Social Welfare

Overview

 

There is no doubt that there was a need to revisit the provisions of the previous social welfare law (Law No. 6 of 1974) and perfect them to reflect the standards and developments in social welfare. The government’s role in the provision of social welfare is mandated in the 1945 Constitution and within the five principles of Pancasila, in essence this role is protect all the sons and daughters of the Motherland whilst advancing the social welfare of all within the framework of independence, peace, and social justice.

 

Despite the best efforts of the previous incarnation of the social welfare law, it failed to meet the expectations of the nation. Simply, there are still Indonesians living in situations and circumstances that hardly are indicative of a suitable or appropriate standard of living where they are able to meet the most basic of the social welfare needs. And it is in this sense that the previous law needed to be perfected as a means of ensuring that all Indonesians, irrespective of their lot in life, are able to live lives that are as they should be and dignified.

 

It is worth noting at this point that the new Law is not without its critics and detractors. Primary among these is the Indonesian Community Anti-Poverty Group (Gabungan Anti Pemiskinan Rakyat Indonesia / GAPRI). According to GAPRI the new Law reflects the lack of understanding that the House of Representatives (DPR) has regarding issues of poverty.

 

Nevertheless, it seems that the main concerns that GAPRI has with the new Law relate to the number of implementing regulations that are required in order for the new Law to be effective and that the new Law over-regulates the social welfare sector and thereby decreases the sector’s effectiveness. And, it is for these reasons that GAPRI considers the new Law to in fact be a step backwards in social welfare rather than a bold step forward into the future.

 

The legal foundation for the government’s role is Article 34(1) of the 1945 Constitution which explicitly mandates that the government provide for the poor and neglected children through the provision of such services as social rehabilitation, social welfare and guarantees, social empowerment, and social protection in order that the have nots and the unables can still live decent lives.

 

However, the new law does not envisage that this is an exclusively government responsibility, to the contrary, the new law envisages that there is to be a wide-ranging role for the community (individuals and families), religious organizations, social organizations, non-government organizations, professional organizations, companies, and social welfare agencies (national and international). All of these are seen to be part of an ongoing and integrated initiative to ensure that the Constitutional mandate is met.

 

To this end the new law endeavors to establish what the basic rights and necessities of life are and ensure that these are met in a comprehensive and professional manner. The new law is also expected to reduce and eliminate the misuse and abuse of authority through the strict regulation of licensing procedures and enhanced power for imposing sanctions on those that breach the provisions of the new law.

 

This ILD will examine and analyze some of the key features of the new law and their likely impact on social welfare in Indonesia.

What is Social Welfare?

Social welfare in most circumstances and situations relates primarily to the ability to satisfy one’s basic material needs. However, in this Law, social welfare also contains an element of the spiritual that allows for self-development and ultimately for the individual to make a contribution to the broader community.

 

There are two basic components of social welfare, namely: social empowerment and social security. This is simply the concept of teaching a person how to fish and giving them a fish. Social empowerment is envisaged as being a mechanism of teaching the individual to fish. In this sense, providing the necessary tools to individuals to allow them to provide for themselves and satisfy their own social welfare needs. The social security scheme is one in which the basic needs of all citizens are able to satisfy their basic needs. This is to be done through the establishment of agencies that are tasked with fulfilling those needs.

 

The Bases and Objectives

The basis of the Law is straightforward and as such includes many standard features that may be found in other laws. These include:

 

·                     Justice / fairness

·         Benefit

·                     Integrated

·         Accountability

·                     Partnership

·         Participation

·                     Openness

·         Professionalism

·                     Continuing

·         Solidarity

 

The objectives are equally straightforward and address the basic failings of the previous regime. The Law is designed to provide a regulatory framework that allows for increases in the level and quality of social welfare provided. A critical component of the social welfare law is the need to develop a system that rehabilitates the social functions with a view to becoming autonomous.

