The potential for tourism in Indonesia is huge seems to be somewhat of an understatement when one considers that this is a land with a rich and diverse cultural and religious history spread out over more than 17,000 tropical islands hugging the equator. The opportunities on the tourism front would appear to only be limited by one’s imagination and desire to explore this archipelagic paradise.
The government, to its credit, attempted to exploit this with a campaign directly targeting an increase in tourist numbers. The “Visit Indonesia 2008” campaign has seeming transited to become the “Visit Indonesia 2009” campaign if the Department’s website is accurate.
A law to regulate Indonesian tourism is not a new phenomenon. The previous regulatory framework contained in Law No. 9 of 1990 was clearly no longer appropriate to regulate the needs of the tourist industry in 2009. Therefore, rather than a series of amendments to an unworkable law the government embarked on a process of drafting, debating, passing, and enacting a new law, Law No. 10 of 2009, which would repeal and replace the previous incarnation of the law in this sector.
The Considerations that premise Indonesian laws generally set out the “big picture” elements justifying the need to enact a particular law. The Tourism Law is no different in this regard. The Considerations start with the fact that Indonesia has been blessed by almighty God as it has been populated with diverse flora and fauna, as well as extraordinary antiquities, history, art and culture. In light of this Consideration alone it would be remiss of the government and Indonesia not to regulate these things to ensure maximum returns from God’s gifts.
Yet, perhaps more interesting is the Consideration that characterizes the ability to travel and enjoy one’s time as a tourist as a basic human right. This is clearly not the case and definitely not true in the Indonesian context. A tourist is certainly not free to travel wherever and whenever they want in Indonesia. If one wants to travel to provinces such as Papua and Aceh or even parts of the Mollucas then travel is generally required to be notified in advance and approved. That said, travel is definitely freer in Indonesia than it has been in times past.
However, what is true beyond a reasonable doubt is that tourism and the income it conceivably can generate for the State coffers is an integral part of the national development of Indonesia over the short, medium, and long terms. For tourism to be an integral part of the national development program there is a clear need for policies in this area to be systematic, planned, integrated, ongoing, and responsible.
The government is convinced that a functioning and effective tourism sector will provide ongoing social and community benefits by providing increased opportunities and prosperity for those directly involved in the sector and a trickle-down effect will ensure that the prosperity is spread around and throughout the broader Indonesian community.
It is certainly true that the tourism sector in Indonesia has been challenged over the past seven years or so with a number of bombings targeting tourist areas and the tourists themselves. So, it is hoped that the new Law will provide a framework that will allow the sector and the industry to grow and continue to provide not only revenue to the State but also livelihoods for a great many Indonesians.
This ILD will examine and analyze some of the key features of the new Tourism Law.
Objects and Purposes
The basis for the tourism law sets out what the content of the succeeding articles and provisions will be with respect to what the law expects to achieve. The basic premises of the law include: benefits, fairness, balance, autonomy, participation, continuity, democracy, and equality, among others. The function of tourism is to fulfill the mind, body, and intellectual needs of tourists while at the same time increasing revenue into State coffers with a view to realizing community welfare.
The purposes of the law are to increase economic growth and the prosperity of the community at large. Interestingly, the law sees tourism as a means of eliminating poverty and overcoming unemployment. Both of these will require significant and fundamental changes to the policy platform if they are to be achieved and sustained. The creation of a conducive tourism climate, particularly as it relates to poverty and unemployment, will require on the part of the government some novel and creative approaches to policy as it seeks to exploit a wealth of natural and cultural resources at its disposal.
The Development of Tourism
To develop a viable and sustainable tourism sector it is clear that the government is going to need to be able to successfully exploit the diversity, uniqueness, and special characteristics of the cultural and natural resources present in Indonesia.
Therefore, development is to focus on four main areas:
1.
Tourism industry;
2.
Tourist destinations;
3.
Marketing; and
4.
