Regulation of essential utilities such as electricity is always a difficult proposition as the government seeks to balance competing interests and competing needs. Nevertheless, as the recently passed Bill on Electricity highlights, there was that need. The bill has now been enacted through promulgation as Law No. 30 of 2009.
The House of Representatives (Dewan Perwakilan Rakyat / DPR) enjoyed a legislation blitz in the period leading up to its dissolution and replacing with a newly elected parliament. There was a raft of legislation passed. Amongst these was the Bill on Electricity (Rancangan Undang-undang Ketenagalistrikan / RUU Ketenagalistrikan). The bill since becoming law has repealed and replaced Law No. 15 of 1985.
The bill came about after the Constitutional Court handed down a decision on 15 December 2004 which in effect ordered the government to draft and enact a new electricity law. So, it is fair to say that the new law has been a long time in the making. In fact, the route to the passage of a law that now seemingly complies with the 1945 Constitution has been a long and tortuous one.
The previous Electricity Law, No. 20 of 2002, was struck down by the Constitutional Court. Nevertheless, as was noted above, this meant that the law had to return to the previous constitutionally valid law in the field, Law No. 15 of 1985. This law was clearly no longer suitable with respect to regulating the electricity needs of a modern and developing democratic society.
It is therefore reasonable to suggest that the current incarnation of the Electricity Law contains a little bit of something for everyone, and is clearly a compromise designed to improve efficiency but also to avert any further Constitutional Court challenges to the substantive provisions of the law.
Yet, that said, it is worth noting that the bill is still not short of controversy. After the bill passed the House, there was considerable opposition from nationalist groups, particularly those who brought the previous challenge of the provisions that saw Law No. 20 of 2002 struck down by the Constitutional Court.
These groups are adamant that the provisions although reworded still intend to see a liberalizing of the electricity and power sectors to an extent that they are no longer compatible with the 1945 Constitution. The opposition by its very nature suggests that a future challenge may be undertaken. The gist of the argument is that a liberalization of this nature endangers future power and electricity supply to the broader population.
The primary difference between the new law and the old law is in who can supply electricity to the masses. Under Law No. 15 of 1985 the State Electricity Company (Perusahaan Listrik Negara (Persero) / PLN) enjoyed a monopoly over supply. This has turned out to be an inefficient manner to supply electricity. The revolving black and brown outs that Jakarta and the surrounding suburbs have been forced to endure over the years is testament to that inefficiency.
The simple fact now is that it is expected more competition will see an increase in efficiency and ensure the development of the necessary infrastructure while simultaneously broadening the base of supply.
Those that can now be involved in the supply of electricity include the central and regional governments through state and regional owned enterprises, cooperatives, communities, and the private sector.
The Constitutional Court Decision – Setting a Threshold
There were three applicants who lodged the judicial review of the 2002 Law, namely: Serikat Pekerja PLN, APHI (Asosiasi Penasehat Hukum Indonesia), and Ikatan Keluarga Pensiunan Listrik Negara. The Court determined that the applicants had the requisite legal standing to proceed, and then the Court then heard arguments.
Interestingly, the Court found that only certain provisions of the 2002 Electricity Law were in violation of the 1945 Constitution. Nevertheless, the Court went on to state that these provisions were the heart and soul of the 2002 Law. The primary article of contention was Article 33(2) of the 1945 Constitution as it relates to control of the state over essentially resources and services.
Yet, rather than strike down just the offending provisions; Articles 16, 17(3), and 68, the Court held that the invalidation of these articles meant that the 2002 Law would be unworkable without them. Therefore, the Court saw it necessary to strike down the whole law.
In essence, the Court held that the liberalizing of the electricity sector and the simultaneous stripping away of PLN’s effective monopoly would result in the government losing control of the provision of electricity to the broader community. The fear, that market forces would negatively impact on electricity supply to the broader community as businesses driven by market forces would be only interested in supplying electricity to those that can afford to pay for it.
This fear was not considering the major urban areas in Java, Madura, and Bali, but rather the more remote areas that would not benefit from any liberalization of the sector.
The Court then ordered the government, in effect, to draft and enact a new electricity law.
The basic premise of the Court’s decision was contained in the following:
-
The State, through its State Owned Enterprise (PLN), must hold the controlling power over the electricity supply;
-
Non-State entities are permitted to participate, yet only by way of cooperation with PLN;
-
The competition in the power sector must not eliminate the State’s controlling power; and
-
The prohibition is to apply the “unbundling system.”
