Placement and Protection of Indonesian Migrant Workers
Overview
The placement and protection of Indonesian Migrant Workers is an issue that repeatedly finds itself on the front page of local and national newspapers each time an Indonesian Migrant Worker dies overseas at the hands of negligent employers. There are also excellent financial reasons for wanting to regulate placement and protection of Indonesia’s migrant workforce. Simply, they are an economic stimulus package in their own right as these workers remit upwards of a billion dollars in foreign reserves into the Indonesian banking system each year.
The regulatory framework in this field is no longer appropriate in the current climate and the Minister of Labor and Transmigration has determined that the previous regulation needs perfecting. The previous regulation, No. 18/MEN/IX/2007 has been repealed and replaced with this Regulation. The Regulation, No. PER. 22/MEN/XII/2008, was issued on 9 December 2008 and comes into force on 1 February 2009.
The Regulation facilitates the implementation of the provisions contained in Articles 26(3), 27(2), 28, 32(4), 36(2), 40, 47, 56(3), 58(3), 63(2), 68(2), 69(4), 75(4), and 76(2) of Law No. 39 of 2004 as they relate to the placement of Indonesian Migrant Workers overseas. Furthermore, the Regulation will also reflect the enactment of Government Regulation 38 of 2007 which addresses matters related to the division of responsibilities between the Central Government, the Regional Governments, and the District / City Governments.
The placement of Indonesian Migrant Workers in foreign locales has been problematic for some time as it appeared the government was not making a serious effort to protect Indonesian citizens employed abroad while enjoying the fruits of these citizens labor in the form of remittances.
Nevertheless, it is worth noting that Indonesian Migrant Workers also need protection through the recruitment process to ensure that they are not exploited before they are even placed overseas. This protection then must also be extended on the workers return. The exploitation that these workers suffer at the hands of officials and others on their return is infamous and notorious.
General Provisions
The General Provisions are in fact a list of defined terms that are used in the Regulation. In the complicated process of recruiting, placing, and ultimately repatriating migrant workers means that explicit definitions are a critical part of the enforcement puzzle for Indonesia.
Placement
Indonesian Migrant Labor (Tenaga Kerja Indonesia / TKI) are to be placed overseas by Private Indonesian Migrant Labor Placement Agencies (Pelaksana Penempatan Tenaga Kerja Indonesia Swasta / PPTKIS) who have already obtained Mobilization License (Surat Izin Pengerahan / SIP) from the Minister of Labor and Transmigration.
To obtain a SIP the PPTKIS must submit a written application to the Minister. The application must include:
-
A copy of the agreement between the PPTKIS and the user of the services provided;
-
Job order, employment order, demand letter;
-
Draft placement agreement; and
-
Draft work contract.
The above documents can be in Indonesian, English, or the language of the country of placement.
The SIP is to be issued in 1 working day once the completed application is received. The Sip can be cancelled where any of the parties involved encounters problems.
The SIP is to contain, among others the following information:
-
The number, type, and qualifications of the prospective TKI that is to be recruited;
-
The number and date of the demand letter;
-
The name of the prospective user or partner agency in the country of placement;
-
The type of work and position;
-
The length of validity of the SIP; and
-
The region in which recruitment is to take place.
Recruitment Procedures
Where a PPTKIS intends to recruit in a particular district or city then it must submit the original SIP and a draft placement agreement to the district or city authority. The recruitment process for prospective TKI is to be proceeded by the provision of information that includes at least, among other matters, the following:
-
Location and work environment;
-
Protection procedures for at risk TKI;
-
Requirements for the TKI;
-
Rights and obligations of the TKI; and
-
Fees to be borne by the TKI.
A prospective TKI must be at least 18 years of age except where the requirement is for the TKI to be at least 21 years of age. TKI must possess a statement letter from a doctor to say that they are not currently pregnant. The TKI will also need a letter of permission from their spouse, parents, or guardians as appropriate.
Education and Training
The education and training provisions of the Regulation are rudimentary in that they merely state that a prospective TKI must satisfy certain skill and competency levels. Once these levels have been achieved then the prospective TKI has a right to obtain a certificate stating the levels achieved and the skills held. However, the Regulation does state that the skills and competency levels required are to be stipulated in a Ministerial Regulation. Presumably, this Regulation will be issued in the near future.
Passports
To ensure that a prospective TKI who has satisfied all the requirements for placement can actually be placed overseas, then the prospective TKI is to be issued a recommendation letter in order to facilitate the process of gaining a passport.
Work Contracts
The provisions as they relate to work contracts contain standard features that one would expect to see in a work contract. The primary difference is that a TKI work contract must also gain the approval of the Indonesian Representative Mission in the country of placement. The provisions deal with matters such as extending the work contract, insurance, and fees, among others. However, it is unclear in the Regulation whether the work contract, even if signed by the ultimate employer, is valid in the country of placement in terms of being enforceable.
