BAPEPAM-LK Regulation on Fit and Proper Tests in the Insurance Sector

Overview

 

The government has been leading the drive to reduce, and perhaps eliminate, all breaches of the insurance sector regulatory framework through myriad of amendments to old legislation and the introduction and the subsequent enactment of new legislation. Nevertheless, these amendments and additions have been at best mixed however there are many who believe that the results to date have been far from effective in achieving the stated goals. The most recent addition to this regulatory framework has been a revision to the guidelines governing fit and proper tests for directors and commissioners issued by the Capital Market and Financial Institutions Supervisory Agency (Bapepam-LK).

 

There are many cases that highlight the need for a revised and enhanced set of guidelines to ensure that directors and commissioners are fully vetted prior to assuming that role is important. However, it is equally important, if not more so, that the relevant authorities ensure strict enforcement of the prevailing laws and regulations. The cold hard reality is that any legislation in the insurance sector is only ever going to be as good as the enforcement regime charged with ensuring compliance with the rules.

 

At least two cases of note; Asuransi Angkatan Bersenjata Republik Indonesia (Asabri) case and the Bumiputera case, highlight that in many instances the breaches or violations of the prevailing laws and regulations are orchestrated and carried out by the upper echelons of management, including, among others: directors, commissioners, and shareholders.  

 

The torch of responsibility in the insurance sector has long passed to the Department of Finance pursuant to Law No. 2 of 1992 on Insurance. The actual responsibility for issuing guidelines on fit and proper tests has been delegated to Bapepam-LK. Bapepam-LK is tasked with ensuring that the directors and commissioners engaged in the insurance sector meet very specific requirements with respect to competency and integrity. It is expected that the “new” guidelines will ensure much greater levels of compliance and that this compliance will simultaneously lead to greater levels of accountability to be exerted over and on directors and commissioners in the insurance sector. It remains to be seen whether the expected outcomes are realized however the enactment of this Regulation is a step in the right direction.

 

The regulation, No. PER-04/BL/2009, repeals and replaces an earlier regulation, No. per-03/BL/2009 on the same subject matter. However, it is important to note that this is not the only regulation purporting to govern this subject matter. The Minister of Finance has issued Regulation No. 78/PMK.05/2007 which is also on similar subject matter. The current Bapepam-LK regulation considers the Minister of Finance Regulation however it does not explicitly state that the two regulations must be read in conjunction with one another. On reading the current Bapepam-LK regulation it is reasonable to assume, considering the comprehensive nature of the provisions, that the Bapepam-LK regulation could be read as a stand-alone piece of legislation.

 

Nevertheless, it is important to note that despite the comprehensive nature of the guidelines with respect to setting out the procedures for a fit and proper test, neither the regulation nor the guidelines define all of the key terms. Therefore, it is in this sense that the other pieces of legislation in the insurance sector must be read.

 

The rationale behind these guidelines is simply to improve the fit and proper test process. Yet, the rationale also has an element of increasing not only consumer confidence in the insurance sector, but more generally community confidence in the government being pro-active in ensuring that directors and commissioners are competent and have integrity, and therefore will operate in the best interests of the company, consumer and broader community and not in their own interests.

 

The regulation contains only three articles and covers the following: (i) reference to the content of the Guidelines as contained in the Attachment to the regulation; (ii) acknowledgment that the regulation repeals and replaces the earlier regulation that is Head of BAPEPAM-LK Regulation No. PER-03/BL/2009, and; (iii) announcement that the Guidelines have been in force since the enactment of the regulation.

 

There was considerable criticism of the previous regulation and guidelines. The current regulation and guidelines do not make significant amendments or changes. Therefore, it is expected that there will also be considerable criticism of the new regulation and the supposedly new guidelines for fit and proper tests.

 

The lack of fundamental amendments or change can be seen from the “Press Release of BAPEPAM-LK Regulation” on 24 April 2009, which summarizes the three areas of amendment: (i) the types of experience and ability required from the participating director and commissioner, (ii) directives on the element of integrity, and lastly (iii) the advancement criterion for independent or other types of commissioners.

 

This ILD will further discuss and examine the important features of the new regulation while simultaneously highlight the potential impact of the Guidelines on the business.

 

Key Terms and Definitions

Simply, a fit and proper test is defined as a test for candidates to qualify as directors or commissioners in an insurance company. The fit and proper test is to be held under the auspices of the BAPEPAM-LK.