Tourism institutions and agencies.
Each of these is then further enumerated in the law. However, it is worth noting that each of these areas is potentially, at least, an excellent opportunity for Indonesians and Indonesian-based companies to make considerable strides in terms of providing a sizeable contribution to national development and fulfilling the stated objectives and purposes of the law.
The law envisages a master plan will be developed that is designed to address tourism issues on both national and local levels. The tourism master plan is to be incorporated into the long-term national development plan and is to form an integral part of that plan. This in turn will require three levels of legislation to be drafted and enacted, specifically: Government Regulations on the national level, Regional Regulations on the provincial level, and District and City Regulation at the district and city levels. The master plan is to address the four issues note above.
Further, the master plan is to set out capital investment matters for tourism based initiatives. The Law envisages that this capital investment will be both domestic and foreign. To ensure that the master plan is implemented as it is intended gives rise to an obligation on the government and other associated agencies to study tourism development and drive greater success in the sector. Presumably, these studies will be undertaken through existing government services and agencies.
Strategic Zones
The development of strategic tourism zones is a creative and novel mechanism to ensure that tourism initiatives and income are spread throughout the archipelago. It is clearly the case that at present there are a limited number of areas that domestic and foreign tourists are familiar with. There is a classic story that has done the rounds over many years about an Indonesian traveling abroad and asking a local of that country whether they had been to Indonesia, to which the local responds, “No, but I have been to Bali!”
The moral of this story is two-fold; there are definitely marketing and promotion opportunities available in terms of highlighting the fact that Bali is part of Indonesia, but it is also an opportunity to broaden the destinations available for tourists. Simply, Indonesia is so much more than just Bali.
Indonesia saw some 6.4 million tourists arrive on its shores through 2008. This is short of the projected 7 million that were expected. Nevertheless, it must be pointed out that the number is a significant increase over the 5.5 million who made the journey in 2007. The 6.4 million tourists in 2008 pumped some USD 7.5 billion into the Indonesian economy.
When one considers the amount of money being spent by tourists when they visit Indonesia it becomes abundantly clear that there is an immediate need to develop strategic zones on two levels; to keep tourists here longer and to attract specific tourists to certain destinations.
Tourism Businesses
The new law sets out what types of tourism business are permissible. However, the list is not exhaustive and the Minister has the power to add to the approved list by issuing a Ministerial Regulation.
In order to exercise greater control over the sector, a tourism business must register the business prior to operations commencing with the relevant government authority at either the national or local level.
This will afford the government the opportunity of expanding and developing micro, small, and medium tourism businesses, as well as cooperatives. Generally, it is expected that the government will fulfill this objective through the facilitation of partnerships between these smaller business models and established large-scale tourism businesses.
Indonesian Tourism Promotion Board
The government is to facilitate the establishment of the Indonesian Tourism Promotion Board. This Board is to be located in Jakarta. The Board is to be a private agency and independent and will be established through Presidential Decree.
The Board is to have two components, namely: develop policy and implementation. The Board is to comprise of nine individuals. These individuals will come from four groups: tourism associations, profession, airline associations, and experts / academics.
The roles and functions of the Board are enumerated in the succeeding articles.
The Board is to be established within two years of the law being enacted.
Indonesian Tourism Industry Group
The Indonesian Tourism Industry Group is the peak body that is to be established in order to promote competition and expansion of the tourism sector. The members of the Group will come from tourism businesses, tourism associations, professional associations, and any other association that is directly related to the tourism sector.
This Group is to be established within two years of the law being enacted.
Training, Standardization, Certification, and Labor
The training provisions in this law merely state that the government, central and regional, is responsible for training of human resources in accordance with prevailing legislation in the sector.
The standardization and certification provisions are somewhat more comprehensive. Nevertheless, the provisions within articles 53 and 54 are expected to generate considerable numbers of Government Regulations in order to give effect to the provisions.
