There is no doubt that State-Owned Enterprises (SOEs) play a crucial role in the national economy. However, there have always been questions as to whether these SOEs have been performing at optimal levels with regards to the products and services they provide and contribute or the manner in which they have been managed.
It is evident that to ensure that the SOEs contribute in the way in which is expected, then those that can be restructured and revitalized must be so restructured and revitalized. To this end the State Minister of State-Owned Enterprises has issued Regulation No. PER-01/MBU/2009 setting out the guidelines for restructuring and revitalizing SOEs by the Asset Management Company (PT Perusahaan Pengelola Aset / PT PPA) as provided for under Article 1(2) of Government Regulation No. 61 of 2008 which has amended Government Regulation No. 10 of 2004.
This regulation is the product of consultations between the State Minister of State-Owned Enterprises and the Minister of Finance. Therefore, it is reasonable to say that this is indicative of a much broader, and perhaps much more structured, approach to ensuring the future of SOEs and the contributions that these enterprises make.
Critical Terms and Definitions
The basic terms of the regulation are defined in the General Provisions section (Article 1) and state that restructuring is fixing the internal conditions of the SOE in order that those conditions are more conducive to long-term sustainability. Restructuring is considered to be a strategic step that is intended to fulfill the objective of fixing performance issues and raising the value of the enterprise.
Furthermore, revitalization is defined as the provision of loans and capital injections. This is also done with the view of fixing performance issues and raising the value of the enterprise. Other terms defined include Letter of Commitment and Due Diligence, both of which are critical elements of the envisaged success of any restructuring and revitalization program undertaken by the PT PPA of any SOE.
A Letter of Commitment must be signed by the Directors and the Commissioners or the SOE Supervisory Board before any restructuring or revitalization can take place. The rationale for this is simple, those that are ultimately responsible for ensuring the success of any recommendations relating to restructuring and revitalization must state their willingness to follow the conditions and provisions of the restructuring and revitalization as stipulated by the PT PPA.
Due diligence is necessary to ensure that there is an accurate understanding of the current situation within the SOE, including any failings or deficiencies, in order that a comprehensive restructuring and revitalization plan can be developed, implemented, and evaluated over the short, medium, and long terms.
Finally, the regulation requires the establishment of a SOE Restructuring and Revitalization Committee which is tasked with providing inputs on the feasibility of SOE to participate in any restructuring and revitalization program and to provide recommendations as to the scheme of any agreed restructuring and revitalization that is set out for the SOE.
Objectives and Principles
The objectives of the regulation and the restructuring and revitalizing process are simply to ensure long-term viability and sustainability of the SOE through short-term assistance.
The driving principles are of good corporate governance and include, among others, transparency; accountability, responsibility, independence, and sustainability.
The Restructuring and Revitalization Process
The provisions of the regulation are indicative that the restructuring and revitalization process are not driven pro-actively by the government but rather by the SOEs themselves. This is to say that the guidelines require that the SOE submit a recommendation for restructuring and revitalization to the State Minister.
The recommendation is to be completed with all the required documents as set out by the PT PPA. This is to include the agreement of the General Meeting of Shareholders or whoever owns the capital. This agreement is to be in the form of a Letter of Commitment included that sets out that the SOE and the relevant directors and commissioners are committed to carrying out the restructuring and revitalization as envisaged and stipulated by PT PPA.
The State Minister is then to instruct PT PPA to undertake due diligence to assess whether the recommended restructuring and revitalization is feasible.
The Letter of Commitment
The Letter of Commitment is to be addressed to the PT PPA and must contain the following, as a minimum requirement to proceed:
-
The full support to implement the restructuring or revitalization process as evidenced in a decision of the General Meeting of Shareholders;
-
A guarantee to continue to perform one’s duties professionally throughout the restructuring and revitalization process;
-
An agreement to implement mechanisms, requirements, and any conditions as set out by the PT PPA;
-
A statement of preparedness to release and explain all documents and other information, including legal and credit documents, requested by the PT PPA;
-
An agreement to pay any debts / expenses arising as a result of the restructuring and revitalization process;
-
An agreement to take responsibility for all legal consequences that arise as a result of the restructuring and revitalization; and
-
Any other requirements stipulated by the PT PPA.
The directors and commissioners or supervisory board must be aware that once the Letter of Commitment is signed and delivered to the PT PPA it cannot be withdrawn and will remain valid until the restructuring and revitalization is complete.
The PT PPA is not completely free of obligations under the regulation. The PT PPA is required to keep all corporate information and data confidential. This data and information is only to be used for the purposes of the restructuring and revitalization.
Due Diligence
The due diligence process is enumerated through Articles 5 – 7.
The need for due diligence is so that once all the preliminary agreements have been made between the SOE and the PT PPA, the PT PPA can then map the current and potential problems faced by the SOE, study the potential of the SOE, identify possible business development and alternative resolution activities, and to formulate restructuring and revitalization options.
These options might be singular or a combination of areas, including financial; organizational / management; operational, or systems and procedures. For example the financial options include the restructuring of any debts held by the SOE. Operational activities include the cooperation with third parties, acquisition and selling of assets, and divestment, among others.
