It would appear that economic integration is one of the only things that can compel states in the Association of South East Asian Nations (ASEAN) to give up any inch of their sovereignty. In the interest of integrating markets, among other notable agreements and processes, ASEAN states agreed in 2003 to establish the ASEAN Economic Community (AEC) and implement the provisions of the AEC Blueprint by 2015. A critical aspect of the Blueprint, and indeed an express purpose of the AEC, is the integration of capital markets - ‘free capital flows throughout the region,’ as is often said. To that extent, clearing away ‘red tape’ that restricts or circumscribes foreign investment activity is essential, and one thing that must be streamlined is the ‘cross border public offering’.
Simply stated, a ‘public offering’ is when a company issues equity securities (i.e., stocks or shares) to the public, almost invariably by making the securities available on the public market, or stock exchange. A ‘cross border public offering’ is such that the securities are made available synonymously in two or more national stock exchanges; that kind of market integration requires coordination of policy, harmonized stock exchanges, effective supervisory institutions, and so on.
To date, the cross-border public offering has been a thing of myth in Southeast Asia; when a company wishes to be listed in two separate stock exchanges, it cannot do so simultaneously but rather must separately list stocks in each exchange - this is known as ‘cross listing’. Although there can actually be some benefits of that for an individual company (e.g., trading in different time zones), at the market level, it obstructs the free flow of capital, is thus restrictive of international investment activity, and has the final effect of acting as a systemic barrier to foreign participation in national stock exchanges.
After having time to digest the AEC Blueprint, and as it gets closer to 2015, Indonesia has grudgingly resolved itself to make the regulatory adjustments needed to integrate the domestic capital market into the ASEAN fold. This Indonesian Law Digest will briefly discuss the issues of implementation, and the initial steps that have been taken to the effect of preparation for market integration and cross-border public offerings thus far.
Implementation
In order to conduct any cross-border public offering, financial ‘infrastructure’ must be developed - harmonized stock exchange systems, aligned capital market regulations, and so on. In each ASEAN member state, the stock exchange operates according to different prevailing rules and regulations; unifying these systems under an AEC ‘umbrella’ exchange takes time, and extensive preparation.
Indonesia has indicated that it is not yet ready to integrate its capital market with others in ASEAN, and Bapepam-LK has communicated that this will continue to be the case until at least 2013. Considerations are likely to incorporate such concerns as: First, Indonesia’s capital markets are volatile; whether this would be helped, or hampered by regional integration is (despite convictions otherwise) a difficult thing to anticipate. Second, supervision and management has been an area of considerable issue; resolving domestic inconsistencies is likely the first priority. Third, aligning with the AEC Blueprint provisions (i.e., integrating with the regional capital market) is actually relatively voluntary, as it has not been ratified into Indonesian law - unlike the ASEAN-China Free Trade Area, which is relatively binding.
First Steps of Implementation
However, Fuad Rahmany, the Head of Bapepam-LK, has assured that although it will be difficult, there is an ongoing regulatory effort to prepare for ASEAN stock exchange integration and, more specifically, equip Indonesia for cross-border public offering. According to him, two draft regulations are being formulated to jumpstart the implementation of cross-border public offering: (1) Guidelines on the Form and Content of Public Offering Prospectus of Equity Securities, and; (2) Guidelines on the Form and Content of Public Offering Prospectus of Debt Securities.
The drafts of these regulations are available for public dissemination on the Bapepam-LK website, http://www.bapepam.go.id/. The public has been given three weeks since 20 January 2010 to provide their input, and on 18 February 2010, the comments will be compiled and discussed in detail by Bapepam-LK, along with experts and stakeholders if necessary.
Although the two draft regulations are far from what is necessary to harmonize stock markets and facilitate cross-border public offering, they at least lay a foundation for subsequent regulation. For the most part, they articulate details around ‘prospectus’ - legal documents required to ‘go public’ (i.e., conduct an initial public offering). They regulate what must be written in the prospectus, the format, the necessary disclosures, and so on.
Although similar in most respects to the previous regulation on the subject, Head of Bapepam-LK Decision No. Kep-51/PM/1996 on Guidelines for the Form and Content of Public Offering Prospectus, the drafts make a few departures from the regulatory predecessor: (1) they separately regulate ‘equity securities’ (e.g., stocks, shares) and ‘debt securities (e.g., bonds, deposits, notes), and; (2) include additional clauses on cross-border public offerings.
As with the previous regulation, prospectus documents must disclose information about the supervision of the company: how it manages itself, what is internally regulated, and so on. Cross-border public offerings require additional disclosures, which among other things include: (1) the name of the organ that is equivalent to ‘Board of Directors,’ and listing of those related individuals; (2) a review of the home-country regulations that may effect the import or export of capital, or the payment of dividends, yields, or other types of payments, and; (3) disclosure of the risks investors may face due to tax differences and different home-country laws regarding dispute settlement. Additionally, financial reports must be conducted in accordance with either International Financial Reporting Standards, or International Accounting Standards.