Foreign Expertise
In an almost throw-away article the law provides for foreign expertise to be engaged based on prevailing provisions in other legislation. However, any foreign expertise required must be engaged only after a recommendation from a tourism professional association.
Generally, it is expected that this expertise would only be required in circumstances where Indonesia is unable to furnish the expertise from within.
Administrative Sanctions
The standard administrative sanctions apply for breach of the provisions, including: written warnings, restrictions on business activities, and the temporary suspension of business activities.
Criminal Sanctions
The criminal sanctions relate to the intentional and negligent destruction or damage to tourist sites. The intentional destruction gives rise to a maximum sentence of seven years imprisonment and fines of up to IDR 10 billion. The negligent destruction or damage gives rise to a maximum prison sentence of 1 year and fines of up to IDR 5 billion.
Implementing Regulations
All of the implementing regulations required under the law in order to give effect to the provisions of the law are required to be issued within two years of the enactment of the law.
Enactment
The law came into force on 16 January 2009.
Conclusion
It is clear that in 2009 Indonesia needed a new law on tourism in order to face the new challenges that have arisen since the previous law had been enacted in 1990. The new law on tourism sets out not only what tourism is and what it means to the future national development of Indonesia, the law also establishes a tourism promotion board and a tourism group, both of which are tasked with providing significant and substantial inputs on the expansion and development of Indonesian tourism.
The law, although not directly stating so, will provide significant opportunities to Indonesians, both at the business level and the individual level, to grow and expand professionally and financially.
The law recognizes the potential that Indonesia holds with respect to tourism. Nevertheless, the success or lack thereof in this law will be the commitment that the government has towards ensuring implementation of the provisions. This means that the government can no longer just pay lip service to the ideal that tourism is an important part of the national development jigsaw puzzle, but must actively engage the sector and challenge the sector to develop and expand in an environment of government support.
Finally, the proof of the tourism pudding is not in the just the implementation but in the numbers, and only time will tell on this front whether the new law has been successful.
The potential for tourism in Indonesia is huge seems to be somewhat of an understatement when one considers that this is a land with a rich and diverse cultural and religious history spread out over more than 17,000 tropical islands hugging the equator. The opportunities on the tourism front would appear to only be limited by one’s imagination and desire to explore this archipelagic paradise.
The government, to its credit, attempted to exploit this with a campaign directly targeting an increase in tourist numbers. The “Visit Indonesia 2008” campaign has seeming transited to become the “Visit Indonesia 2009” campaign if the Department’s website is accurate.
A law to regulate Indonesian tourism is not a new phenomenon. The previous regulatory framework contained in Law No. 9 of 1990 was clearly no longer appropriate to regulate the needs of the tourist industry in 2009. Therefore, rather than a series of amendments to an unworkable law the government embarked on a process of drafting, debating, passing, and enacting a new law, Law No. 10 of 2009, which would repeal and replace the previous incarnation of the law in this sector.
The Considerations that premise Indonesian laws generally set out the “big picture” elements justifying the need to enact a particular law. The Tourism Law is no different in this regard. The Considerations start with the fact that Indonesia has been blessed by almighty God as it has been populated with diverse flora and fauna, as well as extraordinary antiquities, history, art and culture. In light of this Consideration alone it would be remiss of the government and Indonesia not to regulate these things to ensure maximum returns from God’s gifts.
Yet, perhaps more interesting is the Consideration that characterizes the ability to travel and enjoy one’s time as a tourist as a basic human right. This is clearly not the case and definitely not true in the Indonesian context. A tourist is certainly not free to travel wherever and whenever they want in Indonesia. If one wants to travel to provinces such as Papua and Aceh or even parts of the Mollucas then travel is generally required to be notified in advance and approved. That said, travel is definitely freer in Indonesia than it has been in times past.
