Green Trading: Certified Emission Reductions in Indonesia
Overview
Global warming, climate change, carbon footprints, greenhouse gases, an Inconvenient Truth, and a Nobel Peace Prize for the former Vice President of the United States of America, Al Gore, has the world talking and looking at ways to ensure that the environment survives. Whether one believes in the science of global warming or the seriousness of the threat, or even the urgency of facing the associated problems, the fact remains that the global community is, albeit, slowly moving towards doing something about how countries pollute the atmosphere.
The 1997 Kyoto Protocol were the first truly serious attempt to sign states up to making binding commitments to tackle the task at hand, global warming. This protocol is generally considered to be the starting point for a Certified Emission Reductions (CERs) scheme.
A CER is an instrument that can be traded amongst states, usually between those with high and those with low levels of emissions. As an instrument CERs will ultimately become like other trading instruments such as commercial paper, bonds, shares, and the like. A great number of states have already started to explore the potential of CERs and how to maximize the benefits they may bring. Indonesia is one of those states.
This edition of the Indonesian Law Digest intends to discuss and analyze some important features of the trading in CERs and the impact that this will have on the Indonesian business sector.
Kyoto Protocols
The 1997 Kyoto Protocols to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (Kyoto Protocols) included three basic protocols; Clean Development Mechanism (CDM), Joint Implementation, and Emission Trading. The CDM in essence seeks to reduce greenhouse gas emissions (GHG) by implementing projects that endeavor to fulfill this aim in developing countries. A CER is then granted as a return on the project. These CERs are then tracked and traded by industrialized countries as the CERs can be used to offset their respective emissions of GHG and ensure that they satisfy their respective commitments under the Kyoto Protocols.
It must be noted that the Kyoto Protocols are not as effective as they might have been. Simply, not all industrialized nations have signed up to them. The cold hard reality is that domestic political concerns far outweigh any global benefits of participation. For example, the US whose GHG emissions are some of the largest on the planet has steadfastly refused to sign onto the Kyoto Protocols. Therefore, it is fair to say that only those countries listed within Annex B of the Kyoto Protocols are likely to be interested in and able to trade CERs with developing countries.
Indonesia and the Kyoto Protocols
Indonesia’s commitment to the Kyoto Protocols has been affirmed in a number of ways. First, Indonesia has supported the development of the Kyoto Protocols and has signed on in terms of joining the frameworks proposed within them. Second, Indonesia has ratified the Kyoto Protocols in Law No. 17 of 2004. The driving, or motivating, force for Indonesia to sign on and ratify the Kyoto Protocols was to take advantage of the potential investment opportunities that would arise through the development of the CDM framework.
However, if Indonesia is really serious about capitalizing on the potential of CDM and CERs then it is clear that this potential must be sold to the broader business, investment, and local communities. Since 2004 there have only been a small number of CDM and CER projects implemented. The government must, therefore, commit to disseminating all of the pertinent information to those that will need it in order to make informed decisions about the CDM and the use and benefit of CERs. The failure to do so will ensure that Indonesia does not maximize its potential returns or benefits from the CER trading schemes that are developing.
Obtaining CERs
Obtaining a CER is not onerous. The more difficult the proposition the less likely it is to be successful. Therefore, with this in mind the process has been simplified. To obtain a CER requires (1) the buyer (whether a private or public entity) to purchase CERs from the project developer of the emissions reduction project; and (2) the buyer and the project developer can work together, but in return for this cooperation the buyer would have possession ofthe CERs.
Nevertheless, the relationship between the CERs and the CDM requires that the authorized body approves the implementation of the CDM. Simply, an unapproved CDM will not provide any tradable CERs. Therefore, it is important that any project interested in generating CERs follow the application process.
The procedural steps to apply for a CDM project are generally referred to as the “CDM project cycle.” The procedure consists of the following:
1.
Project Identification - Identification of the proposed GHG emission reduction plan by the project developer;
2.
Project Design - A preparation for the succeeding phase, in which all relevant information (details of the project, baseline - a situation without the proposed project, and financial resources, among others) are collated;
3.
Project Design Document - Every document related to the CDM project (general description of the project, baseline calculation, environmental quality threshold, and monitoring plan, among others);
4.
