Corruption is not something that is unique to Indonesia or any one state in the world. Nevertheless, the Indonesian government recognizes that corruption is a problem and took measures to address the problem with the passage of the Law on the Corruption Eradication Commission (Komisi Pemberantasan Korupsi / KPK). Law No. 30 of 2002 not only established the KPK but also established a Corruption Court based in the Central Jakarta District Court.
The 2002 law was subject to judicial review at the Constitutional Court. The Court in Decision No. 012-016-019/PUU-IV/2006 held that the law breached constitutional provisions that mandated that a special court be established under a specific law of its own and not part of any other legislation instrument. Therefore, the provisions contained in Articles 53 though 62 were held to be in breach of the prevailing norms of the Constitution, and the expected standards of legislation drafting in this instance.
Interestingly, the Court provided the government a three-year window of opportunity to draft and enact a specific piece of legislation to establish the new Corruption Court. The government after a long and tortuous process managed to get Law No. 46 of 2009 on the Corruption Court passed during the final throes of the recently departed House of Representatives (Dewan Perwakilan Rakyat / DPR). A new DPR was sworn in towards the end of October 2009 after general elections earlier in the year.
Mammoth Undertaking
The new Law sets out a rather mammoth undertaking in terms of both the establishment of facilities and the recruiting of staff. The Corruption Court is a specialized court under the auspices of the Supreme Court. This is a mammoth undertaking because the law stipulates that there is to be a corruption court established within every District Court throughout Indonesia. For example, this means that within the greater Jakarta area there will be five courts established at the Central, East, West, North, and South Jakarta District Courts.
Initial Phase
The law is clear that the establishment process is to be phased. The initial focus will be in establishing at least one Corruption Court at the provincial level. This is court is expected to be established in the capital city of the respective provinces. Yet, it would seem clear that the establishment of courts beyond this initial step will be heavily dependent on the availability of resources, particularly human resources. The law, at Article 35(4), requires that this initial phase be completed no later than two years after the enactment of this legislation. In essence, all Corruption Courts at the provincial level must be established no later than 29 October 2011.
Corruption Courts and Corruption Cases
The need to comply with the initial phase of the establishment of the new corruption courts at the provincial level is essential because the law explicitly states in Article 5 that the corruption courts are the only courts that have the authority to handle corruption matters. This authority extends from the examination, trial, and decision phases of the process. Article 6 stipulates that corruption cases are those that are identified as:
a.
A corruption case;
b.
A money laundering case where corruption was the motive; and /or
c.
Any crime that is defined in legislation as being a crime that constitutes corruption, and must be tried as a crime of corruption.
The above three points are further enumerated in the Elucidations to the law. Specifically, the elucidations refer to Law No. 31 of 1999 as amended by Law No. 20 of 2001. And, for point be the elucidations refer to predicate crimes with respect to defining the motivation for money laundering.
Corruption by Indonesians Abroad
Where Indonesian citizens commit acts of corruption outside of the territorial jurisdiction of the Republic of Indonesia, then the Central Jakarta District Court is granted the jurisdictional authority to try these matters.
Human Resources
The human resources are a critical component of the law as the provisions mandate the appointment of both career and ad hoc judges to the courts. The appointment of career judges may not be too problematic with respect to numbers. However, the handling of corruption cases is not always a simple criminal matter. Corruption cases quite often involve complex financial transactions which require specialized skills, knowledge, and expertise. These elements may not be so readily available within the current ranks of the career judges.
For ad hoc judges the requirements are even more stringent. To be appointed, a prospective ad hoc judge must have been vetted, and then recommended, by the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court. There are, for example, explicit age and experience requirements for appointment as an ad hoc judge at the District, High, and Supreme Court levels. Before any ad hoc appointment can be finalized the prospective ad hoc judge must swear an oath or promise. The oath and promise are noted in Article 14.
The conditions for both career and ad hoc judges are set out in Articles 11 through 13 of the law.
Prohibitions Relating to Ad Hoc Judges
However, Articles 15 and 16 set out special prohibitions for ad hoc judges that must be satisfied before they can be appointed to a vacancy. These prohibitions generally relate to the prospective ad hoc judge / justice having dual roles. This is expressly concerned with ensuring that the judges / justices are independent. For example, an ad hoc judge / justice cannot hold concurrent positions as a Head of a Region, an advocate, a public notary, or the head of a company, among others.
For those in the public sector, a prospective ad hoc judge / justice must relinquish any structural responsibilities they have within the organization / institution that they are employed in. Generally, it is expected that the individual concerned will take a leave of absence in order to perform their duties as an ad hoc judge / justice.