However, what is true beyond a reasonable doubt is that tourism and the income it conceivably can generate for the State coffers is an integral part of the national development of Indonesia over the short, medium, and long terms. For tourism to be an integral part of the national development program there is a clear need for policies in this area to be systematic, planned, integrated, ongoing, and responsible.
The government is convinced that a functioning and effective tourism sector will provide ongoing social and community benefits by providing increased opportunities and prosperity for those directly involved in the sector and a trickle-down effect will ensure that the prosperity is spread around and throughout the broader Indonesian community.
It is certainly true that the tourism sector in Indonesia has been challenged over the past seven years or so with a number of bombings targeting tourist areas and the tourists themselves. So, it is hoped that the new Law will provide a framework that will allow the sector and the industry to grow and continue to provide not only revenue to the State but also livelihoods for a great many Indonesians.
This ILD will examine and analyze some of the key features of the new Tourism Law.
Objects and Purposes
The basis for the tourism law sets out what the content of the succeeding articles and provisions will be with respect to what the law expects to achieve. The basic premises of the law include: benefits, fairness, balance, autonomy, participation, continuity, democracy, and equality, among others. The function of tourism is to fulfill the mind, body, and intellectual needs of tourists while at the same time increasing revenue into State coffers with a view to realizing community welfare.
The purposes of the law are to increase economic growth and the prosperity of the community at large. Interestingly, the law sees tourism as a means of eliminating poverty and overcoming unemployment. Both of these will require significant and fundamental changes to the policy platform if they are to be achieved and sustained. The creation of a conducive tourism climate, particularly as it relates to poverty and unemployment, will require on the part of the government some novel and creative approaches to policy as it seeks to exploit a wealth of natural and cultural resources at its disposal.
The Development of Tourism
To develop a viable and sustainable tourism sector it is clear that the government is going to need to be able to successfully exploit the diversity, uniqueness, and special characteristics of the cultural and natural resources present in Indonesia.
Therefore, development is to focus on four main areas:
1.
Tourism industry;
2.
Tourist destinations;
3.
Marketing; and
4.
Tourism institutions and agencies.
Each of these is then further enumerated in the law. However, it is worth noting that each of these areas is potentially, at least, an excellent opportunity for Indonesians and Indonesian-based companies to make considerable strides in terms of providing a sizeable contribution to national development and fulfilling the stated objectives and purposes of the law.
The law envisages a master plan will be developed that is designed to address tourism issues on both national and local levels. The tourism master plan is to be incorporated into the long-term national development plan and is to form an integral part of that plan. This in turn will require three levels of legislation to be drafted and enacted, specifically: Government Regulations on the national level, Regional Regulations on the provincial level, and District and City Regulation at the district and city levels. The master plan is to address the four issues note above.
Further, the master plan is to set out capital investment matters for tourism based initiatives. The Law envisages that this capital investment will be both domestic and foreign. To ensure that the master plan is implemented as it is intended gives rise to an obligation on the government and other associated agencies to study tourism development and drive greater success in the sector. Presumably, these studies will be undertaken through existing government services and agencies.
Strategic Zones
The development of strategic tourism zones is a creative and novel mechanism to ensure that tourism initiatives and income are spread throughout the archipelago. It is clearly the case that at present there are a limited number of areas that domestic and foreign tourists are familiar with. There is a classic story that has done the rounds over many years about an Indonesian traveling abroad and asking a local of that country whether they had been to Indonesia, to which the local responds, “No, but I have been to Bali!”
The moral of this story is two-fold; there are definitely marketing and promotion opportunities available in terms of highlighting the fact that Bali is part of Indonesia, but it is also an opportunity to broaden the destinations available for tourists. Simply, Indonesia is so much more than just Bali.
Indonesia saw some 6.4 million tourists arrive on its shores through 2008. This is short of the projected 7 million that were expected. Nevertheless, it must be pointed out that the number is a significant increase over the 5.5 million who made the journey in 2007. The 6.4 million tourists in 2008 pumped some USD 7.5 billion into the Indonesian economy.
