Education: Indonesia's Newest Field of Investment

Overview

Despite being met by considerable resistance, the Indonesian government appears to maintain an uncompromising stance towards liberalizing the education sector, and has enacted laws that in a fixed matter of time will open schools to foreign and domestic investment. In fact, as a result of Law No. 20 of 2003 on the National Education System (the Sisdiknas Law) in conjunction with Law No. 9 of 2009 on Legal Education Entities (the ‘BHP’ Law), all schools will be made into ‘legal entities’, meaning they can go bankrupt, sue and be sued, and make decisions through agents. Given their legal entity status, the BHP Law additionally allows them to engage in investment and business activities

 

Predictably, the Laws have been the subject of more than one application for judicial review at the Constitutional Court in 2009. The state is obliged to provide and legally administer education according to Indonesia’s 1945 Constitution, and this causes no small dilemma for the Sisdiknas and BHP Laws, which effectively decentralize state management of the education system, and allow it to ration funding to schools - among other things that have raised Constitutional concerns.

 

Although in other settings it is not entirely uncommon for education services - particularly at the tertiary level - to be legally empowered in a similar manner, the extent of Indonesia’s liberalization of the entire sector is comparatively aggressive. As such, the questions prompting the current investigation are simply: What will Indonesia’s education legal reforms do, and why?

 

Liberalization of Education in Indonesia

The story begins with the Sisdiknas Law, the umbrella regulation passed by the House of Representatives (DPR) in 2003, which in Article 53 set out that all educational institutions must be established as a ‘Legal Education Entity’ or ‘BHP’. This includes public schools.   

 

In congruence with the mandate of Article 53(4) of the Sisdiknas Law, a subsequent implementing regulation was issued on 16 January 2009 to translate the BHP legal concept into reality: enter the BHP Law. According to Chapter XIII, all form of “formal education” service providers (i.e., schools) must convert to BHPs by 2014, with schools at each form - government-owned, regional-owned, and private schools - given different timeframes for their mandatory conversion. Schools established by the central and regional governments are given until 2012 to convert to BHPs, however schools established by private entities, such as foundation (yayasan), are given until 2014.

 

Governance and Management of BHPs

BHPs are essentially self-managed, although the government will continue to exercise a degree of curricular control at primary and secondary levels by way of standardized examinations. Since those exams determine who may progress to the next level of education, schools are incentivized to align their curriculums accordingly.

 

Management is broken down into two categories: (1) Stakeholders, who retain policy-making authority, and; (2) Education Management Organ, which is tasked with executive management of a BHP’s operations, and is essentially synonymous with ‘school principal and supporting managerial staff’. The first is considerably more complicated than the second, and this evaluation takes but a moment to investigate its meaning.

 

Stakeholders: Precious Little Details

Stakeholders at primary and secondary levels consist of: school founders, Education Management representative, support staff representative, teacher’s representative, and the school committee (i.e., parent) representative.

 

At the tertiary level, Stakeholders consist of: school founders, Education Management representative, support staff representative, community representative, educator’s representative, and non-academic audit representative. The educator representative speaks for the Educators Organ, which retains special rights to determine academic values, as well as supervise and manage the academic development, integrity, and independence of the school. Meanwhile, the non-academic audit representative speaks for the Non-Academic Audit Organ, which coordinates financial policy for the BHP and relates with external auditors.

 

Stakeholders ostensibly behave in a democratic fashion to determine such things as the annual budget, general policy, and long-term strategy. They also supervise and evaluate BHP operations, and disseminate reports from other organs and BHPs. There is precious little detail beyond what is listed here as to precisely which authorities are assigned to which Organs, how they are to work together, whether and what kind of additional parties (e.g., investors) may be included in the body, and how much can be arbitrarily decided in the BHP’s Articles of Association.

 

In the view of this evaluation, subsequent implementing regulation is needed to paint a clearer picture of BHP governance, particularly in the area of Stakeholder dynamics.

