Draft Government Regulations on Mineral and Coal Mining

Overview

 

The enactment of the Bill on Mineral and Coal Mining as Law No. 4 of 2009 on 16 December 2008 had been, and continues to be, one of the most hotly debated new laws to come into existence over the past few years. The seriousness of the debate and the considerable divergence on the issues culminated in a number of the House of Representative (DPR) factions walking out (see ILB No. 994 17/12/2008). Furthermore, there continues to be rigorous criticism of several of the provisions as they are deemed to be detrimental to many of the stakeholders in this area.

 

Nevertheless, not all of the provisions are considered to be steps backwards and the overall intent appears to be to simplify the process while simultaneously providing greater legal certainty. Whether the Law achieves its state purposes and objectives depends largely on the implementing provisions that are drafted and then enacted to facilitate the implementation and subsequent enforcement of the provisions of the Law.

 

The most criticized provisions, among others, are the provisions on licensing which lack of transparency and accountability, as well as the non-existence of evaluation on existing mining license holders. The lack of evaluation has led to charges that this is tantamount to opening the door to the possible triple threat of corruption, collusion, and nepotism. Yet, for other commentators, the provisions on existing working contracts are problematic, since the Law states that the remaining contract may still be valid until its due date expires, but on the other hand the provisions of the contract must be in compliance with the provisions of the Law within one year of the Law coming into force.

 

This gives rise to considerable confusion as in effect the current working contracts are not valid until their respective terms end as there is the competing obligation of being in compliance with the new norms set out in the new law. Consequently, there are questions being asked regarding the proclaimed enhanced legal certainty that the new law is supposed to bring into play.

 

In responding to these criticisms, the Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources, Purnomo Yusgiantoro, stated that the Law is an ideal product which favors the national interest, therefore there is no reason to re-evaluate any existing work contract, in so far as the content of those work contracts are in compliance with the Law.

 

In line with the Minister’s stance and in an effort to cover any existing loopholes within the Law, the Directorate General of Mineral, Coal, and Geothermal Resources has formulated and submitted four drafts of the proposed Government Regulation on Mineral and Coal Mining to the Legal Bureau of the Department of Energy and Mineral Resources. These drafts were submitted in April 2009. The draft regulations encompass the following subjects: (i) Mining Zones; (ii) Mineral and Coal Mining Activities; (iii) Development and Supervision of Mining, and; (iv) Reclamation and Post-Mining Activities.

 

This ILD will focus on and examine the drafts on Mining Zones, as well as Guidance and Supervision in the Mining Sector. The remaining drafts will be examined in a succeeding ILD.

 

Mining Areas

 

The draft Government Regulation on Mining Zones is required by Articles 12, 19, 25, 33, and 89 of the Law. It focuses on the investigation and research in the field of mining, management of the results of the activity, and the determination of the Mining Zones.

                                                                                                               

Key terms and Definitions

The draft Government Regulation does not add any new terms that require definition. The majority of the terms have already been defined in other legislation or remain the same as those definitions in the previous law. Nevertheless, some of the definitions for the key terms need to be noted for the purposes of this ILD.

 

Mining is defined as the whole, or part of the, activity encompassing the experimental, management, and exploitation of mineral and coal resources, and covers general investigation, exploration, feasibility studies, construction, mining, processing and refining, distribution and sale, and post mining activities.

 

Mining Zones are defined as an area within the national spatial arrangement which have the potential of having mineral and / or coal. The Mining Zones are comprised of Mining Efforts Zones (Wilayah Usaha Pertambangan / WUP), Community Mining Zones (Wilayah Pertambangan Rakyat / WPR), and the State Reserves Zones (Wilayah Pencadangan Negara / WPN). Each of these has been further defined in the legislation.

 

Furthermore, Mining Efforts (Usaha Pertambangan) is an activity that exploits mineral or coal which includes several parts of mining, namely: general investigation, exploration, feasibility studies, construction, mining, processing and refining, distribution and sale, and post mining activities. The license for Exploitation is called a Mining Efforts License (Izin Usaha Pertambangan / IUP).

