The Indonesian government, as most governments do, has made a long-standing commitment to national economic development. In times of crisis, and particularly in times of world-wide financial turmoil, it is essential that the government have in place clear, functioning, and enforceable regulatory frameworks that provide legal certainty to investors and business alike.
The Indonesian Capital Market plays an integral and critical role in the development of the Indonesian economy. To this end, the government has provided a clear legal and regulatory mandate to the Capital Market and Financial Institutions Supervisory Agency (Bapepam-LK) and the Indonesian Stock Exchange (ISX) to focus on improving the Indonesian investment climate as it relates to these two institutions, both of whom play important roles in the capital markets.
The regulatory framework has been drafted to ensure that the system is able to facilitate both domestic and foreign capital investment and not to preference one or the other in the ease in which investments can be made.
The right of foreign investors to take their chances in the Indonesian Capital Market is not a new phenomenon or development. The Indonesian Capital Markets have been open to foreign investors and their capital investment initiatives since the late 1980s. This is codified in the Capital Market Law (Law No. 8 of 1995) which in the Elucidation to Article 1(15) explicitly permits foreign issuers to list on the Indonesian Stock Exchange (ISX) and investors the right to trade in shares listed on the ISX.
With a view to providing a specific regulatory framework by which foreign entities can list on the ISX, rather than just participate in the buying and selling of shares, the Directors of the ISX have issued Decision No. Kep-00389/BEI/06-2009 setting out the provisions for Indonesian Depository Receipts (Sertifikat Penitipan Efek Indonesia / SPEI) in order to facilitate future listings.
The SPEI is not a new trading product in Indonesia. The reality is that the Head of Bapepam-LK Decision No. Kep-49/PM/1997 provided for the introduction of an SPEI in 1997. Sadly, as an instrument of trade it had not been used based on the Bapepam-LK decision.
The primary reason for the 1997 Bapepam-LK decision to generate any SPEI activity was that investors generally considered the decision to fail in the provision of (1) sufficient legal certainty for any investors, local or foreign, in trading with the SPEI instrument in the local market; and, (2) comprehensive information regarding SPEI and their beneficial use to investors (Gunawan Widjadja & Todhi Pratama, Sertifikat Penitipan Efek Indonesia, 2008). In light of the above noted failures, it became increasing obvious that the decision was not sufficient by itself to convince investors to place any equity in the Indonesian markets.
Therefore, it is expected that the existence of both the Directors of ISX Decision No. Kep-00389/BEI/06-2009 and the Head of Bapepam-LK Decision No. Kep-49/PM/1997 with respect to the implementation of SPEI will be mutually complementary and provide a sufficient degree of legal certainty to attract capital investment.
This ILD will simply examine some key features of the provisions of the SPEI regulations and provide analysis with respect to the impact these regulations will have on the business sector.
SPEI in General
Simply, an SPEI is a trading instrument, particularly in the form of securities that give ownership in the shares of a company. These can be either Indonesian or non-Indonesian companies that trade in Indonesia’s capital market. However, according to the existing regulation, an SPEI is defined as securities that give their holders the rights to the underlying securities that have been deposited collectively in the Custodian Bank, and which have Bapepam-LK’s approval.
An SPEI is actually the Indonesian version of the U.S. American Depository Receipt, in that through the use of this type of instrument foreign issuers may undertake transactions with local investors and vice versa.
The utilization of an SPEI conceivably makes it possible for investors and foreign issuers to trade and operate in markets without the need for complex cross-border transactions. This is undoubtedly a potential boon for both the investors and the foreign issuers as it expands a traditionally limited market to a much broader one with greatly enhanced potential benefits flowing on from these transactions in the local markets.
As mentioned earlier, the SPEI is generally to be in the form of securities that will be converted as an SPEI. However it should be noted that the securities are to be in a form of equity in order to trade in the ISX.
Public Offering of SPEI
It is abundantly clear that the regulatory framework will provide foreign issuers with the right to offer and sell their shares to local Indonesian investors on the ISX. Nevertheless, any trading in the shares of a foreign issuer will require that the issuer first undertake an Initial Public Offering in order to list on the ISX.
