Public Services - DPR Finally Passes Bill

Overview

For most of its history since independence, Indonesian public services have often borne the brunt of considerable criticism for not reaching the levels of quality befitting of a state with large amounts of resources, both human and natural. This reputation for the provision of poor public services is primarily the result of systemic failures and the inability of services providers to get the job done properly. The purpose of this bill was to provide a regulatory framework that will facilitate the provision of public services to a level of quality that the community not only desires to see but expects from the world’s third largest democracy.

 

The provision of public services is never easy. The simple reality is that the demands on providers and services offered almost always exceed the limited capabilities that exist. This simple reality is exacerbated even further in Indonesia as traditional providers of public services are underfunded. The under-funding of the public service has meant that there is less money available to provide an acceptable and sustainable variety of public services. Traditionally, this has been most obvious in the provision of public services related to utilities such as electricity, water, natural gas. However, in general public services where there is interaction between the community and the government, the coal face of this relationship, there has been considerable failure to provide public services.

 

The primary criticism of public services is that the regulatory framework is weak. This weakness allows for the development of a system where corruption, collusion, and nepotism (korupsi, kolusi, dan nepotisme, or as it is generally known, KKN) are able to prosper and further disadvantage users of public services. This is not to suggest that all public servants or service providers are corrupt. However, it would be remiss if one was to fail to acknowledge that KKN is a significant problem.

 

There has been some debate as to whether the system is flawed because the human resources that are tasked with operating the system are flawed. Nevertheless, and in spite of this debate, it would seem that the government believes that it is not the people who are necessarily flawed but rather a lack of legal certainty in the regulatory framework that permits the people tasked with providing these public services to not take their responsibilities as seriously as they must. Therefore, a tightening of the regulatory framework and maintaining much of the human resources infrastructure that currently exists will be sufficient to see significant improvements in the provision of public services.  

 

However, what is clear is that the government has decided, for the first time since the reformation process got underway in 1998 with the fall of the Soeharto regime, to be pro-active in endeavouring to confront head-on and resolve the issues plaguing the public services sector. It is worth noting that the government has not been inactive in tinkering with the public services sector and has in fact attempted to address some of the issues through the following legislation: (1) the enactment of Law No. 44 of 1999 as an amendment to Law No. 8 of 1974 on State Personnel (Kepegawaian); (2) the enactment of Law No. 32 of 2004 on Regional Government (Pemerintahan Daerah) as an amendment to Law No. 22 of 1999, and; (3) the State Minister of State Administrative Reforms Decision No. KEP/26/M.PAN/2/2004 on the Development of Public Services.

 

The unfortunate reality of the above noted legislation was that it was somewhat piecemeal and did not satisfactorily, in lieu of a comprehensive approach, address community needs and expectations with respect to the quality of public services required. Simply, the two laws were not specific or explicit with regards to the subject matter of public services and the Ministerial Decision was viewed as being subsidiary to a pending law that just was not forthcoming.  The necessity was for a subject specific law, namely: a law on public services. Some might argue that this law on public services has been a long time coming.

 

In 2005, the government, particularly the Department of State Administrative Reforms, proposed a draft Bill on Public Services to the House of Representatives (Dewan Perwakilan Rakyat / DPR) to be formulated and debated, and presumably enacted quickly. The bill was an “on again, off again” affair meaning that any visions of a quick turn-around from submission to the DPR through enactment was never going to be realized. Unfortunately, this has meant that the greater Indonesian community has had to suffer through ineffective and inefficient public services. Nevertheless, these aspirations of hope seem to have finally been realized as the DPR has passed the legislation on 23 June 2009.

 

As with any piece of legislation, it is impossible to please everyone all of the time and this legislation is no different. The initial response towards the legislation was positive and was seemingly celebrated as a step in the right direction with respect to the provision of public services. The primary concerns on this legislation are that the settlement of complaints involves appointed legislative bodies that have traditionally been bound to political interests. The fear then is that if political interests are allowed to gain a foothold again in the administration of public services, then this is destined to become a fertile breeding ground for renewed KKN.