Procedural Law
The procedural law that is to apply in the corruption courts is the criminal procedural law as contained in Law No. 8 of 1981. However, the law also makes special mention of procedural requirements that are contained in Law No. 31 of 1999 as amended by Law No. 20 of 2001 and Law No. 14 of 1985 as amended by Law No. 3 of 2009. Nevertheless, the law also makes explicit mention of wiretapping within the context of corruption matters. The issue of wiretapping by the KPK has been a controversial issue since it was first permitted. And, there was serious discussion about removing the wiretapping powers that the KPK has. Removing these powers and wiretapping as a form of evidence would undoubtedly be detrimental to the successful prosecution of corrupters.
Wiretapping
In addressing the wiretapping issue, Article 28 of the law sets out that if a wiretap is to be adduced as evidence, then the wiretap must have been legally conducted according to the prevailing laws and regulations. The judges / justices in the relevant hearing are to determine the legality of any wiretap adduced either by the public prosecutor or the defense.
Generally, this will require that the wiretap relates to a criminal activity that falls within the parameters of a corruption offense as noted previously. Furthermore, a wiretap will require a warrant to be issued by a judge prior to wiretap taking place or in the event that time does not permit the warrant to be issued prior to the wiretap, then the action must obtain a warrant post-action.
Panel of Judges
Other procedural matters that are set out in the law relate to the division of duties between the Chief Judge and Deputy Chief Judge of the corruption courts, the composition of the panel of judges, the time frame for the completion of cases, evidence, and the establishment of a secretariat for the court.
For example, the composition of the panel of judges can be anywhere from three to five judges. The composition is generally in favour of career judges over ad hoc judges. Therefore, in a three-judge panel there is to be two career judges and one ad hoc judge. If the panel is five judges, then this is to be three against two in favour of career judges. The Chief Judge of the relevant court will determine which judges are to sit on which corruption cases. However, the law implies that these decisions will factor in such considerations as the importance of the case.
This is problematic for a number of reasons. However, chief among these is the fact that there is considerable concern that the current list of career judges / justices does not include sufficient current expertise and skills in the handling and administering of justice in complex corruption cases. There is also a general belief that the appointment of ad hoc judges would permit these skills, expertise, and experience to be enhanced by individuals with current knowledge and practical skills relevant to handling and administering corruption related cases.
There is clearly an expectation within the community that those alleged to have committed acts of corruption are dealt with in a manner commensurate to the seriousness of the crime. Therefore, this community expectation also requires that the panel of judges appointed to any specific corruption case has the knowledge, skills, and experience base that ensures the purposes of justice are served.
Time Frames
With respect to time frames, the law is explicit about how much time is permitted for the completion of each phase of the case. Once a case file has been received, the Chief Judge has three working days to determine a panel of judges to sit on the case. The first hearing in the case must take place within seven days of the panel of judges being appointed to hear the matter. The total length of time permitted for the completion of a corruption case at the District Court (court of first instance) is 120 working days. If the decision is appealed, then the appellate court has a further 60 working days to hear the appeal from the date the case file is received by the High Court.
In the event that the decision of the High Court is appealed to the Supreme Court, then the Supreme Court has a further 120 working days to hear the cassation appeal from the date the case file is received from the High Court. Finally, if the case is then appealed to the case review level then there is a further 60 working days for the case review to be concluded.
The law requires that the corruption courts are transparent and accountable. This specifically refers to the type of information that is to be made publicly available. In spite of Article 24(1) setting out that every person has a right to obtain information, it must be noted that this is modified by legislation and by Supreme Court regulations. It remains to be seen as to how much information is going to be made publicly available under Article 24.
Transitional Provisions
In order to avoid the need to restart current corruption cases before the corruption court established under Law No 30 of 2002, the law stipulates that these cases are to be heard and finalized in accordance with the relevant laws.
Enactment
The law has been in force since 29 October 2009.
Conclusion
It is clear that the government has acted, albeit just within the nick of time, to comply with the requirements set out by the Constitutional Court with respect to drafting and enacting a law that recreates the corruption court and establishes a corruption court system throughout Indonesia. Nevertheless, the new law is not without issues. Of particular importance here are the issues of appointing judges to the court and wiretapping.
It is expected that the government will devote considerable resources to the initial phase of establishing all the necessary courts at the provincial level. However, this expectation is that for some provinces the government is likely to push the time frame yet again with some of these corruption courts not being created until close to the 29 October 2011 cut-off date.
Generally, the law is an important step in the continuing fight against corruption. A fully functioning court may or may not be a deterrent to those thinking about participating in corrupt activities. However, a fully functioning corruption court system will ensure that those individuals caught participating in corrupt activities will face justice.
