New Regional Taxes and Regional Retributions Law

Overview

Decentralization and the devolution of power and authority is not a new phenomenon in Indonesia. The Central Government has long realized that there needs to be a managed decentralization and devolution of power to ensure the long-term success on the Republic of Indonesia. Nevertheless, the intent and theory has not always been realized in, or as, uniform practice. It is arguable whether Indonesia and her regional governments have ever really tasted the full flavors that decentralization and devolution have to offer.

 

The process of decentralization and the devolution of power to regional governments got into full swing in the period after the fall of the New Order government of Soeharto and the beginning of “reformasi”. It was believed that the increasingly authoritarian regime of the New Order was the basis for an ever-increasing centralization of power in Java and in particular Jakarta. To this end, the governments that have followed the New Order have taken steps to right the imbalances of the past through legislation culminating with the enactment of Law No. 32 of 2004 on Regional Government and Law No. 33 of 2004 on Fiscal Balance Between the Central and Regional Governments.

 

It is worth noting that these laws do not address all specific issues relating to the relationship between the Central and Regional governments. Therefore, it was expected that other legislation would be enacted to deal with the specifics of the relationship, such as, for example, taxation and retributions

 

The House of Representatives (Dewan Perwakilan Rakyat / DPR) has recently passed the Bill on Regional Taxation and Regional Retributions (Rancangan Undang-undang Pajak Daerah dan Retribusi Daerah / RUU PDRD). The bill was passed on 18 August 2009 and conforms with the spirit of decentralization and devolution of power from the centre to the regions. The essence of the new law is that it significantly moves the balance towards the regions by increasing the types of taxes and retributions that can be levied and collected in comparison to the previous regulatory framework as it was encompassed in Law No. 18 of 1997 as amended by Law No. 34 of 2000.

 

In a Nutshell

The basic objectives of the bill are:

i.

Provide the requisite authorities to the relevant regions with respect to the levying of taxes and retributions;

ii.

Raise levels of accountability at the regional level, improve the provision of services, and ultimately strengthen regional autonomy; and

iii.

Provide legal certainty for businesses and other with respect to what are legal taxes and retributions.

 

The bill is also premised on a number of key principles, including:

i.

Provide authorities to the relevant regional powers that were not onerous on the community when exercised and that were relatively fiscal neutral;

ii.

Restrict the types of taxation and retributions that may be levied by the regional powers to those that have been codified in law (closed lists);

iii.

Give the authority to regions to set taxes and retributions within the minimum and maximum frameworks provided for;

iv.

Allow the relevant regions to determine whether they are going to levy a certain tax or retribution according to the public policies of the relevant regions; and

v.

Strengthening of preventive and corrective measures through improved enforcement and punishment mechanisms.

 

The bill also enumerates an earmarking mechanism. Earmarking is, in essence, legislating that specific amounts of taxes and retributions collected are to be allocated to specific matters. For example, a minimum of 10% of motor vehicle taxes collected are to be allocated to road maintenance and development. Similarly, for cigarette (tobacco) taxes, at least 50% of these taxes are to be allocated to health and the enforcement of law matters.

 

The bill will repeal and replace Law No. 18 of 1997 as amended by Law No. 34 of 2000.

 

What’s New? – The Details

The most notable of the “new” is that the bill introduces new taxation and retribution powers for regional governments. Under the previous regime there were 11 types of regional taxes and 27 types of retributions that may be levied by a regional government. The bill introduces an additional 4 types of tax and 4 types of retribution that may be levied. Generally, this is referred to as the “base extension”.

 

These taxes and retributions include the following:

-

Taxes on lands and buildings in both villages and cities;

-

Taxes on the acquisition of lands and building rights; and

-

Taxes on Cigarettes (tobacco).

 

Furthermore,

-

Retributions on official seals;

-

Education;

-

Telecommunication towers; and

-

Fishing business licenses.

 

It is worth noting that these taxes and retributions on the whole are not new, but rather a phased transfer from their previous centralized collection to collection by the relevant and respective regional governments where that income is generated.