 

Investment in BHPs

Although the state is required to fully account for the operating costs of primary-level BHPs, it will only cover 1/3 of secondary-level costs, and 1/2 of tertiary-level costs. The state-imposed deficit effectively forces any school in the latter two categories to engage in profit-generating and / or fund-raising activities if it intends to have the resources to deliver a quality education.

 

Although pandering for funds from foreign donors is not explicitly provided by the BHP Law, Government Regulation No. 48 of 2008 on Education Funding allows foreigners to inject capital into a BHP. This is reinforced by Presidential Regulation No. 77 of 2007 on the Negative Investment List and Conditional Positive Investment List (as amended by Presidential Regulation No. 111 of 2007), which allows foreign and domestic investors to invest in BHPs.

 

According to the Conditional Positive Investment list, investors can maximally own a 49% share in a BHP, although the BHP Law does not make it clear how share ownership is to be measured - this requires attention in subsequent implementing regulation. Notably, the Negative / Positive Investment Regulation is now being revised, and there is talk that it will allow investors to own a majority share in a BHP; this also would require implementing regulation to specify what special authorities would befall to a majority shareholder.

 

To the extent that it uniformly applies to all forms of education service provision, the BHP Law standardizes the platform for injecting capital into education services. Foreign investment in Indonesia is - unless an exceptional situation is explicitly detailed by law - restricted to limited liability (‘PT’) entities. Many education services seeking to allow foreign financial participation established themselves as such. Meanwhile, as the education sector is - or at least in the past has been - widely regarded as a non-profit sector, many more services established themselves as foundations (yayasan). Given the sometimes-problematic differentiation, the BHP Law reconciles financial and legal aspects of education services to allow foreign and domestic financial participation on a standardized basis.

 

The BHP as a Corporation and Legal Entity

BHPs may themselves participate in investment, and on the other side of that equation, may also become bankrupt. According to Article 53 of the Sisdiknas Law and Artice 4 of the BHP Law, BHPs are bound by the ‘non-profit principle,’ and must engage in financing activities without being profit-oriented; all revenues must be used solely by the BHP for educational purposes.

 

Article 42 of the BHP Law allows tertiary-level BHPs to not only invest, but also engage in their own business (See: Elucidation of Article 42(1)). Article 43 mandates they first establish a separate legal entity - limited liability company, cooperative, and so on - through which to engage in business activity. However, no employees of the tertiary BHP may synonymously be employed by the subsidiary-business legal entity.

 

BHPs are granted the right to autonomously manage their own finances. BHPs established by central and regional governments - known alternatively by Bahasa Indonesia acronyms ‘BHPP’ and ‘BHPD’ respectively - also retain the right to determine their own financial needs. The Law guarantees that financial autonomy cannot be used to prevent qualified but financially-hindered individuals from being provided an education. The Law does not elaborate any supervisory or regulatory framework for how that guarantee will be guaranteed, and does not elucidate whether that guarantee obligates all BHPs to provide education to anyone who can justify their need for a particular level of schooling (in which case the existing education infrastructure would be overwhelmed).

 

Debate

Although it is perhaps possible that the BHP Law contains some sort of indwelling potential, it would have to be liberated by subsequent implementing regulation. That being said, the fundamental foundation or ‘principle’ of the Law is widely disputed.

 

Professor Dr. Sofian Effendi, a specialist in public policy, is apprehensive about the move to economically liberalize the education sector. He asserts that the paradigm of education will shift from promotion of learning to promotion of things that keep schools competitive in the field of commerce; a field which the education sector will become (Pendidikan Indonesia Akan Jadi Ladang Investor Asing, Suara Pembaruan Daily, 2007).

 

Professor Effendi agrees that regardless of the form it takes, there is great potential for education-sector expansion. He observes that 103 million Indonesians are in the common age range for primary to tertiary education. Of those, 24.8 million are in the common range for tertiary education, however less than 14% are enrolled: clearly there is a large unsatisfied demand. This means there is plenty of room for new foreign or domestic education providers to supply that demand.

