On the basis that natural gas is not a renewable natural resource, and that its usage should be well managed, on 27 January 2010, the Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources issued Regulation No. 03 of 2010 on the Allocation and Utilization of Natural Gas for the Fulfillment of Domestic Necessities.
An instrumental provision of the regulation is to obligate natural gas contractors (local and foreign) to prioritize the domestic natural gas demand: a fixed portion of the natural gas production in a given year must be contributed towards fulfilling the domestic demand before ‘surplus’ resources can be exported or otherwise utilized. Previous relevant regulations have made similar attempts, but have encountered difficulties - one critical example being the failure of existing regulation to sufficiently define the business-end details of ‘domestic necessities’ or ‘national demand’ of natural gas.
The current regulation elaborates practical definitions of those terms, and provides details around what proportion of production must be contributed towards the national demand, where natural gas will be distributed, and how it will be utilized.
The regulation is prescribed by Law No. 22 of 2001 on Oil and Gas (Oil and Gas Law) and its various implementing regulations, which mandate that the government commit to providing a policy framework that can both (a) satisfy the national demand for oil and gas resources, and (b) encourage their efficient utilization. This inquiry will go on to discuss the current regulation in context with its predecessors and existing relevant regulations.
For a brief overview of the regulation see ILB No. 1301 04/02/2010
Purpose
Although the explicitly-stated purpose of the regulation is to control the exploitation of natural gas to protect national long-term resource interests, the implicit purpose is most certainly to limit the overseas outflow of Indonesia’s natural gas resources.
Indonesia as an exporter of natural gas is no new phenomenon, and due to long-term contracts the government has committed and is still bound to, it will continue to be the case. Although those contracts may cause anxiety to the state with relation to the evolved environmental and economic conditions, at the time of the agreements, natural gas had not been regarded as a commodity of concern, nor was it preferable to consumption of oil.
Given the current environmental, economic, and resource-supply situations, natural gas is considered to be a substitute to oil: Indonesian supplies are some of the largest in the world, it is less destructive to the environment, and - perhaps the most important consideration for many - it is cheaper.
Policy-Making Process for Natural Gas Allocation and Utilization
The task of determining policy for the prioritization and efficient utilization of natural gas falls to the Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources, who is responsible to ensure that the national demand for natural gas is satisfied before other interests are served. In so doing, the Minister must consider a number of factors - in addition to any inputs deemed relevant.
First, 6 core points must be considered prior to any policy formulation:
-
Public interest;
-
National interest;
-
National Energy Policy;
-
Amount of natural gas reserves, and market opportunity;
-
Availability of infrastructure, and that which is being planned, and;
-
‘Economic conditions’ of a natural gas field from which the domestic portion of production is to be taken.
Second, as provided in Article 2 (4) of the regulation, the Minister must consider recommendations from the Upstream Oil and Gas Supervisory Agency, or ‘BP Migas’.
Third, and perhaps most importantly, the Minister must take into account the IndonesianNatural Gas Balance. The Gas Balance is a document that essentially lays out the estimated Indonesian supply of natural gas reserves, the estimated period of time that those resources can be used, and the levels of natural gas demand from particular areas. Using the Gas Balance, the Minister can make informed decisions around natural gas prioritization policies.
The Gas Balance allows the government to readily appraise the acute needs of natural gas throughout each territory of Indonesia: if there should ever be a deficit, the government - through the Minister - can ostensibly respond immediately to resolve the insufficiency. As the natural gas resource situation is a dynamic one, the 2010 regulation on Fulfillment of Domestic Necessities appropriately requires that it be updated annually.
Business Contribution
Article 4 of the regulation obliges natural gas contractors to set aside a portion of the resources for Indonesia’s natural gas necessities: to “provide 25%” of the natural gas produced for domestic usage. That provision essentially restates that of Article 22 (1) of the Oil and Gas Law, and Article 46 (3) of Government Regulation No. 35 of 2004, as lastly amended by Regulation No. 55 of 2009.
However small the difference in wording, the previous regulations (e.g., Article 22 (1) of the Oil and Gas Law) created substantial issues by stating that contractors are obligated to “provide at the maximum 25%” of their natural gas for Indonesian domestic priorities. On that basis, one could provide 0.1% of the natural gas produced in a given year and still comply with the regulation - so in reality, the provision did little to prioritize or retain natural gas resources for the satisfaction of domestic necessities.