 

Central and Regional Governments’ Rights – A Balancing Act

The 1945 Constitution leaves no doubt that there are some powers that are exclusively reserved for the Central Government. Therefore, it is a misinterpretation to suggest that the point of regional autonomy is to see full decentralization and devolution of power from the central government to the respective regional governments. Clearly, matters of foreign affairs and policy, defense, judicial affairs, national monetary and fiscal policy, and religion remain outside the scope of regional governments.

 

Yet, it is clear that taxes and retributions are a matter that is to be within the scope of regional governments. This is recognized in Law No. 32 of 2004 as taxes and retributions are one of the ways in which regional governments are expected to generate income to fund themselves. Prior to the bill, the general authority was assumed by the central government however this has now clearly shifted to the regional governments.

 

Nevertheless, the changes are expected to be fiscally neutral. Simply, as the relevant regions assume more taxation and retribution authority there will be a commensurate decrease in the amount of financial support required from the central government.

 

It is expected that with increasing authorities and powers over taxes and retributions that regional governments as a matter of course will be required to become more accountable, more transparent, and better able to implement accepted principles of good governance. Nevertheless, the central government is not allowing the regional governments to set minimum and maximum tax and retribution levels. The central government reserves the right to set both the minimum and maximum level of tax or retribution that may be levied. The regional governments can levy a tax or retribution within those parameters. In fact, if for reasons of public policy or law, regions can choose not to levy a certain tax or retribution that it may otherwise have been permitted to.

 

Closed-List and Businesses

The beauty of the bill, and soon to be law, on regional taxation and retribution is that it sets out explicitly what taxes and retributions can be levied at the regional level. To all intents and purposes this must remove the often traumatic illegal taxes and levies imposed as part of doing business that had been standard procedure of the past. The closed list is essentially a list of taxes and retributions that may be levied by the regional governments. The closed list also sets out the rate at which these may be imposed.

 

For businesses, this means that there will no longer be any need to pay illegal taxes and retributions to facilitate business in certain regional government areas. The closed list in effect provides greater legal certainty for businesses in the conduct of their affairs. Whether this bears out in practice remains to be seen.

 

Preventive Policy

The preventive policy is a policy that is designed to ensure that the high cost of doing business does not remain a high cost in the future. Under the previous regulatory framework regional regulations that included taxes and retributions were not always consistent with other prevailing laws and regulations. This often led to double taxation and as such was not consistent with the idea of good taxation principles (prinsip pajak yang baik). Simply, the taxation and retribution system must facilitate business and not be a hindrance to overall costs and the free movement of goods and services.

 

This means that all regional taxes and levies will need to be approved before they may officially be levied and collected. The process will call for an evaluation by the Department of Finance. The Department of Finance will make a determination as to whether the proposed tax or retribution regulation is in compliance with the public interest and or legislation higher in the hierarchy of laws. If it is in compliance then the regulation may be enacted. In contrast, if the proposed regulation is in conflict then the Minister of Finance will reject the proposed regulation and the Minister of Home Affairs will be tasked with ensuring that the regulation does not come into force.

 

The regional governments would seem unlikely to then go ahead and implement a regulation that was not approved. The reason being that to do so would lead to the central government postponing or reducing any monies that might have been forthcoming under the General Allocation of Funds scheme (Dana Alokasi Umum) or the Profit Sharing Fund (Dana Bagi Hasil)  or restitution (Article 159(1) of the Regional Tax Law).

 

Conclusion

The intent and purpose of the bill is clear, a commitment to perfecting the decentralization and devolution of powers and authorities from the central government to that of the regional governments. The central government has realized that the regional governments need to have greater authority over their taxation and retribution powers in order to successfully administer themselves under the move towards greater, and ultimately full, regional autonomy.

 

The new regional taxation and retribution law is also more business friendly than provisions of the past. It is clear that the central government was only going to transfer greater taxation and retribution powers if the regions were prepared to provide greater legal certainty with respect to ensuring that businesses only pay those taxes and retributions that are permitted under valid legislation. A key element of the new law is that it is ultimately designed to be fiscally neutral in that regional governments will collect a larger share of the tax and retribution burden and consequently be less dependent on the central government for funding.