Approval from the Designated National Authority (DNA) - the preceding documents are to be sent to and assessed by the National Commission on CDM as Indonesia’s DNA (See Attachment I);
5.
Validation - if the DNA approves the project, then the documents will be validated by an independent validating body called the Designated Operational Entity (DOE);
6.
Registration - if the validation is also approved, the project is to be registered with the CDM-Executive Board and posted on its website for public comment;
7.
Implementation;
8.
Supervision and Monitoring - these measures are conducted by the project developer itself in the implementation of its approved projects;
9.
Verification - in this phase, the implementation is to be evaluated by an independent party, and;
10.
Issuance of the CERs - if the verification result is satisfactory, the project developer is entitled to request its CERs from the CDM-Executive Board, and these will be issued within 15 days (Pelangi Indonesia, Mencari Pohon Uang: CDM Kehutanan di Indonesia, 2003).
Emissions Reduction Purchase Agreement
Traditional sale and purchase agreements are not sufficient with respect to trading in CERs. The transaction between the project developer and the purchaser is to be contained in a new form of agreement called the Emissions Reduction Purchase Agreement (ERPA).
The standards for the ERPA are outlined by a non-profit organization in the field of trading GHG emissions reductions, the International Emissions Trading Association (IETA) (See Attachment II). The standard ERPA from IETA has been reviewed and modified a number of times to ensure that it is sufficient for its intended purpose; facilitating the trade of CERs under the CDM regime. The latest modification is ERPA Version 3.0 (2006).
In Indonesia, the ERPA has also been frequently utilized. In 2007, PT. Gikoko Kogyo Indonesia signed an ERPA with the World Bank Carbon Finance Unit for a Methane Abatement Project in the Batulayang, Pontianak Dumping Area. Furthermore, PT. Perusahaan Listrik Negara has also recently signed an ERPA with Agrienergy Pte Ltd for a CDM project relating to a Gas Power Plant in Bontang, East Kalimantan (30/7).
Risks Surrounding the Trading of CERs
There are rarely business transactions of this type that are risk free. However, to ensure that risk is minimized, then those risks must be acknowledged and due diligence undertaken to further reduce risk exposure.
The implementation of the CDM projects that are designed to generate CERs give rise to the following potential risks, and these may be distinguished into three separate parts:
1.
Risks arising from the projects alone - financing, approval, delays, and project underperformance;
2.
Risks relating to the Kyoto Protocol - the DOE gives inaccurate GHG emissions verification, and the project would be rejected by the CDM-Executive Board;
3.
Risks from the Host Country - domestic political instability would potentially result in the change of the laws, imposition of tax on CERs, and requirement of licenses because of risk that CERs are considered derivatives and financial arrangements.
Risks Insurance
The potential risks noted above have led to the development of a specialized sector of the insurance industry to address these risk concerns. Simply, where any risk is identified it makes good common sense to insure against those possible detrimental outcomes. The primary difference in this type of insurance are the objects that the project, the buyers,and any other relevant party would be seeking to insure.
Basically, insurance in this area is to ensure that the CERs are provided and change hands according to the prevailing ERPA.
Conclusion
The Kyoto Protocols are explicit in providing the best solution to deal with the current threat of global warming and climate change. The arguments for the wider adoption of the Kyoto Protocols, particularly for developing countries, are that the mechanisms are flexible and directly address the core issue of global warming. Furthermore, it is reasonable to state that for developing countries the mechanisms are generally economically friendly for the countries and for business.
It is clear that Indonesia has committed itself to the Kyoto Protocols by signing onto them and then ratifying them in domestic legislation. However, this is not the end of the game as far as it relates to CERs and CDM. The government clearly needs to do more in order to provide greater legal certainty in this developing area of carbon-based trading mechanisms. To this end, there is a need for more legislation to be enacted in order to provide the requisite legal certainty.
The ball is clearly in Indonesia’s court. If Indonesia is to take advantage of this opportunity then the government must be pro-active in promoting the benefits of CERs and facilitating the process of developing CDM projects that will generate tradable CERs. There is considerable potential for the trade in CERs to have a significant impact on the development and growth of the Indonesian economy going forward.