 

This ILD will highlight and examine some key features of the bill.

 

For a brief overview of the bill see ILB No. 1131 1/7/2009.

 

Key Terms and Definitions

The drafting of the bill saw the definition of what constitutes a public service go through multiple revisions, which generally produced quite different interpretations from one definition to the next. Ultimately, the agreed definition is the one contained here. Essentially, public services are any activity or series of activities that provide a publicly available service to citizens or residents which relate to goods, services, and / or administrative services as provided by a recognized public services provider.

 

It is important to note that the individuals (for example, state officials) that are tasked with providing public services are defined separately from the institutions that are categorized as public services providers (penyelenggara pelayanan publik) as provided for in Article 1(2). Public services providers are specifically: government bodies, corporations, independent bodies that are established by law and designed for the provision of public services, and other legal entities established for the purpose of providing public services.

 

Scope of the Bill

The list of matters covered in the legislation is extensive. As has been noted previously, the legislation covers services related to goods, services, and administration. The sectors covered, include among others, education, work and business, citizens / residents, communication and information, environment, health, social security, energy, banking, transportation, natural resources, tourism, and other strategic sectors. The scope of the services covered is further enumerated in Article 5 and relevant Elucidations.

 

Coordination and Cooperation

As was noted in the “scope” section previous, the potential for the provision of public services extends to almost any endeavour where there is interaction where the community is seeking to gain a service. In order to facilitate the provision of public services, the legislation provides two basic alternatives:  (1) by way of coordination between the public service providers, and / or; (2) cooperation with certain non-public service providers. The word “certain” indicates that not every entity may perform public services. Only those that fulfill the following conditions may become eligible:

-

There must be a working agreement, and that agreement is to comply with the existing regulations and service standards;

-

The cooperation must be publicly informed, including the clear identity of the public service provider(s) and the complaint address;

-

The parties in the cooperation have their respective responsibilities;

-

The entity must be a legal entity (badan hukum), and;

-

The cooperation must not be more than 14 days.

 

Rights and Obligations

This is one important feature in the bill that no earlier regulations have been able to tackle, which is to set out what are the rights and obligations of the parties in the public service sector. This feature is simply expected to give clarity in the legal sense.

 

The public service providers and the individuals implementing such services, namely: the state officials. These state officials are given distinct rights and obligations. Articles 14 and 16 set out the rights, while Articles 15 and 17 lay down the obligations of both parties.

 

In addition, the bill adds 15 points that the state officials are obliged to perform in their daily activity as a public servant, among others, just and non-discriminative treatment of users; be meticulous; be friendly; be professional; services are to be simple; no abusing or misusing public service facilities, and obey / comply with the prevailing procedures in the provision of public services.

 

The provision of public services is not wholly dependent on public servants to ensure effectiveness and efficiency. So, it is not surprising that the legislation also sets out the rights and obligations of public services users, and this is irrespective of whether they are citizens or residents. This is most clearly evidenced in the provisions of Articles 18 and 19. However, the involvement of the public in the provision of their own public services is also to be noted in other articles that deal with public participation in the establishment processes.

 

Participation of the Public

Following on from the previous paragraph, it is clear that the public is to play a varied but simultaneously specific role in the establishment processes for public services. For example, the public is to be involved in the determination of acceptable and appropriate service standards. Furthermore, the public is to play a role in supervising the provision of public services through the Public Services Supervisory Agency.

 

Special Services

Pancasila (Five Principles), the state ideology, every person is guaranteed equal treatment. However, the legislation interprets this in Article 29 to include the provision of specialized public services for people with special needs. Special needs in this instance is explicitly defined in the Elucidations to include, among others, those with physical disabilities (or challenges), the elderly, pregnant women and those with young children, and victims of natural and social disasters.

 

Nevertheless, it would seem that not everyone is satisfied with Article 29, Masyarakat Peduli Pelayanan Publik (MP3) has noted that there are still some obvious omissions from the special needs category such as indigenous people, adat communities, and victims of domestic violence.    

