Postal Services Bill - A Better Postal Services Industry

Overview

On 15 September 2009 the House of Representatives (Dewan Perwakilan Rakyat / DPR) passed the Postal Services Bill. This bill is now waiting the signature of the President and to be given a number before becoming law. The bill is to repeal and replace the previous law in this field, Law No. 6 of 1984.

 

The bill had been bouncing around the DPR for 8 years before its recent passage. It was first submitted in 2001 by the government. The long and tortuous process of drafting this bill was mainly caused by the DPR’s reluctance - and partly by the government’s lack of effort - to prioritize the bill in the National Legislation Program (Program Legislasi Nasional / Prolegnas). However, the government chose to focus its energies and efforts on political related bills in the lead up to the general elections in 2009.

 

For some 25 years, postal services in Indonesia have been by and large dominated by the Indonesian Post Office Limited Liability Company (PT. Pos Indonesia Persero / Posindo). Posindo is the only authorized entity and therefore is the only entity that has the right to provide certain postal services, including mail, aerogram (warkatpos), and postcards.

 

The exclusive rights that Posindo hold under Law No. 6 of 1984 have been roundly criticized as being anti-competitive, a monopoly, and unhealthy as a business practice. Generally, those leveling those criticisms are providers of other postal services that see the monopoly enjoyed by Posindo as crippling their businesses and making it too difficult to compete on an equal footing.

 

The bill recognizes that the needs of the country and the economy have changed over time. Where a monopoly in crucial public services may have been a necessity in the early post-independence years, as a means of ensuring the provision of basic services, including postal services, those times, in most instances, have passed. State owned enterprises now have the tools at their disposal to be competitive in a more open market place, and as such the monopoly enjoyed by Posindo is considered redundant across the majority of postal services provided.

 

The impact that the provisions in the bill have on the monopoly enjoyed by Posindo are obvious. However, the bill is so much more than just a monopoly buster. The bill also seeks to codify a number of issues that had not been clear in Law No. 6 of 1984. For example, the bill explicitly deals with cooperation with foreign postal services and interconnections, among others. The bill also endeavors to codify matters that had not previously been legislated for.

 

It is worth noting that the bill covers many issues in a very general sense, and relies much more heavily on government and ministerial regulations to provide clarity and context to the provisions for the purposes of implementation. As such, even once the bill is enacted the previous implementing regulation will remain in force until such time as they are repealed and replaced.

 

It is for these reasons that the DPR finally passed the bill.

 

 “The End” of the Postal Monopoly Era

Law No. 6 of 1984 granted Posindo a monopoly in that Posindo had exclusive rights over mail, aerograms, and postcards at certain weights. So, in that sense it was a limited monopoly as other postal service providers could provide services where the packages and mail weighed more than 2000 grams.

 

Even though the monopoly was not absolute it clearly harmed consumer choice as most standard mail was within the exclusive domain of Posindo. To ensure that other postal services providers were not tempted to engage in the exclusive domain of Posindo, Law No. 6 of 1984 criminalized the actions of any non-Posindo provider who engaged in the exclusive domain of Posindo. Simply, the lack of choice meant that consumers were required to use Posindo services no matter whether they were good or bad.

 

The bill stipulates that other providers can offer postal services. It is expected that regional governments, the private sector, and cooperatives will take up the opportunity to broaden and bolster the current postal services that they provide. This in theory should allow for greater competition, greater consumer choice, and ultimately a reduction in costs with a simultaneous increase in service quality.

 

Services Standards

The bill is clear from the outset that the law will no longer discriminate against postal services providers. However, those that opt to enter the market, do so under strict conditions. The postal services providers must be able to meet minimum, but prevailing, standards with respect to (1) time, (2) fees /costs, and (3) procedures. The explicit nature of the standards remains to be defined as these are to be contained in a subsequent implementing regulation.

 

Nevertheless, it is expected that these implementing regulations will deal with a variety of matters, including that all equipment used in providing postal services meet exacting national and international standards.

 

Mail: Clarity in its Meaning

The definition of mail is much broader than it once was. The definition covers not only traditional mail, but also covers electronic mail, packaged services, logistical services, financial transactions, and postal agency services. For many, the definition is too broad and does not distinguish between the value of mail by lumping all mail together. Nevertheless, the expansion of the meaning poses new challenges and opportunities with respect to the introduction of electronic mail services and financial transactions, among others.

