Amendment to the Transmigration Law

Overview:

A scan of any population map of Indonesia will show that Indonesia’s population primarily finds itself concentrated in cities and the most significant numbers being found on the island of Java. The government’s response to this rapid urbanization is transmigration. The down side of increasing urbanization is that vast areas of Indonesia remain as untapped potential reserves or resources. The increasing urbanization demands, for example, better and higher levels of agricultural production to feed an ever-increasing population. The government has always believed that one of the key benefits of transmigration was the ability for Indonesia to remain self-sufficient while exploiting previously uninhabited areas of the archipelago.

 

Therefore, the primary objective of the Indonesian transmigration program is national development. Some of the key elements of the transmigration program were getting those urban dwellers with limited or no employment prospects into regions that hold huge potential but lack development. In simple terms, transmigration also served to take the pressure off of ever-expanding urban areas.

 

The transmigration program has travelled a long and tortuous road. It had been regulated in various regulations and under different political conditions as well. Transmigration has existed in some form throughout the years of the “Old Order” and the “New Order”, and until the present government of SBY.

 

Nevertheless, it is only since the period of “reformasi” and the greater emphasis placed on regional autonomy that the laws and regulations governing the comings and goings of Indonesians have started to be decentralized and the power and authorities associated with governance have begun to trickle down to the regional governments. Simply, under the old and new order regimes of Soekarno and Soeharto, transmigration was a central government matter and was regulated in a very authoritarian manner.

 

The new framework does not just provide greater power and authority to regional governments and administrations to regulate and manage transmigration, it also provides enhanced opportunities for community participation in the development of the transmigration program.

 

Greater public participation will clearly be of benefit as it is likely to result in outcomes that are more in-line with expectations, as the “locals” and those looking to be beneficiaries of the transmigration program have more say in how the program must evolve in order to be successful.

 

Therefore, in many ways the DPR’s decision to pass the Transmigration Law Bill can conceivably be viewed as the light at the end of the tunnel. The purpose of the bill is to address the perceived deficiencies in the current framework and replace those with provisions that serve the purposes of transmigration. The scope ensures that the transmigration program is no longer a simple means of Javanization of the archipelago or population control in terms of moving people out of an over-populated Java to the outer islands and sparsely populated provinces.

 

Transmigration in a Nutshell

The freedom of movement has been recognized as one of the basic human rights under the general rule of law. Therefore, the implementation of urbanization of people from villages or towns to cities is nothing else but lawful.

 

Nevertheless, there are drawbacks in urbanization, particularly where those people who are moving to an urban area in pursuit of a better life are those who are not equipped with sufficient skills or education. This is problematic for a number of reasons; limited skills and limited education means limited employment opportunities, increased exploitation of those on the margins of society, increased homelessness, increased desperation, and increasing pressure on the local environment as it tries to sustain the urban scrawl. For a city, such as Jakarta, the ability to sustain the population is critical. It is clear that Jakarta is not a city where the natural environment is capable of sustaining increasing numbers of residents without considerable upgrading of current infrastructure and the development of new infrastructure.

 

There are two choices; improve and develop infrastructure or look to remove some of the population through voluntary transmigration to less-densely populated areas. The government’s choice is to utilize and to perfect the transmigration system.

 

As was noted earlier, the transmigration system is not a new phenomenon in Indonesia. To the contrary, transmigration has a long history in Indonesia. A transmigration program was first used by the Dutch during colonial times. The program differs only in who benefits, as the objective is still to develop untapped potential and resources, and instead of the benefits accruing only for Dutch interests, the current program is looking to not only tap untapped resources but to spread wealth and prosperity throughout the archipelago by providing opportunities to all Indonesians to use their expertise and industriousness to develop and exploit undeveloped parts of the Republic.

 

The Regulatory Framework

Before 1997 the prevailing law with respect to transmigration was Law No. 3 of 1972. In essence, the Law permitted the Central Government to run a lone hand when it came to matters related to transmigration. This ensured that more often than not, transmigration goals were not reached or targets achieved as the policies almost always failed to take into account local needs. The reality was that the big picture was like a jigsaw puzzle and required all the little pieces to be placed in the right order for that picture to become clear. Simply, without regional and local participation the big picture never came into focus.

