Health Services - A Constitutional Right and the Passage of the Hospital Bill
Overview
The Bill on Hospitals was always destined to be. This is so for a number of reasons. But, paramount among these is that the government has recognized that it was failing in providing a regulatory framework that satisfied the guaranteed constitutional rights all Indonesian citizens enjoy to health care and health services. Furthermore, the regulatory framework of a mish-mash of government regulations and ministerial decisions was simply no longer able to cope with medical and health services in the 21st Century.
Yet, if the government was going to satisfy the burden of providing health services to a level that the 1945 Constitution envisaged, then any legislation would need to be pro-patient while simultaneously not neglecting the reality of business needs with respect to the provision of these most critical services. It is from within this framework that the bill was drafted, debated, and finally passed.
As has been noted, the regulatory framework for such an important and critical component of Indonesian life needed to be regulated in the form of a law. The deficiencies of the current regulatory regime in the modern era highlighted that there were insufficient provisions to govern matters such as malpractice, discrimination in the provisions of medical services, poor safety procedures, and even poorer procedures for patient complaints to be heard.
Nevertheless, the bill includes some innovative provisions with respect to the rights and obligations of hospitals, the rights and obligations of patients, and also introduces, at least conceptually, the idea of living wills. The bill seemingly also addresses the issue of the right to die for patients.
The provisions are not necessarily responsive to any one particular issue. However, it is worth noting that had passage of the bill occurred earlier in the year, then perhaps an issue such as the Prita Mulyasari defamation case might have been avoided. The bill provides clear and explicit complaint mechanisms that conceivably circumvent the need for disgruntled patients from going public with their complaints.
Nevertheless, if a patient does make public any complaint regarding medical or health treatment, then this would in effect trigger a “right of reply” provision in the bill that permits the hospital or relevant doctor to breach doctor - patient confidentiality in order to defend themselves against the complaint.
It was clear that the government was keen to see the hospital bill passed before the end of the current parliamentary session.
Pro-Patient or Pro-Business or a Little Bit of Both
The bill is pro-patient in many respects. The Health Minister, Siti Fadilah Supari, has gone to great lengths to highlight this fact. However, this should not be construed as being anti-business. The provisions that make this bill pro-patient are not onerous in the sense that the health services business is going to be assuming financial losses to meet any pro-patient ideals. Yet, there is an element of Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) about these provisions. Health services providers, and in particular hospitals in this case, are required to provide health and medical services without consideration of one’s ability to pay. Simply, gone are the days of demanding an up-front “fee” or down payment before considering the provision of emergency treatment.
The bill is hardly universal health care. Yet, it does go some way to ensuring that even the poorest and most marginalized of Indonesia’s citizens can obtain medical and health services.
To maintain a functioning hospital and health services sector, the government has realized that there is a need for huge levels of investment to ensure that Indonesian hospitals and health services meet a standard that is capable of facing the impacts of globalization, but more importantly facing the stresses that an ever-increasing population will put on the provision of hospital and health services. Clearly, the government is not going to be able to fund all this investment from its own coffers. Therefore, there is an expectation that there will be increasing opportunities for public / private partnerships, and in very specific circumstances, private investment.
Promotion, Prevention, Cure, and Rehabilitation
It is also important to note that the bill focuses on four key medical and health services, namely: promotion, prevention, cure (treatment), and rehabilitation. Unfortunately, the bill does not deal with the specifics of how each of these four key areas is to be addressed. Nevertheless, it is expected that health services initiatives will be constructed along these lines.
The rationale clearly being that it is cheaper to promote good health and well-being practices and offer preventive medicine and health services than it is to cure disease and illness, and then rehabilitate patients. For example, obesity is a medical problem that gives rise to myriad of other health related issues that would subsequently require medical treatment and rehabilitation. Therefore, if promotion and preventive measures can be undertaken, and are successful then there would conceivably less financial stress on the sector in dealing with obesity and related health problems in the future.
Physical Structures
The bill is comprehensive in that it also sets out specifications for hospitals with respect to buildings and facilities that must be provided to satisfy minimum standards. For example, hospitals must have an emergency room, operation theatre, radiology room, and a morgue, among others.
Foreign Medical Staff
Hospitals can employ foreign staff. However, this is premised on need. Generally, it is expected that Indonesian hospitals will utilize Indonesian expertise where the expertise exists. Foreign medical staff will need to prove that they are qualified and licensed in their country of origin. It is also expected that any foreign medical staff engaged will transfer their skills and knowledge to local doctors and staff.