Although, and as noted previously, the Head of Bapepam-LK Decision No. Kep-49/PM/1997 regulates SPEI and this decision includes an Attachment, Rule No. IX.A.10, that sets out how a public offering is to be conducted.
The current rule for a public offering of an SPEI by a foreign issuer is that the public offering must comply with all the prevailing laws and regulations in the relevant field. Therefore, any public offering must comply with the Capital Market Law and any relevant implementing regulations where the issuer has not undertaken a public offering in the country of their origin. And, if the issuer has undertaken a public offering in their country, then the public offering will be compared to the Indonesian legal standard for the capital market. Chief among the concerns is that the country of the foreign issuer has a regulatory framework in place that provides sufficient investor protection.
In essence, this means that where the standard is determined to be comparable then the foreign issuer is required to comply with the provisions of Bapepam Rule No. IX.A.1 (on Registration Statement) and Rule No. IX.A.2 (on Procedure on Public Offering) except for points 14 and 17. However, where the standard is determined to be insufficient or inappropriate then the foreign issuer is obligated to comply with the Indonesian standard and wholly apply all prevailing Indonesian laws and regulations.
Listing of SPEI
One of the reasons why Rule IX.A.10 was ineffective was because there had not been any follow-up of the provisions since the rule came into force. The rule, which deals with the public offering of SPEI, is supposed to have a succeeding mechanism, specifically regarding the listing of SPEI. However, the succeeding regulation took nearly 11 years to be issued. But, “it is better late than never”, or at least that is how the saying goes. The ISX finally put an end to the waiting by issuing the Director of ISX Decision No. Kep-00389/BEI/06-2009 on Listing of SPEI in the ISX.
The decision includes an Attachment, Rule No. I-D.1. This rule sets out the mechanism and requirements for the listing of SPEI. The foreign issuer (or the Sponsoring Company in the rule) may only apply for the listing of an SPEI to the ISX if it fulfills all 12 conditions stipulated in section III.1, which among others, includes the following:
-
The registration statement that has been submitted to Bapepam-LK has already become effective;
-
A listing request will only be approved if the requesting party is the relevant Sponsoring Company, or other entities that are registered in Bapepam-LK and are given the power of attorney to represent the latter;
-
A letter of statement from the Director of the sponsoring company concerning the rights of the SPEI holders in the sponsoring company;
-
Having a capitalization in the amount of at least IDR 250 billion;
-
The minimum number of SPEI holders must be at least 300 investors, and;
-
The initial value of SPEI at the time of the listing is at least IDR 1 thousand.
The rule further provides that any request to the ISX states that the sponsoring company, or their representatives, must satisfy a further ten steps before the ISX will announce the listing and permit trading of the SPEI. The listing procedures set out that the sponsoring company must complete all the necessary forms, agreements, statements, and reports as noted in Attachments I-D.1 - I-D.5.
The rule also sets out de-listing procedures for SPEI listed on the ISX. There are two basic scenarios for a de-listing to occur, namely: (1) the sponsoring company wishes to de-list its SPEI; or, (2) the ISX will seek to de-list the SPEI. Each of the de-listing requirements and procedures are elaborated in sections VIII.2 - VIII.3 of the rule.
For a brief overview of the rule on listing of SPEI see ILB No. 1136 6/7/2009.
Conclusion
The rule clearly sets out the procedures and mechanisms for foreign issuers seeking to list on the ISX through the use of an SPEI structure. It is also clear that the rule is moving the ISX towards prevailing and acceptable listing standards for foreign issuers. The most direct benefit of this movement is that investors, foreign and local, will have a much enhanced degree of confidence in Indonesian markets and their ability to ensure legal certainty.
This legal certainty will be with respect to both the procedures for listing and the enforcement protections afforded to investors irrespective of whether they be the lister of the SPEI or an investor who has bought into the SPEI.
Nevertheless, it is expected that there will be more legislation developments in this sector in order to ensure that the process is smoothly and expeditiously implemented. It is clear that the government views investment as a sound means of continuing current national economic development and returning Indonesia to the high levels of economic growth that it has enjoyed in the past despite the ever-present financial crisis engulfing many of major economies of the world.
Finally, it is expected that the current regulatory framework is sufficient to allow initial foreign listings to take place on the ISX and to avail themselves of the benefits of such listings within the Indonesian capital market.