 

One of Professor Effendi’s concerns, however, is: “if foreign education providers are allowed to establish [branches in Indonesia], then who would be responsible to provide the teachings of the national values, such as nationalism and the love of the country. Clearly this policy will have implications in the future to the people in the country.”  

 

Fitria Sunarto, who works for an NGO advocating for education on behalf of marginalized children (LAPAM), argues that the implementation of BHPs will cause education providers to prioritize financial concerns over the cultivation of critical thinking and intelligence. “Those who can go to school are only those who have high financial ability,” she pointed out. The BHP Law will only further stimulate that trend, she argued, in an interview with hukumonline last year (22/12): “Regardless of whether students are unintelligent or intelligent, what will matter are their financial abilities.”

 

The government predictably has done what it can to negate the criticism. Education Minister Mohammad Nuh reasoned that BHPs can be differentiated from other businesses due to the fact that they do not seek to turn a profit, but rather satisfy education-related demands; in other words, being bound by the non-profit principle, they operate on a different incentive structure. Any revenues gained from education-entity business-involvements are ‘bound to be’ returned into schools, used for the purposes of education provision, and enjoyed by students.

 

Although some consider the move to liberalize the education sector a method to absolve the state of its constitutional obligation to provide education, it is prudent to consider the situation to which the government responds: principally, the costs of substantially improving a clearly inadequate system. Opening the sector to foreign and domestic financial participation responds reasonably well to the immediate necessity of funding.

 

Although a great many Indonesians feel relieved of the Soeharto regime, it is the case that tertiary institutions since that time have experienced a general decline in quality, and the trend of financially-capable students going abroad for their tertiary education has increased from year to year. Funding is highly correlated with the quality of tertiary outputs, and it is the fuel upon which academic progress is based; this is readily evident in American universities, for example, which receive fabulous amounts of external investment. Moreover, the Sisdiknas and BHP Law’s fundamental objective is educational autonomy, and at the tertiary level - where academic progress is defined by intellectual departures - this autonomy is welcome.

 

This is not so much the case at earlier educational stages, however, where the fundamental objective is standardized, well-managed preparation for employment opportunities and tertiary intellectual exploration; quite the opposite. Meanwhile, although the engagement of primary and secondary schools in business activity is relatively innovative, the idea that a state public school could go bankrupt or be sued for an investment activity is essentially unheard of and quite problematic. These aspects of the BHP Law have been subject to particularly vocal opposition.

 

International Agreements

A secondary consideration is that the Laws come on the heels of international agreements to which Indonesia is treatise. Most notably, the 1995 General Agreement on Trade in Services (GATS), a World Trade Organization (WTO) agreement to which Indonesia is no exception.

 

Almost all service sectors - including education - fall under the GATS. In the December 2005 Hong Kong Round, Indonesia offered two education categories for liberalization: higher education services, and post-secondary technical and vocational education services (Sofian Effendi, Quality Transparency: Indonesia’s Approach Towards Cross Border Higher Education, 2005).

 

Although Indonesia is yet to ratify, as of 27 February 2009 it is also party to the ASEAN-Australia-New Zealand Free Trade Area (AANZFTA). Included in that is an agreement for the progressive liberalization of education, though Indonesia’s commitment is incremental at best. Indonesia’s Schedule of Commitments in Point II(5) of Annex 3 to the AANZFTA opens four education categories: technical and vocational secondary education services (electronic automotive); post secondary technical and vocational education services (poly-technic, machine, and electrical); adult educational services (language course and training) and; other education services (football and chess only).

 

Judicial Review

Overall, issue is regarded as so critical that opponents sought relieve at the Constitutional Court, or ‘MK’, not once but twice in 2009 (when the BHP Law was passed). Notably, the applicants in Case No. 21/PUU-VII/2009 sought to annul Article 53(1) of the Sisdiknas Law and the BHP Law as a whole. Among many of the arguments they provide, they maintain that the concept of a BHP renders education a market commodity, and - contrary to the Education Minister’s confidence otherwise - insist education providers will become profit-oriented. Both applications for judicial review were lodged in 2009, however the MK is yet to issue a decision on the matter.