Benefits
To the extent that establishing the financial infrastructure for cross-border public offering will open greater access to foreign financiers, it is hoped that the process of capital market integration will benefit Indonesia’s domestic industries. Being able to synonymously list public offerings in stock markets across ASEAN will certainly cut transaction costs for both investors and issuers of securities alike, and encourage the free movement of capital throughout Southeast Asia. Meanwhile, it provides investors more venues to exploit their capital. By dismantling the market barriers, it is hoped that member states and the region as a whole will be able to attract and move around the kind of capital needed for robust economic development.
Drawbacks
As with any economic policy, there will be (many) trade-offs to consider with cross-border public offerings. Chief amongst the concerns is that, although it is hoped that it will attract foreign equity participation in the Indonesian economy, the opposite - capital flight - is also possible. If one ASEAN state’s stock exchange offers more attractive facilities, deals, transaction costs, or other services, it is likely that investors will invest (i.e., move their capital) accordingly.
Mas Achmad Daniri, former President Director of the Jakarta Stock Exchange (now the Indonesian Stock Exchange), has called for swift action on the part of the government and Bapepam-LK to develop market efficiency in Indonesia. That, he says, is the principal determinant of Indonesia’s success in ASEAN market integration; any potential issues caused by cross-border public offering and market integration will be cosmetic symptoms of the core failure to develop domestic market efficiency. According to Mr. Daniri, ‘market efficiency’ includes legal certainty - well-tailored regulations, increased supervision, law enforcement, and so on - and commitment to Good Corporate Governance principles on the part of issuers of any securities (Pasar Modal ASEAN Jangan Merugikan, Kompas, 25 March 2009).
Conclusion
At least if all the member states comply, within 5 years it is a certainty that ASEAN member states will have integrated stock exchanges administered under one system, one mechanism, and perhaps one umbrella regulation. The AEC Blueprint has mandated that member states structurally prepare their capital markets for the adjustment in 2015.
Although the initial years since 2003 have been characterized by feet-dragging, it appears that incremental preparations for ASEAN market integration are underway; a critical element of the preparations is to lay the groundwork for cross-border public offerings. This inquiry has assessed the last benchmark of regulatory preparations thus far: two draft regulations on prospectus documents for cross-border public offerings. This assessment concludes that they are simple, clean regulations that ensure any issuers of securities are disclosing all necessary information according to a standardized regimen. Although in themselves insufficient to affect the business-end operations of harmonized stock exchanges, they suggest that the Indonesian state has started to anticipate the integrated markets brought by the AEC and is preparing accordingly.
It would appear that economic integration is one of the only things that can compel states in the Association of South East Asian Nations (ASEAN) to give up any inch of their sovereignty. In the interest of integrating markets, among other notable agreements and processes, ASEAN states agreed in 2003 to establish the ASEAN Economic Community (AEC) and implement the provisions of the AEC Blueprint by 2015. A critical aspect of the Blueprint, and indeed an express purpose of the AEC, is the integration of capital markets - ‘free capital flows throughout the region,’ as is often said. To that extent, clearing away ‘red tape’ that restricts or circumscribes foreign investment activity is essential, and one thing that must be streamlined is the ‘cross border public offering’.
Simply stated, a ‘public offering’ is when a company issues equity securities (i.e., stocks or shares) to the public, almost invariably by making the securities available on the public market, or stock exchange. A ‘cross border public offering’ is such that the securities are made available synonymously in two or more national stock exchanges; that kind of market integration requires coordination of policy, harmonized stock exchanges, effective supervisory institutions, and so on.
To date, the cross-border public offering has been a thing of myth in Southeast Asia; when a company wishes to be listed in two separate stock exchanges, it cannot do so simultaneously but rather must separately list stocks in each exchange - this is known as ‘cross listing’. Although there can actually be some benefits of that for an individual company (e.g., trading in different time zones), at the market level, it obstructs the free flow of capital, is thus restrictive of international investment activity, and has the final effect of acting as a systemic barrier to foreign participation in national stock exchanges.
After having time to digest the AEC Blueprint, and as it gets closer to 2015, Indonesia has grudgingly resolved itself to make the regulatory adjustments needed to integrate the domestic capital market into the ASEAN fold. This Indonesian Law Digest will briefly discuss the issues of implementation, and the initial steps that have been taken to the effect of preparation for market integration and cross-border public offerings thus far.
Implementation
In order to conduct any cross-border public offering, financial ‘infrastructure’ must be developed - harmonized stock exchange systems, aligned capital market regulations, and so on. In each ASEAN member state, the stock exchange operates according to different prevailing rules and regulations; unifying these systems under an AEC ‘umbrella’ exchange takes time, and extensive preparation.
Indonesia has indicated that it is not yet ready to integrate its capital market with others in ASEAN, and Bapepam-LK has communicated that this will continue to be the case until at least 2013. Considerations are likely to incorporate such concerns as: First, Indonesia’s capital markets are volatile; whether this would be helped, or hampered by regional integration is (despite convictions otherwise) a difficult thing to anticipate. Second, supervision and management has been an area of considerable issue; resolving domestic inconsistencies is likely the first priority. Third, aligning with the AEC Blueprint provisions (i.e., integrating with the regional capital market) is actually relatively voluntary, as it has not been ratified into Indonesian law - unlike the ASEAN-China Free Trade Area, which is relatively binding.