The Indonesian government, as most governments do, has made a long-standing commitment to national economic development. In times of crisis, and particularly in times of world-wide financial turmoil, it is essential that the government have in place clear, functioning, and enforceable regulatory frameworks that provide legal certainty to investors and business alike.
The Indonesian Capital Market plays an integral and critical role in the development of the Indonesian economy. To this end, the government has provided a clear legal and regulatory mandate to the Capital Market and Financial Institutions Supervisory Agency (Bapepam-LK) and the Indonesian Stock Exchange (ISX) to focus on improving the Indonesian investment climate as it relates to these two institutions, both of whom play important roles in the capital markets.
The regulatory framework has been drafted to ensure that the system is able to facilitate both domestic and foreign capital investment and not to preference one or the other in the ease in which investments can be made.
The right of foreign investors to take their chances in the Indonesian Capital Market is not a new phenomenon or development. The Indonesian Capital Markets have been open to foreign investors and their capital investment initiatives since the late 1980s. This is codified in the Capital Market Law (Law No. 8 of 1995) which in the Elucidation to Article 1(15) explicitly permits foreign issuers to list on the Indonesian Stock Exchange (ISX) and investors the right to trade in shares listed on the ISX.
With a view to providing a specific regulatory framework by which foreign entities can list on the ISX, rather than just participate in the buying and selling of shares, the Directors of the ISX have issued Decision No. Kep-00389/BEI/06-2009 setting out the provisions for Indonesian Depository Receipts (Sertifikat Penitipan Efek Indonesia / SPEI) in order to facilitate future listings.
The SPEI is not a new trading product in Indonesia. The reality is that the Head of Bapepam-LK Decision No. Kep-49/PM/1997 provided for the introduction of an SPEI in 1997. Sadly, as an instrument of trade it had not been used based on the Bapepam-LK decision.
The primary reason for the 1997 Bapepam-LK decision to generate any SPEI activity was that investors generally considered the decision to fail in the provision of (1) sufficient legal certainty for any investors, local or foreign, in trading with the SPEI instrument in the local market; and, (2) comprehensive information regarding SPEI and their beneficial use to investors (Gunawan Widjadja & Todhi Pratama, Sertifikat Penitipan Efek Indonesia, 2008). In light of the above noted failures, it became increasing obvious that the decision was not sufficient by itself to convince investors to place any equity in the Indonesian markets.
Therefore, it is expected that the existence of both the Directors of ISX Decision No. Kep-00389/BEI/06-2009 and the Head of Bapepam-LK Decision No. Kep-49/PM/1997 with respect to the implementation of SPEI will be mutually complementary and provide a sufficient degree of legal certainty to attract capital investment.
This ILD will simply examine some key features of the provisions of the SPEI regulations and provide analysis with respect to the impact these regulations will have on the business sector.
SPEI in General
Simply, an SPEI is a trading instrument, particularly in the form of securities that give ownership in the shares of a company. These can be either Indonesian or non-Indonesian companies that trade in Indonesia’s capital market. However, according to the existing regulation, an SPEI is defined as securities that give their holders the rights to the underlying securities that have been deposited collectively in the Custodian Bank, and which have Bapepam-LK’s approval.
An SPEI is actually the Indonesian version of the U.S. American Depository Receipt, in that through the use of this type of instrument foreign issuers may undertake transactions with local investors and vice versa.
The utilization of an SPEI conceivably makes it possible for investors and foreign issuers to trade and operate in markets without the need for complex cross-border transactions. This is undoubtedly a potential boon for both the investors and the foreign issuers as it expands a traditionally limited market to a much broader one with greatly enhanced potential benefits flowing on from these transactions in the local markets.
As mentioned earlier, the SPEI is generally to be in the form of securities that will be converted as an SPEI. However it should be noted that the securities are to be in a form of equity in order to trade in the ISX.
Public Offering of SPEI
It is abundantly clear that the regulatory framework will provide foreign issuers with the right to offer and sell their shares to local Indonesian investors on the ISX. Nevertheless, any trading in the shares of a foreign issuer will require that the issuer first undertake an Initial Public Offering in order to list on the ISX.