 

It has been argued that during the old and new orders a steady hand was needed as the nation moved out of a period of colonization into independence. The rationale was simply that an authoritarian central government was the only way that transmigration could conceivably succeed, particularly when the nation was populated by incompetent regional governments. Yet, hindsight is 20/20 and a more likely rationale was that transmigration permitted the exploitation of Indonesia’s vast natural wealth and the central government was desperate to ensure that it had full control over this exploitation and the wealth that it was to generate.

 

In 1997, Law No. 3 of 1972 was repealed and replaced by Law No. 15 of 1997 (in force from 9 May 1997). In essence, the new law put an end to the centralized system and provided the regional governments greater opportunities to capitalize on the transmigration program. The basic goal being to ensure the welfare and prosperity of the transmigrants themselves, the local communities to which they relocated or created, and to spread the wealth around with a view to improving the prosperity of all Indonesians.

 

Nevertheless, the enactment of Law No. 15 of 1997 posed some interesting issues with regards to consistency in legislation.

 

Transmigration Amendment Bill: A Limited Amendment for Consistency

As a general rule of law there is maxim of lex superiori derogat lex inferiori - that a lower regulation will be void if it conflicts with a higher regulation. This means that every piece of legislation must be in harmony with its relevant superior regulation(s).

 

Law No. 15 of 1997 was established pursuant to several provisions of the 1945 Constitution, specifically: Articles 5(1), 18, 20(1), 27(2), and 33(3). In this instance, it is clear that the previous law is hierarchically lower than the latter regulation. Thus, Law No. 15 of 1997 was correctly enacted. The hierarchy of legislations in Indonesia is enumerated in Law No. 10 of 2004 on Legislation Drafting.

 

However, the 1998 “reformasi” became a pivotal moment for any legislation that was produced on the basis of the 1945 Constitution. Subsequent to the reformation in Indonesia, the 1945 Constitution underwent a series of four amendments through the period from 1999 to 2002. Consequently, Law No. 15 of 1997 has to be amended in order for it to be consistent with the amended 1945 Constitution.

 

It must be noted that the bill is an amendment bill. Therefore, the bill amends specific articles of Law No. 15 of 1997 and does not repeal and replace the whole.

 

What’s New? - Decentralization

The amendments focus almost exclusively on the decentralization of certain transmigration-related authorities from the Central government to the Regional Governments. These authorities that have devolved to the regional governments in the most general terms include the authority to provide, establish, and develop areas for transmigration.

 

The most notable result from the decentralization above is that now the roles of the central, provincial, and regency / city governments are clear. Consequently, it is expected that there will no longer be any centralization of practices.

 

As stated earlier, the amendment bill mostly consists of the transfer of authorities that the central government used to hold to the regional governments. These authorities include the following points:

-

The authorities to take part in the implementation of all types of transmigration (Normal Transmigration, Cooperative Transmigration - the central and / or regional governments and private entities, and Self-Initiative Transmigration - initiated by the transmigrants but with the help of the central and / or regional governments) [See Articles 7(1), 8(1), and 9(1)];

-

The rights to assist any transmigrants in order to facilitate the transmigration types [See Articles 13(1), 14(1 - 3), 15 (1), and 25(6)];

-

The provision of transmigration sites within Normal Transmigration and Cooperative Transmigration initiatives [See Articles 25(4 )];

-

The authorities to disseminate information with respect to the availability of vacancies, business opportunities, places to live, geographical conditions, and the cultures of the transmigration destination(s) [See Article 26(1)];

-

The rights to provide education and training for the prospective transmigrants in both the Normal Transmigration and Cooperative Transmigration initiatives [Article 29(2)];

-

The relocation of transmigration [See Article 30(2 - 4)];

-

The authorities to develop both the transmigrants as well as their respective areas [Article 32(2)];

-

The authorities to facilitate the community to be part of the transmigration process [See Article 35(3)], and;

-

Lastly, the regional governments, specifically the Governor, and / or the Regent / Mayor, are also granted the supervisory duty in order to oversee the implementation of transmigration initiatives [See Article 35A(1)].

 

Impact of the Amendments

The amendments have granted greater power to the regional government in the process of implementing transmigration. Generally, the greater authorities that one possesses the greater responsibility one holds. This is also true in this case. The authorities that the regional governments hold entails equal responsibility on their part.

