Infrastructure Development Public-Private Partnerships

Overview

Arguably infrastructure development - roads, water sanitation, airports, telecommunications, and so on - is a constitutional obligation of the state. Yet, given a variety of factors including the tight budget and explosion of infrastructure demand, the government has had to consult private-sector participation through Public-Private Partnership schemes. Those schemes have been regulated by Presidential Regulation No. 67 of 2005 on Cooperation Between the Government and Business Entities in the Procurement of Infrastructure Projects (hereinafter, the 2005 Regulation).

 

In addition to addressing implementation of public-private partnerships, the 2005 Regulation governs the principles underpinning the schemes, types of infrastructure projects that are priorities, methods for risk management, and ‘Government Support’.

 

That regulation arguably failed to realize its objective - as will be discussed subsequently - and a revision was needed to liberate its indwelling potential and invigorate infrastructure development across the country - as had been originally intended. This ILD’s inquiry will address Presidential Regulation No. 13 of 2010 - the Amendment to the 2005 Regulation - to evaluate the extent to which the Amendment addresses the issues of its regulatory antecedent, focusing particularly on the modified provisions.

 

Purpose

The 2005 Regulation’s implementation was hampered. Not only did give rise to practical dilemmas, such as uncertainties around land acquisition for infrastructure projects, but the regulation itself was considered economically unattractive to the private sector, due to unappealing incentives and benefits. In short, few private parties took interest in participating, and the 2005 Regulation failed to significantly stimulate national infrastructure development.

 

Given the lingering deficiency of the 2005 Regulation, Presidential Regulation No. 13 of 2010 (hereinafter, the Amendment), was released on 28 February. Rather than overhaul the 2005 Regulation, the Amendment modifies some of its critically-issued provisions so as to make infrastructure development more attractive for private sector participation, and stimulate development projects across the nation.

 

For a brief overview of Presidential Regulation No. 13 of 2010, see ILB No. 1322 18/2/2010.

 

Government Support for Infrastructure Projects Defined

Government financial contribution to public-private projects - ‘Government Support’ - is addressed in Article 17 of the 2005 Regulation, and is to be drawn from State and Regional Budgets. Its distribution befalls to the Minister of Finance, or the Head of a Regional Financial Management Working Unit. That much is clear, but a serious weakness of the regulation is the failure to specify or systematize the scope of Government Support that could be afforded to a project.

 

The Amendment addresses that weakness by specifying the extents and forms of Government Support, replacing Article 17 of the 2005 Regulation with Articles 17A, B, and C under a new chapter, Chapter VIA. 

 

Apart from financial support, Article 17A of the Amendment provides that the government may support infrastructure development in the following ways: licensing, land acquisition, construction, tax preferences, and/or other supports set out by various authorities - Ministers, Heads of an Institution, and Heads of Regional Governments.

 

Land Acquisition Clarified

A recurring issue that has inhibited infrastructure development projects (and caused the private sector to be cautious when engaging in public partnerships) is land acquisition for a project - specifically, the fact that in many cases it is not entirely guaranteed, and ownership can be disputed. The contentious Palembang-Indralaya and Palembang-Betung highway constructions are recent notable examples of when infrastructure has been carried out prior to land ownership being firmly settled. Not only has this warded-off prospective private parties, but it has stopped ongoing development projects in the past.

 

Article 17A (6) of the Amendment clearly states that the responsibility falls to the government to assure that land acquisition is settled before any public-private partnership infrastructure project can get underway, or is even tendered to private parties who are interested in the contract. Consequent to that amendment, the refurbished 2005 Regulation can support Presidential Regulation No. 36 of 2005 on Land Acquisition for the Implementation of Public Interest Development, as amended by Presidential Regulation No. 65 of 2006.

 

Government Guarantee: Insurance for Private Partners in a Project

The 2005 Regulation’s provisions to protect private parties from costly ‘surprises’ during the course of an infrastructure project for the state are hardly sufficient: the regulation says only that any risks will be borne by both the government and the business, and that further details of risk allocation are to be detailed further in the public-private Cooperation Agreement.

 

The passivity around providing further details around insurance for private partners in a project was tantamount to a disincentive for a businesses’ engagement in public-private infrastructure development. As such, the Amendment provides for a ‘Government Guarantee’; an alluring financial compensation assurance that will be awarded by the state in the event of unpredictable losses during a project.

