The end of 2008 had been a particularly busy one for the House of Representatives (DPR) as it managed to pass a raft of legislation, including the Bill on Aviation. There was no doubt that there was a need for a new law in this sector. If for no other reason that providing the perception that the government was being pro-active in regulating a sector which has been notorious for its lack of safety, oversight, and accountability. The safety concerns have been more prevalent in the public eye when one considers the sheer number of air accidents that have occurred in Indonesia over the recent past and the decision by European nations to ban Indonesian aircraft from flying into Europe.
Furthermore, in line with the thought of seeing to be doing is half the battle, it is of very little surprise that the new law would attempt to be as comprehensive as possible and cover anything and everything remotely related to aviation and the management of aviation in Indonesian skies. To this end the new law has 24 Chapters, 466 Articles, and runs to 195 pages. A good measure of the comprehensive nature of the new law, aside from its volume, is that while it was still just a bill it had been subject to some 55 meetings to discuss the substantive content of the bill and to thrash out the issues.
The bill requires implementing legislation to be passed in five key areas, namely: airports, flight navigation, aircraft, air transport, and flight safety. This implementing legislation has already been drafted and is in the form of government and ministerial regulations. This is a standard feature of Indonesian legislation in that the law generally sets out a basic framework for regulation of the sector and subsidiary legislation is then enacted to provide the necessary detail to allow the more general provisions of the law to be implemented and enforced.
Some of the key features of the new law are that it establishes a National Committee on Aviation Safety, an Aviation Profession Council, and Public Service Agency. Each of these has a specific function and those functions are enumerated in the law, as is the time frame for the establishment of the respective organizations. These are critical in terms of restoring confidence, both at home and abroad, in Indonesia’s aviation sector.
The other key feature of the new law is greater legal certainty with respect to protection of consumers.
This ILD will examine these two key features in detail.
A New Law
The basic premise for Law No. 1 of 2009 is that the previous law in this field, Law No. 15 of 1992, was no longer suitable for the purpose and objectives intended. Therefore, the government determined that a “perfection” of the previous law was necessary. The perfection has been drafted to reflect advances in knowledge and technology, changes to the strategic paradigm and environment such as regional autonomy, regional and global competition, business competition, enhanced roles for communities, international conventions, professional protection, and consumer protection.
Each of these is enumerated in greater detail in the new law. The consumer protection provisions, which will be analyzed in greater detail later, are interesting as they will demand that operators provide better services and at better value. This should drive significant improvements in good corporate governance if aviation companies are to remain competitive and in business.
The recent spate of aircraft accidents throughout Indonesia and the subsequent bans put in place by the European Union were not the spur to repeal the previous law and replace it with Law No. 1 of 2009. However, it is clear that both of these things provided some impetus to getting the bill into a form that could be passed by the DPR and enacted.
The positive reaction from European policy makers to the news that the bill had passed is testament to the need for a new law to have been drafted, passed, and subsequently enacted into law. The provisions of the new law are considered to satisfy the requirements of the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) and as a result Indonesia is hopeful that once the ICAO signs off on the provisions of the new law that there will no longer be any suspicion regarding Indonesian aviation safety practices and consequently all routes that have been closed to Indonesian carriers in the past will be re-opened.
National Committee on Aviation Safety
The National Committee on Aviation Safety is intended to alleviate the constant criticism that Indonesia has not taken aviation safety seriously enough in the past. The establishment of this Committee is designed to provide assurances to all that Indonesia is indeed serious and is capable of administering and managing aviation safety.
The Minister is responsible for establishing the Committee. The Committee’s basic functions and duties include:
-
The development of aviation safety regulations;
-
Setting aviation safety targets;
-
Addressing matters of aviation safety personnel;
-
Division of responsibilities for aviation safety;
-
Protection of airports, aircraft, and navigation facilities;
-
Handling of violations of the law;
-
Set up safety systems that are reflective of threats to aviation security; and
-
Supervision of aviation safety matters.