 

It is important to note that before the introduction of the new IUP in the new law, the previous Law on Mineral and Coal Mining, Law No. 11 of 1967, the definition of Mining Concession (Kuasa Pertambangan / KP) has a very similar meaning to the definition of the IUP. However neither the new law, its elucidation nor the draft Government Regulations are silent on the differences or overlap of the terms IUP and KP.

 

The issue of definition is proving to bring considerable legal uncertainty to the process as those parties holding a current KP, such as State-Owned Enterprises (SOEs), remain uncertain of the validity of their respective KPs in their current format. This concern remains despite the assurances of the Minister because the new Law is clear that current KPs remain valid but must come into compliance with the new Law within 12 months.

 

In an attempt to overcome the confusion and to resolve the issue, the Directorate General of Mineral, Coal, and Geothermal Resources has issued a Circular (Surat Edaran / SE) No. 03.E/31/DJB/2009. In essence, this Circular should settle the debate over the definitions of the IUP and the KP and their respective validity. Nevertheless, some remain unconvinced as they question the legally binding nature of a Circular in preference to other legislation instruments. Specifically, the concern is that this is an issue of sufficient importance that it must be regulated in a higher regulation that falls clearly within the hierarchy of legislation as defined in Law No. 10 of 2004 on Legislation Drafting.

 

Objectives and Principles

The draft on Mining Zones contains three underlying objectives which are:

-

To realize, among others, areas within the national spatial arrangement that have potential for minerals and coal;

-

Become the standard in implementing the Mining Efforts Zones, Community Mining Zones, and the State Reserves Zones plans, and;

-

To create an understanding between the central government, provincial governments, and municipal / city governments on the use and utilization of the national spatial arrangement for mining activities.

 

The principles of the Mining Zones are to be found in the Law, where it states, among others, that the Mining Zones are to be implemented transparently, in a participative manner, and responsibly.

 

Investigation and Research

The Minister in coordination with the local governments is to perform investigations and research on the mining and / or exploitation of resources in preparing the Mining Zone. These activities shall include the following phases: (i) identification of potential areas; (ii) calculation of the natural resources and reserves of minerals and coal; (iii) geographical indication, utilization of the land, and size of the area; (iv) the geological condition; (v) social, economic, and cultural aspects of the community, and; (vi) environment.

 

Management of Data and Information

The Draft states that any information obtained from the investigation and research belongs to the state, and by that, the state has the ultimate right to do whatever it deems fit with that information. The Draft also indicates that the state also has the right to “destroy” the information. Although, having gone to the trouble and expense of facilitating the collection of that information the need to subsequently then destroy the information remains unclear.

 

Both the central government and the local governments must have information systems in place that holds, and is accessible, the data relating to mineral and coal resources within any Mineral Zone. In addition, the Draft also regulates the base price of the data and / or information which results from the investigation and research as well as the exploration.

 

Determination of Mining Zones

The right to decide which areas are to be declared Mining Zones resides with the government after coordination with the relevant local government and consultation with the House of Representatives (DPR). Coordination is rendered by the Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources, the relevant Governor, and the relevant Regent / Mayor.

 

The authorities shall determine the license Mining Zones on separate basis. Each Mining Zone is to have a list of their own criteria for granting a license.

 

Every implementing instrument of Government Regulation No. 32 of 1969, as amended by No. 75 of 2001, remains in force insofar as they are consistent with the new Government Regulations and Law.

 

Guidance and Supervision in the Mining Sector

 

Articles 71(2) and 144 of the Law require the existence of a Government Regulation on Guidance and Supervision in the Mining Sector. The draft that has been formulated by the Directorate General of Mineral, Coal, and Geothermal Resources consists of two points of discussion: (i) practical mining requirements, and; (ii) supervision standards and procedures.

 

Key Terms and Definitions

Similar to the draft Government Regulation on Mining Zones, this draft also uses most of the terms in the Law. Thus, for the purpose of comprehending the draft those terms will be defined in this section.