 

The Indonesian Association of Express Service Companies (Asosiasi Perusahaan Jasa Ekspres Indonesia / ASPERINDO) has consistently argued that there must be a universal rate for compensation for lost mail. Simply, it does not matter whether the mail lost is a love letter or a certificate of graduation, there is not differentiation between the two and compensation is the same. This would clearly whittle away consumer protections when postal services companies provide the ultimate bad service and lose one’s mail.

 

However, the bill in fact distinguishes between various types of mail and documents, and accommodates developments in the types of mail available as part of the provision of postal services. The distinctions can be found in the Elucidation to Article 5(1)(a) of the bill.

 

Simply, mail is defined as written communication either in the physical or electronic form. Documents are defined as data, records, and / or any kind of statements (written or tape recorded), in so far as they are to be seen, read, or heard. Moreover, a document must have a commercial value.

 

Compensation for Losses

Law No. 6 of 1984 regulates that when losses have occurred to the postal goods, the customer will be paid compensation proportional or equivalent to the damaged or the lost goods.

 

However in the bill, compensation is not set up in a rigid manner; it only requires the postal providers to pay compensation, but does not dictate how this compensation is to be made. Instead the bill sets out both the providers and the customers are to settle the compensation payable by way of mutual agreement.

 

Yet, there are legitimate concerns that this places the balance of power in the relationship with the provider, as it is expected that the fine print or clauses that will accompany the sending of mail will stipulate maximum values for loss that constitute any liability incumbent upon the provider of postal services.

 

Interconnections

In order to achieve the goals of providing a universal postal service, it is imperative that there is a link between the providers. Under this bill, this link is called interconnections.

 

The bill sets forth that any interconnections, whether for the purpose of providing inter-local or international postal services, must comply with 4 principles: non-discrimination, transparency, liability, and mutual benefit.

 

Foreign Investment and Cooperation

The postal services market is not only the domain of local providers. The market already contains a significant foreign presence through global companies like DHL, UPS, and Fedex having a presence in Indonesia. The liberalization of the postal services market provides, seemingly, not only an opportunity for local postal services providers but for international postal services providers as well. It is expected that consequently there is likely to be aggressive expansion in the sector over the coming months and years.

 

Any foreign investment in the postal services sector is regulated under the provisions of the relevant foreign investment laws and regulations. However, the bill sets out the manner in which a foreign postal services provider may operate, including licensing. These provisions are to be found in Articles 11 – 13 of the bill.

 

The bill clearly stipulates that foreign investment, irrespective of whether it is a postal or non-postal company, may engage in postal businesses in Indonesia. Nevertheless, there are certain requirements that they are bound to fulfill. For example, the foreign entities are to cooperate with local postal services providers, and their shares ownership cannot be at a level that makes them the majority shareholder.

 

Additionally, any cooperation between foreign investors and local postal services will have limited access to the market. They are only allowed to provide services to the provincial level. This is further moderated to require that the relevant province have an international airport or port.

 

The bill also requires any postal service companies, including those affiliated with foreign entities, to be incorporated (badan hukum).

 

It must be noted that the cooperation also includes working together with local postal companies, including Posindo. Posindo’s role in the provision of postal services throughout the country is without doubt significant, as it has more than 3000 post offices, and 8000 vehicles to assist in the provision of its services.

 

The non-Posindo providers are likely to cooperate with Posindo, and further share Posindo’s infrastructure and facilities. This is expected to ensure that the provision of postal services improve both in efficiency and effectiveness.

 

Conclusion

Considering, the length of time that the bill was bounced around at the DPR it is not surprising that once the commitment to pass the bill was made that the bill passed quickly. There was surprisingly little debate or matters of contention in the bill, meaning that the DPR and the government have seemingly been successful in accommodating all of the necessary requirements to keep both providers and consumers satisfied.

 

It is worth noting that the bill requires further implementing regulations in order to be enforceable. It is expected that these regulations, although not prioritized, will be available in the not too distant future.