The Restructuring and Revitalization Committee
The regulation provides for the establishment of a Restructuring and Revitalization Committee. The Committee is to be comprised of the State Minister of SOE, the Minister of Finance, other relevant Ministers and representatives from each of the departments and agencies represented. Therefore, it is expected that the primary inputs into the restructuring and revitalization process from the government perspective will come from these elements.
The inputs in this context are merely to discuss and agree to the findings of the study that has been conducted by the PT PPA. The discussion is also expected to determine the length of time that the restructuring and revitalization process is expected to take.
Once these agreements have been obtained the State Minister of SOEs is to instruct the PT PPA to commence the restructuring and revitalization process.
Restructuring and Revitalization Agreement
Once a restructuring and revitalization has been agreed, the terms and conditions are to be enumerated in an agreement. This agreement is to include:
-
A credit agreement;
-
A guarantee;
-
A letter / statement of debt; and
-
An agreement to issue shares.
The use of funds from Asset Management is to be restricted to 15% of total capital deposited for the purposes of restructuring and revitalization.
Third Parties
The PT PPA can engage third parties to undertake the due diligence investigation. The procurement of the third party can be done by either the SOE or the PT PPA.
Fund Sources for Restructuring and Revitalization
Generally, funds for the restructuring and revitalization process will come from one of three sources:
1.
The State Budget;
2.
Funds available from the Asset Manager; and
3.
Funds from a third party.
The use of funds from the asset manager is restricted to 15% of the paid up capital. However, limits higher than this are not expressly prohibited and can be made on the agreement of the Minister of Finance.
Fees and Expenses
All expenses related to the restructuring and revitalization are to be borne by the relevant SOE.
Reporting
The PT PPA is to report to the Minister of Finance and the State Minister of State-Owned Enterprises at least once every three months or as required.
Enactment and Enforcement
The regulation has been in force since 8 April 2009.
Conclusion
There is little doubt that SOE play a large role in the development of the national economy. It is also clear that SOE could conceivably play an even larger role still and hence the need to restructure and revitalize those SOE that can be feasibly restructured and revitalized.
To ensure a degree of independence in this process the State Minister of SOE can appoint the PT PPA to evaluate and then manage the restructuring and revitalization process. Integral to the success of any restructuring and revitalization is the agreement of the directors and commissioners or supervisory board of the SOE. The regulation is clear that without this agreement any proposed restructuring and revitalization will not proceed.
It is expected that the regulation will allow for immediate restructuring and revitalization initiatives to be commenced.
There is no doubt that State-Owned Enterprises (SOEs) play a crucial role in the national economy. However, there have always been questions as to whether these SOEs have been performing at optimal levels with regards to the products and services they provide and contribute or the manner in which they have been managed.
It is evident that to ensure that the SOEs contribute in the way in which is expected, then those that can be restructured and revitalized must be so restructured and revitalized. To this end the State Minister of State-Owned Enterprises has issued Regulation No. PER-01/MBU/2009 setting out the guidelines for restructuring and revitalizing SOEs by the Asset Management Company (PT Perusahaan Pengelola Aset / PT PPA) as provided for under Article 1(2) of Government Regulation No. 61 of 2008 which has amended Government Regulation No. 10 of 2004.
This regulation is the product of consultations between the State Minister of State-Owned Enterprises and the Minister of Finance. Therefore, it is reasonable to say that this is indicative of a much broader, and perhaps much more structured, approach to ensuring the future of SOEs and the contributions that these enterprises make.
Critical Terms and Definitions
The basic terms of the regulation are defined in the General Provisions section (Article 1) and state that restructuring is fixing the internal conditions of the SOE in order that those conditions are more conducive to long-term sustainability. Restructuring is considered to be a strategic step that is intended to fulfill the objective of fixing performance issues and raising the value of the enterprise.
Furthermore, revitalization is defined as the provision of loans and capital injections. This is also done with the view of fixing performance issues and raising the value of the enterprise. Other terms defined include Letter of Commitment and Due Diligence, both of which are critical elements of the envisaged success of any restructuring and revitalization program undertaken by the PT PPA of any SOE.
A Letter of Commitment must be signed by the Directors and the Commissioners or the SOE Supervisory Board before any restructuring or revitalization can take place. The rationale for this is simple, those that are ultimately responsible for ensuring the success of any recommendations relating to restructuring and revitalization must state their willingness to follow the conditions and provisions of the restructuring and revitalization as stipulated by the PT PPA.
Due diligence is necessary to ensure that there is an accurate understanding of the current situation within the SOE, including any failings or deficiencies, in order that a comprehensive restructuring and revitalization plan can be developed, implemented, and evaluated over the short, medium, and long terms.
Finally, the regulation requires the establishment of a SOE Restructuring and Revitalization Committee which is tasked with providing inputs on the feasibility of SOE to participate in any restructuring and revitalization program and to provide recommendations as to the scheme of any agreed restructuring and revitalization that is set out for the SOE.
Objectives and Principles
The objectives of the regulation and the restructuring and revitalizing process are simply to ensure long-term viability and sustainability of the SOE through short-term assistance.