Global warming, climate change, carbon footprints, greenhouse gases, an Inconvenient Truth, and a Nobel Peace Prize for the former Vice President of the United States of America, Al Gore, has the world talking and looking at ways to ensure that the environment survives. Whether one believes in the science of global warming or the seriousness of the threat, or even the urgency of facing the associated problems, the fact remains that the global community is, albeit, slowly moving towards doing something about how countries pollute the atmosphere.
The 1997 Kyoto Protocol were the first truly serious attempt to sign states up to making binding commitments to tackle the task at hand, global warming. This protocol is generally considered to be the starting point for a Certified Emission Reductions (CERs) scheme.
A CER is an instrument that can be traded amongst states, usually between those with high and those with low levels of emissions. As an instrument CERs will ultimately become like other trading instruments such as commercial paper, bonds, shares, and the like. A great number of states have already started to explore the potential of CERs and how to maximize the benefits they may bring. Indonesia is one of those states.
This edition of the Indonesian Law Digest intends to discuss and analyze some important features of the trading in CERs and the impact that this will have on the Indonesian business sector.
Kyoto Protocols
The 1997 Kyoto Protocols to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (Kyoto Protocols) included three basic protocols; Clean Development Mechanism (CDM), Joint Implementation, and Emission Trading. The CDM in essence seeks to reduce greenhouse gas emissions (GHG) by implementing projects that endeavor to fulfill this aim in developing countries. A CER is then granted as a return on the project. These CERs are then tracked and traded by industrialized countries as the CERs can be used to offset their respective emissions of GHG and ensure that they satisfy their respective commitments under the Kyoto Protocols.
It must be noted that the Kyoto Protocols are not as effective as they might have been. Simply, not all industrialized nations have signed up to them. The cold hard reality is that domestic political concerns far outweigh any global benefits of participation. For example, the US whose GHG emissions are some of the largest on the planet has steadfastly refused to sign onto the Kyoto Protocols. Therefore, it is fair to say that only those countries listed within Annex B of the Kyoto Protocols are likely to be interested in and able to trade CERs with developing countries.
Indonesia and the Kyoto Protocols
Indonesia’s commitment to the Kyoto Protocols has been affirmed in a number of ways. First, Indonesia has supported the development of the Kyoto Protocols and has signed on in terms of joining the frameworks proposed within them. Second, Indonesia has ratified the Kyoto Protocols in Law No. 17 of 2004. The driving, or motivating, force for Indonesia to sign on and ratify the Kyoto Protocols was to take advantage of the potential investment opportunities that would arise through the development of the CDM framework.
However, if Indonesia is really serious about capitalizing on the potential of CDM and CERs then it is clear that this potential must be sold to the broader business, investment, and local communities. Since 2004 there have only been a small number of CDM and CER projects implemented. The government must, therefore, commit to disseminating all of the pertinent information to those that will need it in order to make informed decisions about the CDM and the use and benefit of CERs. The failure to do so will ensure that Indonesia does not maximize its potential returns or benefits from the CER trading schemes that are developing.
Obtaining CERs
Obtaining a CER is not onerous. The more difficult the proposition the less likely it is to be successful. Therefore, with this in mind the process has been simplified. To obtain a CER requires (1) the buyer (whether a private or public entity) to purchase CERs from the project developer of the emissions reduction project; and (2) the buyer and the project developer can work together, but in return for this cooperation the buyer would have possession ofthe CERs.
Nevertheless, the relationship between the CERs and the CDM requires that the authorized body approves the implementation of the CDM. Simply, an unapproved CDM will not provide any tradable CERs. Therefore, it is important that any project interested in generating CERs follow the application process.
The procedural steps to apply for a CDM project are generally referred to as the “CDM project cycle.” The procedure consists of the following:
1.
Project Identification - Identification of the proposed GHG emission reduction plan by the project developer;
2.
Project Design - A preparation for the succeeding phase, in which all relevant information (details of the project, baseline - a situation without the proposed project, and financial resources, among others) are collated;
3.
Project Design Document - Every document related to the CDM project (general description of the project, baseline calculation, environmental quality threshold, and monitoring plan, among others);
4.