 

However, the goal of better postal services requires that the commitment to enforcement remains high.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku

Overview

On 15 September 2009 the House of Representatives (Dewan Perwakilan Rakyat / DPR) passed the Postal Services Bill. This bill is now waiting the signature of the President and to be given a number before becoming law. The bill is to repeal and replace the previous law in this field, Law No. 6 of 1984.

 

The bill had been bouncing around the DPR for 8 years before its recent passage. It was first submitted in 2001 by the government. The long and tortuous process of drafting this bill was mainly caused by the DPR’s reluctance - and partly by the government’s lack of effort - to prioritize the bill in the National Legislation Program (Program Legislasi Nasional / Prolegnas). However, the government chose to focus its energies and efforts on political related bills in the lead up to the general elections in 2009.

 

For some 25 years, postal services in Indonesia have been by and large dominated by the Indonesian Post Office Limited Liability Company (PT. Pos Indonesia Persero / Posindo). Posindo is the only authorized entity and therefore is the only entity that has the right to provide certain postal services, including mail, aerogram (warkatpos), and postcards.

 

The exclusive rights that Posindo hold under Law No. 6 of 1984 have been roundly criticized as being anti-competitive, a monopoly, and unhealthy as a business practice. Generally, those leveling those criticisms are providers of other postal services that see the monopoly enjoyed by Posindo as crippling their businesses and making it too difficult to compete on an equal footing.

 

The bill recognizes that the needs of the country and the economy have changed over time. Where a monopoly in crucial public services may have been a necessity in the early post-independence years, as a means of ensuring the provision of basic services, including postal services, those times, in most instances, have passed. State owned enterprises now have the tools at their disposal to be competitive in a more open market place, and as such the monopoly enjoyed by Posindo is considered redundant across the majority of postal services provided.

 

The impact that the provisions in the bill have on the monopoly enjoyed by Posindo are obvious. However, the bill is so much more than just a monopoly buster. The bill also seeks to codify a number of issues that had not been clear in Law No. 6 of 1984. For example, the bill explicitly deals with cooperation with foreign postal services and interconnections, among others. The bill also endeavors to codify matters that had not previously been legislated for.

 

It is worth noting that the bill covers many issues in a very general sense, and relies much more heavily on government and ministerial regulations to provide clarity and context to the provisions for the purposes of implementation. As such, even once the bill is enacted the previous implementing regulation will remain in force until such time as they are repealed and replaced.

 

It is for these reasons that the DPR finally passed the bill.

 

 “The End” of the Postal Monopoly Era

Law No. 6 of 1984 granted Posindo a monopoly in that Posindo had exclusive rights over mail, aerograms, and postcards at certain weights. So, in that sense it was a limited monopoly as other postal service providers could provide services where the packages and mail weighed more than 2000 grams.

 

Even though the monopoly was not absolute it clearly harmed consumer choice as most standard mail was within the exclusive domain of Posindo. To ensure that other postal services providers were not tempted to engage in the exclusive domain of Posindo, Law No. 6 of 1984 criminalized the actions of any non-Posindo provider who engaged in the exclusive domain of Posindo. Simply, the lack of choice meant that consumers were required to use Posindo services no matter whether they were good or bad.

 

The bill stipulates that other providers can offer postal services. It is expected that regional governments, the private sector, and cooperatives will take up the opportunity to broaden and bolster the current postal services that they provide. This in theory should allow for greater competition, greater consumer choice, and ultimately a reduction in costs with a simultaneous increase in service quality.

 

Services Standards

The bill is clear from the outset that the law will no longer discriminate against postal services providers. However, those that opt to enter the market, do so under strict conditions. The postal services providers must be able to meet minimum, but prevailing, standards with respect to (1) time, (2) fees /costs, and (3) procedures. The explicit nature of the standards remains to be defined as these are to be contained in a subsequent implementing regulation.

 

Nevertheless, it is expected that these implementing regulations will deal with a variety of matters, including that all equipment used in providing postal services meet exacting national and international standards.

 

Mail: Clarity in its Meaning

The definition of mail is much broader than it once was. The definition covers not only traditional mail, but also covers electronic mail, packaged services, logistical services, financial transactions, and postal agency services. For many, the definition is too broad and does not distinguish between the value of mail by lumping all mail together. Nevertheless, the expansion of the meaning poses new challenges and opportunities with respect to the introduction of electronic mail services and financial transactions, among others.

