Ship Financing: A Key Problem to the Implementation of the Cabotage Principle

Overview

There is a cold, hard reality to Indonesia’s commitment and drive to fully implement the cabotage principle throughout the archipelago; sufficient quality and quantity of vessels to ply sea transportation routes. The commitment stems from a Presidential Instruction issued back in 2005, No. 5 of 2005, which set out what amounted to a cabotage roadmap. The government has until 2011 to get all the necessary pieces of the puzzle into order if it is to comply with the timetable it set itself in terms of fully implementing the cabotage principle.

 

A major road block has arisen in the form of ship financing. In situations of limited financing, such as in a depressed global economy, the challenge of meeting the cabotage principle commitments becomes exponentially harder to fulfill, albeit not impossible. 

 

It is worth noting that the idea of the full implementation of the cabotage principle is not a new phenomenon in Indonesia. To the contrary, the cabotage principles have been a part of Indonesian shipping for a considerable period of time. What is different now is that since 2005 the commitment to full implementation has been much clearer. This clarity came about with the issue of the Presidential Instruction noted above on the Empowerment of the National Shipping Industry.

 

In essence, carrying out the cabotage principle would mean that only the State in question will have the right to trade, navigate, and ship in coastal waters within its boundaries. Nonetheless, under the roadmap the principle means that only Indonesian-flagged ships are allowed to carry goods between ports in Indonesia.

 

In the same year, the Minister of Transportation has issued Regulation No. KM 71 of 2005 on the Transportation of Goods between Domestic Ports in order to facilitate the implementation of the roadmap. In this regulation, the principle is regulated in even more detail. It stipulates that the implementation to be conducted in several phases (See table below).

 

Commodities / Goods

Deadline for Implementation

General cargo

18 November 2005

Wood and wood products

18 November 2005

Cement

18 November 2005

Fertilizer

18 November 2005

Rice

18 November 2005

Crude Palm Oil

1 January 2008

Extracted mining materials

1 January 2008

Other grains

1 January 2008

Vegetables, fruits, and fish (fresh products)

1 January 2008

Oil and natural gas

1 January 2010

Coal

1 January 2010

Supplementing downstream and upstream oil and natural gas activities

1 January 2011

(Cabotage as Key to Domestic Maritime Trade, Yoga Prakasa, 2008)

 

Benefits

The domestic carriers will benefit from this scheme because they will not have to compete with foreign ships in the particular sector (domestic routes) any longer.

 

Nevertheless, the benefits will not come as a gift. In order to reap revenues from the implementation of the cabotage principle, the national shipping industry has to provide adequate services to the clients.

 

The services that the national shipping industry has to make available, among other things, is to provide enough vessels to the shipping armada. This is critical because once non-Indonesian flagged ships are restricted from shipping between domestic ports, then national shipping companies are required to pick up the slack. If there are not enough vessels in the domestic armada then, quite simply, goods will not move at the required rate between ports. This is of particular concern when there are significant time constraints with respect to moving fresh produce between the far-flung islands of the archipelago.

 

Another requirement is that the local shipping industry must “free up” vessels with specific characteristics and for specific purposes. Among these vessels are to be double-hulled and very large crude carriers (VLCC).

 

Investment

It is clear that the above two requirements are capital intensive. Simply, the shipping industry is going to need large levels of capital investment in order to purchase the required vessels or to build them from scratch. Herein lies the problem; a lack of investment funding.

 

 

Unfortunately, throughout the years the Indonesian shipping sector has had difficulty in attracting investment at the required levels, and this has been particularly true in the period since 2005. Much of the difficulty in attracting investment has been because banks have been reluctant to make the necessary loans or provide financial injections to struggling shipping companies.

 

Therefore, the primary question is, in spite of the government’s and the industry’s best efforts, will the government and industry succeed in rising and meeting the challenge on full implementation of the cabotage principle?

 

The Cabotage Laws and Ship Financing

Presidential Instruction No. 5 of 2005 and Minister of Transportation Regulation No. KM 71 of 2005 are the primary regulations on the subject of the cabotage principle. However, the principle was recently reinforced by the enactment of Law No. 17 of 2008 on Shipping (See ILB No.