This sets out a threshold with respect to how much control the government must retain over the electricity sector in order to comply with its obligations under the 1945 Constitution.
The New Law – Liberalization, Monopoly, or a Little Bit of Both
The debate as to whether the new law has sufficiently taken into account the Constitutional Court’s decision with respect to liberalization and control of the electricity sector remains t to be seen. However, it s worth noting that business is generally receptive of the new law and the opportunities that it seemingly provides to them to become more involved in the electricity sector.
In contrast, those that opposed the previous incarnation of the electricity law in 2002 maintain that the new law does not sufficiently protect ordinary citizens from the harm that private ownership of electricity sources would conceivably rain on affordable electricity supply.
Yet, the current framework seems to acknowledge that the tone of the new electricity law is different, and perhaps judgment needs to be reserved in order to allow the provisions to be tested in practice before judging whether or not the broader Indonesian community is going to suffer from foreign and private interests in the electricity sector.
The support for the idea of giving the new law some time stems from the quite different construction of the new law. It is clear that the provisions no longer allow a pure free market mechanism to determine production or cost of electricity supply. Nevertheless, the effective monopoly that PLN once enjoyed has been wound back, and wound back quite significantly.
Under the new law, electricity providers besides PLN, such as regional owned enterprises, cooperatives, private companies, and even communities, can engage in the power supply business. Non-PLN entities are also given the chance to supply electricity in areas where no electricity is available (remote areas, for example). It is worth remembering that the supply of electricity is an all inclusive endeavor and covers the generation, transmission, distribution, and sale of electricity.
The fundamental change that must be recognized between the new law and the old law is that the PLN, although not an absolute monopoly, held the powers of sector regulator in that it could set tariffs for electricity under the old law. Under the new law, PLN is essentially just another electricity provider or operator, as the government has assumed full control as regulator. Nevertheless, it is not all bad news for PLN. The new law still provides a priority mandate for PLN to supply electricity in the public interest.
The priority mandate functions as a “first right of refusal” and by definition this ensures that the government can state that there is always a guarantee for the supply of electricity.
Unbundling System
One of the reasons cited regarding the unconstitutionality of the 2000 electricity law was the “the unbundling system” to manage the supply of electricity (Article 16). Basically, the system separates the management of electricity, and consequently providers are enabled to control and manage the generation, transmission, distribution, and sale of electricity.
The problem is illustrated in the following table:
Generation
Owned by foreign private company (since generation is expensive)
According to the Court this system would create a situation where PLN or the government would not have sufficient control over the supply process. Consequently, the Court considered that this was a real risk to across the board supply to all Indonesians. Therefore, the 2002 electricity law failed in guaranteeing that the government fulfilled its constitutional obligations with respect to control exerted over electricity supply.
In contrast, under the 1985 electricity law the single integrated system meant that PLN had control over the whole process, and seemingly this ensured electricity supply across the board. The reality is that the theory and practice were considerably different as the 1985 electricity law highlighted that this mechanism was also considerably less efficient than required for optimal electricity supply to the greatest number of Indonesian citizens.
The new law though is problematic with regards to terminology and definition. The new law refers to an integrated system, but uses “may” within the framework of supply (see Article 10(2)). This is problematic because the elucidations are silent as to what this might entail. Therefore, it is expected that there will be a need to confirm implementing regulations at, at least, the ministerial level to provide clarity as to how this provision is to be interpreted and implemented.
Decentralization
Standard practice for all new legislation is that it includes provisions relating to the decentralization of powers and authorities. The decentralization provisions in this law relate to providing enhanced authority and power to the regional governments with respect to setting electricity tariffs. This is expected to provide sufficient incentive to regional governments to be pro-active in developing their respective electricity industry.
The authorities of the regional and local governments are clearly described in the new law in Article 5(2) and (3) and include, among others:
-
The right to issue regional and local electricity regulations;
-
The right to issue regional and local electricity plans (Rencana Umum Ketenagalistrikan Daerah);
-
The right to stipulate business permits within the regional and local governments respective territories, and;
-
The right to set tariffs for electricity.
Regionalization of Electricity Tariffs
The new law provides in Article 34(1) that the Central Government will set electricity tariffs. Article 34(2) states that Regional Governments can also set electricity tariffs. On face value, this would seemingly create a multi-tier pricing system. Critics point out that legislating in this way will lead to discrimination between electricity consumers. Some consumers will enjoy much cheaper electricity that others depending on where they live. The critics go on to claim that this type of discrimination is unfair.
