), which it will collect. The Head of each BPN Regional Office is the government authority directly responsible for the neglected land identification process; the Central-level BPN only supervises in this respect.
The inventory process is one subject of the implementing 2010 BPN Regulation. According to Article 5 (2) of that regulation, all land title-holders in the 6 categories listed previously must report both the type of land granted to them, and if the land is being used for its intended purpose to the BPN Regional Office. The BPN Regional Office will assess the provided information, and investigate any suspicions about dishonest information. Title-holders must comply with further requests for information by the BPN Regional Office.
On the basis of collected information, the Head of the BPN Regional Office will conclude whether land being investigated is neglected. If ‘neglected,’ the BPN will warn the title-holder that they must utilize the land correctly, fully, and shortly - or risk the land being controlled by the state.
Warning Notifications
As with the 1998 Government Regulation, 3 warnings will be issued to title-holders of ‘neglected land,’ but the timeframe for response is significantly shortened. Whereas previously, title-holders had nearly 3 years, they now have about 3 months. After the first warning is issued, title-holders have one month to respond meaningfully (i.e., use the land) before they are warned a second time: after another month they will be warned a third time; after another (third) month of neglecting the land, they will have effectively forfeited their rights to it.
Legal Consequences
According to Articles 19 and 20 of the 2010 BPN Regulation, after failing to comply with warnings, the Head of the BPN Regional Office will issue a Decision on the Determination of Neglected Land. In short, it (1) terminates any title-holder rights over the land(s), (2) terminates all legal associations entirely between the land and former title-holders, and (3) confirms that the lands are no longer the property of any title-holder besides the Indonesian state.
Landowners or title-holders must vacate the premises and ‘clear away’ all goods on the neglected lands within one month from a BPN Decision. Any expenses for that are to be borne by the title-holder. Any items on the neglected lands remaining after that one month will be regarded as state property.
Financial Reparation
Whereas Article 15 of the 1998 Government Regulation provides for financial ‘reparation’ to title-holders whose land is re-controlled by the state, neither that provision nor any with similar effect are contained in the current two 2010 regulations. Thus, no financial compensation will be afforded to any title-holders who have not optimally utilized their lands.
Maximizing the Use of Neglected Lands for Public Purposes
Given what some have alleged to be the ‘clandestine’ fashion in which the government drafted this regulation, more than a few elements of the public have voiced doubts about the extent to which the regulation is in fact ‘pro-public’. Before the regulations were released, Usep Setiawan, the Agrarian Reform Consortium’s National Council Chairperson, was concerned that the regulations might empower investor interests more than those of lower and middle-classes, for whom re-adjusted land distribution is perhaps more pertinent (Konsorsium Pembaharuan Agraria, 2009).
Article 15 of the 2010 Government Regulation takes on those concerns explicitly: neglected lands are designated for the prosperity of the people and the state, delivered through agrarian reform, strategic programs, and other pro-social programs. The Article’s Elucidation states that ‘Agrarian Reform’ involves distributing and redistributing neglected land for social interests, that ‘state strategic programs’ include development of such sectors as energy, public housing, and food security, and that other programs range from national defense to natural disaster relocation.
Enforcement Date
Government Regulation No.11 of 2010 has been in force since 22 January 2010. Head of the National Land Agency Regulation No. 4 of 2010 has been in force since 1 February 2010.
Conclusion
Taken together, the two 2010 regulations discussed in this inquiry are effectively a sanction upon any land title-holder who is identified to be neglecting their land, or the obligations befallen to a particular type of land. Considering that no incentives are provided for state re-control of neglected land, title-holders are almost predestined to fight the implementation of these regulations as much as possible. That said, the regulations are clear, and they are forceful; a great deal of arbitrary capacities are given to the BPN to exercise the regulatory mandate over a wide-ranging land jurisdiction. That arbitrary power does however disguise relatively lacking formal standards for the identification of ‘neglected land,’ inviting opportunities for both inconsistency and corruption. In sum, implementation of these regulations will be difficult.
On the other hand, with an estimated 7.3 million acres or more of underutilized land, even a marginal modicum of success would likely have substantial positive effects for the lower and middle classes of Indonesia - the almost expressly-stated beneficiaries of this regulation. In addition to at least creating the opportunity for a substantial increase in social wellbeing due to improved land access (and thus, chances for meaningful livelihood), land reform tends to exercise very significant influences on both short- and long-term economic development.