Conventional Banks Becoming Syariah Banks - BI Regulation

Overview

 

The idea that Syariah financial services and in particular Syariah-based banking is an emerging sector in Indonesia is perhaps a bit of a misnomer as Bank Muamalat first pioneered the concept of Syariah based banking products way back in 1991. A more accurate description would be that the Syariah-based banking and financial systems have been slowly but surely meandering their way to greater influence and importance over the intervening years since 1991. The Banking Law, No. 7 of 1992 as amended by Law No 10 of 1998, did not sufficiently address the issue of Syariah banking.

 

This lack of specific regulation gave birth to the need for a piece of legislation that dealt explicitly with the substance of Syariah banking. This led to the drafting, passage, and subsequent enactment of Law No. 21 of 2008 on Syariah Banking (see ILB No.1084 5/5/2009). The drive to increase the level of Syariah-based financial and banking services available to the broader community has resulted in the enactment of other legislation.

 

The enactment of the Syariah Banking law has clearly opened the door to a potential explosion in the number of Syariah banks catering to the needs of customers demanding Syariah-based banking products. It is expected that the Syariah banking sector will continue to expand. The growth in the sector will be through the introduction of new Syariah banks and the conversion of conventional banks to Syariah banks. To this end, Bank Indonesia (Indonesian Central Bank / BI) has issued Regulation No. 11/15/PBI/2009 which sets out how a conventional bank is to convert to a Syariah bank.

 

The regulation sets out the provisions regarding how a conventional bank may convert into a Syariah bank. Interestingly, Syariah banks are expressly prohibited form converting into conventional banks. Presumably this is because BI believes that there will always be a greater need in the future for Syariah banks rather than those in the conventional banking sector. Nevertheless, the regulation is silent on this.

 

Overall, the regulation offers a number of incentives in order to achieve the stated objects and purposes of the regulation. Furthermore, the provisions enhance and simplify the bureaucracy within the system.

 

Finally, this Regulation came into existence as a result of a belief within the executive structure at BI that there were a number of conventional banks who have established Syariah Business Units (Unit Usaha Syariah / UUS) but were not really making a significant contribution to the Syariah banking sector. This is evidenced in an interview by the Indonesian version of hukumonline with Director of Syariah Banking at BI, Ramzi A Zuhudi, who claims that many conventional banks have UUS but the capital invested in these units is only three percent of their total capital in the conventional bank. According to Ramli this is a sign of irresponsibly that needs to be put in order.    

 

 

For a brief overview of the regulation please see ILB 1057 23/3/2009.

 

Key terms and Definitions

A Syariah bank is defined as a bank that operates and carries out its activities pursuant to the Syariah principles. It comprises of two kinds of bank: (i) General Syariah Bank (Bank Umum Syariah / BUS), and; (ii) Community Credit Syariah Bank (Bank Pembiayaan Rakyat Syariah / BPRS). Syariah principles are defined as the principles of banking as accepted in Islamic law. Generally, these principles will be included in edicts (fatwas) issued by the Indonesian Ulama Council (Majelis Ulama Indonesia / MUI) - particularly those fatwas issued by the MUI’s National Syariah Council (Dewan Syariah Nasional).

 

In contrast, a conventional or general bank is one that operates and carries on its business activities through standard banking practices. Similarly, to Syariah banks, there are two basic types of banks; General Banks (Bank Umum / BU) and Community Credit Banks (Bank Pembiayaan Rakyat / BPR).

 

Finally, the Syariah Supervisory Council (Dewan Pengawas Syariah / DPS) is defined as a body that not only supervises implementation and compliance, but one that may also advise and provide counsel to the Director with respect to Syariah banks and Syariah principles.

 

Underlying Principles

The underlying principles are ones that relate to sound and prudential banking practices. Once a conversion has been completed the resulting Syariah bank must still ensure that aside from the proscribed Syariah banking principles that apply that they also retain  (i) sound banking principles (azas perbankan yang sehat), and; (ii) prudential banking principles (prinsip kehati-hatian).