818 10/4/2008 and ILD No. 90 21/4/2008).

 

Basically, these regulations (cabotage laws) endorse the implementation of the principle. Amongst the provisions that the cabotage laws provide, there are provisions pertaining to ship financing. These particular clauses on ship financing include the following matters, among others:

-

Urges national banks and non-bank financial institutions to finance the national shipping industry (Point 2(b) of the 2005 Instruction);

-

To provide “financing facilities.” Financial facilities mean:

 

-

To develop special non-bank financial institutions to grant ship financing,

 

-

Stimulating financers in ship financing by way of introducing attractive lending conditions (Article 57(1)(a) of the 2008 Law; See also its Elucidation), and;

-

Allows foreign financing (Article 57(2)(g) of the 2008 Law);

 

However, it must be noted that failure to comply with these provisions will not give rise to any types of sanctions.

 

The Reluctance of Financers to Ship Financing

Generally, financers are not only local banks and non-bank financial institutions, but also international banks, financial institutions, and large ship owners. These financers are to finance shipbuilding, shipping, crewing, as well as resource exploitation. From these sentences, it is fair to say that the role of the financers is critical to the development of the national shipping industry.

 

Nevertheless, there are some financers, particularly local banks that have been unwilling to grant credits to finance the national shipping companies. According to Yoga Prakarsa, as quoted from the Jakarta Post (24/4/08), the reason why they tend to refuse to lend money to shipping companies is because of “the high-risk, low-yield and long-term repayment characteristics of the shipping sector” (Jakarta Post, 24/04/08).

 

The lack of enthusiasm of the financers in the ship financing is unsurprising since the government, through the cabotage laws, does not impose any sanctions, instead merely encourages the financers to contribute to the improvement of the national shipping industry.

 

The cabotage laws, specifically Law No. 17 of 2008, have provided a clause on the mortgage of ships. The government expects that by including this provision it will convince and guarantee the financers when conducting a loan agreement with the debtors, in this case the national shipping industry. Unfortunately, only a small numbers of local banks and financial institutions have been tempted to participate in ship financing.

 

Alternative Ship Financing

Interestingly, the reluctance for sourcing local financing is also prevalent within Indonesia’s shipping industry. One of the primary concerns of local shipping companies is that local banks and financial institutions that are capable of providing financing are only willing to do so at extremely high interest rates. This has prompted some shipping companies to source alternative funding sources such as foreign banks and financial institutions, as foreign banks and financial institutions have tended to offer lower rates of interest.

 

Yet, despite lower interest rates the foreign financing of vessels is not without its problems. Most notably there are problems with the “arrest of ship” principle, as set out by the International Convention on the Arrest of Ships.

 

Ratifying the convention has been the government’s agenda subsequent to the ratification of the 1993 International Convention on Maritime Liens and Mortgages. Yet, due to several technical troubles the ratification of the convention will have to be postponed.

 

A direct consequence of this failure to ratify is that foreign financers are reluctant to provide loans because if the debtors in any case fail to meet their obligations, the creditors then will have a hard time - even impossible - to arrest the ships when the ships’ are located within Indonesian territorial waters.

 

Nevertheless, it must be noted that the Indonesian government has stated that it is committed to ratifying the convention. However, foreign financing is not likely to be forthcoming until that ratification becomes a reality.

 

Conclusion

Based on current developments it is reasonable to suggest that the local shipping industry is not going to be able to meet the requirements with respect to the full implementation of the cabotage principle on the schedule set by the government. Perhaps blame can be apportioned among a number of the stakeholders involved. However, the target was always ambitious and difficult to achieve, particularly once the global economy came under pressure and sources of investment cash quickly dried up.