Constitutional Court Decision on the “Provide at the Maximum 25%” Phrase
According to Article 33 (3) of the 1945 Indonesian Constitution, the state is responsible to ensure that natural resources are used for the utmost wealth and wellbeing of the Indonesian people. The regulatory failure of Article 22 (1) of the Oil and Gas Law to have that effect concerned elements in both public and private sectors, and among other reasons for dispute of that Law, in 2003 the issue was taken up at the Constitutional Court (MK) as Case No. 002/PUU-I/2003.
The applicants for the judicial review did not explicitly ask that the “provide at the maximum 25%” phrase in Article 22 (1) be declared unconstitutional and subsequently revoked. However, during the 16 February 2004 hearing, the applicants disputed the phrase as a legal loophole for oil and gas contractors to absolve themselves of the responsibility to provide a portion of the resources for domestic priorities (i.e., uphold related national interests).
In its deliberation, the MK asserted that the phrase in Article 22 (1) could indeed allow contractors to escape the obligation to contribute the required amount of oil and gas for state needs. The MK agreed that any insufficiency of oil and gas for Indonesian priorities would be a violation of Article 33 (3) of the 1945 Constitution. Instead of ensuring that the domestic demand for oil and gas resources would take priority, the MK viewed Article 22 (1) as simply setting a maximum allocation threshold - not a minimum allocation threshold as would be desired from the Law.
As such, it was decided that “at the maximum” be removed from the phrase, and that it be interpreted instead as simply: contractors must “provide 25%” of the proportion of annual oil and gas production for the domestic demand. Incidentally, the Law has never been amended - it has only been instructed to be interpreted in that fashion.
Failure to Provide 25 % for Domestic Necessities - Sanctioned?
Sanctions are often an issue with Indonesian regulation, and the subject of this inquiry - Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources Regulation No. 03 of 2010 to prioritize natural gas for domestic necessities - is no exception. Although its mandate is obligatory, as indicated by the word “shall,” the essential question is: what are the repercussions for not complying the requirement?
Article 22 (1) of the Oil and Gas Law (after MK interpretation) merely obligates that producers provide 25% of oil and gas production to the state, calling for further elaboration in the form of Government Regulation. The regulation in question is Government Regulation No. 35 of 2004, as amended lastly by Regulation No. 55 of 2009: neither bring clarity to the issue of whether a producer can be sanctioned for failing to meet their obligations.
The most that is provided by the Government Regulation is that the 25% production provision will be dictated under Production Sharing Contracts, or ‘KKS’. Since the state agency, BP Migas, negotiates those Sharing Contracts with prospective contractors, it can stipulate sanctions at that level - but it is not explicitly provided in the regulation what those sanctions should be or how they should be enforced. Lacking regulatory clarity, the consistency of sanction application relies on the largely ad hoc stipulations of BP Migas, and only during the process of contract negotiation.
Prioritized Sectors
Article 6 (3) of the regulation prioritizes 4 sectors for the distribution and utilization of natural gas: (1) increasing national oil and gas production; (2) the fertilizer industry; (3) electricity supplies, and; (4) other industries.
Importing Natural Gas
In the event that domestic natural gas demands cannot be fulfilled, Article 5 of the regulation grants the Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources authority to issue policy that would allow Indonesia to import natural gas. Although insufficient supplies are always a possibility, particularly given Indonesia’s engagement in long-term contracts, it is unlikely. According to Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources data for 2008, Indonesia’s natural gas reserves could reach 170.07 Trillion Cubic Feet (TCF): 112.47 TCF in proven reserves, and 57.6 TCF in potential reserves; collectively, the 13th largest reserve in the world.
Enforcement
The regulation has been in force since 27 January 2010.
Conclusion
In short, Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources Regulation No. 03 of 2010 restates the obligation of natural gas contractors to provide 25% of their annual production to the state, for the purposes of fulfilling domestic natural gas needs. Given the opaque, and indeed disputed nature of previous regulations, this may have been a prudent action.
The regulation goes on to detail the considerations that must be incorporated into any future Ministerial policies relating to upholding the national interest in protecting natural gas resources for the wellbeing of Indonesian citizens. It also clearly lists what sectors are prioritized for distribution of natural gas; sectors which together define ‘domestic necessities’. In the view of this inquiry, a subject for further regulation or amendment is the issue of sanctions, as they remain unclear and are left for BP Migas to determine during the contract negotiation stage.