Nevertheless, the construction of the relevant articles indicates that the central government will set out a general pricing or tariff pattern. Then the regional governments have a degree of flexibility in terms of constructing their pricing or tariff patterns within that basic central government framework. In any event, the new law grants ultimate control over tariff matters to the central government in that the central government can overrule a regional government if the tariff structure is deemed inappropriate.
Inter-State Transactions
The buying and selling of electricity across borders was not directly regulated previously. This short-coming has been rectified in the new law. This is important as the new law sets out explicitly the conditions that must be present to either buy or sell electricity.
The key concern with the sale of electricity is satisfaction of domestic demand. Simply, before any application to sell electricity will be entertained, the applicant must prove that there is enough electricity supply for domestic consumption that the sale will not negatively impact on the needs of Indonesian consumers.
In contrast, purchasing electricity entails a lot more to be proven. First and foremost, the applicant must be able to prove that there is a shortage of electricity that cannot be satisfied through domestic supply mechanisms and channels. The purchase of electricity is prohibited where it will harm the national interest, or where there are questions of sovereignty, security, or economic development being harmed.
Conclusion
The fact that the Constitutional Court declared the previous electricity law invalid and that the government has attempted to balance the concerns of the Court concerning control with the need for greater efficiency generally in the electricity sector suggests that the government did a rather poor job in drafting the previous attempt. In all likelihood, if the previous incarnation of the electricity law had been allowed to stand then the majority of Indonesia’s electricity resources would have been snapped up by foreign companies.
As a result, the new law provides a unique approach in regulating the power sector. The provisions of the new law appear to facilitate the expectations of the masses, and introduce a win-win solution that will overcome the prevailing issues in the supply of electricity.
The possibility of another judicial review remains, particularly as the criticisms remain with respect to the liberalization of the electricity sector. However, it is expected that the government will more vigorously defend this incarnation of the electricity law as they are loathe to be seen to have failed twice in the construction of the electricity law. Furthermore, the new law appears to comply with the ruling of the Constitutional Court. This does not make the new law immune from challenge. However, it does make it less likely that a challenge would be successful.
Regulation of essential utilities such as electricity is always a difficult proposition as the government seeks to balance competing interests and competing needs. Nevertheless, as the recently passed Bill on Electricity highlights, there was that need. The bill has now been enacted through promulgation as Law No. 30 of 2009.
The House of Representatives (Dewan Perwakilan Rakyat / DPR) enjoyed a legislation blitz in the period leading up to its dissolution and replacing with a newly elected parliament. There was a raft of legislation passed. Amongst these was the Bill on Electricity (Rancangan Undang-undang Ketenagalistrikan / RUU Ketenagalistrikan). The bill since becoming law has repealed and replaced Law No. 15 of 1985.
The bill came about after the Constitutional Court handed down a decision on 15 December 2004 which in effect ordered the government to draft and enact a new electricity law. So, it is fair to say that the new law has been a long time in the making. In fact, the route to the passage of a law that now seemingly complies with the 1945 Constitution has been a long and tortuous one.
The previous Electricity Law, No. 20 of 2002, was struck down by the Constitutional Court. Nevertheless, as was noted above, this meant that the law had to return to the previous constitutionally valid law in the field, Law No. 15 of 1985. This law was clearly no longer suitable with respect to regulating the electricity needs of a modern and developing democratic society.
It is therefore reasonable to suggest that the current incarnation of the Electricity Law contains a little bit of something for everyone, and is clearly a compromise designed to improve efficiency but also to avert any further Constitutional Court challenges to the substantive provisions of the law.
Yet, that said, it is worth noting that the bill is still not short of controversy. After the bill passed the House, there was considerable opposition from nationalist groups, particularly those who brought the previous challenge of the provisions that saw Law No. 20 of 2002 struck down by the Constitutional Court.
These groups are adamant that the provisions although reworded still intend to see a liberalizing of the electricity and power sectors to an extent that they are no longer compatible with the 1945 Constitution. The opposition by its very nature suggests that a future challenge may be undertaken. The gist of the argument is that a liberalization of this nature endangers future power and electricity supply to the broader population.