 

Ultimately, the government and the shipping industry must come together to ensure that the 2011 target for full implementation is realized. The challenge is not merely full implementation of the cabotage principle, but providing the vessels and other assorted services required to facilitate shipping among the islands of the archipelago. Any delay in meeting the 2011 target will only serve to increase pressure on Indonesian shipping and shipping companies as Indonesia heads towards the free trade era of 2020, as free trade will remove any protections the Indonesian shipping sector enjoys under the implementation of the cabotage principle.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku

Overview

There is a cold, hard reality to Indonesia’s commitment and drive to fully implement the cabotage principle throughout the archipelago; sufficient quality and quantity of vessels to ply sea transportation routes. The commitment stems from a Presidential Instruction issued back in 2005, No. 5 of 2005, which set out what amounted to a cabotage roadmap. The government has until 2011 to get all the necessary pieces of the puzzle into order if it is to comply with the timetable it set itself in terms of fully implementing the cabotage principle.

 

A major road block has arisen in the form of ship financing. In situations of limited financing, such as in a depressed global economy, the challenge of meeting the cabotage principle commitments becomes exponentially harder to fulfill, albeit not impossible. 

 

It is worth noting that the idea of the full implementation of the cabotage principle is not a new phenomenon in Indonesia. To the contrary, the cabotage principles have been a part of Indonesian shipping for a considerable period of time. What is different now is that since 2005 the commitment to full implementation has been much clearer. This clarity came about with the issue of the Presidential Instruction noted above on the Empowerment of the National Shipping Industry.

 

In essence, carrying out the cabotage principle would mean that only the State in question will have the right to trade, navigate, and ship in coastal waters within its boundaries. Nonetheless, under the roadmap the principle means that only Indonesian-flagged ships are allowed to carry goods between ports in Indonesia.

 

In the same year, the Minister of Transportation has issued Regulation No. KM 71 of 2005 on the Transportation of Goods between Domestic Ports in order to facilitate the implementation of the roadmap. In this regulation, the principle is regulated in even more detail. It stipulates that the implementation to be conducted in several phases (See table below).

 

Commodities / Goods

Deadline for Implementation

General cargo

18 November 2005

Wood and wood products

18 November 2005

Cement

18 November 2005

Fertilizer

18 November 2005

Rice

18 November 2005

Crude Palm Oil

1 January 2008

Extracted mining materials

1 January 2008

Other grains

1 January 2008

Vegetables, fruits, and fish (fresh products)

1 January 2008

Oil and natural gas

1 January 2010

Coal

1 January 2010

Supplementing downstream and upstream oil and natural gas activities

1 January 2011

(Cabotage as Key to Domestic Maritime Trade, Yoga Prakasa, 2008)

 

Benefits

The domestic carriers will benefit from this scheme because they will not have to compete with foreign ships in the particular sector (domestic routes) any longer.

 

Nevertheless, the benefits will not come as a gift. In order to reap revenues from the implementation of the cabotage principle, the national shipping industry has to provide adequate services to the clients.

 

The services that the national shipping industry has to make available, among other things, is to provide enough vessels to the shipping armada. This is critical because once non-Indonesian flagged ships are restricted from shipping between domestic ports, then national shipping companies are required to pick up the slack. If there are not enough vessels in the domestic armada then, quite simply, goods will not move at the required rate between ports. This is of particular concern when there are significant time constraints with respect to moving fresh produce between the far-flung islands of the archipelago.

 

Another requirement is that the local shipping industry must “free up” vessels with specific characteristics and for specific purposes. Among these vessels are to be double-hulled and very large crude carriers (VLCC).

 

Investment

It is clear that the above two requirements are capital intensive. Simply, the shipping industry is going to need large levels of capital investment in order to purchase the required vessels or to build them from scratch. Herein lies the problem; a lack of investment funding.

 

 

Unfortunately, throughout the years the Indonesian shipping sector has had difficulty in attracting investment at the required levels, and this has been particularly true in the period since 2005. Much of the difficulty in attracting investment has been because banks have been reluctant to make the necessary loans or provide financial injections to struggling shipping companies.

 

Therefore, the primary question is, in spite of the government’s and the industry’s best efforts, will the government and industry succeed in rising and meeting the challenge on full implementation of the cabotage principle?

 

The Cabotage Laws and Ship Financing

Presidential Instruction No. 5 of 2005 and Minister of Transportation Regulation No. KM 71 of 2005 are the primary regulations on the subject of the cabotage principle. However, the principle was recently reinforced by the enactment of Law No. 17 of 2008 on Shipping (See ILB No.