First Steps of Implementation
However, Fuad Rahmany, the Head of Bapepam-LK, has assured that although it will be difficult, there is an ongoing regulatory effort to prepare for ASEAN stock exchange integration and, more specifically, equip Indonesia for cross-border public offering. According to him, two draft regulations are being formulated to jumpstart the implementation of cross-border public offering: (1) Guidelines on the Form and Content of Public Offering Prospectus of Equity Securities, and; (2) Guidelines on the Form and Content of Public Offering Prospectus of Debt Securities.
The drafts of these regulations are available for public dissemination on the Bapepam-LK website, http://www.bapepam.go.id/. The public has been given three weeks since 20 January 2010 to provide their input, and on 18 February 2010, the comments will be compiled and discussed in detail by Bapepam-LK, along with experts and stakeholders if necessary.
Although the two draft regulations are far from what is necessary to harmonize stock markets and facilitate cross-border public offering, they at least lay a foundation for subsequent regulation. For the most part, they articulate details around ‘prospectus’ - legal documents required to ‘go public’ (i.e., conduct an initial public offering). They regulate what must be written in the prospectus, the format, the necessary disclosures, and so on.
Although similar in most respects to the previous regulation on the subject, Head of Bapepam-LK Decision No. Kep-51/PM/1996 on Guidelines for the Form and Content of Public Offering Prospectus, the drafts make a few departures from the regulatory predecessor: (1) they separately regulate ‘equity securities’ (e.g., stocks, shares) and ‘debt securities (e.g., bonds, deposits, notes), and; (2) include additional clauses on cross-border public offerings.
As with the previous regulation, prospectus documents must disclose information about the supervision of the company: how it manages itself, what is internally regulated, and so on. Cross-border public offerings require additional disclosures, which among other things include: (1) the name of the organ that is equivalent to ‘Board of Directors,’ and listing of those related individuals; (2) a review of the home-country regulations that may effect the import or export of capital, or the payment of dividends, yields, or other types of payments, and; (3) disclosure of the risks investors may face due to tax differences and different home-country laws regarding dispute settlement. Additionally, financial reports must be conducted in accordance with either International Financial Reporting Standards, or International Accounting Standards.
Benefits
To the extent that establishing the financial infrastructure for cross-border public offering will open greater access to foreign financiers, it is hoped that the process of capital market integration will benefit Indonesia’s domestic industries. Being able to synonymously list public offerings in stock markets across ASEAN will certainly cut transaction costs for both investors and issuers of securities alike, and encourage the free movement of capital throughout Southeast Asia. Meanwhile, it provides investors more venues to exploit their capital. By dismantling the market barriers, it is hoped that member states and the region as a whole will be able to attract and move around the kind of capital needed for robust economic development.
Drawbacks
As with any economic policy, there will be (many) trade-offs to consider with cross-border public offerings. Chief amongst the concerns is that, although it is hoped that it will attract foreign equity participation in the Indonesian economy, the opposite - capital flight - is also possible. If one ASEAN state’s stock exchange offers more attractive facilities, deals, transaction costs, or other services, it is likely that investors will invest (i.e., move their capital) accordingly.
Mas Achmad Daniri, former President Director of the Jakarta Stock Exchange (now the Indonesian Stock Exchange), has called for swift action on the part of the government and Bapepam-LK to develop market efficiency in Indonesia. That, he says, is the principal determinant of Indonesia’s success in ASEAN market integration; any potential issues caused by cross-border public offering and market integration will be cosmetic symptoms of the core failure to develop domestic market efficiency. According to Mr. Daniri, ‘market efficiency’ includes legal certainty - well-tailored regulations, increased supervision, law enforcement, and so on - and commitment to Good Corporate Governance principles on the part of issuers of any securities (Pasar Modal ASEAN Jangan Merugikan, Kompas, 25 March 2009).
Conclusion
At least if all the member states comply, within 5 years it is a certainty that ASEAN member states will have integrated stock exchanges administered under one system, one mechanism, and perhaps one umbrella regulation. The AEC Blueprint has mandated that member states structurally prepare their capital markets for the adjustment in 2015.
Although the initial years since 2003 have been characterized by feet-dragging, it appears that incremental preparations for ASEAN market integration are underway; a critical element of the preparations is to lay the groundwork for cross-border public offerings. This inquiry has assessed the last benchmark of regulatory preparations thus far: two draft regulations on prospectus documents for cross-border public offerings. This assessment concludes that they are simple, clean regulations that ensure any issuers of securities are disclosing all necessary information according to a standardized regimen. Although in themselves insufficient to affect the business-end operations of harmonized stock exchanges, they suggest that the Indonesian state has started to anticipate the integrated markets brought by the AEC and is preparing accordingly.