Copenhagen and Indonesia - The Climate Change Debate and the Future

Overview

 

Background

It is an understatement to suggest that all eyes will be on Copenhagen from 7 December 2009 as the latest installment of climate change talks get underway. The nations of the world will be gathering in an attempt to hammer out some kind of deal on climate change that will see nations take responsibility for the harm that they are doing to the globe and the irreparable damage that is set to be wrought on the environment and on our children and grandchildren, and their children. The purpose of the Copenhagen round of the UN Climate Change Conference is to put into place a deal that will succeed the Kyoto Protocol, which is set to end in 2012.

 

Climate Change - True Believers vs. The Skeptics

The interest in this conference is not only on what might be done, but it is equally on what will not be done during the course of the conference. The reality is that there are still considerable numbers of people out there in the world that are best described as climate change skeptics, some might argue that they are no longer skeptics but ‘deniers’. Simply, they remain unconvinced of the science, and as such do not see the need to tie themselves or their nations into long term “climate deals” where the ‘funky’ science, at least in their minds, does not warrant a global response.

 

Those that support a climate change deal, and who fully expect to see a deal struck in Copenhagen, argue that climate change is a problem that the world cannot afford to sit back on and adopt a ‘wait and see’ approach. The argument of these individuals is that when it becomes even clearer that climate change is real, it will be too late to achieve any significant or fundamental change that will save the world for the damage done.

 

Best and Worst Case Scenarios

Best case scenario is that an ambitious, far-reaching, and effective deal will be struck in Copenhagen. The best case scenario is considered a real possibility because the world can no longer sit back and watch the disaster of climate change unfold. The disasters that are sure to take center stage are those that involve low-lying islands disappearing under rising sea levels; places like Kirabati and the Maldives. Some of the governments of these low-lying islands are so committed to striking a climate change deal that they have taken the opportunity to hold underwater parliamentary sessions to highlight that in the not too distant future they will have no land left to meet on.

 

The real fear seems to be that inaction is tantamount to signing a global death warrant for the world. Fundamentally, inaction will be the death of us all. It must be noted that not all are ‘true’ believers of the worst case scenario and as such do not feel as compelled to sign off on anything that is put forward at Copenhagen. The cold hard reality of politics on the international scale is that it is not completely independent of the national scale. Most leaders and representatives making an appearance in Copenhagen must also consider that once the conference is done that they have to return ‘home’ and face their constituents. So, the reality is that despite a solid global movement in support of climate change, a deal might not be as easy to come by as many would have us believe. Indonesia is not exception to this international / national dichotomy.

 

Is it all just Carbon Footprints, Emission Trading, and Carbon Markets

The challenge that all governments face is going to be how they make the changes pay. Climate change is more than just carbon footprints and emission trading schemes, and the creation of a carbon market. It is about changing individual choices one individual at a time. The reality is that it is not necessarily the governments that contribute to global warming or climate change, however, it is clearly a responsibility that falls to governments to regulate their collective citizens to participate in change.

 

For a nation such as Indonesia, the truth of climate change is even more pronounced being an archipelagic nation. President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono or SBY, and perhaps all nations’ leaders in the world over, suggested that the conference “must reach consensus for the sake of our planet and for the future of humanity,” according to him when speaking at the United Nations Summit on Climate Change in New York (22/9).

 

This suggests that Indonesia believes that the climate of the globe is changing and that these impacts have the potential to be catastrophic over the long-term, however, the key question that must be asked and answered by all nations, Indonesia included, is can they afford to participate in any initiative aimed at saving the planet that might come out of the Copenhagen conference.

 

Stumbling Blocks

One of the biggest stumbling blocks is most likely going to be that the cost of change is going to outweigh the ability to sell those changes on the national front. The stumbling block is that developed nations are undoubtedly going to baulk at the need to help fund the change by subsidizing developing nations while simultaneously agreeing to reduce their own emissions and the size of their carbon footprints. In essence, a double whammy; driving change and paying in full for that change at the same time.

 

Nevertheless, a fundamental truth is that developing nations will also baulk at signing onto any new protocol or deal if that deal means that there will be negative impacts upon their collective abilities to drive economic development or to fight entrenched poverty in their respective nations.

 

The art of the deal is certainly going to be tested during this round in Copenhagen.

 

The Copenhagen Conference

Targets Expected from the Conference in Copenhagen

The UN Climate Change Conference, which will be held from 7 - 18 December 2009, is, as Yvo de Boer puts it, “the historic turning point in the fight against climate change.” Last week at the UNFCCC Press Briefing in Bonn, Germany (25/11), Mr. de Boer, the UNFCCC Executive Secretary, addressed the recipes for success of the Copenhagen Conference.