 

Community Mining License (IPR) is a license to implement mining efforts in community mining territories. Generally, these are limited with respect to size of the mining area and the scale of the investment. Special Mining Efforts License (IUPK) is defined as a license to implement mining efforts in special mining efforts license territories. And Mining Efforts Zone License (WIUP) is a zone that is granted to the holder of an IUP.

 

Guidance

Guidance in this sense is the direction given by the Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources to the provincial, and municipal / city governments in the implementation of the Law. The guidance covers the following acts:

-

Provision of guidelines on running a mining business;

-

Provision of assistance and consultation;

-

Education and training, and;

-

Planning, research, development, and evaluation of the mining business.

 

In the process of managing the mining business, any breach of the relevant regulations by the local governments may result in a warning being issued. And, if the warning is ignored, then the management of the relevant mining area will be returned to the government until the local government in question has come into compliance with the required standards.

 

Moreover, the guidance is not solely for the relevant local governments, but guidance also permits the Minister to provide directions to the IUP, IPR, and IUPK holders as well.

 

Supervision

Again, supervision is performed by the Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources. This supervision is also over the local government’s management of the mining business. The Minister is permitted to do both administrative and operational supervision.

 

Administrative supervision is supervision by means of evaluating the reports on the planning and implementation of the mining activities. While operational supervision, consists of fifteen points of supervision, among others:

-

Work health and safety management;

-

Conservation on mining and coal resources;

-

Development of the local community, and;

-

Environmental management, reclamation, and post-mining activities.

 

Supervision also applies to IUP, IPR, and IUPK holders, in which the supervisory bodies (both the central and local governments) oversee different IUP, IPR, and IUPK holders. The Minister supervises (i) IUP holders, where the WIUP is located within the province and where the mining location is within the province and / or territorial waters beyond twelve miles from the base line, and; (ii) IUPK holders of exploration and IUPK holders of operation production for the mining of minerals and coal.

 

Furthermore, the Governor oversees IUP holders, where the WIUP is located within its municipality / city and the IUP holders have their production activity within the municipality / city and / or between four miles and twelve miles of the relevant territorial waters. As for the Regent / Mayor, they supervise (i) IUP holders, where the WIUP is located within their municipality / city and the IUP holders have their production activity within the municipality / city and / or within four miles of the territorial waters, and; (ii) IPR holders, where the WUIPR is located within the municipality / city and the IUP holders have their production activity within the municipality / city and / or within four miles of the territorial waters.

                                                                                                                    

The closing provisions of this Draft should be read closely, as it repeals and replaces Government Regulation No. 32 of 1969 as amended by No. 75 of 2001 while simultaneously affirming that all regulations that have been enacted based on Government Regulation No. 32 of 1969 as amended by Government Regulation No. 75 of 2001 remain in force so long as they are consistent with this regulation and the new Law.

 

These Draft Regulations Scheduled for Enactment in May

These draft Government Regulations are expected to be enacted this month.

 

Conclusion

 

The new Law on Mineral and Coal Mining gives more stringent requirements prior to a mining concession being issued. The draft regulations clearly highlight that the government is to assume a more pro-active role in the administration and management of the mining sector with respect to determining mining zones and the issuance of licenses and permits.

 

The draft regulations should allow both the right and left hands of the government to know what the other is doing. It is expected that this in turn will enhance the quality of services and obtain better returns from the long-term sustainable exploitation of Indonesia’s natural resources. It is also expected that the new draft regulations will allow the government to avoid making the perceived mistakes of the past, particularly by prioritizing the interests of the state over the interests of business.