 

These responsibilities may vary in practice. The best way to identify and determine the responsibility is by assessing whether the transmigration-related activities are conducted pursuant to the principles of autonomy (asas otonomi) or auxiliary duty (asas tugas pembantuan). Under the Amendment Bill, both principles are acknowledged as one of the reasons behind the drive to amend Law No. 15 of 1997.

 

Provided that the implementation of transmigration employs the principle of autonomy, then anything that arises in the process of implementation will be fully borne by the regional governments. This is so because the usage of the principle of autonomy means that the regional governments are to implement their governmental affairs, in this case transmigration, directly through initiatives they generate themselves.

 

In contrast, if the transmigration uses the principles of auxiliary duty, then the regional governments are only responsible for the task they are specifically assigned. According to this principle, the funding, human resources, and facilities and infrastructure are to be provided by the central government.

 

Sanctions

Originally, the provisions concerning sanctions are enumerated in Articles 37 and 38 of Law No. 15 of 1997. These provisions only explain that any violations in the process of transmigration will be subject to an administrative action by the Minister of Labor and Transmigration. Furthermore, it also stipulates that the provisions on such administrative action will be regulated in a Government Regulation.

 

For the reason above, the amendments inserted two special chapters with respect to sanctions, particularly: Chapters XB and XC. The former deals specifically with the administrative sanctions that are to be imposed on any state officials, whether those of the central and / or regional governments, private entities, transmigrants, and groups that have infringed any of the bill’s provisions.

 

These administrative sanctions take the following forms: oral warning, written warning, or cancellation of documents depending on the subjects. These documents may be a license (for business entities), transmigrant status (for transmigrants), and the Minister of Labor and Transmigration permission (for groups). However, for state officials, the amendments only stipulate that the administrative sanctions will be imposed based on the relevant regulations.

 

Meanwhile, Chapter XC provides criminal sanctions if any of the breaches in Chapter XB contain criminal elements.

 

Conclusion

It is clear that transmigration is very important to Indonesia. The transmigration scheme has also provided Indonesia with great assistance. Nonetheless, despite the foregoing discussion about the positive impacts that transmigration have brought, there are also the negative aspects on the other side of the equation.

 

Therefore, the latest amendment is expected to further reduce the negatives while simultaneously enhancing the positives.

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku

Overview:

A scan of any population map of Indonesia will show that Indonesia’s population primarily finds itself concentrated in cities and the most significant numbers being found on the island of Java. The government’s response to this rapid urbanization is transmigration. The down side of increasing urbanization is that vast areas of Indonesia remain as untapped potential reserves or resources. The increasing urbanization demands, for example, better and higher levels of agricultural production to feed an ever-increasing population. The government has always believed that one of the key benefits of transmigration was the ability for Indonesia to remain self-sufficient while exploiting previously uninhabited areas of the archipelago.

 

Therefore, the primary objective of the Indonesian transmigration program is national development. Some of the key elements of the transmigration program were getting those urban dwellers with limited or no employment prospects into regions that hold huge potential but lack development. In simple terms, transmigration also served to take the pressure off of ever-expanding urban areas.

 

The transmigration program has travelled a long and tortuous road. It had been regulated in various regulations and under different political conditions as well. Transmigration has existed in some form throughout the years of the “Old Order” and the “New Order”, and until the present government of SBY.

 

Nevertheless, it is only since the period of “reformasi” and the greater emphasis placed on regional autonomy that the laws and regulations governing the comings and goings of Indonesians have started to be decentralized and the power and authorities associated with governance have begun to trickle down to the regional governments. Simply, under the old and new order regimes of Soekarno and Soeharto, transmigration was a central government matter and was regulated in a very authoritarian manner.

 

The new framework does not just provide greater power and authority to regional governments and administrations to regulate and manage transmigration, it also provides enhanced opportunities for community participation in the development of the transmigration program.

 

Greater public participation will clearly be of benefit as it is likely to result in outcomes that are more in-line with expectations, as the “locals” and those looking to be beneficiaries of the transmigration program have more say in how the program must evolve in order to be successful.

 

Therefore, in many ways the DPR’s decision to pass the Transmigration Law Bill can conceivably be viewed as the light at the end of the tunnel. The purpose of the bill is to address the perceived deficiencies in the current framework and replace those with provisions that serve the purposes of transmigration. The scope ensures that the transmigration program is no longer a simple means of Javanization of the archipelago or population control in terms of moving people out of an over-populated Java to the outer islands and sparsely populated provinces.