 

Prerequisites for Conversion

The regulation stipulates that for a conversion to be effective the conventional banl must complete a number of steps. These include the following:

-

Any intention to convert to Syariah bank requires that the conventional bank  state this as part of the conventional bank business plan; The Articles of Association must be amended to reflect the new business requirements;

-

All capital requirements must be met;

-

Amendment of the roles of directors and commissioners to comply with Syariah banking requirements;

-

Establish a DPS, and;

-

Submit an initial financial report as a Syariah bank.

 

Moreover, there are other conditions that the conventional bank is required to fulfill in order to become a Syariah bank. It must be noted that there is a distinction made between the conditions for the BU and that of the BPR.

-

BU to BUS requirements

 

-

Any intention to convert to a Syariah bank requires that the conventional bank have a Capital Adequacy Ratio (Kewajiban Penyediaan Modal Minimum / KPMM) of at least eight percent and its core capital at a level of at least IDR 100 billion;

 

-

The Board of Commissioners and Directors of the conventional bank is bound to comply with the BI regulation concerning BUS. These include fit and proper tests and implementation of Good Corporate Governance, among others, and;

 

-

Establish a DPS whose members are to be selected based on the BI regulations that govern such matters with respect to the BUS.

 

In comparison, BI regulation No. 11/3/PBI/2009 on BUS sets out a minimum paid up capital requirement of just IDR 1 trillion (Art. 5) in order to start-up a new Syariah bank. Therefore, for those interested in getting into the Syariah banking sector then perhaps the conversion of a conventional bank may be a more quick-fire option in terms of capital investment.

 

-

BPR to BPRS requirements

 

-

Any BPR that intends to convert to a BPRS must fulfill the conditions stipulated under the BI regulation on BPRS;

 

-

The Boards of Commissioners and Directors of the BPRS are bound to comply with BI regulations on BPRS, namely: fit and proper tests, implementation of principles of Good Corporate Governance, and the provision of KPMM, among others, and;

 

-

Establish a DPS whose members are to be selected based on the prevailing provisions of current BI regulations as they relate to BPRS.

 

Conversion Procedures

BI is the authority with regards to approving and then licensing any conventional bank’s conversion into a Syariah bank. Once BI approves a conversion it will issue a conversion license (izin perubahan kegiatan usaha).

 

Before BI can make a decision on whether an approval will be granted, the conventional bank must first lodge an application with BI that expresses the intent of the conventional bank to convert. The conventional bank must furnish the following documents as part of the application process:

-

The mission and vision once the conventional bank coverts into a Syariah bank;

-

The plan to amend the Articles of Association;

-

Names and Identities of the controlling shareholders (Pemegang Saham Pengendali), prospective candidates for both the Board of Commissioners and the Board of Directors, and the prospective candidates of the DPS;

-

The Syariah bank business plan;

-

Feasibility statement setting out the conventional bank’s market and economic potential once it converts to a Syariah bank, and;

-

Plans on the settlement of customer rights and duties.

 

Assuming that the conventional bank has successfully completed the application process and BI has granted a conversion license, then the new Syariah bank must include the word “Syariah” in its name and “iB” (Islamic Bank) in all forms, letterheads, products, offices, and related Syariah Bank offices.

 

Once the conversion license has been granted the new Syariah bank must have implemented the requisite Syariah principles within 60 days of receiving the license.

 

The regulation is explicit in ensuring that the sole responsibility in this area remains with BI. This is expected to streamline bureaucracy in the sector as it removes any potential for overlapping authority with respect to the granting of licenses.

 

Sanctions

Although, BI would be expecting that all conventional banks converting into Syariah banks would comply with all the provisions in the prevailing laws and regulations however BI retains the power to sanction those conventional banks who have converted into Syariah banks who fail to comply with the terms and conditions of their licenses. The available sanctions are set out in Article 19.

 

Status of Previous Regulation

The Regulation repeals and replaces the earlier Regulation on the same subject matter, namely: Regulation No. 8/3/PBI/2006 and Regulation No. 9/7/PBI/2007.

 

Enforcement

The Regulation has been in force since 29 April 2009.


Conclusion

 

The regulation reflects a belief that Syariah banking and financial services are the gateway to opening Indonesia’s financial and economic future. It is clear that in order to successfully manage the rapid developments in the Syariah banking sector BI needs to put in place an explicit regulatory framework. This regulation puts into place the requisite regulatory framework.

 

The regulation sets out the role of all the relevant players and stakeholders.