 

Finally, it is expected that the new regulatory framework in the mining sector will facilitate growth in investment, growth in revenue, and protection of the long-term sustainability of the industry. Nevertheless, there remain considerable questions from the various stakeholders as to whether the provisions of the new law and the draft regulations achieve the stated aims that drove the need to amend the old regulatory framework. In this sense, time will tell with regards to the overall success of the new laws and regulation in the minerals and coal mining sector.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku

Overview

 

The enactment of the Bill on Mineral and Coal Mining as Law No. 4 of 2009 on 16 December 2008 had been, and continues to be, one of the most hotly debated new laws to come into existence over the past few years. The seriousness of the debate and the considerable divergence on the issues culminated in a number of the House of Representative (DPR) factions walking out (see ILB No. 994 17/12/2008). Furthermore, there continues to be rigorous criticism of several of the provisions as they are deemed to be detrimental to many of the stakeholders in this area.

 

Nevertheless, not all of the provisions are considered to be steps backwards and the overall intent appears to be to simplify the process while simultaneously providing greater legal certainty. Whether the Law achieves its state purposes and objectives depends largely on the implementing provisions that are drafted and then enacted to facilitate the implementation and subsequent enforcement of the provisions of the Law.

 

The most criticized provisions, among others, are the provisions on licensing which lack of transparency and accountability, as well as the non-existence of evaluation on existing mining license holders. The lack of evaluation has led to charges that this is tantamount to opening the door to the possible triple threat of corruption, collusion, and nepotism. Yet, for other commentators, the provisions on existing working contracts are problematic, since the Law states that the remaining contract may still be valid until its due date expires, but on the other hand the provisions of the contract must be in compliance with the provisions of the Law within one year of the Law coming into force.

 

This gives rise to considerable confusion as in effect the current working contracts are not valid until their respective terms end as there is the competing obligation of being in compliance with the new norms set out in the new law. Consequently, there are questions being asked regarding the proclaimed enhanced legal certainty that the new law is supposed to bring into play.

 

In responding to these criticisms, the Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources, Purnomo Yusgiantoro, stated that the Law is an ideal product which favors the national interest, therefore there is no reason to re-evaluate any existing work contract, in so far as the content of those work contracts are in compliance with the Law.

 

In line with the Minister’s stance and in an effort to cover any existing loopholes within the Law, the Directorate General of Mineral, Coal, and Geothermal Resources has formulated and submitted four drafts of the proposed Government Regulation on Mineral and Coal Mining to the Legal Bureau of the Department of Energy and Mineral Resources. These drafts were submitted in April 2009. The draft regulations encompass the following subjects: (i) Mining Zones; (ii) Mineral and Coal Mining Activities; (iii) Development and Supervision of Mining, and; (iv) Reclamation and Post-Mining Activities.

 

This ILD will focus on and examine the drafts on Mining Zones, as well as Guidance and Supervision in the Mining Sector. The remaining drafts will be examined in a succeeding ILD.

 

Mining Areas

 

The draft Government Regulation on Mining Zones is required by Articles 12, 19, 25, 33, and 89 of the Law. It focuses on the investigation and research in the field of mining, management of the results of the activity, and the determination of the Mining Zones.

                                                                                                               

Key terms and Definitions

The draft Government Regulation does not add any new terms that require definition. The majority of the terms have already been defined in other legislation or remain the same as those definitions in the previous law. Nevertheless, some of the definitions for the key terms need to be noted for the purposes of this ILD.

 

Mining is defined as the whole, or part of the, activity encompassing the experimental, management, and exploitation of mineral and coal resources, and covers general investigation, exploration, feasibility studies, construction, mining, processing and refining, distribution and sale, and post mining activities.

 

Mining Zones are defined as an area within the national spatial arrangement which have the potential of having mineral and / or coal. The Mining Zones are comprised of Mining Efforts Zones (Wilayah Usaha Pertambangan / WUP), Community Mining Zones (Wilayah Pertambangan Rakyat / WPR), and the State Reserves Zones (Wilayah Pencadangan Negara / WPN). Each of these has been further defined in the legislation.

 

Furthermore, Mining Efforts (Usaha Pertambangan) is an activity that exploits mineral or coal which includes several parts of mining, namely: general investigation, exploration, feasibility studies, construction, mining, processing and refining, distribution and sale, and post mining activities. The license for Exploitation is called a Mining Efforts License (Izin Usaha Pertambangan / IUP).