Consumer Protection
The largest part of the new aviation law can be considered as providing greater and enhanced legal protection to consumers. This is done in two simple ways; stipulating what the minimum requirements are and by increasing punishments for breaches of the provisions.
The first hint that there is increased consumer protection provisions in the new law can be seen in Article 1 (22) where it is stated that operators are responsible for any losses suffered by passengers or those sending cargo.
The obligations and responsibilities on operators are set out in considerable detail in Articles 140 through 186. Interestingly, the provisions provide that operators are responsible for providing compensation where flights are delayed. To avoid this responsibility an operator would need to be able to prove that the delay was a result of an issue outside of their control such as the weather or a technical problem.
The size of any compensation that is to be provided will be determined by the Minister and regulated through a Ministerial Regulation. For aircraft that are lost without a trace, the passengers on any such flight will be deemed to have perished on the flight if after three months from the expected time of landing they have not been found alive. This determination of death does not require a decision to be issued by the District Court. Once the three months have elapsed the right to claim compensation is activated.
Article 176 also provides that victims of a breach of the provisions have a right to take legal action at the District Court based on prevailing Indonesian laws and regulations.
Furthermore, Article 186 specifically prohibits operators from completely special agreements that voids operator responsibility or limits the amount of compensation payable in the event any compensation is due.
Passage and Enactment
The bill was passed on 17 December 2008 and enacted into law as Law No. 1 of 2009 on 12 January 2009.
Conclusion
It is expected that the new aviation law will serve to repair Indonesia’s reputation in the sector by reinforcing Indonesia’s commitment to best safety practices in aviation. The second expected positive is that consumers will be able to fly with the full knowledge that they have increased legal certainty and protection. Simply, passengers and cargo users are no longer at the whim of operators. Operators are required to meet certain basic standards in the provision of their services and to make reparations when they fail to provide those services at the basic level.
The new aviation law is a step in the right direction. It is expected that the requisite implementing regulations will be enacted in the near future and provide the necessary clarity required for full enforcement of the prevailing provisions.
The end of 2008 had been a particularly busy one for the House of Representatives (DPR) as it managed to pass a raft of legislation, including the Bill on Aviation. There was no doubt that there was a need for a new law in this sector. If for no other reason that providing the perception that the government was being pro-active in regulating a sector which has been notorious for its lack of safety, oversight, and accountability. The safety concerns have been more prevalent in the public eye when one considers the sheer number of air accidents that have occurred in Indonesia over the recent past and the decision by European nations to ban Indonesian aircraft from flying into Europe.
Furthermore, in line with the thought of seeing to be doing is half the battle, it is of very little surprise that the new law would attempt to be as comprehensive as possible and cover anything and everything remotely related to aviation and the management of aviation in Indonesian skies. To this end the new law has 24 Chapters, 466 Articles, and runs to 195 pages. A good measure of the comprehensive nature of the new law, aside from its volume, is that while it was still just a bill it had been subject to some 55 meetings to discuss the substantive content of the bill and to thrash out the issues.
The bill requires implementing legislation to be passed in five key areas, namely: airports, flight navigation, aircraft, air transport, and flight safety. This implementing legislation has already been drafted and is in the form of government and ministerial regulations. This is a standard feature of Indonesian legislation in that the law generally sets out a basic framework for regulation of the sector and subsidiary legislation is then enacted to provide the necessary detail to allow the more general provisions of the law to be implemented and enforced.
Some of the key features of the new law are that it establishes a National Committee on Aviation Safety, an Aviation Profession Council, and Public Service Agency. Each of these has a specific function and those functions are enumerated in the law, as is the time frame for the establishment of the respective organizations. These are critical in terms of restoring confidence, both at home and abroad, in Indonesia’s aviation sector.
The other key feature of the new law is greater legal certainty with respect to protection of consumers.
This ILD will examine these two key features in detail.