 

The two other key definitions are:

-

Competency - this element measures the applicant’s ability in running an insurance company (knowledge of relevant regulations, or experience in the field, among others), and;

-

Integrity - this element determines the applicant’s level of compliance and good faith in operating an insurance company (no criminal record or sentence of more than five years imprisonment or a participant in unfair business, among others).

 

 

However, as was noted earlier not all of the terms are defined in either the regulation or the guidelines. Some of the terms not defined in this piece of legislation include, among others, are director, commissioner, insurance company, Examination Team, Evaluation Committee, Insurance Bureau, and preliminary analysis.

 

Therefore, if definitions for any of these terms is required to ensure compliance with the guidelines as they relate to fit and proper tests, then it will be necessary to refer to the more lex generalis regulations in this sector, namely: Law No. 2 of 1992, Government Regulation No. 73 of 1992 as amended by Government Regulation No. 81 of 2008, Presidential Decree No. 45/M of 2006, Minister of Finance Decision No. 426/KMK.03/2003, and finally Minister of Finance Regulation No. 78/PMK.05/2007.

 

Objectives

The basic objective of the guidelines is to ensure that only those candidate directors and commissioners with the requisite skills, specifically competency and integrity, are able to pass the fit and proper test. It is expected that the guidelines will set the pass bar higher and thereby ensure that the quality of the directors and commissioners in the insurance sector are the crème de la crème when it comes to directors and commissioners.

 

If the guidelines are able to achieve this then it is reasonable to assume that issues of accountability will no longer be issues as all directors and commissioners will be fully aware of their obligations and knowledgeable of the risks associated with breach of the provisions. Hence, directors and commissioners will be fully accountable for their actions.

 

Assessment

The fit and proper test covers two basic elements; competency and integrity.

 

The competency of a director or commissioner is assessed through four evaluations:

-

Sufficient and relevant knowledge of the field of insurance;

-

Experience in the field of insurance and of other relevant fields;

-

Education or proficiency in the field of insurance and of other relevant fields, and;

-

Strategic management ability in terms of improving a sound insurance business.

 

While the integrity of a director or commissioner is assessed according to eight evaluations:

-

Whether they have participated in any unfair business practices in the field of insurance or financial services;

-

Been part of an insurance or economic crime;

-

Committed a crime where the term of imprisonment is five-years or more;

-

Violated an agreement which was made with an authorized insurance institution;

-

Committed an act that enriches shareholders, directors, commissioners, staff and/or others to the detriment of insurance policy holders and/or the insurance company for which they worked;

-

Violated the principle of prudential business in the insurance sector;

-

Acted incompetently as a director or commissioner, and;

-

Committed an act that made the insurance company they worked for violate existing regulations concerning insurance or other relevant regulations.

 

The primary criticism of the fit and proper test process is that it is reactive to past indiscretions or lack thereof, but it cannot predict future actions of directors and commissioners. Therefore, the criticism is that the accuracy of the test is compromised as the evaluation method can only ever tell half the story. Simply, once the fit and proper test process has run its course and directors and commissioners have been appointed, then the burden passes to those tasked with ensuring compliance to prevailing laws and regulations; the law enforcers.

 

Authorized Assessment Bodies

The fit and proper test is to be conducted by an Evaluation Committee. The Evaluation Committee is to comprise of a maximum of fifty eminent individuals with requisite qualifications in the insurance sector. However, to qualify the eminent individuals cannot be currently serving in the capacity of director or commissioner of an insurance company.

 

The Evaluation Committee will then appoint an Examination Team. The Examination Team will comprise five members appointed from within the ranks of the Evaluation Team. Two of the Examination Team members will be from the Insurance Bureau and Bapepam-LK and the remaining members are to come from other agencies or institutions.

 

Considering, the critical role of the Committee in ensuring the successful outcomes of the regulation it would be reasonable to expect that a fit and proper test apply to those conducting the fit and proper tests against others. However, the current belief is that providing that the members of the Committee satisfy the eminent requirements then the assumption is that they are suitably qualified to conduct fit and proper tests against prospective directors and commissioners. 