When one considers the amount of money being spent by tourists when they visit Indonesia it becomes abundantly clear that there is an immediate need to develop strategic zones on two levels; to keep tourists here longer and to attract specific tourists to certain destinations.
Tourism Businesses
The new law sets out what types of tourism business are permissible. However, the list is not exhaustive and the Minister has the power to add to the approved list by issuing a Ministerial Regulation.
In order to exercise greater control over the sector, a tourism business must register the business prior to operations commencing with the relevant government authority at either the national or local level.
This will afford the government the opportunity of expanding and developing micro, small, and medium tourism businesses, as well as cooperatives. Generally, it is expected that the government will fulfill this objective through the facilitation of partnerships between these smaller business models and established large-scale tourism businesses.
Indonesian Tourism Promotion Board
The government is to facilitate the establishment of the Indonesian Tourism Promotion Board. This Board is to be located in Jakarta. The Board is to be a private agency and independent and will be established through Presidential Decree.
The Board is to have two components, namely: develop policy and implementation. The Board is to comprise of nine individuals. These individuals will come from four groups: tourism associations, profession, airline associations, and experts / academics.
The roles and functions of the Board are enumerated in the succeeding articles.
The Board is to be established within two years of the law being enacted.
Indonesian Tourism Industry Group
The Indonesian Tourism Industry Group is the peak body that is to be established in order to promote competition and expansion of the tourism sector. The members of the Group will come from tourism businesses, tourism associations, professional associations, and any other association that is directly related to the tourism sector.
This Group is to be established within two years of the law being enacted.
Training, Standardization, Certification, and Labor
The training provisions in this law merely state that the government, central and regional, is responsible for training of human resources in accordance with prevailing legislation in the sector.
The standardization and certification provisions are somewhat more comprehensive. Nevertheless, the provisions within articles 53 and 54 are expected to generate considerable numbers of Government Regulations in order to give effect to the provisions.
Foreign Expertise
In an almost throw-away article the law provides for foreign expertise to be engaged based on prevailing provisions in other legislation. However, any foreign expertise required must be engaged only after a recommendation from a tourism professional association.
Generally, it is expected that this expertise would only be required in circumstances where Indonesia is unable to furnish the expertise from within.
Administrative Sanctions
The standard administrative sanctions apply for breach of the provisions, including: written warnings, restrictions on business activities, and the temporary suspension of business activities.
Criminal Sanctions
The criminal sanctions relate to the intentional and negligent destruction or damage to tourist sites. The intentional destruction gives rise to a maximum sentence of seven years imprisonment and fines of up to IDR 10 billion. The negligent destruction or damage gives rise to a maximum prison sentence of 1 year and fines of up to IDR 5 billion.
Implementing Regulations
All of the implementing regulations required under the law in order to give effect to the provisions of the law are required to be issued within two years of the enactment of the law.
Enactment
The law came into force on 16 January 2009.
Conclusion
It is clear that in 2009 Indonesia needed a new law on tourism in order to face the new challenges that have arisen since the previous law had been enacted in 1990. The new law on tourism sets out not only what tourism is and what it means to the future national development of Indonesia, the law also establishes a tourism promotion board and a tourism group, both of which are tasked with providing significant and substantial inputs on the expansion and development of Indonesian tourism.
The law, although not directly stating so, will provide significant opportunities to Indonesians, both at the business level and the individual level, to grow and expand professionally and financially.
The law recognizes the potential that Indonesia holds with respect to tourism. Nevertheless, the success or lack thereof in this law will be the commitment that the government has towards ensuring implementation of the provisions. This means that the government can no longer just pay lip service to the ideal that tourism is an important part of the national development jigsaw puzzle, but must actively engage the sector and challenge the sector to develop and expand in an environment of government support.
Finally, the proof of the tourism pudding is not in the just the implementation but in the numbers, and only time will tell on this front whether the new law has been successful.