 

Conclusion

Whether or not it is the so-called ‘correct approach’, the government certainly has an interest in overhauling the education system: education is the most direct method to produce a skilled and highly differentiated labor force as Indonesia sets out to consolidate its recent developmental trajectory towards a robust economy and developed nation. The government has clearly identified liberalization of the education sector as a positive step towards developing the national education system.

 

From that perspective, there are a number of mutually-reinforcing potential gains from the BHP Law. First, in order to improve the national education system as a whole, it is a method to open a flood-gate of funding into the system: this is clearly necessitated by Indonesia’s less than satisfactory education system as compared with international and even Southeast Asian averages. Second, it decreases the burden on the government of overhauling the system on its own. Third, to the extent that it relates to educational autonomy, it may considerably improve Indonesian universities, so long as the governance structure does not interfere with dynamics underpinning educator’s capacity to cultivate intellectual enrichment amongst themselves and students. Fourth, it satisfies Indonesia’s international obligations in full. Additionally, by opening the system to foreign and domestic external financing, it is an excellent method for corporations to satisfy their obligation of corporate social responsibility.

 

On the other hand, the aforementioned points paint a rosy picture, and there are many who take serious issue with the move. Although some of those views were presented in previous discussion, many points of debate escaped the scope of this evaluation. What is certain is that the public challenge to the Sisdiknas and BHP Laws has been taken to the highest juridical level, the Constitutional Court. The judicial review may result in aspects or the entirety of the law being repealed; only time will tell. Nevertheless, the government has in the past found strategic ways to work around decisions of that Court, and indeed seems intent on this course of action.

 

On the basis that this process will move forward, this evaluation concludes that a raft of implementing regulation is necessary to liberate any indwelling potential these Laws may have.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku

Overview

Despite being met by considerable resistance, the Indonesian government appears to maintain an uncompromising stance towards liberalizing the education sector, and has enacted laws that in a fixed matter of time will open schools to foreign and domestic investment. In fact, as a result of Law No. 20 of 2003 on the National Education System (the Sisdiknas Law) in conjunction with Law No. 9 of 2009 on Legal Education Entities (the ‘BHP’ Law), all schools will be made into ‘legal entities’, meaning they can go bankrupt, sue and be sued, and make decisions through agents. Given their legal entity status, the BHP Law additionally allows them to engage in investment and business activities

 

Predictably, the Laws have been the subject of more than one application for judicial review at the Constitutional Court in 2009. The state is obliged to provide and legally administer education according to Indonesia’s 1945 Constitution, and this causes no small dilemma for the Sisdiknas and BHP Laws, which effectively decentralize state management of the education system, and allow it to ration funding to schools - among other things that have raised Constitutional concerns.

 

Although in other settings it is not entirely uncommon for education services - particularly at the tertiary level - to be legally empowered in a similar manner, the extent of Indonesia’s liberalization of the entire sector is comparatively aggressive. As such, the questions prompting the current investigation are simply: What will Indonesia’s education legal reforms do, and why?

 

Liberalization of Education in Indonesia

The story begins with the Sisdiknas Law, the umbrella regulation passed by the House of Representatives (DPR) in 2003, which in Article 53 set out that all educational institutions must be established as a ‘Legal Education Entity’ or ‘BHP’. This includes public schools.   

 

In congruence with the mandate of Article 53(4) of the Sisdiknas Law, a subsequent implementing regulation was issued on 16 January 2009 to translate the BHP legal concept into reality: enter the BHP Law. According to Chapter XIII, all form of “formal education” service providers (i.e., schools) must convert to BHPs by 2014, with schools at each form - government-owned, regional-owned, and private schools - given different timeframes for their mandatory conversion. Schools established by the central and regional governments are given until 2012 to convert to BHPs, however schools established by private entities, such as foundation (yayasan), are given until 2014.