Corruption is not something that is unique to Indonesia or any one state in the world. Nevertheless, the Indonesian government recognizes that corruption is a problem and took measures to address the problem with the passage of the Law on the Corruption Eradication Commission (Komisi Pemberantasan Korupsi / KPK). Law No. 30 of 2002 not only established the KPK but also established a Corruption Court based in the Central Jakarta District Court.
The 2002 law was subject to judicial review at the Constitutional Court. The Court in Decision No. 012-016-019/PUU-IV/2006 held that the law breached constitutional provisions that mandated that a special court be established under a specific law of its own and not part of any other legislation instrument. Therefore, the provisions contained in Articles 53 though 62 were held to be in breach of the prevailing norms of the Constitution, and the expected standards of legislation drafting in this instance.
Interestingly, the Court provided the government a three-year window of opportunity to draft and enact a specific piece of legislation to establish the new Corruption Court. The government after a long and tortuous process managed to get Law No. 46 of 2009 on the Corruption Court passed during the final throes of the recently departed House of Representatives (Dewan Perwakilan Rakyat / DPR). A new DPR was sworn in towards the end of October 2009 after general elections earlier in the year.
Mammoth Undertaking
The new Law sets out a rather mammoth undertaking in terms of both the establishment of facilities and the recruiting of staff. The Corruption Court is a specialized court under the auspices of the Supreme Court. This is a mammoth undertaking because the law stipulates that there is to be a corruption court established within every District Court throughout Indonesia. For example, this means that within the greater Jakarta area there will be five courts established at the Central, East, West, North, and South Jakarta District Courts.
Initial Phase
The law is clear that the establishment process is to be phased. The initial focus will be in establishing at least one Corruption Court at the provincial level. This is court is expected to be established in the capital city of the respective provinces. Yet, it would seem clear that the establishment of courts beyond this initial step will be heavily dependent on the availability of resources, particularly human resources. The law, at Article 35(4), requires that this initial phase be completed no later than two years after the enactment of this legislation. In essence, all Corruption Courts at the provincial level must be established no later than 29 October 2011.
Corruption Courts and Corruption Cases
The need to comply with the initial phase of the establishment of the new corruption courts at the provincial level is essential because the law explicitly states in Article 5 that the corruption courts are the only courts that have the authority to handle corruption matters. This authority extends from the examination, trial, and decision phases of the process. Article 6 stipulates that corruption cases are those that are identified as:
a.
A corruption case;
b.
A money laundering case where corruption was the motive; and /or
c.
Any crime that is defined in legislation as being a crime that constitutes corruption, and must be tried as a crime of corruption.
The above three points are further enumerated in the Elucidations to the law. Specifically, the elucidations refer to Law No. 31 of 1999 as amended by Law No. 20 of 2001. And, for point be the elucidations refer to predicate crimes with respect to defining the motivation for money laundering.
Corruption by Indonesians Abroad
Where Indonesian citizens commit acts of corruption outside of the territorial jurisdiction of the Republic of Indonesia, then the Central Jakarta District Court is granted the jurisdictional authority to try these matters.
Human Resources
The human resources are a critical component of the law as the provisions mandate the appointment of both career and ad hoc judges to the courts. The appointment of career judges may not be too problematic with respect to numbers. However, the handling of corruption cases is not always a simple criminal matter. Corruption cases quite often involve complex financial transactions which require specialized skills, knowledge, and expertise. These elements may not be so readily available within the current ranks of the career judges.
For ad hoc judges the requirements are even more stringent. To be appointed, a prospective ad hoc judge must have been vetted, and then recommended, by the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court. There are, for example, explicit age and experience requirements for appointment as an ad hoc judge at the District, High, and Supreme Court levels. Before any ad hoc appointment can be finalized the prospective ad hoc judge must swear an oath or promise. The oath and promise are noted in Article 14.
The conditions for both career and ad hoc judges are set out in Articles 11 through 13 of the law.
Prohibitions Relating to Ad Hoc Judges
However, Articles 15 and 16 set out special prohibitions for ad hoc judges that must be satisfied before they can be appointed to a vacancy. These prohibitions generally relate to the prospective ad hoc judge / justice having dual roles. This is expressly concerned with ensuring that the judges / justices are independent. For example, an ad hoc judge / justice cannot hold concurrent positions as a Head of a Region, an advocate, a public notary, or the head of a company, among others.
For those in the public sector, a prospective ad hoc judge / justice must relinquish any structural responsibilities they have within the organization / institution that they are employed in. Generally, it is expected that the individual concerned will take a leave of absence in order to perform their duties as an ad hoc judge / justice.