 

Furthermore, it is expected that the provisions of the Law will strengthen social defenses within the community enabling the prevention and handling of problems that arise related to issues of social welfare. Interestingly, it is foreseen that the Law will create a community that cares and is responsible on a wide-ranging scale for matters of social welfare. Nevertheless, this seems to be dependent on a significant increase in the skills and abilities of social welfare providers and a simultaneous increase in how much people care about matters of social welfare.

 

Finally, the vision for better social welfare in Indonesia realizes that there is an urgent need to address the human resource skills issue, particularly at the management level. At an anecdotal level there appears to be little shortage of people willing to help in terms of assisting those that have not to achieve their basic material needs. Although, it is fair to say that this is still not enough. Yet, where funds are made available for social welfare programs there has always been a concern about the proper and transparent use of those funds in order that they reach the most needy. The Law clearly pictures a scenario of highly skilled and trained managers administering social welfare programs in the future.

 

Who is Targeted to Receive Social Welfare?

It is clear that not everyone is in need of social welfare and as such it is not surprising that there are restrictions on who is to benefit from the programs that the new Law envisions. The primary targets of social welfare are:

 

·         The poor

·         The neglected

·         The physically challenged (disabled)

·         Those who are remote (from facilities and services)

·         The socially defective

·         Those with deviant behaviors

·         Victims of disaster

·         Victims of violence, exploitation, and discrimination

 

The above will be able to enjoy the benefits of four basic programs that are encompassed under the following thematic areas: social rehabilitation, social security, social empowerment, and social protection.

 

Each of the thematic areas is further enumerated in the new Law.

 

Social Rehabilitation

Social rehabilitation is about getting people back into the community as functioning and contributing members. The social rehabilitation can be undertaken in a number of ways: persuasive, motivation, or coercive. The primary forms of social rehabilitation will focus on matters such as psycho-social motivations and diagnosis, treatment and care, vocational training, spiritual guidance, and re-socialization for re-entry to the community at large.

 

Social Security

The provision of social security payments is a very socialist democratic ideal that mandates wealth distribution among the haves and have nots. For the government to legislate responsibility to itself to make payments to those who are categorized as have nots is noble, but simultaneously puts added pressure on the government to balance budgets and to find revenue.

 

Most countries with social security systems that are facilitated and paid for by the government also have effective and efficient tax systems. Successive Indonesian governments have been poor tax collectors. It is generally an effective taxation system that is used as the primary means of facilitating the redistribution of wealth.

 

Social Empowerment

The focus of social empowerment is expressly the improvement of opportunity and increasing one’s skills and abilities. This may be simply training programs to develop old skills or learn new ones. Social empowerment also includes the provision of start-up capital or business tools or the facilitation of a place of business in order that the individual can eventually and ultimately provide for themselves and perhaps make a continuing contribution to their local community in the process.

 

Social empowerment is clearly not only a government responsibility and the relevant provisions envisage partnerships. These partnerships could conceivably encompass corporate social responsibility.

 

Social Protection

There are three basic areas of social protection under the new Law: social assistance, social advocacy, and legal aid.

 

Government Responsibility – Central and Regional

The responsibilities of the Central and Regional governments are set out in Articles 24 through 31. As would be expected, the Central government maintains overall authority with respect to stipulating national policies regarding social welfare and allocating funds to ensure the implementation of the requisite programs. The Central government’s role also includes licensing and supervision.

 

The regional governments obviously have regional specific authorities and powers such as the allocation of budget funds and interestingly enough the maintenance of national hero gravesites.

 

Resources

The new Law categorizes resources into three broad categories: human, infrastructure and equipment, and funds.

 

The new Law mandates that the human resources that work in the social welfare sector must meet certain basic qualifications and skill requirements. Presumably, as it is not explicitly stated, human resources in the sector would need some kind of certification in order to verify their skills. It is expected that accreditation of, at the very least, professional social welfare workers will be enhanced.