 

Procedural Steps

The fit and proper test must follow the steps listed below:

-

The subject of a fit and proper test may be: (i) a candidate for the position of director or commissioner, or (ii) a director or commissioner;

-

A preliminary analysis of the prospective director or commissioner to be made by the Insurance Bureau;

-

Testing the fitness and properness of the prospective director or commissioner is to be held by the Evaluation Committee through its Examination Team, and;

-

Finally, the result of the test will be delivered to the Head of BAPEPAM-LK for subsequent determination.

 

The Head of BAPEPAM-LK may at any time call a participant as stipulated in (ii) to participate in the test. This summons may be exempted for those who have passed a fit and proper test within the previous three years. However, if a fit and proper test has not been successfully passed in the previous three years then no exemption can be claimed.

 

Once an examination has been completed on a prospective director or commissioner, the Head of Bapepam-LK has the ability to make a determination on the outcome of the examination, order a review of the results, or re-start the process and request a new Examination Team be appointed to re-test the prospective director or commissioner.

 

The Head of Bapepam-LK in making a determination on the results of the examination can only accept or reject. Simply, the Head of Bapepam-LK can state that the prospective director or candidate has successfully passed the fit and proper test process or they have failed that process.

 

Enforcement

The Guidelines have been in force since 24 April 2009.

 

Conclusion

 

It is clear from the regulation and the guidelines contained therein are designed to reduce and eliminate breaches of the insurance sector regulatory framework by directors and commissioners. Despite the criticisms that the guidelines only address the activities of prospective directors and commissioners up to the date of the examination process it is reasonable to state that the guidelines are a significant step in the right direction to ensuring greater accountability for directors and commissioner.

 

Nevertheless, it must be noted that once a prospective director or commissioner passes the fit and proper test process, then the onus of ensuring compliance shifts from those conducting the fit and proper tests to those tasked with enforcing the prevailing laws and regulations in the insurance sector.

 

Successfully passing a fit and proper test is certainly no guarantee that a director or commissioner will always comply with their obligations. Yet, it is fair to say that the fit and proper test process was never meant to achieve this outcome. The fit and proper test process is designed to ensure that the best candidates pass and those with suspect credentials do not.

 

It is expected that the guidelines will achieve the stated objective of ensuring a higher quality of candidate passes the fit and proper test, which in turn is expected to result in greater compliance and accountability in the insurance sector.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku

Overview

 

The government has been leading the drive to reduce, and perhaps eliminate, all breaches of the insurance sector regulatory framework through myriad of amendments to old legislation and the introduction and the subsequent enactment of new legislation. Nevertheless, these amendments and additions have been at best mixed however there are many who believe that the results to date have been far from effective in achieving the stated goals. The most recent addition to this regulatory framework has been a revision to the guidelines governing fit and proper tests for directors and commissioners issued by the Capital Market and Financial Institutions Supervisory Agency (Bapepam-LK).

 

There are many cases that highlight the need for a revised and enhanced set of guidelines to ensure that directors and commissioners are fully vetted prior to assuming that role is important. However, it is equally important, if not more so, that the relevant authorities ensure strict enforcement of the prevailing laws and regulations. The cold hard reality is that any legislation in the insurance sector is only ever going to be as good as the enforcement regime charged with ensuring compliance with the rules.

 

At least two cases of note; Asuransi Angkatan Bersenjata Republik Indonesia (Asabri) case and the Bumiputera case, highlight that in many instances the breaches or violations of the prevailing laws and regulations are orchestrated and carried out by the upper echelons of management, including, among others: directors, commissioners, and shareholders.  

 

The torch of responsibility in the insurance sector has long passed to the Department of Finance pursuant to Law No. 2 of 1992 on Insurance. The actual responsibility for issuing guidelines on fit and proper tests has been delegated to Bapepam-LK. Bapepam-LK is tasked with ensuring that the directors and commissioners engaged in the insurance sector meet very specific requirements with respect to competency and integrity. It is expected that the “new” guidelines will ensure much greater levels of compliance and that this compliance will simultaneously lead to greater levels of accountability to be exerted over and on directors and commissioners in the insurance sector. It remains to be seen whether the expected outcomes are realized however the enactment of this Regulation is a step in the right direction.