On the basis that natural gas is not a renewable natural resource, and that its usage should be well managed, on 27 January 2010, the Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources issued Regulation No. 03 of 2010 on the Allocation and Utilization of Natural Gas for the Fulfillment of Domestic Necessities.
An instrumental provision of the regulation is to obligate natural gas contractors (local and foreign) to prioritize the domestic natural gas demand: a fixed portion of the natural gas production in a given year must be contributed towards fulfilling the domestic demand before ‘surplus’ resources can be exported or otherwise utilized. Previous relevant regulations have made similar attempts, but have encountered difficulties - one critical example being the failure of existing regulation to sufficiently define the business-end details of ‘domestic necessities’ or ‘national demand’ of natural gas.
The current regulation elaborates practical definitions of those terms, and provides details around what proportion of production must be contributed towards the national demand, where natural gas will be distributed, and how it will be utilized.
The regulation is prescribed by Law No. 22 of 2001 on Oil and Gas (Oil and Gas Law) and its various implementing regulations, which mandate that the government commit to providing a policy framework that can both (a) satisfy the national demand for oil and gas resources, and (b) encourage their efficient utilization. This inquiry will go on to discuss the current regulation in context with its predecessors and existing relevant regulations.
For a brief overview of the regulation see ILB No. 1301 04/02/2010
Purpose
Although the explicitly-stated purpose of the regulation is to control the exploitation of natural gas to protect national long-term resource interests, the implicit purpose is most certainly to limit the overseas outflow of Indonesia’s natural gas resources.
Indonesia as an exporter of natural gas is no new phenomenon, and due to long-term contracts the government has committed and is still bound to, it will continue to be the case. Although those contracts may cause anxiety to the state with relation to the evolved environmental and economic conditions, at the time of the agreements, natural gas had not been regarded as a commodity of concern, nor was it preferable to consumption of oil.
Given the current environmental, economic, and resource-supply situations, natural gas is considered to be a substitute to oil: Indonesian supplies are some of the largest in the world, it is less destructive to the environment, and - perhaps the most important consideration for many - it is cheaper.
Policy-Making Process for Natural Gas Allocation and Utilization
The task of determining policy for the prioritization and efficient utilization of natural gas falls to the Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources, who is responsible to ensure that the national demand for natural gas is satisfied before other interests are served. In so doing, the Minister must consider a number of factors - in addition to any inputs deemed relevant.
First, 6 core points must be considered prior to any policy formulation:
-
Public interest;
-
National interest;
-
National Energy Policy;
-
Amount of natural gas reserves, and market opportunity;
-
Availability of infrastructure, and that which is being planned, and;
-
‘Economic conditions’ of a natural gas field from which the domestic portion of production is to be taken.
Second, as provided in Article 2 (4) of the regulation, the Minister must consider recommendations from the Upstream Oil and Gas Supervisory Agency, or ‘BP Migas’.
Third, and perhaps most importantly, the Minister must take into account the IndonesianNatural Gas Balance. The Gas Balance is a document that essentially lays out the estimated Indonesian supply of natural gas reserves, the estimated period of time that those resources can be used, and the levels of natural gas demand from particular areas. Using the Gas Balance, the Minister can make informed decisions around natural gas prioritization policies.
The Gas Balance allows the government to readily appraise the acute needs of natural gas throughout each territory of Indonesia: if there should ever be a deficit, the government - through the Minister - can ostensibly respond immediately to resolve the insufficiency. As the natural gas resource situation is a dynamic one, the 2010 regulation on Fulfillment of Domestic Necessities appropriately requires that it be updated annually.
Business Contribution
Article 4 of the regulation obliges natural gas contractors to set aside a portion of the resources for Indonesia’s natural gas necessities: to “provide 25%” of the natural gas produced for domestic usage. That provision essentially restates that of Article 22 (1) of the Oil and Gas Law, and Article 46 (3) of Government Regulation No. 35 of 2004, as lastly amended by Regulation No. 55 of 2009.
However small the difference in wording, the previous regulations (e.g., Article 22 (1) of the Oil and Gas Law) created substantial issues by stating that contractors are obligated to “provide at the maximum 25%” of their natural gas for Indonesian domestic priorities. On that basis, one could provide 0.1% of the natural gas produced in a given year and still comply with the regulation - so in reality, the provision did little to prioritize or retain natural gas resources for the satisfaction of domestic necessities.