Procedural Law
The procedural law that is to apply in the corruption courts is the criminal procedural law as contained in Law No. 8 of 1981. However, the law also makes special mention of procedural requirements that are contained in Law No. 31 of 1999 as amended by Law No. 20 of 2001 and Law No. 14 of 1985 as amended by Law No. 3 of 2009. Nevertheless, the law also makes explicit mention of wiretapping within the context of corruption matters. The issue of wiretapping by the KPK has been a controversial issue since it was first permitted. And, there was serious discussion about removing the wiretapping powers that the KPK has. Removing these powers and wiretapping as a form of evidence would undoubtedly be detrimental to the successful prosecution of corrupters.
Wiretapping
In addressing the wiretapping issue, Article 28 of the law sets out that if a wiretap is to be adduced as evidence, then the wiretap must have been legally conducted according to the prevailing laws and regulations. The judges / justices in the relevant hearing are to determine the legality of any wiretap adduced either by the public prosecutor or the defense.
Generally, this will require that the wiretap relates to a criminal activity that falls within the parameters of a corruption offense as noted previously. Furthermore, a wiretap will require a warrant to be issued by a judge prior to wiretap taking place or in the event that time does not permit the warrant to be issued prior to the wiretap, then the action must obtain a warrant post-action.
Panel of Judges
Other procedural matters that are set out in the law relate to the division of duties between the Chief Judge and Deputy Chief Judge of the corruption courts, the composition of the panel of judges, the time frame for the completion of cases, evidence, and the establishment of a secretariat for the court.
For example, the composition of the panel of judges can be anywhere from three to five judges. The composition is generally in favour of career judges over ad hoc judges. Therefore, in a three-judge panel there is to be two career judges and one ad hoc judge. If the panel is five judges, then this is to be three against two in favour of career judges. The Chief Judge of the relevant court will determine which judges are to sit on which corruption cases. However, the law implies that these decisions will factor in such considerations as the importance of the case.
This is problematic for a number of reasons. However, chief among these is the fact that there is considerable concern that the current list of career judges / justices does not include sufficient current expertise and skills in the handling and administering of justice in complex corruption cases. There is also a general belief that the appointment of ad hoc judges would permit these skills, expertise, and experience to be enhanced by individuals with current knowledge and practical skills relevant to handling and administering corruption related cases.
There is clearly an expectation within the community that those alleged to have committed acts of corruption are dealt with in a manner commensurate to the seriousness of the crime. Therefore, this community expectation also requires that the panel of judges appointed to any specific corruption case has the knowledge, skills, and experience base that ensures the purposes of justice are served.
Time Frames
With respect to time frames, the law is explicit about how much time is permitted for the completion of each phase of the case. Once a case file has been received, the Chief Judge has three working days to determine a panel of judges to sit on the case. The first hearing in the case must take place within seven days of the panel of judges being appointed to hear the matter. The total length of time permitted for the completion of a corruption case at the District Court (court of first instance) is 120 working days. If the decision is appealed, then the appellate court has a further 60 working days to hear the appeal from the date the case file is received by the High Court.
In the event that the decision of the High Court is appealed to the Supreme Court, then the Supreme Court has a further 120 working days to hear the cassation appeal from the date the case file is received from the High Court. Finally, if the case is then appealed to the case review level then there is a further 60 working days for the case review to be concluded.
The law requires that the corruption courts are transparent and accountable. This specifically refers to the type of information that is to be made publicly available. In spite of Article 24(1) setting out that every person has a right to obtain information, it must be noted that this is modified by legislation and by Supreme Court regulations. It remains to be seen as to how much information is going to be made publicly available under Article 24.
Transitional Provisions
In order to avoid the need to restart current corruption cases before the corruption court established under Law No 30 of 2002, the law stipulates that these cases are to be heard and finalized in accordance with the relevant laws.
Enactment
The law has been in force since 29 October 2009.
Conclusion
It is clear that the government has acted, albeit just within the nick of time, to comply with the requirements set out by the Constitutional Court with respect to drafting and enacting a law that recreates the corruption court and establishes a corruption court system throughout Indonesia. Nevertheless, the new law is not without issues. Of particular importance here are the issues of appointing judges to the court and wiretapping.
It is expected that the government will devote considerable resources to the initial phase of establishing all the necessary courts at the provincial level. However, this expectation is that for some provinces the government is likely to push the time frame yet again with some of these corruption courts not being created until close to the 29 October 2011 cut-off date.
Generally, the law is an important step in the continuing fight against corruption. A fully functioning court may or may not be a deterrent to those thinking about participating in corrupt activities. However, a fully functioning corruption court system will ensure that those individuals caught participating in corrupt activities will face justice.