 

The regulation, No. PER-04/BL/2009, repeals and replaces an earlier regulation, No. per-03/BL/2009 on the same subject matter. However, it is important to note that this is not the only regulation purporting to govern this subject matter. The Minister of Finance has issued Regulation No. 78/PMK.05/2007 which is also on similar subject matter. The current Bapepam-LK regulation considers the Minister of Finance Regulation however it does not explicitly state that the two regulations must be read in conjunction with one another. On reading the current Bapepam-LK regulation it is reasonable to assume, considering the comprehensive nature of the provisions, that the Bapepam-LK regulation could be read as a stand-alone piece of legislation.

 

Nevertheless, it is important to note that despite the comprehensive nature of the guidelines with respect to setting out the procedures for a fit and proper test, neither the regulation nor the guidelines define all of the key terms. Therefore, it is in this sense that the other pieces of legislation in the insurance sector must be read.

 

The rationale behind these guidelines is simply to improve the fit and proper test process. Yet, the rationale also has an element of increasing not only consumer confidence in the insurance sector, but more generally community confidence in the government being pro-active in ensuring that directors and commissioners are competent and have integrity, and therefore will operate in the best interests of the company, consumer and broader community and not in their own interests.

 

The regulation contains only three articles and covers the following: (i) reference to the content of the Guidelines as contained in the Attachment to the regulation; (ii) acknowledgment that the regulation repeals and replaces the earlier regulation that is Head of BAPEPAM-LK Regulation No. PER-03/BL/2009, and; (iii) announcement that the Guidelines have been in force since the enactment of the regulation.

 

There was considerable criticism of the previous regulation and guidelines. The current regulation and guidelines do not make significant amendments or changes. Therefore, it is expected that there will also be considerable criticism of the new regulation and the supposedly new guidelines for fit and proper tests.

 

The lack of fundamental amendments or change can be seen from the “Press Release of BAPEPAM-LK Regulation” on 24 April 2009, which summarizes the three areas of amendment: (i) the types of experience and ability required from the participating director and commissioner, (ii) directives on the element of integrity, and lastly (iii) the advancement criterion for independent or other types of commissioners.

 

This ILD will further discuss and examine the important features of the new regulation while simultaneously highlight the potential impact of the Guidelines on the business.

 

Key Terms and Definitions

Simply, a fit and proper test is defined as a test for candidates to qualify as directors or commissioners in an insurance company. The fit and proper test is to be held under the auspices of the BAPEPAM-LK.

 

The two other key definitions are:

-

Competency - this element measures the applicant’s ability in running an insurance company (knowledge of relevant regulations, or experience in the field, among others), and;

-

Integrity - this element determines the applicant’s level of compliance and good faith in operating an insurance company (no criminal record or sentence of more than five years imprisonment or a participant in unfair business, among others).

 

 

However, as was noted earlier not all of the terms are defined in either the regulation or the guidelines. Some of the terms not defined in this piece of legislation include, among others, are director, commissioner, insurance company, Examination Team, Evaluation Committee, Insurance Bureau, and preliminary analysis.

 

Therefore, if definitions for any of these terms is required to ensure compliance with the guidelines as they relate to fit and proper tests, then it will be necessary to refer to the more lex generalis regulations in this sector, namely: Law No. 2 of 1992, Government Regulation No. 73 of 1992 as amended by Government Regulation No. 81 of 2008, Presidential Decree No. 45/M of 2006, Minister of Finance Decision No. 426/KMK.03/2003, and finally Minister of Finance Regulation No. 78/PMK.05/2007.

 

Objectives

The basic objective of the guidelines is to ensure that only those candidate directors and commissioners with the requisite skills, specifically competency and integrity, are able to pass the fit and proper test. It is expected that the guidelines will set the pass bar higher and thereby ensure that the quality of the directors and commissioners in the insurance sector are the crème de la crème when it comes to directors and commissioners.

 

If the guidelines are able to achieve this then it is reasonable to assume that issues of accountability will no longer be issues as all directors and commissioners will be fully aware of their obligations and knowledgeable of the risks associated with breach of the provisions. Hence, directors and commissioners will be fully accountable for their actions.

 

Assessment

The fit and proper test covers two basic elements; competency and integrity.

 

The competency of a director or commissioner is assessed through four evaluations:

-

Sufficient and relevant knowledge of the field of insurance;

-

Experience in the field of insurance and of other relevant fields;

-

Education or proficiency in the field of insurance and of other relevant fields, and;

-

Strategic management ability in terms of improving a sound insurance business.