 

Governance and Management of BHPs

BHPs are essentially self-managed, although the government will continue to exercise a degree of curricular control at primary and secondary levels by way of standardized examinations. Since those exams determine who may progress to the next level of education, schools are incentivized to align their curriculums accordingly.

 

Management is broken down into two categories: (1) Stakeholders, who retain policy-making authority, and; (2) Education Management Organ, which is tasked with executive management of a BHP’s operations, and is essentially synonymous with ‘school principal and supporting managerial staff’. The first is considerably more complicated than the second, and this evaluation takes but a moment to investigate its meaning.

 

Stakeholders: Precious Little Details

Stakeholders at primary and secondary levels consist of: school founders, Education Management representative, support staff representative, teacher’s representative, and the school committee (i.e., parent) representative.

 

At the tertiary level, Stakeholders consist of: school founders, Education Management representative, support staff representative, community representative, educator’s representative, and non-academic audit representative. The educator representative speaks for the Educators Organ, which retains special rights to determine academic values, as well as supervise and manage the academic development, integrity, and independence of the school. Meanwhile, the non-academic audit representative speaks for the Non-Academic Audit Organ, which coordinates financial policy for the BHP and relates with external auditors.

 

Stakeholders ostensibly behave in a democratic fashion to determine such things as the annual budget, general policy, and long-term strategy. They also supervise and evaluate BHP operations, and disseminate reports from other organs and BHPs. There is precious little detail beyond what is listed here as to precisely which authorities are assigned to which Organs, how they are to work together, whether and what kind of additional parties (e.g., investors) may be included in the body, and how much can be arbitrarily decided in the BHP’s Articles of Association.

 

In the view of this evaluation, subsequent implementing regulation is needed to paint a clearer picture of BHP governance, particularly in the area of Stakeholder dynamics.

 

Investment in BHPs

Although the state is required to fully account for the operating costs of primary-level BHPs, it will only cover 1/3 of secondary-level costs, and 1/2 of tertiary-level costs. The state-imposed deficit effectively forces any school in the latter two categories to engage in profit-generating and / or fund-raising activities if it intends to have the resources to deliver a quality education.

 

Although pandering for funds from foreign donors is not explicitly provided by the BHP Law, Government Regulation No. 48 of 2008 on Education Funding allows foreigners to inject capital into a BHP. This is reinforced by Presidential Regulation No. 77 of 2007 on the Negative Investment List and Conditional Positive Investment List (as amended by Presidential Regulation No. 111 of 2007), which allows foreign and domestic investors to invest in BHPs.

 

According to the Conditional Positive Investment list, investors can maximally own a 49% share in a BHP, although the BHP Law does not make it clear how share ownership is to be measured - this requires attention in subsequent implementing regulation. Notably, the Negative / Positive Investment Regulation is now being revised, and there is talk that it will allow investors to own a majority share in a BHP; this also would require implementing regulation to specify what special authorities would befall to a majority shareholder.

 

To the extent that it uniformly applies to all forms of education service provision, the BHP Law standardizes the platform for injecting capital into education services. Foreign investment in Indonesia is - unless an exceptional situation is explicitly detailed by law - restricted to limited liability (‘PT’) entities. Many education services seeking to allow foreign financial participation established themselves as such. Meanwhile, as the education sector is - or at least in the past has been - widely regarded as a non-profit sector, many more services established themselves as foundations (yayasan). Given the sometimes-problematic differentiation, the BHP Law reconciles financial and legal aspects of education services to allow foreign and domestic financial participation on a standardized basis.

 

The BHP as a Corporation and Legal Entity

BHPs may themselves participate in investment, and on the other side of that equation, may also become bankrupt. According to Article 53 of the Sisdiknas Law and Artice 4 of the BHP Law, BHPs are bound by the ‘non-profit principle,’ and must engage in financing activities without being profit-oriented; all revenues must be used solely by the BHP for educational purposes.