 

Transmigration in a Nutshell

The freedom of movement has been recognized as one of the basic human rights under the general rule of law. Therefore, the implementation of urbanization of people from villages or towns to cities is nothing else but lawful.

 

Nevertheless, there are drawbacks in urbanization, particularly where those people who are moving to an urban area in pursuit of a better life are those who are not equipped with sufficient skills or education. This is problematic for a number of reasons; limited skills and limited education means limited employment opportunities, increased exploitation of those on the margins of society, increased homelessness, increased desperation, and increasing pressure on the local environment as it tries to sustain the urban scrawl. For a city, such as Jakarta, the ability to sustain the population is critical. It is clear that Jakarta is not a city where the natural environment is capable of sustaining increasing numbers of residents without considerable upgrading of current infrastructure and the development of new infrastructure.

 

There are two choices; improve and develop infrastructure or look to remove some of the population through voluntary transmigration to less-densely populated areas. The government’s choice is to utilize and to perfect the transmigration system.

 

As was noted earlier, the transmigration system is not a new phenomenon in Indonesia. To the contrary, transmigration has a long history in Indonesia. A transmigration program was first used by the Dutch during colonial times. The program differs only in who benefits, as the objective is still to develop untapped potential and resources, and instead of the benefits accruing only for Dutch interests, the current program is looking to not only tap untapped resources but to spread wealth and prosperity throughout the archipelago by providing opportunities to all Indonesians to use their expertise and industriousness to develop and exploit undeveloped parts of the Republic.

 

The Regulatory Framework

Before 1997 the prevailing law with respect to transmigration was Law No. 3 of 1972. In essence, the Law permitted the Central Government to run a lone hand when it came to matters related to transmigration. This ensured that more often than not, transmigration goals were not reached or targets achieved as the policies almost always failed to take into account local needs. The reality was that the big picture was like a jigsaw puzzle and required all the little pieces to be placed in the right order for that picture to become clear. Simply, without regional and local participation the big picture never came into focus.

 

It has been argued that during the old and new orders a steady hand was needed as the nation moved out of a period of colonization into independence. The rationale was simply that an authoritarian central government was the only way that transmigration could conceivably succeed, particularly when the nation was populated by incompetent regional governments. Yet, hindsight is 20/20 and a more likely rationale was that transmigration permitted the exploitation of Indonesia’s vast natural wealth and the central government was desperate to ensure that it had full control over this exploitation and the wealth that it was to generate.

 

In 1997, Law No. 3 of 1972 was repealed and replaced by Law No. 15 of 1997 (in force from 9 May 1997). In essence, the new law put an end to the centralized system and provided the regional governments greater opportunities to capitalize on the transmigration program. The basic goal being to ensure the welfare and prosperity of the transmigrants themselves, the local communities to which they relocated or created, and to spread the wealth around with a view to improving the prosperity of all Indonesians.

 

Nevertheless, the enactment of Law No. 15 of 1997 posed some interesting issues with regards to consistency in legislation.

 

Transmigration Amendment Bill: A Limited Amendment for Consistency

As a general rule of law there is maxim of lex superiori derogat lex inferiori - that a lower regulation will be void if it conflicts with a higher regulation. This means that every piece of legislation must be in harmony with its relevant superior regulation(s).

 

Law No. 15 of 1997 was established pursuant to several provisions of the 1945 Constitution, specifically: Articles 5(1), 18, 20(1), 27(2), and 33(3). In this instance, it is clear that the previous law is hierarchically lower than the latter regulation. Thus, Law No. 15 of 1997 was correctly enacted. The hierarchy of legislations in Indonesia is enumerated in Law No. 10 of 2004 on Legislation Drafting.

 

However, the 1998 “reformasi” became a pivotal moment for any legislation that was produced on the basis of the 1945 Constitution. Subsequent to the reformation in Indonesia, the 1945 Constitution underwent a series of four amendments through the period from 1999 to 2002. Consequently, Law No. 15 of 1997 has to be amended in order for it to be consistent with the amended 1945 Constitution.

 

It must be noted that the bill is an amendment bill. Therefore, the bill amends specific articles of Law No. 15 of 1997 and does not repeal and replace the whole.

