Amendment to the Fisheries Law

Overview

For an archipelagic nation like Indonesia the need for strong maritime and fishing laws if a foregone conclusion as a simple necessity in terms of being able to protect and manage a vast array of ocean-based resources. Therefore, it is also not surprising that the government has deemed it necessary to update the 2004 law on fisheries to reflect current trends and needs. To this end, the government has sort to reinforce its commitment to the fisheries sector and Indonesian fishermen through the amendment to Law No. 31 of 2004 on Fisheries.

 

The Amended Law, Law No. 45 of 2009, includes amendments that have been enacted with a view to driving sustainable growth in the fisheries industry while simultaneously protecting Indonesia and Indonesians from the threat of illegal, unreported, and unregulated fishing practices. Indonesia is not only the victim of illegal fishing but it also acknowledges that Indonesians are perpetrators of illegal fishing operations in the waters of other sovereign states in the region.

 

Purpose

Nevertheless, the purpose of this amended law is not only to ensure that Indonesia is more stringent in the policing of its own waters for illegal fishermen from other states, but to ensure that there is more effective and efficient law enforcement against Indonesians breaching the provisions of the prevailing laws with respect to failing to report commercial catches or fishing in ways that rapidly deplete reserves or exclude small-scale fishermen from the benefits of Indonesia maritime resources.

 

International Considerations

The Law and the amended Law rely on the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea 1982 (UNCLOS) and the determination of Indonesia’s Exclusive Economic Zones (EEZ) to set out the international dimensions of how far and wide the scope of this law and its amendments extend.

 

Issues of Contention

Aside from the above objectives, it is worth noting that the legislation was the final piece of legislation passed by the 2004 - 2009 House of Representatives (Dewan Perwakilan Rakyat / DPR). This in itself has been the source of a little contention as some have claimed that the DPR forced the legislation through just to get it done. The implication being that the bill still needed further perfection before going to the requisite plenary session for a vote on passage. Nevertheless, what is done is done, and the bill has become law.

 

Despite the good intentions of the parliament in passing this piece of legislation into law there are clearly unresolved issues with respect to the effectiveness of this piece of legislation. The primary concern relates to that there is a significant amount of subsidiary legislation that is required to give force to the provisions of the Law. These subsidiary pieces of legislation have not been fully drafted. Furthermore, the Department of Maritime Resources and Fisheries is still socializing the Law amongst the major stakeholders.

 

Subsidiary Legislation

Even so, the government has a period of 12 months from the date of enactment of this law to put into place all the necessary subsidiary legislation.

 

National Development

The basic premise of the amended law is that fishing can be a key driver in national development; economic, social, and cultural. The amended law focuses more effective regulation of the sector, particularly the bigger fishers, while simultaneously opening up opportunities for small-scale fishermen and fish farmers. The opportunities envisaged for the small-scale fishermen and fish farmers are dependent on freeing up the regulatory framework for them, but not forsaking management of available fish stocks or the maritime environment.

 

Substance

Generally, the law deals with 4 specific matters:

1.

Fisheries management;

2.

Providing favorable treatment to local small-scale fishermen and small fish cultivation farmers;

3.

Expansion of the fisheries courts’ jurisdiction to include all relevant areas within the country; and

4.

Supervision and legal enforcement (inclusive of sanctions and jurisdictional issues).

 

Principles Underpinning the Law

For example, fisheries management stipulates 11 principles that are to apply, these include:

 

Use

Partnership

Efficient

Fairness

Independence

Integrated

Equality

Sustainable Development

Preservation

Transparency

Allocation

 

 

These principles are then each individually further enumerated in the Elucidation. For example, use is defined as whatever activities undertaken with respect to fishing are to be done so with a view to ensuring the maximum benefit to the maximum number of Indonesian citizens in terms of raising the prosperity and welfare of the community as a whole.