Approval from the Designated National Authority (DNA) - the preceding documents are to be sent to and assessed by the National Commission on CDM as Indonesia’s DNA (See Attachment I);
5.
Validation - if the DNA approves the project, then the documents will be validated by an independent validating body called the Designated Operational Entity (DOE);
6.
Registration - if the validation is also approved, the project is to be registered with the CDM-Executive Board and posted on its website for public comment;
7.
Implementation;
8.
Supervision and Monitoring - these measures are conducted by the project developer itself in the implementation of its approved projects;
9.
Verification - in this phase, the implementation is to be evaluated by an independent party, and;
10.
Issuance of the CERs - if the verification result is satisfactory, the project developer is entitled to request its CERs from the CDM-Executive Board, and these will be issued within 15 days (Pelangi Indonesia, Mencari Pohon Uang: CDM Kehutanan di Indonesia, 2003).
Emissions Reduction Purchase Agreement
Traditional sale and purchase agreements are not sufficient with respect to trading in CERs. The transaction between the project developer and the purchaser is to be contained in a new form of agreement called the Emissions Reduction Purchase Agreement (ERPA).
The standards for the ERPA are outlined by a non-profit organization in the field of trading GHG emissions reductions, the International Emissions Trading Association (IETA) (See Attachment II). The standard ERPA from IETA has been reviewed and modified a number of times to ensure that it is sufficient for its intended purpose; facilitating the trade of CERs under the CDM regime. The latest modification is ERPA Version 3.0 (2006).
In Indonesia, the ERPA has also been frequently utilized. In 2007, PT. Gikoko Kogyo Indonesia signed an ERPA with the World Bank Carbon Finance Unit for a Methane Abatement Project in the Batulayang, Pontianak Dumping Area. Furthermore, PT. Perusahaan Listrik Negara has also recently signed an ERPA with Agrienergy Pte Ltd for a CDM project relating to a Gas Power Plant in Bontang, East Kalimantan (30/7).
Risks Surrounding the Trading of CERs
There are rarely business transactions of this type that are risk free. However, to ensure that risk is minimized, then those risks must be acknowledged and due diligence undertaken to further reduce risk exposure.
The implementation of the CDM projects that are designed to generate CERs give rise to the following potential risks, and these may be distinguished into three separate parts:
1.
Risks arising from the projects alone - financing, approval, delays, and project underperformance;
2.
Risks relating to the Kyoto Protocol - the DOE gives inaccurate GHG emissions verification, and the project would be rejected by the CDM-Executive Board;
3.
Risks from the Host Country - domestic political instability would potentially result in the change of the laws, imposition of tax on CERs, and requirement of licenses because of risk that CERs are considered derivatives and financial arrangements.
Risks Insurance
The potential risks noted above have led to the development of a specialized sector of the insurance industry to address these risk concerns. Simply, where any risk is identified it makes good common sense to insure against those possible detrimental outcomes. The primary difference in this type of insurance are the objects that the project, the buyers,and any other relevant party would be seeking to insure.
Basically, insurance in this area is to ensure that the CERs are provided and change hands according to the prevailing ERPA.
Conclusion
The Kyoto Protocols are explicit in providing the best solution to deal with the current threat of global warming and climate change. The arguments for the wider adoption of the Kyoto Protocols, particularly for developing countries, are that the mechanisms are flexible and directly address the core issue of global warming. Furthermore, it is reasonable to state that for developing countries the mechanisms are generally economically friendly for the countries and for business.
It is clear that Indonesia has committed itself to the Kyoto Protocols by signing onto them and then ratifying them in domestic legislation. However, this is not the end of the game as far as it relates to CERs and CDM. The government clearly needs to do more in order to provide greater legal certainty in this developing area of carbon-based trading mechanisms. To this end, there is a need for more legislation to be enacted in order to provide the requisite legal certainty.
The ball is clearly in Indonesia’s court. If Indonesia is to take advantage of this opportunity then the government must be pro-active in promoting the benefits of CERs and facilitating the process of developing CDM projects that will generate tradable CERs. There is considerable potential for the trade in CERs to have a significant impact on the development and growth of the Indonesian economy going forward.