Hospital Types and Classifications
The bill also sets out the types and classifications of hospitals. Public hospitals are to be classifies across four levels, A to D. Article 29 of the bill deals explicitly with the obligations incumbent upon hospitals. The idea that the bill is pro-patient finds support in this article. Hospitals are required to provide medical treatment to the level of their capabilities without discrimination.
Licensing
All hospitals are to be licensed for both their initial establishment and subsequent operations. For example, an establishment license is valid for a period of two years, and may be extended for a further one year if required. In contrast, an operational license is issued for a period of five years. An operational license can be renewed as necessary so long as the hospital remains in compliance with all prevailing laws and regulations relating to hospital operations.
Depending on the classification of the hospital, the license will be issued by the Minister, Regional or Local government.
Hospital Services for the Poor and Marginalized
Furthermore, all hospitals must provide services to those who are unable to pay or who are poor and cannot pay set rates for services. The services must be provided to the poor and unable to pay in emergency situations without a requirement to pay any upfront fees. It would seem that the days of emergency treatment only being rendered after a down payment is made have passed.
Rights and Obligations - Patients
The bill also sets out the obligations and rights of patients. As was noted earlier this Charter of Rights for both the hospitals and the patients may have allowed Prita Mulyasari and OmniInternationalHospital to avoid the defamation litigation that they continue to find themselves in. Patients have a right to a second opinion, either from another hospital doctor where they are or to get another doctor from outside the hospital to provide that opinion.
Patient Medical Records
Patients also have explicit rights to their complete medical records. Patients also have the right to sue hospitals either as a civil or as a criminal matter if they believe the services provided to them breach any of the prevailing laws and regulations in this sector.
National Fee Pattern for Hospital Services
Hospital fees will be set out in a national fee document. It is expected that the fee pattern will provide guidelines for fees based on actual cost of the services provided. And, hospitals are required to set their fees at levels commensurate with what is stipulated in the fee pattern as determined by the Minister.
Costs of Medicines
Hospital pharmacies must guarantee the supply, quality, and safety, among other matters, of any medicines and drugs that they hold. The cost of these medicines and drugs must be reasonable and within the scope of prices / cost set by the government. The elucidation to article 15 requires that hospital pharmacies list all the medicines and drugs that are available for patients either transparently or in a book which also states all relevant costs.
The intention is to provide patients with medicine and drug options other than the branded options recommended by doctors. It is presumed that as a requirement of the transparency provisions that generic alternatives are to be listed as well.
National Hospital Supervisory Agency
The bill also sets out a new independent body called the National Hospital Supervisory Agency to maintain and supervise hospitals. The Agency is set up by the Health Minister in order to guarantee any matters relating to hospitals. It has the function to not only maintain and supervise the rights and obligations of patients and hospitals, but also receive complaints, and to settle disputes.
Accreditation
All hospitals are required to undergo an accreditation process. This process is designed to facilitate constant improvement in the quality of services provided. Accreditation must be renewed at least once every three years. The accreditation can be done either by a domestic or international accreditation agency. The accreditation agency must be independent. The accreditation agencies permitted to provide the requisite hospital accreditation will be determined by the Minister.
It is expected that there will be additional regulations in the form of Ministerial Regulations with respect to this provision.
Doctor – Patient Privilege and Confidentiality
However, it must be noted that the bill includes a provision in Article 44 for the hospital to breach doctor / patient privilege and confidentiality where the patient sues the hospital and then goes public with their claim. Any patient that goes public is to be deemed to have released the hospital and relevant doctors from any confidentiality obligations regarding a patient’s medical records.
The right to defend themselves is categorized as “hak jawab”, or the right to answer or respond to any allegations or claimed by the patient.
Living Wills and the Right to Die
Furthermore, Article 45(1) absolves a hospital and doctors from responsibility for a patient’s death in care if the patient or the patient’s family refuses treatment or medical care. However, the provision requires that the hospital explains the consequences of refusing any such treatment or care. In essence, this is a “right to die” if the patient or the patients family or guardian refuses further medical treatment.
However, the specifics of this provision are almost certainly going to require further clarification. This is particularly so where the patient is of legal age but may otherwise be incapacitated by their illness or disease. Specifically, Article 45 opens the door to “living wills” where a person can stipulate whether or not they want to be treated or resuscitated in the event of a debilitating illness or disease.