 

Article 42 of the BHP Law allows tertiary-level BHPs to not only invest, but also engage in their own business (See: Elucidation of Article 42(1)). Article 43 mandates they first establish a separate legal entity - limited liability company, cooperative, and so on - through which to engage in business activity. However, no employees of the tertiary BHP may synonymously be employed by the subsidiary-business legal entity.

 

BHPs are granted the right to autonomously manage their own finances. BHPs established by central and regional governments - known alternatively by Bahasa Indonesia acronyms ‘BHPP’ and ‘BHPD’ respectively - also retain the right to determine their own financial needs. The Law guarantees that financial autonomy cannot be used to prevent qualified but financially-hindered individuals from being provided an education. The Law does not elaborate any supervisory or regulatory framework for how that guarantee will be guaranteed, and does not elucidate whether that guarantee obligates all BHPs to provide education to anyone who can justify their need for a particular level of schooling (in which case the existing education infrastructure would be overwhelmed).

 

Debate

Although it is perhaps possible that the BHP Law contains some sort of indwelling potential, it would have to be liberated by subsequent implementing regulation. That being said, the fundamental foundation or ‘principle’ of the Law is widely disputed.

 

Professor Dr. Sofian Effendi, a specialist in public policy, is apprehensive about the move to economically liberalize the education sector. He asserts that the paradigm of education will shift from promotion of learning to promotion of things that keep schools competitive in the field of commerce; a field which the education sector will become (Pendidikan Indonesia Akan Jadi Ladang Investor Asing, Suara Pembaruan Daily, 2007).

 

Professor Effendi agrees that regardless of the form it takes, there is great potential for education-sector expansion. He observes that 103 million Indonesians are in the common age range for primary to tertiary education. Of those, 24.8 million are in the common range for tertiary education, however less than 14% are enrolled: clearly there is a large unsatisfied demand. This means there is plenty of room for new foreign or domestic education providers to supply that demand.

 

One of Professor Effendi’s concerns, however, is: “if foreign education providers are allowed to establish [branches in Indonesia], then who would be responsible to provide the teachings of the national values, such as nationalism and the love of the country. Clearly this policy will have implications in the future to the people in the country.”  

 

Fitria Sunarto, who works for an NGO advocating for education on behalf of marginalized children (LAPAM), argues that the implementation of BHPs will cause education providers to prioritize financial concerns over the cultivation of critical thinking and intelligence. “Those who can go to school are only those who have high financial ability,” she pointed out. The BHP Law will only further stimulate that trend, she argued, in an interview with hukumonline last year (22/12): “Regardless of whether students are unintelligent or intelligent, what will matter are their financial abilities.”

 

The government predictably has done what it can to negate the criticism. Education Minister Mohammad Nuh reasoned that BHPs can be differentiated from other businesses due to the fact that they do not seek to turn a profit, but rather satisfy education-related demands; in other words, being bound by the non-profit principle, they operate on a different incentive structure. Any revenues gained from education-entity business-involvements are ‘bound to be’ returned into schools, used for the purposes of education provision, and enjoyed by students.

 

Although some consider the move to liberalize the education sector a method to absolve the state of its constitutional obligation to provide education, it is prudent to consider the situation to which the government responds: principally, the costs of substantially improving a clearly inadequate system. Opening the sector to foreign and domestic financial participation responds reasonably well to the immediate necessity of funding.

 

Although a great many Indonesians feel relieved of the Soeharto regime, it is the case that tertiary institutions since that time have experienced a general decline in quality, and the trend of financially-capable students going abroad for their tertiary education has increased from year to year. Funding is highly correlated with the quality of tertiary outputs, and it is the fuel upon which academic progress is based; this is readily evident in American universities, for example, which receive fabulous amounts of external investment. Moreover, the Sisdiknas and BHP Law’s fundamental objective is educational autonomy, and at the tertiary level - where academic progress is defined by intellectual departures - this autonomy is welcome.