Constitutional Court Decision on the “Provide at the Maximum 25%” Phrase
According to Article 33 (3) of the 1945 Indonesian Constitution, the state is responsible to ensure that natural resources are used for the utmost wealth and wellbeing of the Indonesian people. The regulatory failure of Article 22 (1) of the Oil and Gas Law to have that effect concerned elements in both public and private sectors, and among other reasons for dispute of that Law, in 2003 the issue was taken up at the Constitutional Court (MK) as Case No. 002/PUU-I/2003.
The applicants for the judicial review did not explicitly ask that the “provide at the maximum 25%” phrase in Article 22 (1) be declared unconstitutional and subsequently revoked. However, during the 16 February 2004 hearing, the applicants disputed the phrase as a legal loophole for oil and gas contractors to absolve themselves of the responsibility to provide a portion of the resources for domestic priorities (i.e., uphold related national interests).
In its deliberation, the MK asserted that the phrase in Article 22 (1) could indeed allow contractors to escape the obligation to contribute the required amount of oil and gas for state needs. The MK agreed that any insufficiency of oil and gas for Indonesian priorities would be a violation of Article 33 (3) of the 1945 Constitution. Instead of ensuring that the domestic demand for oil and gas resources would take priority, the MK viewed Article 22 (1) as simply setting a maximum allocation threshold - not a minimum allocation threshold as would be desired from the Law.
As such, it was decided that “at the maximum” be removed from the phrase, and that it be interpreted instead as simply: contractors must “provide 25%” of the proportion of annual oil and gas production for the domestic demand. Incidentally, the Law has never been amended - it has only been instructed to be interpreted in that fashion.
Failure to Provide 25 % for Domestic Necessities - Sanctioned?
Sanctions are often an issue with Indonesian regulation, and the subject of this inquiry - Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources Regulation No. 03 of 2010 to prioritize natural gas for domestic necessities - is no exception. Although its mandate is obligatory, as indicated by the word “shall,” the essential question is: what are the repercussions for not complying the requirement?
Article 22 (1) of the Oil and Gas Law (after MK interpretation) merely obligates that producers provide 25% of oil and gas production to the state, calling for further elaboration in the form of Government Regulation. The regulation in question is Government Regulation No. 35 of 2004, as amended lastly by Regulation No. 55 of 2009: neither bring clarity to the issue of whether a producer can be sanctioned for failing to meet their obligations.
The most that is provided by the Government Regulation is that the 25% production provision will be dictated under Production Sharing Contracts, or ‘KKS’. Since the state agency, BP Migas, negotiates those Sharing Contracts with prospective contractors, it can stipulate sanctions at that level - but it is not explicitly provided in the regulation what those sanctions should be or how they should be enforced. Lacking regulatory clarity, the consistency of sanction application relies on the largely ad hoc stipulations of BP Migas, and only during the process of contract negotiation.
Prioritized Sectors
Article 6 (3) of the regulation prioritizes 4 sectors for the distribution and utilization of natural gas: (1) increasing national oil and gas production; (2) the fertilizer industry; (3) electricity supplies, and; (4) other industries.
Importing Natural Gas
In the event that domestic natural gas demands cannot be fulfilled, Article 5 of the regulation grants the Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources authority to issue policy that would allow Indonesia to import natural gas. Although insufficient supplies are always a possibility, particularly given Indonesia’s engagement in long-term contracts, it is unlikely. According to Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources data for 2008, Indonesia’s natural gas reserves could reach 170.07 Trillion Cubic Feet (TCF): 112.47 TCF in proven reserves, and 57.6 TCF in potential reserves; collectively, the 13th largest reserve in the world.
Enforcement
The regulation has been in force since 27 January 2010.
Conclusion
In short, Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources Regulation No. 03 of 2010 restates the obligation of natural gas contractors to provide 25% of their annual production to the state, for the purposes of fulfilling domestic natural gas needs. Given the opaque, and indeed disputed nature of previous regulations, this may have been a prudent action.
The regulation goes on to detail the considerations that must be incorporated into any future Ministerial policies relating to upholding the national interest in protecting natural gas resources for the wellbeing of Indonesian citizens. It also clearly lists what sectors are prioritized for distribution of natural gas; sectors which together define ‘domestic necessities’. In the view of this inquiry, a subject for further regulation or amendment is the issue of sanctions, as they remain unclear and are left for BP Migas to determine during the contract negotiation stage.