A recent case in the United Kingdom has highlighted some of the dilemma that medical professionals will face in circumstances where the patient or the patient’s family and / or guardians opt to cease treatment. In this case, a suicidal woman, who had made a living will stipulating that she was not to be treated or resuscitated, drank enough poison to kill herself. The medical staff that were called felt compelled not to treat or resuscitate her. The medical staff were also concerned that legally, treating her would have exposed them to charges of assault.
In a separate case in the United Kingdom, a quadriplegic man won the right to legally refuse treatment in the event of illness. He subsequently succumbed to an infection after refusing treatment.
It is worth noting that the elucidation to this provision states that treatment and care cannot be stopped for financial reasons alone. If a patient or the patient’s family is no longer able to afford treatment or care, then they are to be informed that the government will guarantee treatment and care.
Article 45(2) states that hospitals, and presumably doctors, cannot be sued or prosecuted for attempting to save the life of a person, if that person is to later die. The elucidation on this particular provision is silent as to the parameters for this. It is expected that this provision may require further clarification. However, if further clarification is not forthcoming, then this would imply that those with a grievance in this area would rely on provisions relating to medical malpractice to sustain any claim where someone dies whilst being treated in a life or death situation, which ultimately results in death.
Compliance Issues
All current hospitals are given a two-year grace period to come into compliance with the provisions of the bill once it is enacted into law.
Enactment
The bill comes into immediate force once it is enacted. Enactment requires the signature of the President. If the President fails to sign the bill into law then the bill will self-enact after 30 days pursuant to the 1945 Constitution.
Conclusion
The Bill on Hospitals is an important piece of legislation as it codifies the constitutional rights that Indonesian citizens are guaranteed by simply being Indonesian. The provisions are pro-patient, but this is not at the expense of fundamental needs of attracting investment into the hospitals sector.
The bill does not specifically address matters such as public / private partnerships. However, it is clear that foreign and domestic capital is envisaged to play an integral role in the development of a hospitals system that serves the needs of an ever-growing Indonesian population.
Interestingly, the bill introduces the concept of living wills and codifies a right to die for patients who wish to refuse further treatment. It is expected that these provisions will require further clarification, but it is unclear whether this additional regulatory clarification will precede or succeed an incident where a living will is invoked for the purposes of enjoying the right to die.
Ultimately, the bill puts in place a hospital system that ensures basic health services to all of Indonesia’s citizens irrespective of whether one is rich, marginalized, or poor.
The Bill on Hospitals was always destined to be. This is so for a number of reasons. But, paramount among these is that the government has recognized that it was failing in providing a regulatory framework that satisfied the guaranteed constitutional rights all Indonesian citizens enjoy to health care and health services. Furthermore, the regulatory framework of a mish-mash of government regulations and ministerial decisions was simply no longer able to cope with medical and health services in the 21st Century.
Yet, if the government was going to satisfy the burden of providing health services to a level that the 1945 Constitution envisaged, then any legislation would need to be pro-patient while simultaneously not neglecting the reality of business needs with respect to the provision of these most critical services. It is from within this framework that the bill was drafted, debated, and finally passed.
As has been noted, the regulatory framework for such an important and critical component of Indonesian life needed to be regulated in the form of a law. The deficiencies of the current regulatory regime in the modern era highlighted that there were insufficient provisions to govern matters such as malpractice, discrimination in the provisions of medical services, poor safety procedures, and even poorer procedures for patient complaints to be heard.
Nevertheless, the bill includes some innovative provisions with respect to the rights and obligations of hospitals, the rights and obligations of patients, and also introduces, at least conceptually, the idea of living wills. The bill seemingly also addresses the issue of the right to die for patients.
The provisions are not necessarily responsive to any one particular issue. However, it is worth noting that had passage of the bill occurred earlier in the year, then perhaps an issue such as the Prita Mulyasari defamation case might have been avoided. The bill provides clear and explicit complaint mechanisms that conceivably circumvent the need for disgruntled patients from going public with their complaints.
Nevertheless, if a patient does make public any complaint regarding medical or health treatment, then this would in effect trigger a “right of reply” provision in the bill that permits the hospital or relevant doctor to breach doctor - patient confidentiality in order to defend themselves against the complaint.
It was clear that the government was keen to see the hospital bill passed before the end of the current parliamentary session.
Pro-Patient or Pro-Business or a Little Bit of Both
The bill is pro-patient in many respects. The Health Minister, Siti Fadilah Supari, has gone to great lengths to highlight this fact. However, this should not be construed as being anti-business. The provisions that make this bill pro-patient are not onerous in the sense that the health services business is going to be assuming financial losses to meet any pro-patient ideals. Yet, there is an element of Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) about these provisions. Health services providers, and in particular hospitals in this case, are required to provide health and medical services without consideration of one’s ability to pay. Simply, gone are the days of demanding an up-front “fee” or down payment before considering the provision of emergency treatment.