 

The Indonesian Association of Express Service Companies (Asosiasi Perusahaan Jasa Ekspres Indonesia / ASPERINDO) has consistently argued that there must be a universal rate for compensation for lost mail. Simply, it does not matter whether the mail lost is a love letter or a certificate of graduation, there is not differentiation between the two and compensation is the same. This would clearly whittle away consumer protections when postal services companies provide the ultimate bad service and lose one’s mail.

 

However, the bill in fact distinguishes between various types of mail and documents, and accommodates developments in the types of mail available as part of the provision of postal services. The distinctions can be found in the Elucidation to Article 5(1)(a) of the bill.

 

Simply, mail is defined as written communication either in the physical or electronic form. Documents are defined as data, records, and / or any kind of statements (written or tape recorded), in so far as they are to be seen, read, or heard. Moreover, a document must have a commercial value.

 

Compensation for Losses

Law No. 6 of 1984 regulates that when losses have occurred to the postal goods, the customer will be paid compensation proportional or equivalent to the damaged or the lost goods.

 

However in the bill, compensation is not set up in a rigid manner; it only requires the postal providers to pay compensation, but does not dictate how this compensation is to be made. Instead the bill sets out both the providers and the customers are to settle the compensation payable by way of mutual agreement.

 

Yet, there are legitimate concerns that this places the balance of power in the relationship with the provider, as it is expected that the fine print or clauses that will accompany the sending of mail will stipulate maximum values for loss that constitute any liability incumbent upon the provider of postal services.

 

Interconnections

In order to achieve the goals of providing a universal postal service, it is imperative that there is a link between the providers. Under this bill, this link is called interconnections.

 

The bill sets forth that any interconnections, whether for the purpose of providing inter-local or international postal services, must comply with 4 principles: non-discrimination, transparency, liability, and mutual benefit.

 

Foreign Investment and Cooperation

The postal services market is not only the domain of local providers. The market already contains a significant foreign presence through global companies like DHL, UPS, and Fedex having a presence in Indonesia. The liberalization of the postal services market provides, seemingly, not only an opportunity for local postal services providers but for international postal services providers as well. It is expected that consequently there is likely to be aggressive expansion in the sector over the coming months and years.

 

Any foreign investment in the postal services sector is regulated under the provisions of the relevant foreign investment laws and regulations. However, the bill sets out the manner in which a foreign postal services provider may operate, including licensing. These provisions are to be found in Articles 11 – 13 of the bill.

 

The bill clearly stipulates that foreign investment, irrespective of whether it is a postal or non-postal company, may engage in postal businesses in Indonesia. Nevertheless, there are certain requirements that they are bound to fulfill. For example, the foreign entities are to cooperate with local postal services providers, and their shares ownership cannot be at a level that makes them the majority shareholder.

 

Additionally, any cooperation between foreign investors and local postal services will have limited access to the market. They are only allowed to provide services to the provincial level. This is further moderated to require that the relevant province have an international airport or port.

 

The bill also requires any postal service companies, including those affiliated with foreign entities, to be incorporated (badan hukum).

 

It must be noted that the cooperation also includes working together with local postal companies, including Posindo. Posindo’s role in the provision of postal services throughout the country is without doubt significant, as it has more than 3000 post offices, and 8000 vehicles to assist in the provision of its services.

 

The non-Posindo providers are likely to cooperate with Posindo, and further share Posindo’s infrastructure and facilities. This is expected to ensure that the provision of postal services improve both in efficiency and effectiveness.

 

Conclusion

Considering, the length of time that the bill was bounced around at the DPR it is not surprising that once the commitment to pass the bill was made that the bill passed quickly. There was surprisingly little debate or matters of contention in the bill, meaning that the DPR and the government have seemingly been successful in accommodating all of the necessary requirements to keep both providers and consumers satisfied.

 

It is worth noting that the bill requires further implementing regulations in order to be enforceable. It is expected that these regulations, although not prioritized, will be available in the not too distant future.

 

However, the goal of better postal services requires that the commitment to enforcement remains high.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku
2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info