 

The definition of partnership is designed to highlight the relationship between the exploiters of the fish stocks and the fish stocks themselves. The key here is that the law recognizes that fish stocks are sustainable, but without proper management these same fish stocks will become unsustainable and over-fishing is a real possibility. Therefore, partnership is all about ensuring proportionality.

 

The idea of sustainability is further defined in the final point of Article 2 at (k) to mean managing the resources that exist with a view to ensuring that the greatest benefit is derived not only in the present but that these reserves / resources continue to provide benefit long into the future.

 

But, the key to sustainable management and development is always going to be the successful implementation and subsequent application of an enforcement regime. The issues of enforcement are to be dealt with in the succeeding paragraphs.

 

Policy

In addition to enforcement, a key element of any successful law is sound policy. Sound policy requires an accurate inventory of fishing resources in this instance in order to ensure that the policy is based on ‘real’ conditions as they stand now and not some fanciful set of circumstances that may have been true in 2004 or at some other point in the distant past.

 

Therefore, Article 7 has been amended to ensure that the policy considerations are reflective of current circumstances. The amended law mandates that the minister revisit the issue of a fisheries plan and take an inventory of current resources to facilitate accurate and proper allocations of fishing quotas, for example. The plane must also address matters related to protected zones (sanctuaries) and types and species of fish that are protected, and types and species of fish that are to be introduced for farming or cultivation purposes.

 

With respect to catch limits, the minister is to consider recommendations forwarded by the National Commission tasked with taking the inventory of current fish stocks. It is expected that the minister will follow those recommendations. Nevertheless, the National Commission is one that is to be established by the minister and it is to contain recognized experts in the field.

 

Once the fisheries plan has been compiled and confirmed, then there will be obligations on all those involved in the sector and related industries to ensure that they comply with the objectives of that plan as they are codified in law. For instance, not to fish in sanctuary zones or catch fish out of season.

 

Prohibited Fishing Techniques

The amended law also sets out specific fishing techniques that are outlawed. The focus of the prohibitions is on techniques that are likely to lead to rapid overfishing and the indiscriminate catching of fish and other sea creatures. The elucidations specifically mention trawling (large trawl nets / pukat harimau) and the use of compressors. These techniques are to be further regulated in Ministerial Regulation as required.

 

Fish Farming / Cultivation

The government has recognized that as an archipelagic state that the potential for fish farming and cultivation is high. The law did not deal with this in specific or sufficient detail to be effective. Therefore, the amended law seeks to rectify this deficiency. To ensure that the potential is realized the government is to set out matters relating to quality control and fish cultures that are to be cultivated.

 

In light of the movement over the past decade to greater regional autonomy, the amendments to the law set out specific responsibilities for regional governments in the management and promotion of fishing and fisheries in their respective jurisdictions. Article 18 has been amended to state that regional governments are to be responsible for implementation of programs geared towards exploiting regional maritime resources and areas that are to be subject to cultivation. Unfortunately, this provision is to be further regulated by government regulation. Therefore, it remains to be seen as to how extensive these regional authorities are to be.

 

It is worth noting that Article 23 has been amended with the insertion of an additional paragraph. This paragraph places a positive obligation on the government to socialize what materials, food stuffs, and other assistance may and may not be used in the cultivation of fish. The law sets out in explicit terms that substances dangerous to humans may not be used in the cultivation process.

 

Licensing

The amendments to the Law explicitly require those that own and operate fishing vessels bearing the Indonesian flag to be licensed. This license is a Fishing License (Surat Izin Penangkapan Ikan / SIPI). However, the Law clearly exempts small scale fishing vessel operators from the need to hold a SIPI. Furthermore, the Law also exempts small scale fishing vessel operators and small scale fish farmers from the need to hold a Fishing Vessel License (Surat Izin Kapal Penangkapan Ikan / SIKPI). It must be noted, that those that are required to hold these licenses are also required to be in possession of the originals at all times when fishing.

 

Article 28A provides explicit prohibitions on the falsifying of fishing license documents.