The bill is hardly universal health care. Yet, it does go some way to ensuring that even the poorest and most marginalized of Indonesia’s citizens can obtain medical and health services.
To maintain a functioning hospital and health services sector, the government has realized that there is a need for huge levels of investment to ensure that Indonesian hospitals and health services meet a standard that is capable of facing the impacts of globalization, but more importantly facing the stresses that an ever-increasing population will put on the provision of hospital and health services. Clearly, the government is not going to be able to fund all this investment from its own coffers. Therefore, there is an expectation that there will be increasing opportunities for public / private partnerships, and in very specific circumstances, private investment.
Promotion, Prevention, Cure, and Rehabilitation
It is also important to note that the bill focuses on four key medical and health services, namely: promotion, prevention, cure (treatment), and rehabilitation. Unfortunately, the bill does not deal with the specifics of how each of these four key areas is to be addressed. Nevertheless, it is expected that health services initiatives will be constructed along these lines.
The rationale clearly being that it is cheaper to promote good health and well-being practices and offer preventive medicine and health services than it is to cure disease and illness, and then rehabilitate patients. For example, obesity is a medical problem that gives rise to myriad of other health related issues that would subsequently require medical treatment and rehabilitation. Therefore, if promotion and preventive measures can be undertaken, and are successful then there would conceivably less financial stress on the sector in dealing with obesity and related health problems in the future.
Physical Structures
The bill is comprehensive in that it also sets out specifications for hospitals with respect to buildings and facilities that must be provided to satisfy minimum standards. For example, hospitals must have an emergency room, operation theatre, radiology room, and a morgue, among others.
Foreign Medical Staff
Hospitals can employ foreign staff. However, this is premised on need. Generally, it is expected that Indonesian hospitals will utilize Indonesian expertise where the expertise exists. Foreign medical staff will need to prove that they are qualified and licensed in their country of origin. It is also expected that any foreign medical staff engaged will transfer their skills and knowledge to local doctors and staff.
Hospital Types and Classifications
The bill also sets out the types and classifications of hospitals. Public hospitals are to be classifies across four levels, A to D. Article 29 of the bill deals explicitly with the obligations incumbent upon hospitals. The idea that the bill is pro-patient finds support in this article. Hospitals are required to provide medical treatment to the level of their capabilities without discrimination.
Licensing
All hospitals are to be licensed for both their initial establishment and subsequent operations. For example, an establishment license is valid for a period of two years, and may be extended for a further one year if required. In contrast, an operational license is issued for a period of five years. An operational license can be renewed as necessary so long as the hospital remains in compliance with all prevailing laws and regulations relating to hospital operations.
Depending on the classification of the hospital, the license will be issued by the Minister, Regional or Local government.
Hospital Services for the Poor and Marginalized
Furthermore, all hospitals must provide services to those who are unable to pay or who are poor and cannot pay set rates for services. The services must be provided to the poor and unable to pay in emergency situations without a requirement to pay any upfront fees. It would seem that the days of emergency treatment only being rendered after a down payment is made have passed.
Rights and Obligations - Patients
The bill also sets out the obligations and rights of patients. As was noted earlier this Charter of Rights for both the hospitals and the patients may have allowed Prita Mulyasari and OmniInternationalHospital to avoid the defamation litigation that they continue to find themselves in. Patients have a right to a second opinion, either from another hospital doctor where they are or to get another doctor from outside the hospital to provide that opinion.
Patient Medical Records
Patients also have explicit rights to their complete medical records. Patients also have the right to sue hospitals either as a civil or as a criminal matter if they believe the services provided to them breach any of the prevailing laws and regulations in this sector.
National Fee Pattern for Hospital Services
Hospital fees will be set out in a national fee document. It is expected that the fee pattern will provide guidelines for fees based on actual cost of the services provided. And, hospitals are required to set their fees at levels commensurate with what is stipulated in the fee pattern as determined by the Minister.
Costs of Medicines
Hospital pharmacies must guarantee the supply, quality, and safety, among other matters, of any medicines and drugs that they hold. The cost of these medicines and drugs must be reasonable and within the scope of prices / cost set by the government. The elucidation to article 15 requires that hospital pharmacies list all the medicines and drugs that are available for patients either transparently or in a book which also states all relevant costs.