818 10/4/2008 and ILD No. 90 21/4/2008).

 

Basically, these regulations (cabotage laws) endorse the implementation of the principle. Amongst the provisions that the cabotage laws provide, there are provisions pertaining to ship financing. These particular clauses on ship financing include the following matters, among others:

-

Urges national banks and non-bank financial institutions to finance the national shipping industry (Point 2(b) of the 2005 Instruction);

-

To provide “financing facilities.” Financial facilities mean:

 

-

To develop special non-bank financial institutions to grant ship financing,

 

-

Stimulating financers in ship financing by way of introducing attractive lending conditions (Article 57(1)(a) of the 2008 Law; See also its Elucidation), and;

-

Allows foreign financing (Article 57(2)(g) of the 2008 Law);

 

However, it must be noted that failure to comply with these provisions will not give rise to any types of sanctions.

 

The Reluctance of Financers to Ship Financing

Generally, financers are not only local banks and non-bank financial institutions, but also international banks, financial institutions, and large ship owners. These financers are to finance shipbuilding, shipping, crewing, as well as resource exploitation. From these sentences, it is fair to say that the role of the financers is critical to the development of the national shipping industry.

 

Nevertheless, there are some financers, particularly local banks that have been unwilling to grant credits to finance the national shipping companies. According to Yoga Prakarsa, as quoted from the Jakarta Post (24/4/08), the reason why they tend to refuse to lend money to shipping companies is because of “the high-risk, low-yield and long-term repayment characteristics of the shipping sector” (Jakarta Post, 24/04/08).

 

The lack of enthusiasm of the financers in the ship financing is unsurprising since the government, through the cabotage laws, does not impose any sanctions, instead merely encourages the financers to contribute to the improvement of the national shipping industry.

 

The cabotage laws, specifically Law No. 17 of 2008, have provided a clause on the mortgage of ships. The government expects that by including this provision it will convince and guarantee the financers when conducting a loan agreement with the debtors, in this case the national shipping industry. Unfortunately, only a small numbers of local banks and financial institutions have been tempted to participate in ship financing.

 

Alternative Ship Financing

Interestingly, the reluctance for sourcing local financing is also prevalent within Indonesia’s shipping industry. One of the primary concerns of local shipping companies is that local banks and financial institutions that are capable of providing financing are only willing to do so at extremely high interest rates. This has prompted some shipping companies to source alternative funding sources such as foreign banks and financial institutions, as foreign banks and financial institutions have tended to offer lower rates of interest.

 

Yet, despite lower interest rates the foreign financing of vessels is not without its problems. Most notably there are problems with the “arrest of ship” principle, as set out by the International Convention on the Arrest of Ships.

 

Ratifying the convention has been the government’s agenda subsequent to the ratification of the 1993 International Convention on Maritime Liens and Mortgages. Yet, due to several technical troubles the ratification of the convention will have to be postponed.

 

A direct consequence of this failure to ratify is that foreign financers are reluctant to provide loans because if the debtors in any case fail to meet their obligations, the creditors then will have a hard time - even impossible - to arrest the ships when the ships’ are located within Indonesian territorial waters.

 

Nevertheless, it must be noted that the Indonesian government has stated that it is committed to ratifying the convention. However, foreign financing is not likely to be forthcoming until that ratification becomes a reality.

 

Conclusion

Based on current developments it is reasonable to suggest that the local shipping industry is not going to be able to meet the requirements with respect to the full implementation of the cabotage principle on the schedule set by the government. Perhaps blame can be apportioned among a number of the stakeholders involved. However, the target was always ambitious and difficult to achieve, particularly once the global economy came under pressure and sources of investment cash quickly dried up.

 

Ultimately, the government and the shipping industry must come together to ensure that the 2011 target for full implementation is realized. The challenge is not merely full implementation of the cabotage principle, but providing the vessels and other assorted services required to facilitate shipping among the islands of the archipelago. Any delay in meeting the 2011 target will only serve to increase pressure on Indonesian shipping and shipping companies as Indonesia heads towards the free trade era of 2020, as free trade will remove any protections the Indonesian shipping sector enjoys under the implementation of the cabotage principle.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku
2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info