 

Interestingly, the Law requires that Indonesian-flagged fishing vessels must also use an Indonesian captain and crew. There are administrative sanctions for failure to comply with this provision.

 

Fisheries Court

The amended Law expands the jurisdiction of the Fisheries Courts to encompass all of Indonesia’s territorial waters and exclusive maritime zones. The jurisdiction of the court includes not only citizens of Indonesia but also foreign nationals who are charged with having committed a crime in an area where the court has jurisdiction.

 

Law Enforcement and Armed Vessels

With respect to law enforcement the amended Law provides for armed guard vessels that are tasked with supervising and ensuring compliance within the waters of Indonesia. The vessels have broad powers to stop, search, and detain fishing vessels that are alleged to have breached provisions of the Indonesian fishing laws and regulations. It is worth noting that these broad powers also include the power to burn and scuttle foreign-flagged vessels caught violating the law. These powers can be exercised when the guard vessel is satisfied that there is sufficient preliminary evidence of the breach alleged.

 

Investigations and Investigators

The amended law clarifies who is responsible for investigations and the methods by which an investigation may be started. The investigators of alleged criminal activities in the fisheries sector are to be undertaken by civil service investigators, naval investigation officers, or by the police. The amended law implies that civil service investigators are to generally take the lead role in investigations. Nevertheless, to ensure that there is full cooperation between the various investigators the minister is to establish a coordination forum to facilitate interaction and communication among the investigators.

 

The authorities of investigators are set out in Article 73A. These authorities include the authority to receive reports or complaints of alleged criminal activities, to summons and examine suspects and to hear the testimony of witnesses, to search and seize goods and equipment suspected of being used to commit a crime or as the proceeds of crime, examine the completeness and legality of all documents, and to call for expert testimony, among others.

 

The insertion of Article 73B sets out some strict time limits with respect to how soon an investigation must be notified and how long the investigation has to be completed. For example, an investigator must notify the public prosecutor that they have commenced an investigation within seven days of becoming aware of a suspected crime. Furthermore, investigators must send the completed report to the public prosecutor no later than 30 days after having notified the public prosecutor of the commencement of an investigation.

 

Suspects can be detained for a period of 20 days. This detention can be extended for a further 10 days if required. The suspect can be released at any time during the detention period if the investigators are satisfied that they have completed their investigation and no longer require the suspect to be in detention.

 

Criminal Sanctions

The new law also sets out some additional criminal sanctions for breaches of the provisions of the law. These include periods of incarceration and fines. The periods of incarceration and applicable fines are determined on whether the offender is an official or a small-scale fisherman or fish farmer. Where the offender is an official the applicable penalties are increased by 1/3 where that official is involved in the falsification of documents. Whereas, the period of incarceration and fines are reduced where the offender is a small-scale fisherman or fish farmer. Nonetheless, one-year in prison or a maximum fine of up to IDR 250 million is severe for small-scale fishermen and fish farmers.

 

Enactment

The law repeals and replaces Law No. 9 of 1985, and Articles 14 and 16(1) of Law No. 5 of 1983.

 

The law has been in force since 29 October 2009.

 

Conclusion

The amended Fisheries Law is not without its critics. However, the amendments are intended to provide enhanced protection for not only small-scale fishermen and fish farmers, but to ensure the long-term sustainable future of Indonesia’s fish stocks.

 

The amendments clearly ratchet-up the requirements placed on large scale fishers operating in Indonesian territorial and exclusive economic zone waters. This ratcheting-up is not only with respect to licensing, but also through the severity of enforcement responses permitted under the provisions of the amended law.

 

The key to any law is the enforcement. This law requires additional subsidiary legislation in order for it to have full force and effect as the parliament intends it to have. The onus is now on the government to ensure that this subsidiary legislation is not left to the last minute, but rather drafted and enacted in the immediate future.