 

It is important to note that before the introduction of the new IUP in the new law, the previous Law on Mineral and Coal Mining, Law No. 11 of 1967, the definition of Mining Concession (Kuasa Pertambangan / KP) has a very similar meaning to the definition of the IUP. However neither the new law, its elucidation nor the draft Government Regulations are silent on the differences or overlap of the terms IUP and KP.

 

The issue of definition is proving to bring considerable legal uncertainty to the process as those parties holding a current KP, such as State-Owned Enterprises (SOEs), remain uncertain of the validity of their respective KPs in their current format. This concern remains despite the assurances of the Minister because the new Law is clear that current KPs remain valid but must come into compliance with the new Law within 12 months.

 

In an attempt to overcome the confusion and to resolve the issue, the Directorate General of Mineral, Coal, and Geothermal Resources has issued a Circular (Surat Edaran / SE) No. 03.E/31/DJB/2009. In essence, this Circular should settle the debate over the definitions of the IUP and the KP and their respective validity. Nevertheless, some remain unconvinced as they question the legally binding nature of a Circular in preference to other legislation instruments. Specifically, the concern is that this is an issue of sufficient importance that it must be regulated in a higher regulation that falls clearly within the hierarchy of legislation as defined in Law No. 10 of 2004 on Legislation Drafting.

 

Objectives and Principles

The draft on Mining Zones contains three underlying objectives which are:

-

To realize, among others, areas within the national spatial arrangement that have potential for minerals and coal;

-

Become the standard in implementing the Mining Efforts Zones, Community Mining Zones, and the State Reserves Zones plans, and;

-

To create an understanding between the central government, provincial governments, and municipal / city governments on the use and utilization of the national spatial arrangement for mining activities.

 

The principles of the Mining Zones are to be found in the Law, where it states, among others, that the Mining Zones are to be implemented transparently, in a participative manner, and responsibly.

 

Investigation and Research

The Minister in coordination with the local governments is to perform investigations and research on the mining and / or exploitation of resources in preparing the Mining Zone. These activities shall include the following phases: (i) identification of potential areas; (ii) calculation of the natural resources and reserves of minerals and coal; (iii) geographical indication, utilization of the land, and size of the area; (iv) the geological condition; (v) social, economic, and cultural aspects of the community, and; (vi) environment.

 

Management of Data and Information

The Draft states that any information obtained from the investigation and research belongs to the state, and by that, the state has the ultimate right to do whatever it deems fit with that information. The Draft also indicates that the state also has the right to “destroy” the information. Although, having gone to the trouble and expense of facilitating the collection of that information the need to subsequently then destroy the information remains unclear.

 

Both the central government and the local governments must have information systems in place that holds, and is accessible, the data relating to mineral and coal resources within any Mineral Zone. In addition, the Draft also regulates the base price of the data and / or information which results from the investigation and research as well as the exploration.

 

Determination of Mining Zones

The right to decide which areas are to be declared Mining Zones resides with the government after coordination with the relevant local government and consultation with the House of Representatives (DPR). Coordination is rendered by the Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources, the relevant Governor, and the relevant Regent / Mayor.

 

The authorities shall determine the license Mining Zones on separate basis. Each Mining Zone is to have a list of their own criteria for granting a license.

 

Every implementing instrument of Government Regulation No. 32 of 1969, as amended by No. 75 of 2001, remains in force insofar as they are consistent with the new Government Regulations and Law.

 

Guidance and Supervision in the Mining Sector

 

Articles 71(2) and 144 of the Law require the existence of a Government Regulation on Guidance and Supervision in the Mining Sector. The draft that has been formulated by the Directorate General of Mineral, Coal, and Geothermal Resources consists of two points of discussion: (i) practical mining requirements, and; (ii) supervision standards and procedures.

 

Key Terms and Definitions

Similar to the draft Government Regulation on Mining Zones, this draft also uses most of the terms in the Law. Thus, for the purpose of comprehending the draft those terms will be defined in this section.