 

What’s New? - Decentralization

The amendments focus almost exclusively on the decentralization of certain transmigration-related authorities from the Central government to the Regional Governments. These authorities that have devolved to the regional governments in the most general terms include the authority to provide, establish, and develop areas for transmigration.

 

The most notable result from the decentralization above is that now the roles of the central, provincial, and regency / city governments are clear. Consequently, it is expected that there will no longer be any centralization of practices.

 

As stated earlier, the amendment bill mostly consists of the transfer of authorities that the central government used to hold to the regional governments. These authorities include the following points:

-

The authorities to take part in the implementation of all types of transmigration (Normal Transmigration, Cooperative Transmigration - the central and / or regional governments and private entities, and Self-Initiative Transmigration - initiated by the transmigrants but with the help of the central and / or regional governments) [See Articles 7(1), 8(1), and 9(1)];

-

The rights to assist any transmigrants in order to facilitate the transmigration types [See Articles 13(1), 14(1 - 3), 15 (1), and 25(6)];

-

The provision of transmigration sites within Normal Transmigration and Cooperative Transmigration initiatives [See Articles 25(4 )];

-

The authorities to disseminate information with respect to the availability of vacancies, business opportunities, places to live, geographical conditions, and the cultures of the transmigration destination(s) [See Article 26(1)];

-

The rights to provide education and training for the prospective transmigrants in both the Normal Transmigration and Cooperative Transmigration initiatives [Article 29(2)];

-

The relocation of transmigration [See Article 30(2 - 4)];

-

The authorities to develop both the transmigrants as well as their respective areas [Article 32(2)];

-

The authorities to facilitate the community to be part of the transmigration process [See Article 35(3)], and;

-

Lastly, the regional governments, specifically the Governor, and / or the Regent / Mayor, are also granted the supervisory duty in order to oversee the implementation of transmigration initiatives [See Article 35A(1)].

 

Impact of the Amendments

The amendments have granted greater power to the regional government in the process of implementing transmigration. Generally, the greater authorities that one possesses the greater responsibility one holds. This is also true in this case. The authorities that the regional governments hold entails equal responsibility on their part.

 

These responsibilities may vary in practice. The best way to identify and determine the responsibility is by assessing whether the transmigration-related activities are conducted pursuant to the principles of autonomy (asas otonomi) or auxiliary duty (asas tugas pembantuan). Under the Amendment Bill, both principles are acknowledged as one of the reasons behind the drive to amend Law No. 15 of 1997.

 

Provided that the implementation of transmigration employs the principle of autonomy, then anything that arises in the process of implementation will be fully borne by the regional governments. This is so because the usage of the principle of autonomy means that the regional governments are to implement their governmental affairs, in this case transmigration, directly through initiatives they generate themselves.

 

In contrast, if the transmigration uses the principles of auxiliary duty, then the regional governments are only responsible for the task they are specifically assigned. According to this principle, the funding, human resources, and facilities and infrastructure are to be provided by the central government.

 

Sanctions

Originally, the provisions concerning sanctions are enumerated in Articles 37 and 38 of Law No. 15 of 1997. These provisions only explain that any violations in the process of transmigration will be subject to an administrative action by the Minister of Labor and Transmigration. Furthermore, it also stipulates that the provisions on such administrative action will be regulated in a Government Regulation.

 

For the reason above, the amendments inserted two special chapters with respect to sanctions, particularly: Chapters XB and XC. The former deals specifically with the administrative sanctions that are to be imposed on any state officials, whether those of the central and / or regional governments, private entities, transmigrants, and groups that have infringed any of the bill’s provisions.

 

These administrative sanctions take the following forms: oral warning, written warning, or cancellation of documents depending on the subjects. These documents may be a license (for business entities), transmigrant status (for transmigrants), and the Minister of Labor and Transmigration permission (for groups). However, for state officials, the amendments only stipulate that the administrative sanctions will be imposed based on the relevant regulations.

 

Meanwhile, Chapter XC provides criminal sanctions if any of the breaches in Chapter XB contain criminal elements.

 

Conclusion

It is clear that transmigration is very important to Indonesia. The transmigration scheme has also provided Indonesia with great assistance. Nonetheless, despite the foregoing discussion about the positive impacts that transmigration have brought, there are also the negative aspects on the other side of the equation.

 

Therefore, the latest amendment is expected to further reduce the negatives while simultaneously enhancing the positives.

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku
2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info