 

Sanctions

The legislation provides a comprehensive list of sanctions for the breach of any of the provisions. The sanctions can be imposed against providers or individuals depending on the breach. Chapter VIII includes 5 Articles (Articles 54 - 58) and provides for eight types of sanctions. These include warnings, suspensions from duties, salary reductions for a certain period of time, demotions, honorable dismissal, dishonorable dismissal, freezing of licenses, and license cancellation. It is expected that these sanctions will promote the provision of excellent public services and eliminate any tendencies towards the abuse of power.

 

Complaint Mechanism

Article 40(1) states, complaints regarding any public services may be made to the public service providers, the Ombudsman, and / or the legislature at every level (the central, provincial, and district/city). These three alternative complaint mechanisms are given simply as an option for the public to resolve their unsatisfactory public services experience during their contact with any of the services provided by the public service providers or their official staff.

 

However, these measures are actually confusing according to Sulastio, the Director of the Indonesian Parliamentary Center, who said, “the framers were confused during the drafting process. On one side, there is a willingness not to create a new body, yet on the other side [the drafters] were not confident with the [work of] Ombudsman, thus [they] included the DPR,” to Fathan from hukumonline (27/6).

 

Enforcement

The bill comes into immediate force once it is enacted. Enactment requires the signature of the President. If the President fails to sign the bill into law then the bill will self-enact after 30 days pursuant to the 1945 Constitution.


Conclusion

 

In general, the passage of the bill has been met with considerable enthusiasm. There are critics of the some parts of the bill however this is true of most bills enacted by any parliament and this is hardly unique to Indonesia. Nevertheless, it is disconcerting that on enactment into law the bill will still require a considerable number of implementing regulations to be issued in order for some of the primary provisions to become effective. Yet, the legislation is a positive step and a step in the right direction.

 

The new law provides not only a more comprehensive regulatory framework for enforcement, but it also provides a framework that allows the government to be pro-active on its bureaucratic reform initiatives, particularly in tidying up the image of the under-performing public services.

 

Ultimately, it is expected that the bill will create a bureaucratic and public services environment that meets the needs of all citizens and residents in Indonesia.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku

Overview

For most of its history since independence, Indonesian public services have often borne the brunt of considerable criticism for not reaching the levels of quality befitting of a state with large amounts of resources, both human and natural. This reputation for the provision of poor public services is primarily the result of systemic failures and the inability of services providers to get the job done properly. The purpose of this bill was to provide a regulatory framework that will facilitate the provision of public services to a level of quality that the community not only desires to see but expects from the world’s third largest democracy.

 

The provision of public services is never easy. The simple reality is that the demands on providers and services offered almost always exceed the limited capabilities that exist. This simple reality is exacerbated even further in Indonesia as traditional providers of public services are underfunded. The under-funding of the public service has meant that there is less money available to provide an acceptable and sustainable variety of public services. Traditionally, this has been most obvious in the provision of public services related to utilities such as electricity, water, natural gas. However, in general public services where there is interaction between the community and the government, the coal face of this relationship, there has been considerable failure to provide public services.

 

The primary criticism of public services is that the regulatory framework is weak. This weakness allows for the development of a system where corruption, collusion, and nepotism (korupsi, kolusi, dan nepotisme, or as it is generally known, KKN) are able to prosper and further disadvantage users of public services. This is not to suggest that all public servants or service providers are corrupt. However, it would be remiss if one was to fail to acknowledge that KKN is a significant problem.

 

There has been some debate as to whether the system is flawed because the human resources that are tasked with operating the system are flawed. Nevertheless, and in spite of this debate, it would seem that the government believes that it is not the people who are necessarily flawed but rather a lack of legal certainty in the regulatory framework that permits the people tasked with providing these public services to not take their responsibilities as seriously as they must. Therefore, a tightening of the regulatory framework and maintaining much of the human resources infrastructure that currently exists will be sufficient to see significant improvements in the provision of public services.  