 

Registration and Licensing of Social Welfare Agencies

In order to assert some control over the provision of basic social welfare the government requires that all social welfare agencies be registered and licensed. The provisions in this section of the new Law are scant and it is expected that this is one particular area that is going to require extensive implementing regulations to be effective.

 

Sanctions

Strangely, the new Law does not include a separate and specific set of Articles outlining and describing the sanctioning provisions. The sanctioning provisions are tacked on to the registration and licensing section and merely state that the following administrative sanctions are applicable: written warnings, temporary suspensions, cancelation of licenses, and / or administrative fines.

 

This is not a standard means of regulating sanctions in primary legislation such as laws.

 

Accreditation and Certification

All agencies operating in the social welfare sector are to be accredited and certified. It is expected that this will ensure that there are minimum standards in operation throughout the sector.

 

Once again, this is another part of the new Law that will rely heavily on implementing regulations in order to be effective.

 

Enactment

The new Law has been in force since 16 January 2009. The new Law repeals and replaces Law No. 6 of 1974. All implementing regulations that are required to be enacted under the provisions of this Law must be so enacted within one year of the Law coming into force.

 

All implementing regulations issued under the provisions of Law No. 6 of 1974 remain in force so long as they are not contrary to the provisions of the new Law. Any inconsistency will see the new Law prevail.

 

Conclusion

 

It is clear that there is a need for a new law in the social welfare sector. The attempt by the government to provide a new legal framework has been an honorable one. Nevertheless, the new Law is not without its critics, many of whom consider the new Law to be a step backwards and not forwards.

 

The new Law provides a clear framework for the social welfare sector and as such provides potentially greater control of the provision of social welfare to those most desperately in need for and of it. The Law will also require standardization through the implementation of accreditation and certification procedures sector-wide. This will be of most benefit to those who are in most need of social welfare services.

 

The new Law may not be perfect but its drafters have certainly striven to point the provision of social welfare services into the future in the best way possible.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku

Overview

 

There is no doubt that there was a need to revisit the provisions of the previous social welfare law (Law No. 6 of 1974) and perfect them to reflect the standards and developments in social welfare. The government’s role in the provision of social welfare is mandated in the 1945 Constitution and within the five principles of Pancasila, in essence this role is protect all the sons and daughters of the Motherland whilst advancing the social welfare of all within the framework of independence, peace, and social justice.

 

Despite the best efforts of the previous incarnation of the social welfare law, it failed to meet the expectations of the nation. Simply, there are still Indonesians living in situations and circumstances that hardly are indicative of a suitable or appropriate standard of living where they are able to meet the most basic of the social welfare needs. And it is in this sense that the previous law needed to be perfected as a means of ensuring that all Indonesians, irrespective of their lot in life, are able to live lives that are as they should be and dignified.

 

It is worth noting at this point that the new Law is not without its critics and detractors. Primary among these is the Indonesian Community Anti-Poverty Group (Gabungan Anti Pemiskinan Rakyat Indonesia / GAPRI). According to GAPRI the new Law reflects the lack of understanding that the House of Representatives (DPR) has regarding issues of poverty.

 

Nevertheless, it seems that the main concerns that GAPRI has with the new Law relate to the number of implementing regulations that are required in order for the new Law to be effective and that the new Law over-regulates the social welfare sector and thereby decreases the sector’s effectiveness. And, it is for these reasons that GAPRI considers the new Law to in fact be a step backwards in social welfare rather than a bold step forward into the future.

 

The legal foundation for the government’s role is Article 34(1) of the 1945 Constitution which explicitly mandates that the government provide for the poor and neglected children through the provision of such services as social rehabilitation, social welfare and guarantees, social empowerment, and social protection in order that the have nots and the unables can still live decent lives.