 

The amended law reflects current developments and trends in the Indonesian fisheries sector, and is a step in the right direction if Indonesia is serious about preserving and developing its fish stocks for long-term exploitation as a driver of national development.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku

Overview

For an archipelagic nation like Indonesia the need for strong maritime and fishing laws if a foregone conclusion as a simple necessity in terms of being able to protect and manage a vast array of ocean-based resources. Therefore, it is also not surprising that the government has deemed it necessary to update the 2004 law on fisheries to reflect current trends and needs. To this end, the government has sort to reinforce its commitment to the fisheries sector and Indonesian fishermen through the amendment to Law No. 31 of 2004 on Fisheries.

 

The Amended Law, Law No. 45 of 2009, includes amendments that have been enacted with a view to driving sustainable growth in the fisheries industry while simultaneously protecting Indonesia and Indonesians from the threat of illegal, unreported, and unregulated fishing practices. Indonesia is not only the victim of illegal fishing but it also acknowledges that Indonesians are perpetrators of illegal fishing operations in the waters of other sovereign states in the region.

 

Purpose

Nevertheless, the purpose of this amended law is not only to ensure that Indonesia is more stringent in the policing of its own waters for illegal fishermen from other states, but to ensure that there is more effective and efficient law enforcement against Indonesians breaching the provisions of the prevailing laws with respect to failing to report commercial catches or fishing in ways that rapidly deplete reserves or exclude small-scale fishermen from the benefits of Indonesia maritime resources.

 

International Considerations

The Law and the amended Law rely on the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea 1982 (UNCLOS) and the determination of Indonesia’s Exclusive Economic Zones (EEZ) to set out the international dimensions of how far and wide the scope of this law and its amendments extend.

 

Issues of Contention

Aside from the above objectives, it is worth noting that the legislation was the final piece of legislation passed by the 2004 - 2009 House of Representatives (Dewan Perwakilan Rakyat / DPR). This in itself has been the source of a little contention as some have claimed that the DPR forced the legislation through just to get it done. The implication being that the bill still needed further perfection before going to the requisite plenary session for a vote on passage. Nevertheless, what is done is done, and the bill has become law.

 

Despite the good intentions of the parliament in passing this piece of legislation into law there are clearly unresolved issues with respect to the effectiveness of this piece of legislation. The primary concern relates to that there is a significant amount of subsidiary legislation that is required to give force to the provisions of the Law. These subsidiary pieces of legislation have not been fully drafted. Furthermore, the Department of Maritime Resources and Fisheries is still socializing the Law amongst the major stakeholders.

 

Subsidiary Legislation

Even so, the government has a period of 12 months from the date of enactment of this law to put into place all the necessary subsidiary legislation.

 

National Development

The basic premise of the amended law is that fishing can be a key driver in national development; economic, social, and cultural. The amended law focuses more effective regulation of the sector, particularly the bigger fishers, while simultaneously opening up opportunities for small-scale fishermen and fish farmers. The opportunities envisaged for the small-scale fishermen and fish farmers are dependent on freeing up the regulatory framework for them, but not forsaking management of available fish stocks or the maritime environment.

 

Substance

Generally, the law deals with 4 specific matters:

1.

Fisheries management;

2.

Providing favorable treatment to local small-scale fishermen and small fish cultivation farmers;

3.

Expansion of the fisheries courts’ jurisdiction to include all relevant areas within the country; and

4.

Supervision and legal enforcement (inclusive of sanctions and jurisdictional issues).

 

Principles Underpinning the Law

For example, fisheries management stipulates 11 principles that are to apply, these include:

 

Use

Partnership

Efficient

Fairness

Independence

Integrated

Equality

Sustainable Development

Preservation

Transparency

Allocation

 

 

These principles are then each individually further enumerated in the Elucidation. For example, use is defined as whatever activities undertaken with respect to fishing are to be done so with a view to ensuring the maximum benefit to the maximum number of Indonesian citizens in terms of raising the prosperity and welfare of the community as a whole.