 

This is not so much the case at earlier educational stages, however, where the fundamental objective is standardized, well-managed preparation for employment opportunities and tertiary intellectual exploration; quite the opposite. Meanwhile, although the engagement of primary and secondary schools in business activity is relatively innovative, the idea that a state public school could go bankrupt or be sued for an investment activity is essentially unheard of and quite problematic. These aspects of the BHP Law have been subject to particularly vocal opposition.

 

International Agreements

A secondary consideration is that the Laws come on the heels of international agreements to which Indonesia is treatise. Most notably, the 1995 General Agreement on Trade in Services (GATS), a World Trade Organization (WTO) agreement to which Indonesia is no exception.

 

Almost all service sectors - including education - fall under the GATS. In the December 2005 Hong Kong Round, Indonesia offered two education categories for liberalization: higher education services, and post-secondary technical and vocational education services (Sofian Effendi, Quality Transparency: Indonesia’s Approach Towards Cross Border Higher Education, 2005).

 

Although Indonesia is yet to ratify, as of 27 February 2009 it is also party to the ASEAN-Australia-New Zealand Free Trade Area (AANZFTA). Included in that is an agreement for the progressive liberalization of education, though Indonesia’s commitment is incremental at best. Indonesia’s Schedule of Commitments in Point II(5) of Annex 3 to the AANZFTA opens four education categories: technical and vocational secondary education services (electronic automotive); post secondary technical and vocational education services (poly-technic, machine, and electrical); adult educational services (language course and training) and; other education services (football and chess only).

 

Judicial Review

Overall, issue is regarded as so critical that opponents sought relieve at the Constitutional Court, or ‘MK’, not once but twice in 2009 (when the BHP Law was passed). Notably, the applicants in Case No. 21/PUU-VII/2009 sought to annul Article 53(1) of the Sisdiknas Law and the BHP Law as a whole. Among many of the arguments they provide, they maintain that the concept of a BHP renders education a market commodity, and - contrary to the Education Minister’s confidence otherwise - insist education providers will become profit-oriented. Both applications for judicial review were lodged in 2009, however the MK is yet to issue a decision on the matter.

 

Conclusion

Whether or not it is the so-called ‘correct approach’, the government certainly has an interest in overhauling the education system: education is the most direct method to produce a skilled and highly differentiated labor force as Indonesia sets out to consolidate its recent developmental trajectory towards a robust economy and developed nation. The government has clearly identified liberalization of the education sector as a positive step towards developing the national education system.

 

From that perspective, there are a number of mutually-reinforcing potential gains from the BHP Law. First, in order to improve the national education system as a whole, it is a method to open a flood-gate of funding into the system: this is clearly necessitated by Indonesia’s less than satisfactory education system as compared with international and even Southeast Asian averages. Second, it decreases the burden on the government of overhauling the system on its own. Third, to the extent that it relates to educational autonomy, it may considerably improve Indonesian universities, so long as the governance structure does not interfere with dynamics underpinning educator’s capacity to cultivate intellectual enrichment amongst themselves and students. Fourth, it satisfies Indonesia’s international obligations in full. Additionally, by opening the system to foreign and domestic external financing, it is an excellent method for corporations to satisfy their obligation of corporate social responsibility.

 

On the other hand, the aforementioned points paint a rosy picture, and there are many who take serious issue with the move. Although some of those views were presented in previous discussion, many points of debate escaped the scope of this evaluation. What is certain is that the public challenge to the Sisdiknas and BHP Laws has been taken to the highest juridical level, the Constitutional Court. The judicial review may result in aspects or the entirety of the law being repealed; only time will tell. Nevertheless, the government has in the past found strategic ways to work around decisions of that Court, and indeed seems intent on this course of action.

 

On the basis that this process will move forward, this evaluation concludes that a raft of implementing regulation is necessary to liberate any indwelling potential these Laws may have.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku
2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info