The driving principles are of good corporate governance and include, among others, transparency; accountability, responsibility, independence, and sustainability.
The Restructuring and Revitalization Process
The provisions of the regulation are indicative that the restructuring and revitalization process are not driven pro-actively by the government but rather by the SOEs themselves. This is to say that the guidelines require that the SOE submit a recommendation for restructuring and revitalization to the State Minister.
The recommendation is to be completed with all the required documents as set out by the PT PPA. This is to include the agreement of the General Meeting of Shareholders or whoever owns the capital. This agreement is to be in the form of a Letter of Commitment included that sets out that the SOE and the relevant directors and commissioners are committed to carrying out the restructuring and revitalization as envisaged and stipulated by PT PPA.
The State Minister is then to instruct PT PPA to undertake due diligence to assess whether the recommended restructuring and revitalization is feasible.
The Letter of Commitment
The Letter of Commitment is to be addressed to the PT PPA and must contain the following, as a minimum requirement to proceed:
-
The full support to implement the restructuring or revitalization process as evidenced in a decision of the General Meeting of Shareholders;
-
A guarantee to continue to perform one’s duties professionally throughout the restructuring and revitalization process;
-
An agreement to implement mechanisms, requirements, and any conditions as set out by the PT PPA;
-
A statement of preparedness to release and explain all documents and other information, including legal and credit documents, requested by the PT PPA;
-
An agreement to pay any debts / expenses arising as a result of the restructuring and revitalization process;
-
An agreement to take responsibility for all legal consequences that arise as a result of the restructuring and revitalization; and
-
Any other requirements stipulated by the PT PPA.
The directors and commissioners or supervisory board must be aware that once the Letter of Commitment is signed and delivered to the PT PPA it cannot be withdrawn and will remain valid until the restructuring and revitalization is complete.
The PT PPA is not completely free of obligations under the regulation. The PT PPA is required to keep all corporate information and data confidential. This data and information is only to be used for the purposes of the restructuring and revitalization.
Due Diligence
The due diligence process is enumerated through Articles 5 – 7.
The need for due diligence is so that once all the preliminary agreements have been made between the SOE and the PT PPA, the PT PPA can then map the current and potential problems faced by the SOE, study the potential of the SOE, identify possible business development and alternative resolution activities, and to formulate restructuring and revitalization options.
These options might be singular or a combination of areas, including financial; organizational / management; operational, or systems and procedures. For example the financial options include the restructuring of any debts held by the SOE. Operational activities include the cooperation with third parties, acquisition and selling of assets, and divestment, among others.
The Restructuring and Revitalization Committee
The regulation provides for the establishment of a Restructuring and Revitalization Committee. The Committee is to be comprised of the State Minister of SOE, the Minister of Finance, other relevant Ministers and representatives from each of the departments and agencies represented. Therefore, it is expected that the primary inputs into the restructuring and revitalization process from the government perspective will come from these elements.
The inputs in this context are merely to discuss and agree to the findings of the study that has been conducted by the PT PPA. The discussion is also expected to determine the length of time that the restructuring and revitalization process is expected to take.
Once these agreements have been obtained the State Minister of SOEs is to instruct the PT PPA to commence the restructuring and revitalization process.
Restructuring and Revitalization Agreement
Once a restructuring and revitalization has been agreed, the terms and conditions are to be enumerated in an agreement. This agreement is to include:
-
A credit agreement;
-
A guarantee;
-
A letter / statement of debt; and
-
An agreement to issue shares.
The use of funds from Asset Management is to be restricted to 15% of total capital deposited for the purposes of restructuring and revitalization.
Third Parties
The PT PPA can engage third parties to undertake the due diligence investigation. The procurement of the third party can be done by either the SOE or the PT PPA.
Fund Sources for Restructuring and Revitalization
Generally, funds for the restructuring and revitalization process will come from one of three sources:
1.
The State Budget;
2.
Funds available from the Asset Manager; and
3.
Funds from a third party.
The use of funds from the asset manager is restricted to 15% of the paid up capital. However, limits higher than this are not expressly prohibited and can be made on the agreement of the Minister of Finance.
Fees and Expenses
All expenses related to the restructuring and revitalization are to be borne by the relevant SOE.
Reporting
The PT PPA is to report to the Minister of Finance and the State Minister of State-Owned Enterprises at least once every three months or as required.
Enactment and Enforcement
The regulation has been in force since 8 April 2009.
Conclusion
There is little doubt that SOE play a large role in the development of the national economy. It is also clear that SOE could conceivably play an even larger role still and hence the need to restructure and revitalize those SOE that can be feasibly restructured and revitalized.
To ensure a degree of independence in this process the State Minister of SOE can appoint the PT PPA to evaluate and then manage the restructuring and revitalization process. Integral to the success of any restructuring and revitalization is the agreement of the directors and commissioners or supervisory board of the SOE. The regulation is clear that without this agreement any proposed restructuring and revitalization will not proceed.
It is expected that the regulation will allow for immediate restructuring and revitalization initiatives to be commenced.