 

Community Mining License (IPR) is a license to implement mining efforts in community mining territories. Generally, these are limited with respect to size of the mining area and the scale of the investment. Special Mining Efforts License (IUPK) is defined as a license to implement mining efforts in special mining efforts license territories. And Mining Efforts Zone License (WIUP) is a zone that is granted to the holder of an IUP.

 

Guidance

Guidance in this sense is the direction given by the Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources to the provincial, and municipal / city governments in the implementation of the Law. The guidance covers the following acts:

-

Provision of guidelines on running a mining business;

-

Provision of assistance and consultation;

-

Education and training, and;

-

Planning, research, development, and evaluation of the mining business.

 

In the process of managing the mining business, any breach of the relevant regulations by the local governments may result in a warning being issued. And, if the warning is ignored, then the management of the relevant mining area will be returned to the government until the local government in question has come into compliance with the required standards.

 

Moreover, the guidance is not solely for the relevant local governments, but guidance also permits the Minister to provide directions to the IUP, IPR, and IUPK holders as well.

 

Supervision

Again, supervision is performed by the Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources. This supervision is also over the local government’s management of the mining business. The Minister is permitted to do both administrative and operational supervision.

 

Administrative supervision is supervision by means of evaluating the reports on the planning and implementation of the mining activities. While operational supervision, consists of fifteen points of supervision, among others:

-

Work health and safety management;

-

Conservation on mining and coal resources;

-

Development of the local community, and;

-

Environmental management, reclamation, and post-mining activities.

 

Supervision also applies to IUP, IPR, and IUPK holders, in which the supervisory bodies (both the central and local governments) oversee different IUP, IPR, and IUPK holders. The Minister supervises (i) IUP holders, where the WIUP is located within the province and where the mining location is within the province and / or territorial waters beyond twelve miles from the base line, and; (ii) IUPK holders of exploration and IUPK holders of operation production for the mining of minerals and coal.

 

Furthermore, the Governor oversees IUP holders, where the WIUP is located within its municipality / city and the IUP holders have their production activity within the municipality / city and / or between four miles and twelve miles of the relevant territorial waters. As for the Regent / Mayor, they supervise (i) IUP holders, where the WIUP is located within their municipality / city and the IUP holders have their production activity within the municipality / city and / or within four miles of the territorial waters, and; (ii) IPR holders, where the WUIPR is located within the municipality / city and the IUP holders have their production activity within the municipality / city and / or within four miles of the territorial waters.

                                                                                                                    

The closing provisions of this Draft should be read closely, as it repeals and replaces Government Regulation No. 32 of 1969 as amended by No. 75 of 2001 while simultaneously affirming that all regulations that have been enacted based on Government Regulation No. 32 of 1969 as amended by Government Regulation No. 75 of 2001 remain in force so long as they are consistent with this regulation and the new Law.

 

These Draft Regulations Scheduled for Enactment in May

These draft Government Regulations are expected to be enacted this month.

 

Conclusion

 

The new Law on Mineral and Coal Mining gives more stringent requirements prior to a mining concession being issued. The draft regulations clearly highlight that the government is to assume a more pro-active role in the administration and management of the mining sector with respect to determining mining zones and the issuance of licenses and permits.

 

The draft regulations should allow both the right and left hands of the government to know what the other is doing. It is expected that this in turn will enhance the quality of services and obtain better returns from the long-term sustainable exploitation of Indonesia’s natural resources. It is also expected that the new draft regulations will allow the government to avoid making the perceived mistakes of the past, particularly by prioritizing the interests of the state over the interests of business.

 

Finally, it is expected that the new regulatory framework in the mining sector will facilitate growth in investment, growth in revenue, and protection of the long-term sustainability of the industry. Nevertheless, there remain considerable questions from the various stakeholders as to whether the provisions of the new law and the draft regulations achieve the stated aims that drove the need to amend the old regulatory framework. In this sense, time will tell with regards to the overall success of the new laws and regulation in the minerals and coal mining sector.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku
2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info