 

However, the new law does not envisage that this is an exclusively government responsibility, to the contrary, the new law envisages that there is to be a wide-ranging role for the community (individuals and families), religious organizations, social organizations, non-government organizations, professional organizations, companies, and social welfare agencies (national and international). All of these are seen to be part of an ongoing and integrated initiative to ensure that the Constitutional mandate is met.

 

To this end the new law endeavors to establish what the basic rights and necessities of life are and ensure that these are met in a comprehensive and professional manner. The new law is also expected to reduce and eliminate the misuse and abuse of authority through the strict regulation of licensing procedures and enhanced power for imposing sanctions on those that breach the provisions of the new law.

 

This ILD will examine and analyze some of the key features of the new law and their likely impact on social welfare in Indonesia.

What is Social Welfare?

Social welfare in most circumstances and situations relates primarily to the ability to satisfy one’s basic material needs. However, in this Law, social welfare also contains an element of the spiritual that allows for self-development and ultimately for the individual to make a contribution to the broader community.

 

There are two basic components of social welfare, namely: social empowerment and social security. This is simply the concept of teaching a person how to fish and giving them a fish. Social empowerment is envisaged as being a mechanism of teaching the individual to fish. In this sense, providing the necessary tools to individuals to allow them to provide for themselves and satisfy their own social welfare needs. The social security scheme is one in which the basic needs of all citizens are able to satisfy their basic needs. This is to be done through the establishment of agencies that are tasked with fulfilling those needs.

 

The Bases and Objectives

The basis of the Law is straightforward and as such includes many standard features that may be found in other laws. These include:

 

·                     Justice / fairness

·         Benefit

·                     Integrated

·         Accountability

·                     Partnership

·         Participation

·                     Openness

·         Professionalism

·                     Continuing

·         Solidarity

 

The objectives are equally straightforward and address the basic failings of the previous regime. The Law is designed to provide a regulatory framework that allows for increases in the level and quality of social welfare provided. A critical component of the social welfare law is the need to develop a system that rehabilitates the social functions with a view to becoming autonomous.

 

Furthermore, it is expected that the provisions of the Law will strengthen social defenses within the community enabling the prevention and handling of problems that arise related to issues of social welfare. Interestingly, it is foreseen that the Law will create a community that cares and is responsible on a wide-ranging scale for matters of social welfare. Nevertheless, this seems to be dependent on a significant increase in the skills and abilities of social welfare providers and a simultaneous increase in how much people care about matters of social welfare.

 

Finally, the vision for better social welfare in Indonesia realizes that there is an urgent need to address the human resource skills issue, particularly at the management level. At an anecdotal level there appears to be little shortage of people willing to help in terms of assisting those that have not to achieve their basic material needs. Although, it is fair to say that this is still not enough. Yet, where funds are made available for social welfare programs there has always been a concern about the proper and transparent use of those funds in order that they reach the most needy. The Law clearly pictures a scenario of highly skilled and trained managers administering social welfare programs in the future.

 

Who is Targeted to Receive Social Welfare?

It is clear that not everyone is in need of social welfare and as such it is not surprising that there are restrictions on who is to benefit from the programs that the new Law envisions. The primary targets of social welfare are:

 

·         The poor

·         The neglected

·         The physically challenged (disabled)

·         Those who are remote (from facilities and services)

·         The socially defective

·         Those with deviant behaviors

·         Victims of disaster

·         Victims of violence, exploitation, and discrimination

 

The above will be able to enjoy the benefits of four basic programs that are encompassed under the following thematic areas: social rehabilitation, social security, social empowerment, and social protection.

 

Each of the thematic areas is further enumerated in the new Law.

 

Social Rehabilitation

Social rehabilitation is about getting people back into the community as functioning and contributing members. The social rehabilitation can be undertaken in a number of ways: persuasive, motivation, or coercive. The primary forms of social rehabilitation will focus on matters such as psycho-social motivations and diagnosis, treatment and care, vocational training, spiritual guidance, and re-socialization for re-entry to the community at large.