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku

Overview

 

The idea that Syariah financial services and in particular Syariah-based banking is an emerging sector in Indonesia is perhaps a bit of a misnomer as Bank Muamalat first pioneered the concept of Syariah based banking products way back in 1991. A more accurate description would be that the Syariah-based banking and financial systems have been slowly but surely meandering their way to greater influence and importance over the intervening years since 1991. The Banking Law, No. 7 of 1992 as amended by Law No 10 of 1998, did not sufficiently address the issue of Syariah banking.

 

This lack of specific regulation gave birth to the need for a piece of legislation that dealt explicitly with the substance of Syariah banking. This led to the drafting, passage, and subsequent enactment of Law No. 21 of 2008 on Syariah Banking (see ILB No.1084 5/5/2009). The drive to increase the level of Syariah-based financial and banking services available to the broader community has resulted in the enactment of other legislation.

 

The enactment of the Syariah Banking law has clearly opened the door to a potential explosion in the number of Syariah banks catering to the needs of customers demanding Syariah-based banking products. It is expected that the Syariah banking sector will continue to expand. The growth in the sector will be through the introduction of new Syariah banks and the conversion of conventional banks to Syariah banks. To this end, Bank Indonesia (Indonesian Central Bank / BI) has issued Regulation No. 11/15/PBI/2009 which sets out how a conventional bank is to convert to a Syariah bank.

 

The regulation sets out the provisions regarding how a conventional bank may convert into a Syariah bank. Interestingly, Syariah banks are expressly prohibited form converting into conventional banks. Presumably this is because BI believes that there will always be a greater need in the future for Syariah banks rather than those in the conventional banking sector. Nevertheless, the regulation is silent on this.

 

Overall, the regulation offers a number of incentives in order to achieve the stated objects and purposes of the regulation. Furthermore, the provisions enhance and simplify the bureaucracy within the system.

 

Finally, this Regulation came into existence as a result of a belief within the executive structure at BI that there were a number of conventional banks who have established Syariah Business Units (Unit Usaha Syariah / UUS) but were not really making a significant contribution to the Syariah banking sector. This is evidenced in an interview by the Indonesian version of hukumonline with Director of Syariah Banking at BI, Ramzi A Zuhudi, who claims that many conventional banks have UUS but the capital invested in these units is only three percent of their total capital in the conventional bank. According to Ramli this is a sign of irresponsibly that needs to be put in order.    

 

 

For a brief overview of the regulation please see ILB 1057 23/3/2009.

 

Key terms and Definitions

A Syariah bank is defined as a bank that operates and carries out its activities pursuant to the Syariah principles. It comprises of two kinds of bank: (i) General Syariah Bank (Bank Umum Syariah / BUS), and; (ii) Community Credit Syariah Bank (Bank Pembiayaan Rakyat Syariah / BPRS). Syariah principles are defined as the principles of banking as accepted in Islamic law. Generally, these principles will be included in edicts (fatwas) issued by the Indonesian Ulama Council (Majelis Ulama Indonesia / MUI) - particularly those fatwas issued by the MUI’s National Syariah Council (Dewan Syariah Nasional).

 

In contrast, a conventional or general bank is one that operates and carries on its business activities through standard banking practices. Similarly, to Syariah banks, there are two basic types of banks; General Banks (Bank Umum / BU) and Community Credit Banks (Bank Pembiayaan Rakyat / BPR).

 

Finally, the Syariah Supervisory Council (Dewan Pengawas Syariah / DPS) is defined as a body that not only supervises implementation and compliance, but one that may also advise and provide counsel to the Director with respect to Syariah banks and Syariah principles.

 

Underlying Principles

The underlying principles are ones that relate to sound and prudential banking practices. Once a conversion has been completed the resulting Syariah bank must still ensure that aside from the proscribed Syariah banking principles that apply that they also retain  (i) sound banking principles (azas perbankan yang sehat), and; (ii) prudential banking principles (prinsip kehati-hatian).

 

Prerequisites for Conversion

The regulation stipulates that for a conversion to be effective the conventional banl must complete a number of steps. These include the following:

-

Any intention to convert to Syariah bank requires that the conventional bank  state this as part of the conventional bank business plan; The Articles of Association must be amended to reflect the new business requirements;

-

All capital requirements must be met;

-

Amendment of the roles of directors and commissioners to comply with Syariah banking requirements;

-

Establish a DPS, and;

-

Submit an initial financial report as a Syariah bank.