 

However, what is clear is that the government has decided, for the first time since the reformation process got underway in 1998 with the fall of the Soeharto regime, to be pro-active in endeavouring to confront head-on and resolve the issues plaguing the public services sector. It is worth noting that the government has not been inactive in tinkering with the public services sector and has in fact attempted to address some of the issues through the following legislation: (1) the enactment of Law No. 44 of 1999 as an amendment to Law No. 8 of 1974 on State Personnel (Kepegawaian); (2) the enactment of Law No. 32 of 2004 on Regional Government (Pemerintahan Daerah) as an amendment to Law No. 22 of 1999, and; (3) the State Minister of State Administrative Reforms Decision No. KEP/26/M.PAN/2/2004 on the Development of Public Services.

 

The unfortunate reality of the above noted legislation was that it was somewhat piecemeal and did not satisfactorily, in lieu of a comprehensive approach, address community needs and expectations with respect to the quality of public services required. Simply, the two laws were not specific or explicit with regards to the subject matter of public services and the Ministerial Decision was viewed as being subsidiary to a pending law that just was not forthcoming.  The necessity was for a subject specific law, namely: a law on public services. Some might argue that this law on public services has been a long time coming.

 

In 2005, the government, particularly the Department of State Administrative Reforms, proposed a draft Bill on Public Services to the House of Representatives (Dewan Perwakilan Rakyat / DPR) to be formulated and debated, and presumably enacted quickly. The bill was an “on again, off again” affair meaning that any visions of a quick turn-around from submission to the DPR through enactment was never going to be realized. Unfortunately, this has meant that the greater Indonesian community has had to suffer through ineffective and inefficient public services. Nevertheless, these aspirations of hope seem to have finally been realized as the DPR has passed the legislation on 23 June 2009.

 

As with any piece of legislation, it is impossible to please everyone all of the time and this legislation is no different. The initial response towards the legislation was positive and was seemingly celebrated as a step in the right direction with respect to the provision of public services. The primary concerns on this legislation are that the settlement of complaints involves appointed legislative bodies that have traditionally been bound to political interests. The fear then is that if political interests are allowed to gain a foothold again in the administration of public services, then this is destined to become a fertile breeding ground for renewed KKN.

 

This ILD will highlight and examine some key features of the bill.

 

For a brief overview of the bill see ILB No. 1131 1/7/2009.

 

Key Terms and Definitions

The drafting of the bill saw the definition of what constitutes a public service go through multiple revisions, which generally produced quite different interpretations from one definition to the next. Ultimately, the agreed definition is the one contained here. Essentially, public services are any activity or series of activities that provide a publicly available service to citizens or residents which relate to goods, services, and / or administrative services as provided by a recognized public services provider.

 

It is important to note that the individuals (for example, state officials) that are tasked with providing public services are defined separately from the institutions that are categorized as public services providers (penyelenggara pelayanan publik) as provided for in Article 1(2). Public services providers are specifically: government bodies, corporations, independent bodies that are established by law and designed for the provision of public services, and other legal entities established for the purpose of providing public services.

 

Scope of the Bill

The list of matters covered in the legislation is extensive. As has been noted previously, the legislation covers services related to goods, services, and administration. The sectors covered, include among others, education, work and business, citizens / residents, communication and information, environment, health, social security, energy, banking, transportation, natural resources, tourism, and other strategic sectors. The scope of the services covered is further enumerated in Article 5 and relevant Elucidations.

 

Coordination and Cooperation

As was noted in the “scope” section previous, the potential for the provision of public services extends to almost any endeavour where there is interaction where the community is seeking to gain a service. In order to facilitate the provision of public services, the legislation provides two basic alternatives:  (1) by way of coordination between the public service providers, and / or; (2) cooperation with certain non-public service providers. The word “certain” indicates that not every entity may perform public services. Only those that fulfill the following conditions may become eligible:

-

There must be a working agreement, and that agreement is to comply with the existing regulations and service standards;

-

The cooperation must be publicly informed, including the clear identity of the public service provider(s) and the complaint address;

-

The parties in the cooperation have their respective responsibilities;

-

The entity must be a legal entity (badan hukum), and;

-

The cooperation must not be more than 14 days.