 

The definition of partnership is designed to highlight the relationship between the exploiters of the fish stocks and the fish stocks themselves. The key here is that the law recognizes that fish stocks are sustainable, but without proper management these same fish stocks will become unsustainable and over-fishing is a real possibility. Therefore, partnership is all about ensuring proportionality.

 

The idea of sustainability is further defined in the final point of Article 2 at (k) to mean managing the resources that exist with a view to ensuring that the greatest benefit is derived not only in the present but that these reserves / resources continue to provide benefit long into the future.

 

But, the key to sustainable management and development is always going to be the successful implementation and subsequent application of an enforcement regime. The issues of enforcement are to be dealt with in the succeeding paragraphs.

 

Policy

In addition to enforcement, a key element of any successful law is sound policy. Sound policy requires an accurate inventory of fishing resources in this instance in order to ensure that the policy is based on ‘real’ conditions as they stand now and not some fanciful set of circumstances that may have been true in 2004 or at some other point in the distant past.

 

Therefore, Article 7 has been amended to ensure that the policy considerations are reflective of current circumstances. The amended law mandates that the minister revisit the issue of a fisheries plan and take an inventory of current resources to facilitate accurate and proper allocations of fishing quotas, for example. The plane must also address matters related to protected zones (sanctuaries) and types and species of fish that are protected, and types and species of fish that are to be introduced for farming or cultivation purposes.

 

With respect to catch limits, the minister is to consider recommendations forwarded by the National Commission tasked with taking the inventory of current fish stocks. It is expected that the minister will follow those recommendations. Nevertheless, the National Commission is one that is to be established by the minister and it is to contain recognized experts in the field.

 

Once the fisheries plan has been compiled and confirmed, then there will be obligations on all those involved in the sector and related industries to ensure that they comply with the objectives of that plan as they are codified in law. For instance, not to fish in sanctuary zones or catch fish out of season.

 

Prohibited Fishing Techniques

The amended law also sets out specific fishing techniques that are outlawed. The focus of the prohibitions is on techniques that are likely to lead to rapid overfishing and the indiscriminate catching of fish and other sea creatures. The elucidations specifically mention trawling (large trawl nets / pukat harimau) and the use of compressors. These techniques are to be further regulated in Ministerial Regulation as required.

 

Fish Farming / Cultivation

The government has recognized that as an archipelagic state that the potential for fish farming and cultivation is high. The law did not deal with this in specific or sufficient detail to be effective. Therefore, the amended law seeks to rectify this deficiency. To ensure that the potential is realized the government is to set out matters relating to quality control and fish cultures that are to be cultivated.

 

In light of the movement over the past decade to greater regional autonomy, the amendments to the law set out specific responsibilities for regional governments in the management and promotion of fishing and fisheries in their respective jurisdictions. Article 18 has been amended to state that regional governments are to be responsible for implementation of programs geared towards exploiting regional maritime resources and areas that are to be subject to cultivation. Unfortunately, this provision is to be further regulated by government regulation. Therefore, it remains to be seen as to how extensive these regional authorities are to be.

 

It is worth noting that Article 23 has been amended with the insertion of an additional paragraph. This paragraph places a positive obligation on the government to socialize what materials, food stuffs, and other assistance may and may not be used in the cultivation of fish. The law sets out in explicit terms that substances dangerous to humans may not be used in the cultivation process.

 

Licensing

The amendments to the Law explicitly require those that own and operate fishing vessels bearing the Indonesian flag to be licensed. This license is a Fishing License (Surat Izin Penangkapan Ikan / SIPI). However, the Law clearly exempts small scale fishing vessel operators from the need to hold a SIPI. Furthermore, the Law also exempts small scale fishing vessel operators and small scale fish farmers from the need to hold a Fishing Vessel License (Surat Izin Kapal Penangkapan Ikan / SIKPI). It must be noted, that those that are required to hold these licenses are also required to be in possession of the originals at all times when fishing.

 

Article 28A provides explicit prohibitions on the falsifying of fishing license documents.

 

Interestingly, the Law requires that Indonesian-flagged fishing vessels must also use an Indonesian captain and crew. There are administrative sanctions for failure to comply with this provision.