 

While the integrity of a director or commissioner is assessed according to eight evaluations:

-

Whether they have participated in any unfair business practices in the field of insurance or financial services;

-

Been part of an insurance or economic crime;

-

Committed a crime where the term of imprisonment is five-years or more;

-

Violated an agreement which was made with an authorized insurance institution;

-

Committed an act that enriches shareholders, directors, commissioners, staff and/or others to the detriment of insurance policy holders and/or the insurance company for which they worked;

-

Violated the principle of prudential business in the insurance sector;

-

Acted incompetently as a director or commissioner, and;

-

Committed an act that made the insurance company they worked for violate existing regulations concerning insurance or other relevant regulations.

 

The primary criticism of the fit and proper test process is that it is reactive to past indiscretions or lack thereof, but it cannot predict future actions of directors and commissioners. Therefore, the criticism is that the accuracy of the test is compromised as the evaluation method can only ever tell half the story. Simply, once the fit and proper test process has run its course and directors and commissioners have been appointed, then the burden passes to those tasked with ensuring compliance to prevailing laws and regulations; the law enforcers.

 

Authorized Assessment Bodies

The fit and proper test is to be conducted by an Evaluation Committee. The Evaluation Committee is to comprise of a maximum of fifty eminent individuals with requisite qualifications in the insurance sector. However, to qualify the eminent individuals cannot be currently serving in the capacity of director or commissioner of an insurance company.

 

The Evaluation Committee will then appoint an Examination Team. The Examination Team will comprise five members appointed from within the ranks of the Evaluation Team. Two of the Examination Team members will be from the Insurance Bureau and Bapepam-LK and the remaining members are to come from other agencies or institutions.

 

Considering, the critical role of the Committee in ensuring the successful outcomes of the regulation it would be reasonable to expect that a fit and proper test apply to those conducting the fit and proper tests against others. However, the current belief is that providing that the members of the Committee satisfy the eminent requirements then the assumption is that they are suitably qualified to conduct fit and proper tests against prospective directors and commissioners. 

 

Procedural Steps

The fit and proper test must follow the steps listed below:

-

The subject of a fit and proper test may be: (i) a candidate for the position of director or commissioner, or (ii) a director or commissioner;

-

A preliminary analysis of the prospective director or commissioner to be made by the Insurance Bureau;

-

Testing the fitness and properness of the prospective director or commissioner is to be held by the Evaluation Committee through its Examination Team, and;

-

Finally, the result of the test will be delivered to the Head of BAPEPAM-LK for subsequent determination.

 

The Head of BAPEPAM-LK may at any time call a participant as stipulated in (ii) to participate in the test. This summons may be exempted for those who have passed a fit and proper test within the previous three years. However, if a fit and proper test has not been successfully passed in the previous three years then no exemption can be claimed.

 

Once an examination has been completed on a prospective director or commissioner, the Head of Bapepam-LK has the ability to make a determination on the outcome of the examination, order a review of the results, or re-start the process and request a new Examination Team be appointed to re-test the prospective director or commissioner.

 

The Head of Bapepam-LK in making a determination on the results of the examination can only accept or reject. Simply, the Head of Bapepam-LK can state that the prospective director or candidate has successfully passed the fit and proper test process or they have failed that process.

 

Enforcement

The Guidelines have been in force since 24 April 2009.

 

Conclusion

 

It is clear from the regulation and the guidelines contained therein are designed to reduce and eliminate breaches of the insurance sector regulatory framework by directors and commissioners. Despite the criticisms that the guidelines only address the activities of prospective directors and commissioners up to the date of the examination process it is reasonable to state that the guidelines are a significant step in the right direction to ensuring greater accountability for directors and commissioner.

 

Nevertheless, it must be noted that once a prospective director or commissioner passes the fit and proper test process, then the onus of ensuring compliance shifts from those conducting the fit and proper tests to those tasked with enforcing the prevailing laws and regulations in the insurance sector.

 

Successfully passing a fit and proper test is certainly no guarantee that a director or commissioner will always comply with their obligations. Yet, it is fair to say that the fit and proper test process was never meant to achieve this outcome. The fit and proper test process is designed to ensure that the best candidates pass and those with suspect credentials do not.

 

It is expected that the guidelines will achieve the stated objective of ensuring a higher quality of candidate passes the fit and proper test, which in turn is expected to result in greater compliance and accountability in the insurance sector.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku
2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info