 

Finally, the new law is expected to play an important role in the ongoing decentralization and devolution of power between the central and regional governments.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku

Overview

Decentralization and the devolution of power and authority is not a new phenomenon in Indonesia. The Central Government has long realized that there needs to be a managed decentralization and devolution of power to ensure the long-term success on the Republic of Indonesia. Nevertheless, the intent and theory has not always been realized in, or as, uniform practice. It is arguable whether Indonesia and her regional governments have ever really tasted the full flavors that decentralization and devolution have to offer.

 

The process of decentralization and the devolution of power to regional governments got into full swing in the period after the fall of the New Order government of Soeharto and the beginning of “reformasi”. It was believed that the increasingly authoritarian regime of the New Order was the basis for an ever-increasing centralization of power in Java and in particular Jakarta. To this end, the governments that have followed the New Order have taken steps to right the imbalances of the past through legislation culminating with the enactment of Law No. 32 of 2004 on Regional Government and Law No. 33 of 2004 on Fiscal Balance Between the Central and Regional Governments.

 

It is worth noting that these laws do not address all specific issues relating to the relationship between the Central and Regional governments. Therefore, it was expected that other legislation would be enacted to deal with the specifics of the relationship, such as, for example, taxation and retributions

 

The House of Representatives (Dewan Perwakilan Rakyat / DPR) has recently passed the Bill on Regional Taxation and Regional Retributions (Rancangan Undang-undang Pajak Daerah dan Retribusi Daerah / RUU PDRD). The bill was passed on 18 August 2009 and conforms with the spirit of decentralization and devolution of power from the centre to the regions. The essence of the new law is that it significantly moves the balance towards the regions by increasing the types of taxes and retributions that can be levied and collected in comparison to the previous regulatory framework as it was encompassed in Law No. 18 of 1997 as amended by Law No. 34 of 2000.

 

In a Nutshell

The basic objectives of the bill are:

i.

Provide the requisite authorities to the relevant regions with respect to the levying of taxes and retributions;

ii.

Raise levels of accountability at the regional level, improve the provision of services, and ultimately strengthen regional autonomy; and

iii.

Provide legal certainty for businesses and other with respect to what are legal taxes and retributions.

 

The bill is also premised on a number of key principles, including:

i.

Provide authorities to the relevant regional powers that were not onerous on the community when exercised and that were relatively fiscal neutral;

ii.

Restrict the types of taxation and retributions that may be levied by the regional powers to those that have been codified in law (closed lists);

iii.

Give the authority to regions to set taxes and retributions within the minimum and maximum frameworks provided for;

iv.

Allow the relevant regions to determine whether they are going to levy a certain tax or retribution according to the public policies of the relevant regions; and

v.

Strengthening of preventive and corrective measures through improved enforcement and punishment mechanisms.

 

The bill also enumerates an earmarking mechanism. Earmarking is, in essence, legislating that specific amounts of taxes and retributions collected are to be allocated to specific matters. For example, a minimum of 10% of motor vehicle taxes collected are to be allocated to road maintenance and development. Similarly, for cigarette (tobacco) taxes, at least 50% of these taxes are to be allocated to health and the enforcement of law matters.

 

The bill will repeal and replace Law No. 18 of 1997 as amended by Law No. 34 of 2000.

 

What’s New? – The Details

The most notable of the “new” is that the bill introduces new taxation and retribution powers for regional governments. Under the previous regime there were 11 types of regional taxes and 27 types of retributions that may be levied by a regional government. The bill introduces an additional 4 types of tax and 4 types of retribution that may be levied. Generally, this is referred to as the “base extension”.

 

These taxes and retributions include the following:

-

Taxes on lands and buildings in both villages and cities;

-

Taxes on the acquisition of lands and building rights; and

-

Taxes on Cigarettes (tobacco).

 

Furthermore,

-

Retributions on official seals;

-

Education;

-

Telecommunication towers; and

-

Fishing business licenses.

 

It is worth noting that these taxes and retributions on the whole are not new, but rather a phased transfer from their previous centralized collection to collection by the relevant and respective regional governments where that income is generated.