 

There are three main points that should be done, he explained. These points comprise of the following matters:

1.

The conference must record in black and white four essential sets of country commitments:

 

a.

Industrialized countries must set ambitious targets to reduce emissions;

 

b.

Clarity on the scope and extent of the developing world’s engagement in the fight against climate change;

 

c.

Clarity on short and long term finance to support developing world mitigation (action taken to permanently eliminate or reduce the long-term risk and hazards of climate change to human life and property) and adaptation (the ability of a system to adjust to climate change, to moderate potential damage, to take advantage of opportunities, or to cope with the consequences), and;

 

d.

The conference must provide clarity on how to deploy this money with respect to developing countries needs and in some form of priority;

2.

Copenhagen can and must deliver an agreement that launches immediate action in developing countries to adapt to the impact of climate change, start to put themselves on a clean energy path, get the technology to do that, and build up their skills to deal with all of these, and it also needs to launch immediate international cooperation to preserve and sustain forests, and;

3.

All countries must use all the remaining eleven days in Copenhagen to work towards these aims in the spirit of cooperation and compromise.

 

The driving motivation to reach a deal is clearly the fact that the Kyoto Protocol is set to expire. And, any failure in Copenhagen to reach a deal in essence means that the world will be left in some kind of climate change limbo with no constructive agreement in place as to how the world is to cooperate on addressing the matter of climate change.

 

This is undoubtedly not the optimal outcome if nations are generally in agreement that the world must address the sustainability of human life on this planet over the short, medium, and long terms. The possibility of the climate change initiatives coming to an end after the first phase of what is evidently a multi-phase endeavour will make re-starting the climate change debate at some time, or conference in the future that much more difficult.

 

Another Protocol?

There are several proposals on what legal form will the contracted “deal” be codified, although this will not be dealt-with before the main discussion of the conference has been addressed and reached a consensus. These include (1) an amended Kyoto Protocol, (2) a new protocol, (3) a set of individual decisions on how to tackle climate change immediately and post 2012, or (4) a combination of these options.

 

United States and Reluctance to Commit

To this date, there are several major industrialized countries that have not ratified the Kyoto Protocol, and the United States amongst them. The U.S.’s reluctance has been largely driven by economic reasons. It argues that by signing and adopting the Protocol’s text into its laws, it would mean that the States have to cut their emissions in which will most likely hit its industrial sector, among many others.

 

Nonetheless, the U.S. has recently shifted its firm stance and promised to cut its emission by 17 percent. The pledge has been seen as a signal of cooperation by the U.S. Yet, the U.S. pledge is still not enough; the pledge of reducing 17 percents of its GHGs does not match up to the level of “ambitious” indicated as being necessary by climate change science. To this end, Mr. de Boer had called the U.S., and other industrialized nations, to “give a final push with ambitious leadership.”

 

Given that this ambitious commitment, and also other commitments as set out earlier, has not reached the expected objectives, where emissions continue to rise at their current pace and are allowed to double from their pre-industrial level, all nations are likely to endure what the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) noted:

 

“That…the world will face an average temperature rise of around 3°C this century. Serious impacts are associated with this scenario, including sea-level rise, shifts in growing seasons, and an increasing frequency and intensity of extreme weather events such as storms, floods and droughts.”

 

Impacts on Indonesia

These impacts might not appear to have any significant impact on Indonesian business on their face. However, increasing numbers of natural disasters in Indonesia have tended to focus issues relating to the changing climate in the minds of many ordinary Indonesians. Nevertheless, it must also be noted that while people are dealing with natural disasters that conceivably can be attributed to climate change, such as rising sea levels, there is also a commensurate drop off in productivity. Decreasing productivity will have a significant negative impact on Indonesia’s ability to continue its drive towards full economic development and plans to reduce, and ultimately eradicate, poverty.

 

The changing climatic conditions are also going to have a severe impact on Indonesia’s ability to be self-sustaining, particularly if there are significant climate changes that alter agricultural production. It is abundantly clear that masses of hungry and poor people are going to be a burden not only on Indonesia, but on all nations. There is a very obvious possibility that climate change, if not dealt with sooner rather than later, has the potential to cause considerable instability, political and social, in most countries.

 

Some of these factors where driving forces in Indonesia’s ultimate decision to sign off on the Kyoto Protocol, and ultimately ratify it as Law No. 17 of 2004.

 

Conclusion

Copenhagen is an important next step. Any agreement or lack thereof will be a clear indication of the future direction of climate change debate. So, it is within this framework that it is worth reconsidering a statement from SBY, “We can negotiate about the climate, but we cannot negotiate with the climate. We cannot ask the climate for more time.”

 

Perhaps the final word belongs to Mr. de Boer, “There is no plan B for Copenhagen, only plan A and plan A stands for action”.