 

Rights and Obligations

This is one important feature in the bill that no earlier regulations have been able to tackle, which is to set out what are the rights and obligations of the parties in the public service sector. This feature is simply expected to give clarity in the legal sense.

 

The public service providers and the individuals implementing such services, namely: the state officials. These state officials are given distinct rights and obligations. Articles 14 and 16 set out the rights, while Articles 15 and 17 lay down the obligations of both parties.

 

In addition, the bill adds 15 points that the state officials are obliged to perform in their daily activity as a public servant, among others, just and non-discriminative treatment of users; be meticulous; be friendly; be professional; services are to be simple; no abusing or misusing public service facilities, and obey / comply with the prevailing procedures in the provision of public services.

 

The provision of public services is not wholly dependent on public servants to ensure effectiveness and efficiency. So, it is not surprising that the legislation also sets out the rights and obligations of public services users, and this is irrespective of whether they are citizens or residents. This is most clearly evidenced in the provisions of Articles 18 and 19. However, the involvement of the public in the provision of their own public services is also to be noted in other articles that deal with public participation in the establishment processes.

 

Participation of the Public

Following on from the previous paragraph, it is clear that the public is to play a varied but simultaneously specific role in the establishment processes for public services. For example, the public is to be involved in the determination of acceptable and appropriate service standards. Furthermore, the public is to play a role in supervising the provision of public services through the Public Services Supervisory Agency.

 

Special Services

Pancasila (Five Principles), the state ideology, every person is guaranteed equal treatment. However, the legislation interprets this in Article 29 to include the provision of specialized public services for people with special needs. Special needs in this instance is explicitly defined in the Elucidations to include, among others, those with physical disabilities (or challenges), the elderly, pregnant women and those with young children, and victims of natural and social disasters.

 

Nevertheless, it would seem that not everyone is satisfied with Article 29, Masyarakat Peduli Pelayanan Publik (MP3) has noted that there are still some obvious omissions from the special needs category such as indigenous people, adat communities, and victims of domestic violence.    

 

Sanctions

The legislation provides a comprehensive list of sanctions for the breach of any of the provisions. The sanctions can be imposed against providers or individuals depending on the breach. Chapter VIII includes 5 Articles (Articles 54 - 58) and provides for eight types of sanctions. These include warnings, suspensions from duties, salary reductions for a certain period of time, demotions, honorable dismissal, dishonorable dismissal, freezing of licenses, and license cancellation. It is expected that these sanctions will promote the provision of excellent public services and eliminate any tendencies towards the abuse of power.

 

Complaint Mechanism

Article 40(1) states, complaints regarding any public services may be made to the public service providers, the Ombudsman, and / or the legislature at every level (the central, provincial, and district/city). These three alternative complaint mechanisms are given simply as an option for the public to resolve their unsatisfactory public services experience during their contact with any of the services provided by the public service providers or their official staff.

 

However, these measures are actually confusing according to Sulastio, the Director of the Indonesian Parliamentary Center, who said, “the framers were confused during the drafting process. On one side, there is a willingness not to create a new body, yet on the other side [the drafters] were not confident with the [work of] Ombudsman, thus [they] included the DPR,” to Fathan from hukumonline (27/6).

 

Enforcement

The bill comes into immediate force once it is enacted. Enactment requires the signature of the President. If the President fails to sign the bill into law then the bill will self-enact after 30 days pursuant to the 1945 Constitution.


Conclusion

 

In general, the passage of the bill has been met with considerable enthusiasm. There are critics of the some parts of the bill however this is true of most bills enacted by any parliament and this is hardly unique to Indonesia. Nevertheless, it is disconcerting that on enactment into law the bill will still require a considerable number of implementing regulations to be issued in order for some of the primary provisions to become effective. Yet, the legislation is a positive step and a step in the right direction.

 

The new law provides not only a more comprehensive regulatory framework for enforcement, but it also provides a framework that allows the government to be pro-active on its bureaucratic reform initiatives, particularly in tidying up the image of the under-performing public services.

 

Ultimately, it is expected that the bill will create a bureaucratic and public services environment that meets the needs of all citizens and residents in Indonesia.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku
2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info