 

Fisheries Court

The amended Law expands the jurisdiction of the Fisheries Courts to encompass all of Indonesia’s territorial waters and exclusive maritime zones. The jurisdiction of the court includes not only citizens of Indonesia but also foreign nationals who are charged with having committed a crime in an area where the court has jurisdiction.

 

Law Enforcement and Armed Vessels

With respect to law enforcement the amended Law provides for armed guard vessels that are tasked with supervising and ensuring compliance within the waters of Indonesia. The vessels have broad powers to stop, search, and detain fishing vessels that are alleged to have breached provisions of the Indonesian fishing laws and regulations. It is worth noting that these broad powers also include the power to burn and scuttle foreign-flagged vessels caught violating the law. These powers can be exercised when the guard vessel is satisfied that there is sufficient preliminary evidence of the breach alleged.

 

Investigations and Investigators

The amended law clarifies who is responsible for investigations and the methods by which an investigation may be started. The investigators of alleged criminal activities in the fisheries sector are to be undertaken by civil service investigators, naval investigation officers, or by the police. The amended law implies that civil service investigators are to generally take the lead role in investigations. Nevertheless, to ensure that there is full cooperation between the various investigators the minister is to establish a coordination forum to facilitate interaction and communication among the investigators.

 

The authorities of investigators are set out in Article 73A. These authorities include the authority to receive reports or complaints of alleged criminal activities, to summons and examine suspects and to hear the testimony of witnesses, to search and seize goods and equipment suspected of being used to commit a crime or as the proceeds of crime, examine the completeness and legality of all documents, and to call for expert testimony, among others.

 

The insertion of Article 73B sets out some strict time limits with respect to how soon an investigation must be notified and how long the investigation has to be completed. For example, an investigator must notify the public prosecutor that they have commenced an investigation within seven days of becoming aware of a suspected crime. Furthermore, investigators must send the completed report to the public prosecutor no later than 30 days after having notified the public prosecutor of the commencement of an investigation.

 

Suspects can be detained for a period of 20 days. This detention can be extended for a further 10 days if required. The suspect can be released at any time during the detention period if the investigators are satisfied that they have completed their investigation and no longer require the suspect to be in detention.

 

Criminal Sanctions

The new law also sets out some additional criminal sanctions for breaches of the provisions of the law. These include periods of incarceration and fines. The periods of incarceration and applicable fines are determined on whether the offender is an official or a small-scale fisherman or fish farmer. Where the offender is an official the applicable penalties are increased by 1/3 where that official is involved in the falsification of documents. Whereas, the period of incarceration and fines are reduced where the offender is a small-scale fisherman or fish farmer. Nonetheless, one-year in prison or a maximum fine of up to IDR 250 million is severe for small-scale fishermen and fish farmers.

 

Enactment

The law repeals and replaces Law No. 9 of 1985, and Articles 14 and 16(1) of Law No. 5 of 1983.

 

The law has been in force since 29 October 2009.

 

Conclusion

The amended Fisheries Law is not without its critics. However, the amendments are intended to provide enhanced protection for not only small-scale fishermen and fish farmers, but to ensure the long-term sustainable future of Indonesia’s fish stocks.

 

The amendments clearly ratchet-up the requirements placed on large scale fishers operating in Indonesian territorial and exclusive economic zone waters. This ratcheting-up is not only with respect to licensing, but also through the severity of enforcement responses permitted under the provisions of the amended law.

 

The key to any law is the enforcement. This law requires additional subsidiary legislation in order for it to have full force and effect as the parliament intends it to have. The onus is now on the government to ensure that this subsidiary legislation is not left to the last minute, but rather drafted and enacted in the immediate future.

 

The amended law reflects current developments and trends in the Indonesian fisheries sector, and is a step in the right direction if Indonesia is serious about preserving and developing its fish stocks for long-term exploitation as a driver of national development.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku
2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info