 

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku

Overview

 

Background

It is an understatement to suggest that all eyes will be on Copenhagen from 7 December 2009 as the latest installment of climate change talks get underway. The nations of the world will be gathering in an attempt to hammer out some kind of deal on climate change that will see nations take responsibility for the harm that they are doing to the globe and the irreparable damage that is set to be wrought on the environment and on our children and grandchildren, and their children. The purpose of the Copenhagen round of the UN Climate Change Conference is to put into place a deal that will succeed the Kyoto Protocol, which is set to end in 2012.

 

Climate Change - True Believers vs. The Skeptics

The interest in this conference is not only on what might be done, but it is equally on what will not be done during the course of the conference. The reality is that there are still considerable numbers of people out there in the world that are best described as climate change skeptics, some might argue that they are no longer skeptics but ‘deniers’. Simply, they remain unconvinced of the science, and as such do not see the need to tie themselves or their nations into long term “climate deals” where the ‘funky’ science, at least in their minds, does not warrant a global response.

 

Those that support a climate change deal, and who fully expect to see a deal struck in Copenhagen, argue that climate change is a problem that the world cannot afford to sit back on and adopt a ‘wait and see’ approach. The argument of these individuals is that when it becomes even clearer that climate change is real, it will be too late to achieve any significant or fundamental change that will save the world for the damage done.

 

Best and Worst Case Scenarios

Best case scenario is that an ambitious, far-reaching, and effective deal will be struck in Copenhagen. The best case scenario is considered a real possibility because the world can no longer sit back and watch the disaster of climate change unfold. The disasters that are sure to take center stage are those that involve low-lying islands disappearing under rising sea levels; places like Kirabati and the Maldives. Some of the governments of these low-lying islands are so committed to striking a climate change deal that they have taken the opportunity to hold underwater parliamentary sessions to highlight that in the not too distant future they will have no land left to meet on.

 

The real fear seems to be that inaction is tantamount to signing a global death warrant for the world. Fundamentally, inaction will be the death of us all. It must be noted that not all are ‘true’ believers of the worst case scenario and as such do not feel as compelled to sign off on anything that is put forward at Copenhagen. The cold hard reality of politics on the international scale is that it is not completely independent of the national scale. Most leaders and representatives making an appearance in Copenhagen must also consider that once the conference is done that they have to return ‘home’ and face their constituents. So, the reality is that despite a solid global movement in support of climate change, a deal might not be as easy to come by as many would have us believe. Indonesia is not exception to this international / national dichotomy.

 

Is it all just Carbon Footprints, Emission Trading, and Carbon Markets

The challenge that all governments face is going to be how they make the changes pay. Climate change is more than just carbon footprints and emission trading schemes, and the creation of a carbon market. It is about changing individual choices one individual at a time. The reality is that it is not necessarily the governments that contribute to global warming or climate change, however, it is clearly a responsibility that falls to governments to regulate their collective citizens to participate in change.

 

For a nation such as Indonesia, the truth of climate change is even more pronounced being an archipelagic nation. President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono or SBY, and perhaps all nations’ leaders in the world over, suggested that the conference “must reach consensus for the sake of our planet and for the future of humanity,” according to him when speaking at the United Nations Summit on Climate Change in New York (22/9).

 

This suggests that Indonesia believes that the climate of the globe is changing and that these impacts have the potential to be catastrophic over the long-term, however, the key question that must be asked and answered by all nations, Indonesia included, is can they afford to participate in any initiative aimed at saving the planet that might come out of the Copenhagen conference.

 

Stumbling Blocks

One of the biggest stumbling blocks is most likely going to be that the cost of change is going to outweigh the ability to sell those changes on the national front. The stumbling block is that developed nations are undoubtedly going to baulk at the need to help fund the change by subsidizing developing nations while simultaneously agreeing to reduce their own emissions and the size of their carbon footprints. In essence, a double whammy; driving change and paying in full for that change at the same time.

 

Nevertheless, a fundamental truth is that developing nations will also baulk at signing onto any new protocol or deal if that deal means that there will be negative impacts upon their collective abilities to drive economic development or to fight entrenched poverty in their respective nations.

 

The art of the deal is certainly going to be tested during this round in Copenhagen.

 

The Copenhagen Conference

Targets Expected from the Conference in Copenhagen

The UN Climate Change Conference, which will be held from 7 - 18 December 2009, is, as Yvo de Boer puts it, “the historic turning point in the fight against climate change.” Last week at the UNFCCC Press Briefing in Bonn, Germany (25/11), Mr. de Boer, the UNFCCC Executive Secretary, addressed the recipes for success of the Copenhagen Conference.

 

There are three main points that should be done, he explained. These points comprise of the following matters:

1.