The primary difference between the new law and the old law is in who can supply electricity to the masses. Under Law No. 15 of 1985 the State Electricity Company (Perusahaan Listrik Negara (Persero) / PLN) enjoyed a monopoly over supply. This has turned out to be an inefficient manner to supply electricity. The revolving black and brown outs that Jakarta and the surrounding suburbs have been forced to endure over the years is testament to that inefficiency.
The simple fact now is that it is expected more competition will see an increase in efficiency and ensure the development of the necessary infrastructure while simultaneously broadening the base of supply.
Those that can now be involved in the supply of electricity include the central and regional governments through state and regional owned enterprises, cooperatives, communities, and the private sector.
The Constitutional Court Decision – Setting a Threshold
There were three applicants who lodged the judicial review of the 2002 Law, namely: Serikat Pekerja PLN, APHI (Asosiasi Penasehat Hukum Indonesia), and Ikatan Keluarga Pensiunan Listrik Negara. The Court determined that the applicants had the requisite legal standing to proceed, and then the Court then heard arguments.
Interestingly, the Court found that only certain provisions of the 2002 Electricity Law were in violation of the 1945 Constitution. Nevertheless, the Court went on to state that these provisions were the heart and soul of the 2002 Law. The primary article of contention was Article 33(2) of the 1945 Constitution as it relates to control of the state over essentially resources and services.
Yet, rather than strike down just the offending provisions; Articles 16, 17(3), and 68, the Court held that the invalidation of these articles meant that the 2002 Law would be unworkable without them. Therefore, the Court saw it necessary to strike down the whole law.
In essence, the Court held that the liberalizing of the electricity sector and the simultaneous stripping away of PLN’s effective monopoly would result in the government losing control of the provision of electricity to the broader community. The fear, that market forces would negatively impact on electricity supply to the broader community as businesses driven by market forces would be only interested in supplying electricity to those that can afford to pay for it.
This fear was not considering the major urban areas in Java, Madura, and Bali, but rather the more remote areas that would not benefit from any liberalization of the sector.
The Court then ordered the government, in effect, to draft and enact a new electricity law.
The basic premise of the Court’s decision was contained in the following:
-
The State, through its State Owned Enterprise (PLN), must hold the controlling power over the electricity supply;
-
Non-State entities are permitted to participate, yet only by way of cooperation with PLN;
-
The competition in the power sector must not eliminate the State’s controlling power; and
-
The prohibition is to apply the “unbundling system.”
This sets out a threshold with respect to how much control the government must retain over the electricity sector in order to comply with its obligations under the 1945 Constitution.
The New Law – Liberalization, Monopoly, or a Little Bit of Both
The debate as to whether the new law has sufficiently taken into account the Constitutional Court’s decision with respect to liberalization and control of the electricity sector remains t to be seen. However, it s worth noting that business is generally receptive of the new law and the opportunities that it seemingly provides to them to become more involved in the electricity sector.
In contrast, those that opposed the previous incarnation of the electricity law in 2002 maintain that the new law does not sufficiently protect ordinary citizens from the harm that private ownership of electricity sources would conceivably rain on affordable electricity supply.
Yet, the current framework seems to acknowledge that the tone of the new electricity law is different, and perhaps judgment needs to be reserved in order to allow the provisions to be tested in practice before judging whether or not the broader Indonesian community is going to suffer from foreign and private interests in the electricity sector.
The support for the idea of giving the new law some time stems from the quite different construction of the new law. It is clear that the provisions no longer allow a pure free market mechanism to determine production or cost of electricity supply. Nevertheless, the effective monopoly that PLN once enjoyed has been wound back, and wound back quite significantly.
Under the new law, electricity providers besides PLN, such as regional owned enterprises, cooperatives, private companies, and even communities, can engage in the power supply business. Non-PLN entities are also given the chance to supply electricity in areas where no electricity is available (remote areas, for example). It is worth remembering that the supply of electricity is an all inclusive endeavor and covers the generation, transmission, distribution, and sale of electricity.
The fundamental change that must be recognized between the new law and the old law is that the PLN, although not an absolute monopoly, held the powers of sector regulator in that it could set tariffs for electricity under the old law. Under the new law, PLN is essentially just another electricity provider or operator, as the government has assumed full control as regulator. Nevertheless, it is not all bad news for PLN. The new law still provides a priority mandate for PLN to supply electricity in the public interest.
The priority mandate functions as a “first right of refusal” and by definition this ensures that the government can state that there is always a guarantee for the supply of electricity.