Although, and as noted previously, the Head of Bapepam-LK Decision No. Kep-49/PM/1997 regulates SPEI and this decision includes an Attachment, Rule No. IX.A.10, that sets out how a public offering is to be conducted.
The current rule for a public offering of an SPEI by a foreign issuer is that the public offering must comply with all the prevailing laws and regulations in the relevant field. Therefore, any public offering must comply with the Capital Market Law and any relevant implementing regulations where the issuer has not undertaken a public offering in the country of their origin. And, if the issuer has undertaken a public offering in their country, then the public offering will be compared to the Indonesian legal standard for the capital market. Chief among the concerns is that the country of the foreign issuer has a regulatory framework in place that provides sufficient investor protection.
In essence, this means that where the standard is determined to be comparable then the foreign issuer is required to comply with the provisions of Bapepam Rule No. IX.A.1 (on Registration Statement) and Rule No. IX.A.2 (on Procedure on Public Offering) except for points 14 and 17. However, where the standard is determined to be insufficient or inappropriate then the foreign issuer is obligated to comply with the Indonesian standard and wholly apply all prevailing Indonesian laws and regulations.
Listing of SPEI
One of the reasons why Rule IX.A.10 was ineffective was because there had not been any follow-up of the provisions since the rule came into force. The rule, which deals with the public offering of SPEI, is supposed to have a succeeding mechanism, specifically regarding the listing of SPEI. However, the succeeding regulation took nearly 11 years to be issued. But, “it is better late than never”, or at least that is how the saying goes. The ISX finally put an end to the waiting by issuing the Director of ISX Decision No. Kep-00389/BEI/06-2009 on Listing of SPEI in the ISX.
The decision includes an Attachment, Rule No. I-D.1. This rule sets out the mechanism and requirements for the listing of SPEI. The foreign issuer (or the Sponsoring Company in the rule) may only apply for the listing of an SPEI to the ISX if it fulfills all 12 conditions stipulated in section III.1, which among others, includes the following:
-
The registration statement that has been submitted to Bapepam-LK has already become effective;
-
A listing request will only be approved if the requesting party is the relevant Sponsoring Company, or other entities that are registered in Bapepam-LK and are given the power of attorney to represent the latter;
-
A letter of statement from the Director of the sponsoring company concerning the rights of the SPEI holders in the sponsoring company;
-
Having a capitalization in the amount of at least IDR 250 billion;
-
The minimum number of SPEI holders must be at least 300 investors, and;
-
The initial value of SPEI at the time of the listing is at least IDR 1 thousand.
The rule further provides that any request to the ISX states that the sponsoring company, or their representatives, must satisfy a further ten steps before the ISX will announce the listing and permit trading of the SPEI. The listing procedures set out that the sponsoring company must complete all the necessary forms, agreements, statements, and reports as noted in Attachments I-D.1 - I-D.5.
The rule also sets out de-listing procedures for SPEI listed on the ISX. There are two basic scenarios for a de-listing to occur, namely: (1) the sponsoring company wishes to de-list its SPEI; or, (2) the ISX will seek to de-list the SPEI. Each of the de-listing requirements and procedures are elaborated in sections VIII.2 - VIII.3 of the rule.
For a brief overview of the rule on listing of SPEI see ILB No. 1136 6/7/2009.
Conclusion
The rule clearly sets out the procedures and mechanisms for foreign issuers seeking to list on the ISX through the use of an SPEI structure. It is also clear that the rule is moving the ISX towards prevailing and acceptable listing standards for foreign issuers. The most direct benefit of this movement is that investors, foreign and local, will have a much enhanced degree of confidence in Indonesian markets and their ability to ensure legal certainty.
This legal certainty will be with respect to both the procedures for listing and the enforcement protections afforded to investors irrespective of whether they be the lister of the SPEI or an investor who has bought into the SPEI.
Nevertheless, it is expected that there will be more legislation developments in this sector in order to ensure that the process is smoothly and expeditiously implemented. It is clear that the government views investment as a sound means of continuing current national economic development and returning Indonesia to the high levels of economic growth that it has enjoyed in the past despite the ever-present financial crisis engulfing many of major economies of the world.
Finally, it is expected that the current regulatory framework is sufficient to allow initial foreign listings to take place on the ISX and to avail themselves of the benefits of such listings within the Indonesian capital market.