The intention is to provide patients with medicine and drug options other than the branded options recommended by doctors. It is presumed that as a requirement of the transparency provisions that generic alternatives are to be listed as well.
National Hospital Supervisory Agency
The bill also sets out a new independent body called the National Hospital Supervisory Agency to maintain and supervise hospitals. The Agency is set up by the Health Minister in order to guarantee any matters relating to hospitals. It has the function to not only maintain and supervise the rights and obligations of patients and hospitals, but also receive complaints, and to settle disputes.
Accreditation
All hospitals are required to undergo an accreditation process. This process is designed to facilitate constant improvement in the quality of services provided. Accreditation must be renewed at least once every three years. The accreditation can be done either by a domestic or international accreditation agency. The accreditation agency must be independent. The accreditation agencies permitted to provide the requisite hospital accreditation will be determined by the Minister.
It is expected that there will be additional regulations in the form of Ministerial Regulations with respect to this provision.
Doctor – Patient Privilege and Confidentiality
However, it must be noted that the bill includes a provision in Article 44 for the hospital to breach doctor / patient privilege and confidentiality where the patient sues the hospital and then goes public with their claim. Any patient that goes public is to be deemed to have released the hospital and relevant doctors from any confidentiality obligations regarding a patient’s medical records.
The right to defend themselves is categorized as “hak jawab”, or the right to answer or respond to any allegations or claimed by the patient.
Living Wills and the Right to Die
Furthermore, Article 45(1) absolves a hospital and doctors from responsibility for a patient’s death in care if the patient or the patient’s family refuses treatment or medical care. However, the provision requires that the hospital explains the consequences of refusing any such treatment or care. In essence, this is a “right to die” if the patient or the patients family or guardian refuses further medical treatment.
However, the specifics of this provision are almost certainly going to require further clarification. This is particularly so where the patient is of legal age but may otherwise be incapacitated by their illness or disease. Specifically, Article 45 opens the door to “living wills” where a person can stipulate whether or not they want to be treated or resuscitated in the event of a debilitating illness or disease.
A recent case in the United Kingdom has highlighted some of the dilemma that medical professionals will face in circumstances where the patient or the patient’s family and / or guardians opt to cease treatment. In this case, a suicidal woman, who had made a living will stipulating that she was not to be treated or resuscitated, drank enough poison to kill herself. The medical staff that were called felt compelled not to treat or resuscitate her. The medical staff were also concerned that legally, treating her would have exposed them to charges of assault.
In a separate case in the United Kingdom, a quadriplegic man won the right to legally refuse treatment in the event of illness. He subsequently succumbed to an infection after refusing treatment.
It is worth noting that the elucidation to this provision states that treatment and care cannot be stopped for financial reasons alone. If a patient or the patient’s family is no longer able to afford treatment or care, then they are to be informed that the government will guarantee treatment and care.
Article 45(2) states that hospitals, and presumably doctors, cannot be sued or prosecuted for attempting to save the life of a person, if that person is to later die. The elucidation on this particular provision is silent as to the parameters for this. It is expected that this provision may require further clarification. However, if further clarification is not forthcoming, then this would imply that those with a grievance in this area would rely on provisions relating to medical malpractice to sustain any claim where someone dies whilst being treated in a life or death situation, which ultimately results in death.
Compliance Issues
All current hospitals are given a two-year grace period to come into compliance with the provisions of the bill once it is enacted into law.
Enactment
The bill comes into immediate force once it is enacted. Enactment requires the signature of the President. If the President fails to sign the bill into law then the bill will self-enact after 30 days pursuant to the 1945 Constitution.
Conclusion
The Bill on Hospitals is an important piece of legislation as it codifies the constitutional rights that Indonesian citizens are guaranteed by simply being Indonesian. The provisions are pro-patient, but this is not at the expense of fundamental needs of attracting investment into the hospitals sector.
The bill does not specifically address matters such as public / private partnerships. However, it is clear that foreign and domestic capital is envisaged to play an integral role in the development of a hospitals system that serves the needs of an ever-growing Indonesian population.
Interestingly, the bill introduces the concept of living wills and codifies a right to die for patients who wish to refuse further treatment. It is expected that these provisions will require further clarification, but it is unclear whether this additional regulatory clarification will precede or succeed an incident where a living will is invoked for the purposes of enjoying the right to die.
Ultimately, the bill puts in place a hospital system that ensures basic health services to all of Indonesia’s citizens irrespective of whether one is rich, marginalized, or poor.