Unbundling System
One of the reasons cited regarding the unconstitutionality of the 2000 electricity law was the “the unbundling system” to manage the supply of electricity (Article 16). Basically, the system separates the management of electricity, and consequently providers are enabled to control and manage the generation, transmission, distribution, and sale of electricity.
The problem is illustrated in the following table:
Generation
Owned by foreign private company (since generation is expensive)
According to the Court this system would create a situation where PLN or the government would not have sufficient control over the supply process. Consequently, the Court considered that this was a real risk to across the board supply to all Indonesians. Therefore, the 2002 electricity law failed in guaranteeing that the government fulfilled its constitutional obligations with respect to control exerted over electricity supply.
In contrast, under the 1985 electricity law the single integrated system meant that PLN had control over the whole process, and seemingly this ensured electricity supply across the board. The reality is that the theory and practice were considerably different as the 1985 electricity law highlighted that this mechanism was also considerably less efficient than required for optimal electricity supply to the greatest number of Indonesian citizens.
The new law though is problematic with regards to terminology and definition. The new law refers to an integrated system, but uses “may” within the framework of supply (see Article 10(2)). This is problematic because the elucidations are silent as to what this might entail. Therefore, it is expected that there will be a need to confirm implementing regulations at, at least, the ministerial level to provide clarity as to how this provision is to be interpreted and implemented.
Decentralization
Standard practice for all new legislation is that it includes provisions relating to the decentralization of powers and authorities. The decentralization provisions in this law relate to providing enhanced authority and power to the regional governments with respect to setting electricity tariffs. This is expected to provide sufficient incentive to regional governments to be pro-active in developing their respective electricity industry.
The authorities of the regional and local governments are clearly described in the new law in Article 5(2) and (3) and include, among others:
-
The right to issue regional and local electricity regulations;
-
The right to issue regional and local electricity plans (Rencana Umum Ketenagalistrikan Daerah);
-
The right to stipulate business permits within the regional and local governments respective territories, and;
-
The right to set tariffs for electricity.
Regionalization of Electricity Tariffs
The new law provides in Article 34(1) that the Central Government will set electricity tariffs. Article 34(2) states that Regional Governments can also set electricity tariffs. On face value, this would seemingly create a multi-tier pricing system. Critics point out that legislating in this way will lead to discrimination between electricity consumers. Some consumers will enjoy much cheaper electricity that others depending on where they live. The critics go on to claim that this type of discrimination is unfair.
Nevertheless, the construction of the relevant articles indicates that the central government will set out a general pricing or tariff pattern. Then the regional governments have a degree of flexibility in terms of constructing their pricing or tariff patterns within that basic central government framework. In any event, the new law grants ultimate control over tariff matters to the central government in that the central government can overrule a regional government if the tariff structure is deemed inappropriate.
Inter-State Transactions
The buying and selling of electricity across borders was not directly regulated previously. This short-coming has been rectified in the new law. This is important as the new law sets out explicitly the conditions that must be present to either buy or sell electricity.
The key concern with the sale of electricity is satisfaction of domestic demand. Simply, before any application to sell electricity will be entertained, the applicant must prove that there is enough electricity supply for domestic consumption that the sale will not negatively impact on the needs of Indonesian consumers.
In contrast, purchasing electricity entails a lot more to be proven. First and foremost, the applicant must be able to prove that there is a shortage of electricity that cannot be satisfied through domestic supply mechanisms and channels. The purchase of electricity is prohibited where it will harm the national interest, or where there are questions of sovereignty, security, or economic development being harmed.
Conclusion
The fact that the Constitutional Court declared the previous electricity law invalid and that the government has attempted to balance the concerns of the Court concerning control with the need for greater efficiency generally in the electricity sector suggests that the government did a rather poor job in drafting the previous attempt. In all likelihood, if the previous incarnation of the electricity law had been allowed to stand then the majority of Indonesia’s electricity resources would have been snapped up by foreign companies.
As a result, the new law provides a unique approach in regulating the power sector. The provisions of the new law appear to facilitate the expectations of the masses, and introduce a win-win solution that will overcome the prevailing issues in the supply of electricity.
The possibility of another judicial review remains, particularly as the criticisms remain with respect to the liberalization of the electricity sector. However, it is expected that the government will more vigorously defend this incarnation of the electricity law as they are loathe to be seen to have failed twice in the construction of the electricity law. Furthermore, the new law appears to comply with the ruling of the Constitutional Court. This does not make the new law immune from challenge. However, it does make it less likely that a challenge would be successful.