 

As provided by Article 17B of the Amendemt, the Minister of Finance will be responsible to set out the forms, types, and procedures for the Government Guarantee. That said, the types and procedures are actually regulated further by Minister of Finance Regulation No. 38/PMK.01/2006 on Implementation Guidance for Risk Control and Management of the Infrastructure Provision.   

 

At the business end of compensation, the body that will distribute the Government Guarantee is the Indonesian Infrastructure Financing Company, a recently-established state-owned company that will play a significant facilitative role in national infrastructure development activities and whose principal function is to coordinate public-private partnerships. 

 

For a brief overview of the Indonesian Infrastructure Financing Company, see ILB No. 1122 18/6/2009. 

 

Compensation for ‘Unsolicited Projects’

Although the government is to mainly initiate infrastructure projects, according to the 2005 Regulation, it is within the realm of possibility that a private-sector entity proposes its own project. For such projects, the state would be willing to engage in modified forms of repayment, or ‘compensation’. 

 

Chapter IV of the 2005 Regulation effectively outlines 3 forms of compensation: (1) adding to the businesses’ ‘tender points’ to a maximum of 10% (those are used to determine which companies are awarded contracts); (2) purchasing the project’s intellectual property rights from the company; (3) offering the business the ‘right to match’.

 

The right to match is a compensation introduced and governed by Article 13 (2) (b) of the Amendment, and is a privilege that allows a business to modify their initial offer a second time to challenge an otherwise winning offer for an infrastructure procurement contract. That said, the final decision will remain at the discretion of the government upon recommendation from the Tender Committee.


Conclusion

Although jumpstarting national infrastructure development had been the fundamental objective of the 2005 Regulation, it arguably failed to do so due largely in part to disincentives for the private sector’s engagement. The Amendment to the regulation isolates the acute issues undermining that regulation, and responds accordingly by providing structure around governmental supports for private contractors, land acquisition guarantees, insurance for private contractors involved in state-procured infrastructure projects, and setting out incentives for private, independently-initiated infrastructure development. Although it looks promising, time will tell whether this Amendment is an improvement upon its predecessor.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku

Overview

Arguably infrastructure development - roads, water sanitation, airports, telecommunications, and so on - is a constitutional obligation of the state. Yet, given a variety of factors including the tight budget and explosion of infrastructure demand, the government has had to consult private-sector participation through Public-Private Partnership schemes. Those schemes have been regulated by Presidential Regulation No. 67 of 2005 on Cooperation Between the Government and Business Entities in the Procurement of Infrastructure Projects (hereinafter, the 2005 Regulation).

 

In addition to addressing implementation of public-private partnerships, the 2005 Regulation governs the principles underpinning the schemes, types of infrastructure projects that are priorities, methods for risk management, and ‘Government Support’.

 

That regulation arguably failed to realize its objective - as will be discussed subsequently - and a revision was needed to liberate its indwelling potential and invigorate infrastructure development across the country - as had been originally intended. This ILD’s inquiry will address Presidential Regulation No. 13 of 2010 - the Amendment to the 2005 Regulation - to evaluate the extent to which the Amendment addresses the issues of its regulatory antecedent, focusing particularly on the modified provisions.

 

Purpose

The 2005 Regulation’s implementation was hampered. Not only did give rise to practical dilemmas, such as uncertainties around land acquisition for infrastructure projects, but the regulation itself was considered economically unattractive to the private sector, due to unappealing incentives and benefits. In short, few private parties took interest in participating, and the 2005 Regulation failed to significantly stimulate national infrastructure development.

 

Given the lingering deficiency of the 2005 Regulation, Presidential Regulation No. 13 of 2010 (hereinafter, the Amendment), was released on 28 February. Rather than overhaul the 2005 Regulation, the Amendment modifies some of its critically-issued provisions so as to make infrastructure development more attractive for private sector participation, and stimulate development projects across the nation.

 

For a brief overview of Presidential Regulation No. 13 of 2010, see ILB No. 1322 18/2/2010.

 

Government Support for Infrastructure Projects Defined

Government financial contribution to public-private projects - ‘Government Support’ - is addressed in Article 17 of the 2005 Regulation, and is to be drawn from State and Regional Budgets. Its distribution befalls to the Minister of Finance, or the Head of a Regional Financial Management Working Unit. That much is clear, but a serious weakness of the regulation is the failure to specify or systematize the scope of Government Support that could be afforded to a project.