 

Social Security

The provision of social security payments is a very socialist democratic ideal that mandates wealth distribution among the haves and have nots. For the government to legislate responsibility to itself to make payments to those who are categorized as have nots is noble, but simultaneously puts added pressure on the government to balance budgets and to find revenue.

 

Most countries with social security systems that are facilitated and paid for by the government also have effective and efficient tax systems. Successive Indonesian governments have been poor tax collectors. It is generally an effective taxation system that is used as the primary means of facilitating the redistribution of wealth.

 

Social Empowerment

The focus of social empowerment is expressly the improvement of opportunity and increasing one’s skills and abilities. This may be simply training programs to develop old skills or learn new ones. Social empowerment also includes the provision of start-up capital or business tools or the facilitation of a place of business in order that the individual can eventually and ultimately provide for themselves and perhaps make a continuing contribution to their local community in the process.

 

Social empowerment is clearly not only a government responsibility and the relevant provisions envisage partnerships. These partnerships could conceivably encompass corporate social responsibility.

 

Social Protection

There are three basic areas of social protection under the new Law: social assistance, social advocacy, and legal aid.

 

Government Responsibility – Central and Regional

The responsibilities of the Central and Regional governments are set out in Articles 24 through 31. As would be expected, the Central government maintains overall authority with respect to stipulating national policies regarding social welfare and allocating funds to ensure the implementation of the requisite programs. The Central government’s role also includes licensing and supervision.

 

The regional governments obviously have regional specific authorities and powers such as the allocation of budget funds and interestingly enough the maintenance of national hero gravesites.

 

Resources

The new Law categorizes resources into three broad categories: human, infrastructure and equipment, and funds.

 

The new Law mandates that the human resources that work in the social welfare sector must meet certain basic qualifications and skill requirements. Presumably, as it is not explicitly stated, human resources in the sector would need some kind of certification in order to verify their skills. It is expected that accreditation of, at the very least, professional social welfare workers will be enhanced.

 

Registration and Licensing of Social Welfare Agencies

In order to assert some control over the provision of basic social welfare the government requires that all social welfare agencies be registered and licensed. The provisions in this section of the new Law are scant and it is expected that this is one particular area that is going to require extensive implementing regulations to be effective.

 

Sanctions

Strangely, the new Law does not include a separate and specific set of Articles outlining and describing the sanctioning provisions. The sanctioning provisions are tacked on to the registration and licensing section and merely state that the following administrative sanctions are applicable: written warnings, temporary suspensions, cancelation of licenses, and / or administrative fines.

 

This is not a standard means of regulating sanctions in primary legislation such as laws.

 

Accreditation and Certification

All agencies operating in the social welfare sector are to be accredited and certified. It is expected that this will ensure that there are minimum standards in operation throughout the sector.

 

Once again, this is another part of the new Law that will rely heavily on implementing regulations in order to be effective.

 

Enactment

The new Law has been in force since 16 January 2009. The new Law repeals and replaces Law No. 6 of 1974. All implementing regulations that are required to be enacted under the provisions of this Law must be so enacted within one year of the Law coming into force.

 

All implementing regulations issued under the provisions of Law No. 6 of 1974 remain in force so long as they are not contrary to the provisions of the new Law. Any inconsistency will see the new Law prevail.

 

Conclusion

 

It is clear that there is a need for a new law in the social welfare sector. The attempt by the government to provide a new legal framework has been an honorable one. Nevertheless, the new Law is not without its critics, many of whom consider the new Law to be a step backwards and not forwards.

 

The new Law provides a clear framework for the social welfare sector and as such provides potentially greater control of the provision of social welfare to those most desperately in need for and of it. The Law will also require standardization through the implementation of accreditation and certification procedures sector-wide. This will be of most benefit to those who are in most need of social welfare services.

 

The new Law may not be perfect but its drafters have certainly striven to point the provision of social welfare services into the future in the best way possible.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku
2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info