 

Moreover, there are other conditions that the conventional bank is required to fulfill in order to become a Syariah bank. It must be noted that there is a distinction made between the conditions for the BU and that of the BPR.

-

BU to BUS requirements

 

-

Any intention to convert to a Syariah bank requires that the conventional bank have a Capital Adequacy Ratio (Kewajiban Penyediaan Modal Minimum / KPMM) of at least eight percent and its core capital at a level of at least IDR 100 billion;

 

-

The Board of Commissioners and Directors of the conventional bank is bound to comply with the BI regulation concerning BUS. These include fit and proper tests and implementation of Good Corporate Governance, among others, and;

 

-

Establish a DPS whose members are to be selected based on the BI regulations that govern such matters with respect to the BUS.

 

In comparison, BI regulation No. 11/3/PBI/2009 on BUS sets out a minimum paid up capital requirement of just IDR 1 trillion (Art. 5) in order to start-up a new Syariah bank. Therefore, for those interested in getting into the Syariah banking sector then perhaps the conversion of a conventional bank may be a more quick-fire option in terms of capital investment.

 

-

BPR to BPRS requirements

 

-

Any BPR that intends to convert to a BPRS must fulfill the conditions stipulated under the BI regulation on BPRS;

 

-

The Boards of Commissioners and Directors of the BPRS are bound to comply with BI regulations on BPRS, namely: fit and proper tests, implementation of principles of Good Corporate Governance, and the provision of KPMM, among others, and;

 

-

Establish a DPS whose members are to be selected based on the prevailing provisions of current BI regulations as they relate to BPRS.

 

Conversion Procedures

BI is the authority with regards to approving and then licensing any conventional bank’s conversion into a Syariah bank. Once BI approves a conversion it will issue a conversion license (izin perubahan kegiatan usaha).

 

Before BI can make a decision on whether an approval will be granted, the conventional bank must first lodge an application with BI that expresses the intent of the conventional bank to convert. The conventional bank must furnish the following documents as part of the application process:

-

The mission and vision once the conventional bank coverts into a Syariah bank;

-

The plan to amend the Articles of Association;

-

Names and Identities of the controlling shareholders (Pemegang Saham Pengendali), prospective candidates for both the Board of Commissioners and the Board of Directors, and the prospective candidates of the DPS;

-

The Syariah bank business plan;

-

Feasibility statement setting out the conventional bank’s market and economic potential once it converts to a Syariah bank, and;

-

Plans on the settlement of customer rights and duties.

 

Assuming that the conventional bank has successfully completed the application process and BI has granted a conversion license, then the new Syariah bank must include the word “Syariah” in its name and “iB” (Islamic Bank) in all forms, letterheads, products, offices, and related Syariah Bank offices.

 

Once the conversion license has been granted the new Syariah bank must have implemented the requisite Syariah principles within 60 days of receiving the license.

 

The regulation is explicit in ensuring that the sole responsibility in this area remains with BI. This is expected to streamline bureaucracy in the sector as it removes any potential for overlapping authority with respect to the granting of licenses.

 

Sanctions

Although, BI would be expecting that all conventional banks converting into Syariah banks would comply with all the provisions in the prevailing laws and regulations however BI retains the power to sanction those conventional banks who have converted into Syariah banks who fail to comply with the terms and conditions of their licenses. The available sanctions are set out in Article 19.

 

Status of Previous Regulation

The Regulation repeals and replaces the earlier Regulation on the same subject matter, namely: Regulation No. 8/3/PBI/2006 and Regulation No. 9/7/PBI/2007.

 

Enforcement

The Regulation has been in force since 29 April 2009.


Conclusion

 

The regulation reflects a belief that Syariah banking and financial services are the gateway to opening Indonesia’s financial and economic future. It is clear that in order to successfully manage the rapid developments in the Syariah banking sector BI needs to put in place an explicit regulatory framework. This regulation puts into place the requisite regulatory framework.

 

The regulation sets out the role of all the relevant players and stakeholders.

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku
2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info