 

The Amendment addresses that weakness by specifying the extents and forms of Government Support, replacing Article 17 of the 2005 Regulation with Articles 17A, B, and C under a new chapter, Chapter VIA. 

 

Apart from financial support, Article 17A of the Amendment provides that the government may support infrastructure development in the following ways: licensing, land acquisition, construction, tax preferences, and/or other supports set out by various authorities - Ministers, Heads of an Institution, and Heads of Regional Governments.

 

Land Acquisition Clarified

A recurring issue that has inhibited infrastructure development projects (and caused the private sector to be cautious when engaging in public partnerships) is land acquisition for a project - specifically, the fact that in many cases it is not entirely guaranteed, and ownership can be disputed. The contentious Palembang-Indralaya and Palembang-Betung highway constructions are recent notable examples of when infrastructure has been carried out prior to land ownership being firmly settled. Not only has this warded-off prospective private parties, but it has stopped ongoing development projects in the past.

 

Article 17A (6) of the Amendment clearly states that the responsibility falls to the government to assure that land acquisition is settled before any public-private partnership infrastructure project can get underway, or is even tendered to private parties who are interested in the contract. Consequent to that amendment, the refurbished 2005 Regulation can support Presidential Regulation No. 36 of 2005 on Land Acquisition for the Implementation of Public Interest Development, as amended by Presidential Regulation No. 65 of 2006.

 

Government Guarantee: Insurance for Private Partners in a Project

The 2005 Regulation’s provisions to protect private parties from costly ‘surprises’ during the course of an infrastructure project for the state are hardly sufficient: the regulation says only that any risks will be borne by both the government and the business, and that further details of risk allocation are to be detailed further in the public-private Cooperation Agreement.

 

The passivity around providing further details around insurance for private partners in a project was tantamount to a disincentive for a businesses’ engagement in public-private infrastructure development. As such, the Amendment provides for a ‘Government Guarantee’; an alluring financial compensation assurance that will be awarded by the state in the event of unpredictable losses during a project.

 

As provided by Article 17B of the Amendemt, the Minister of Finance will be responsible to set out the forms, types, and procedures for the Government Guarantee. That said, the types and procedures are actually regulated further by Minister of Finance Regulation No. 38/PMK.01/2006 on Implementation Guidance for Risk Control and Management of the Infrastructure Provision.   

 

At the business end of compensation, the body that will distribute the Government Guarantee is the Indonesian Infrastructure Financing Company, a recently-established state-owned company that will play a significant facilitative role in national infrastructure development activities and whose principal function is to coordinate public-private partnerships. 

 

For a brief overview of the Indonesian Infrastructure Financing Company, see ILB No. 1122 18/6/2009. 

 

Compensation for ‘Unsolicited Projects’

Although the government is to mainly initiate infrastructure projects, according to the 2005 Regulation, it is within the realm of possibility that a private-sector entity proposes its own project. For such projects, the state would be willing to engage in modified forms of repayment, or ‘compensation’. 

 

Chapter IV of the 2005 Regulation effectively outlines 3 forms of compensation: (1) adding to the businesses’ ‘tender points’ to a maximum of 10% (those are used to determine which companies are awarded contracts); (2) purchasing the project’s intellectual property rights from the company; (3) offering the business the ‘right to match’.

 

The right to match is a compensation introduced and governed by Article 13 (2) (b) of the Amendment, and is a privilege that allows a business to modify their initial offer a second time to challenge an otherwise winning offer for an infrastructure procurement contract. That said, the final decision will remain at the discretion of the government upon recommendation from the Tender Committee.


Conclusion

Although jumpstarting national infrastructure development had been the fundamental objective of the 2005 Regulation, it arguably failed to do so due largely in part to disincentives for the private sector’s engagement. The Amendment to the regulation isolates the acute issues undermining that regulation, and responds accordingly by providing structure around governmental supports for private contractors, land acquisition guarantees, insurance for private contractors involved in state-procured infrastructure projects, and setting out incentives for private, independently-initiated infrastructure development. Although it looks promising, time will tell whether this Amendment is an improvement upon its predecessor.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku
2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info