 

Central and Regional Governments’ Rights – A Balancing Act

The 1945 Constitution leaves no doubt that there are some powers that are exclusively reserved for the Central Government. Therefore, it is a misinterpretation to suggest that the point of regional autonomy is to see full decentralization and devolution of power from the central government to the respective regional governments. Clearly, matters of foreign affairs and policy, defense, judicial affairs, national monetary and fiscal policy, and religion remain outside the scope of regional governments.

 

Yet, it is clear that taxes and retributions are a matter that is to be within the scope of regional governments. This is recognized in Law No. 32 of 2004 as taxes and retributions are one of the ways in which regional governments are expected to generate income to fund themselves. Prior to the bill, the general authority was assumed by the central government however this has now clearly shifted to the regional governments.

 

Nevertheless, the changes are expected to be fiscally neutral. Simply, as the relevant regions assume more taxation and retribution authority there will be a commensurate decrease in the amount of financial support required from the central government.

 

It is expected that with increasing authorities and powers over taxes and retributions that regional governments as a matter of course will be required to become more accountable, more transparent, and better able to implement accepted principles of good governance. Nevertheless, the central government is not allowing the regional governments to set minimum and maximum tax and retribution levels. The central government reserves the right to set both the minimum and maximum level of tax or retribution that may be levied. The regional governments can levy a tax or retribution within those parameters. In fact, if for reasons of public policy or law, regions can choose not to levy a certain tax or retribution that it may otherwise have been permitted to.

 

Closed-List and Businesses

The beauty of the bill, and soon to be law, on regional taxation and retribution is that it sets out explicitly what taxes and retributions can be levied at the regional level. To all intents and purposes this must remove the often traumatic illegal taxes and levies imposed as part of doing business that had been standard procedure of the past. The closed list is essentially a list of taxes and retributions that may be levied by the regional governments. The closed list also sets out the rate at which these may be imposed.

 

For businesses, this means that there will no longer be any need to pay illegal taxes and retributions to facilitate business in certain regional government areas. The closed list in effect provides greater legal certainty for businesses in the conduct of their affairs. Whether this bears out in practice remains to be seen.

 

Preventive Policy

The preventive policy is a policy that is designed to ensure that the high cost of doing business does not remain a high cost in the future. Under the previous regulatory framework regional regulations that included taxes and retributions were not always consistent with other prevailing laws and regulations. This often led to double taxation and as such was not consistent with the idea of good taxation principles (prinsip pajak yang baik). Simply, the taxation and retribution system must facilitate business and not be a hindrance to overall costs and the free movement of goods and services.

 

This means that all regional taxes and levies will need to be approved before they may officially be levied and collected. The process will call for an evaluation by the Department of Finance. The Department of Finance will make a determination as to whether the proposed tax or retribution regulation is in compliance with the public interest and or legislation higher in the hierarchy of laws. If it is in compliance then the regulation may be enacted. In contrast, if the proposed regulation is in conflict then the Minister of Finance will reject the proposed regulation and the Minister of Home Affairs will be tasked with ensuring that the regulation does not come into force.

 

The regional governments would seem unlikely to then go ahead and implement a regulation that was not approved. The reason being that to do so would lead to the central government postponing or reducing any monies that might have been forthcoming under the General Allocation of Funds scheme (Dana Alokasi Umum) or the Profit Sharing Fund (Dana Bagi Hasil)  or restitution (Article 159(1) of the Regional Tax Law).

 

Conclusion

The intent and purpose of the bill is clear, a commitment to perfecting the decentralization and devolution of powers and authorities from the central government to that of the regional governments. The central government has realized that the regional governments need to have greater authority over their taxation and retribution powers in order to successfully administer themselves under the move towards greater, and ultimately full, regional autonomy.

 

The new regional taxation and retribution law is also more business friendly than provisions of the past. It is clear that the central government was only going to transfer greater taxation and retribution powers if the regions were prepared to provide greater legal certainty with respect to ensuring that businesses only pay those taxes and retributions that are permitted under valid legislation. A key element of the new law is that it is ultimately designed to be fiscally neutral in that regional governments will collect a larger share of the tax and retribution burden and consequently be less dependent on the central government for funding.

 

Finally, the new law is expected to play an important role in the ongoing decentralization and devolution of power between the central and regional governments.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku
2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info