The conference must record in black and white four essential sets of country commitments:

 

a.

Industrialized countries must set ambitious targets to reduce emissions;

 

b.

Clarity on the scope and extent of the developing world’s engagement in the fight against climate change;

 

c.

Clarity on short and long term finance to support developing world mitigation (action taken to permanently eliminate or reduce the long-term risk and hazards of climate change to human life and property) and adaptation (the ability of a system to adjust to climate change, to moderate potential damage, to take advantage of opportunities, or to cope with the consequences), and;

 

d.

The conference must provide clarity on how to deploy this money with respect to developing countries needs and in some form of priority;

2.

Copenhagen can and must deliver an agreement that launches immediate action in developing countries to adapt to the impact of climate change, start to put themselves on a clean energy path, get the technology to do that, and build up their skills to deal with all of these, and it also needs to launch immediate international cooperation to preserve and sustain forests, and;

3.

All countries must use all the remaining eleven days in Copenhagen to work towards these aims in the spirit of cooperation and compromise.

 

The driving motivation to reach a deal is clearly the fact that the Kyoto Protocol is set to expire. And, any failure in Copenhagen to reach a deal in essence means that the world will be left in some kind of climate change limbo with no constructive agreement in place as to how the world is to cooperate on addressing the matter of climate change.

 

This is undoubtedly not the optimal outcome if nations are generally in agreement that the world must address the sustainability of human life on this planet over the short, medium, and long terms. The possibility of the climate change initiatives coming to an end after the first phase of what is evidently a multi-phase endeavour will make re-starting the climate change debate at some time, or conference in the future that much more difficult.

 

Another Protocol?

There are several proposals on what legal form will the contracted “deal” be codified, although this will not be dealt-with before the main discussion of the conference has been addressed and reached a consensus. These include (1) an amended Kyoto Protocol, (2) a new protocol, (3) a set of individual decisions on how to tackle climate change immediately and post 2012, or (4) a combination of these options.

 

United States and Reluctance to Commit

To this date, there are several major industrialized countries that have not ratified the Kyoto Protocol, and the United States amongst them. The U.S.’s reluctance has been largely driven by economic reasons. It argues that by signing and adopting the Protocol’s text into its laws, it would mean that the States have to cut their emissions in which will most likely hit its industrial sector, among many others.

 

Nonetheless, the U.S. has recently shifted its firm stance and promised to cut its emission by 17 percent. The pledge has been seen as a signal of cooperation by the U.S. Yet, the U.S. pledge is still not enough; the pledge of reducing 17 percents of its GHGs does not match up to the level of “ambitious” indicated as being necessary by climate change science. To this end, Mr. de Boer had called the U.S., and other industrialized nations, to “give a final push with ambitious leadership.”

 

Given that this ambitious commitment, and also other commitments as set out earlier, has not reached the expected objectives, where emissions continue to rise at their current pace and are allowed to double from their pre-industrial level, all nations are likely to endure what the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) noted:

 

“That…the world will face an average temperature rise of around 3°C this century. Serious impacts are associated with this scenario, including sea-level rise, shifts in growing seasons, and an increasing frequency and intensity of extreme weather events such as storms, floods and droughts.”

 

Impacts on Indonesia

These impacts might not appear to have any significant impact on Indonesian business on their face. However, increasing numbers of natural disasters in Indonesia have tended to focus issues relating to the changing climate in the minds of many ordinary Indonesians. Nevertheless, it must also be noted that while people are dealing with natural disasters that conceivably can be attributed to climate change, such as rising sea levels, there is also a commensurate drop off in productivity. Decreasing productivity will have a significant negative impact on Indonesia’s ability to continue its drive towards full economic development and plans to reduce, and ultimately eradicate, poverty.

 

The changing climatic conditions are also going to have a severe impact on Indonesia’s ability to be self-sustaining, particularly if there are significant climate changes that alter agricultural production. It is abundantly clear that masses of hungry and poor people are going to be a burden not only on Indonesia, but on all nations. There is a very obvious possibility that climate change, if not dealt with sooner rather than later, has the potential to cause considerable instability, political and social, in most countries.

 

Some of these factors where driving forces in Indonesia’s ultimate decision to sign off on the Kyoto Protocol, and ultimately ratify it as Law No. 17 of 2004.

 

Conclusion

Copenhagen is an important next step. Any agreement or lack thereof will be a clear indication of the future direction of climate change debate. So, it is within this framework that it is worth reconsidering a statement from SBY, “We can negotiate about the climate, but we cannot negotiate with the climate. We cannot ask the climate for more time.”

 

Perhaps the final word belongs to Mr. de Boer, “There is no plan B for Copenhagen, only plan A and plan A stands for action”.

 

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku
2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info