A New Law
The basic premise for Law No. 1 of 2009 is that the previous law in this field, Law No. 15 of 1992, was no longer suitable for the purpose and objectives intended. Therefore, the government determined that a “perfection” of the previous law was necessary. The perfection has been drafted to reflect advances in knowledge and technology, changes to the strategic paradigm and environment such as regional autonomy, regional and global competition, business competition, enhanced roles for communities, international conventions, professional protection, and consumer protection.
Each of these is enumerated in greater detail in the new law. The consumer protection provisions, which will be analyzed in greater detail later, are interesting as they will demand that operators provide better services and at better value. This should drive significant improvements in good corporate governance if aviation companies are to remain competitive and in business.
The recent spate of aircraft accidents throughout Indonesia and the subsequent bans put in place by the European Union were not the spur to repeal the previous law and replace it with Law No. 1 of 2009. However, it is clear that both of these things provided some impetus to getting the bill into a form that could be passed by the DPR and enacted.
The positive reaction from European policy makers to the news that the bill had passed is testament to the need for a new law to have been drafted, passed, and subsequently enacted into law. The provisions of the new law are considered to satisfy the requirements of the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) and as a result Indonesia is hopeful that once the ICAO signs off on the provisions of the new law that there will no longer be any suspicion regarding Indonesian aviation safety practices and consequently all routes that have been closed to Indonesian carriers in the past will be re-opened.
National Committee on Aviation Safety
The National Committee on Aviation Safety is intended to alleviate the constant criticism that Indonesia has not taken aviation safety seriously enough in the past. The establishment of this Committee is designed to provide assurances to all that Indonesia is indeed serious and is capable of administering and managing aviation safety.
The Minister is responsible for establishing the Committee. The Committee’s basic functions and duties include:
-
The development of aviation safety regulations;
-
Setting aviation safety targets;
-
Addressing matters of aviation safety personnel;
-
Division of responsibilities for aviation safety;
-
Protection of airports, aircraft, and navigation facilities;
-
Handling of violations of the law;
-
Set up safety systems that are reflective of threats to aviation security; and
-
Supervision of aviation safety matters.
Consumer Protection
The largest part of the new aviation law can be considered as providing greater and enhanced legal protection to consumers. This is done in two simple ways; stipulating what the minimum requirements are and by increasing punishments for breaches of the provisions.
The first hint that there is increased consumer protection provisions in the new law can be seen in Article 1 (22) where it is stated that operators are responsible for any losses suffered by passengers or those sending cargo.
The obligations and responsibilities on operators are set out in considerable detail in Articles 140 through 186. Interestingly, the provisions provide that operators are responsible for providing compensation where flights are delayed. To avoid this responsibility an operator would need to be able to prove that the delay was a result of an issue outside of their control such as the weather or a technical problem.
The size of any compensation that is to be provided will be determined by the Minister and regulated through a Ministerial Regulation. For aircraft that are lost without a trace, the passengers on any such flight will be deemed to have perished on the flight if after three months from the expected time of landing they have not been found alive. This determination of death does not require a decision to be issued by the District Court. Once the three months have elapsed the right to claim compensation is activated.
Article 176 also provides that victims of a breach of the provisions have a right to take legal action at the District Court based on prevailing Indonesian laws and regulations.
Furthermore, Article 186 specifically prohibits operators from completely special agreements that voids operator responsibility or limits the amount of compensation payable in the event any compensation is due.
Passage and Enactment
The bill was passed on 17 December 2008 and enacted into law as Law No. 1 of 2009 on 12 January 2009.
Conclusion
It is expected that the new aviation law will serve to repair Indonesia’s reputation in the sector by reinforcing Indonesia’s commitment to best safety practices in aviation. The second expected positive is that consumers will be able to fly with the full knowledge that they have increased legal certainty and protection. Simply, passengers and cargo users are no longer at the whim of operators. Operators are required to meet certain basic standards in the provision of their services and to make reparations when they fail to provide those services at the basic level.
The new aviation law is a step in the right direction. It is expected that the requisite implementing regulations will be enacted in the near future and provide the necessary clarity required for full enforcement of the prevailing provisions.