Therefore, it is questionable as to how much protection a contract such as this provides a TKI once they are placed. The common sense approach to this matter would be to include provisions that require the work contract to be registered with the requisite authorities in the country of placement. This would ensure that the work contract was structured in accordance with the prevailing laws in the country of placement and enforceable in that country as well.
Interestingly, the provisions in Article 29 are indicative of an attempt to ensure that the work contract is legal by demanding that the user (employer) legalize the extension. Unfortunately, it is unclear as to what this legalization means and it is also unclear as to how this is to be enforced in the country of placement.
Protection of TKI
The protection of TKI is in three parts; pre-departure, placement, and return.
The pre-departure protections are to ensure that the prospective TKI are not exploited in the recruitment and training phases prior to their departure to a placement. Generally, this protection is to be organized and administered by the government at the relevant level.
The placement phase protections are the responsibility of Indonesia’s Representative Missions in the respective country of placement. The protections afforded include:
-
Dispute resolution;
-
Legal aid;
-
Advocacy and support;
-
Consular assistance;
-
Diplomatic efforts; and
-
Insurance.
In theory this should ensure that TKI are protected or at least have access to the various protections noted. The reality is that not all TKI are able to freely move and their ability to contact the relevant representative mission is not always guaranteed. Indonesian newspapers have been littered with tragic accounts of abuse against TKI who were simply unable to avail themselves of these protections.
Each of the above noted protections are enumerated individually in the Regulation.
The protections afforded to TKI on their return to Indonesia are as critical, if not more so, as the other two phases. Once again, Indonesian newspapers and television news reports are littered with accounts of returning TKI being exploited on their arrival. Many of the exploitative activities revolve around illegal fees for services, such as transportation to the TKI’s home village or having to exchange foreign currency at non-market rates and with exorbitant fees.
Article 51 addresses each of these concerns.
Fees Borne By the TKI
It is not cheap to become a TKI and avail oneself of an overseas employment opportunity. Article 76(1)(a)-(c) provides that the TKI must bear the costs of organizing and obtaining all personal documents, medical and psychological tests, training and certification. This Regulation adds to that burden by stipulating that the TKI also bears responsibility for fees related to a work visa, accommodation and food prior to departure, air ticket, local transportation, company services, and insurance premiums.
When one considers that the prospective TKI is generally from a lower socio-economic background then the financial burden is quite severe. This burden is often taken as credit and paid back in installments, and sometimes at high interest rates.
Other Provisions
The Minister has within their discretion to blacklist certain countries where there are issues of security and protection of TKI. It is unclear as to what would trigger this discretion and how many “incidents” would be required before a country was blacklisted.
Conclusion
It is clear that the government is taking its responsibilities seriously with respect to protecting the large numbers of Indonesians who choose to head overseas in search of employment. The intentions of the Regulation are honorable. In most instances the provisions are not going to be problematic. However, it is worth noting that the mechanisms for ensuring enforcement of work contracts in the country of placement are not as clear as perhaps they need to be.
It is clear that Indonesian Representative Missions are to play an active role in facilitating protection of TKI and ensuring the enforceability of their rights.
It is expected that the enactment of this Regulation will usher in a new era of greater protection for Indonesian Migrant Workers.
The placement and protection of Indonesian Migrant Workers is an issue that repeatedly finds itself on the front page of local and national newspapers each time an Indonesian Migrant Worker dies overseas at the hands of negligent employers. There are also excellent financial reasons for wanting to regulate placement and protection of Indonesia’s migrant workforce. Simply, they are an economic stimulus package in their own right as these workers remit upwards of a billion dollars in foreign reserves into the Indonesian banking system each year.
The regulatory framework in this field is no longer appropriate in the current climate and the Minister of Labor and Transmigration has determined that the previous regulation needs perfecting. The previous regulation, No. 18/MEN/IX/2007 has been repealed and replaced with this Regulation. The Regulation, No. PER. 22/MEN/XII/2008, was issued on 9 December 2008 and comes into force on 1 February 2009.
The Regulation facilitates the implementation of the provisions contained in Articles 26(3), 27(2), 28, 32(4), 36(2), 40, 47, 56(3), 58(3), 63(2), 68(2), 69(4), 75(4), and 76(2) of Law No. 39 of 2004 as they relate to the placement of Indonesian Migrant Workers overseas. Furthermore, the Regulation will also reflect the enactment of Government Regulation 38 of 2007 which addresses matters related to the division of responsibilities between the Central Government, the Regional Governments, and the District / City Governments.
The placement of Indonesian Migrant Workers in foreign locales has been problematic for some time as it appeared the government was not making a serious effort to protect Indonesian citizens employed abroad while enjoying the fruits of these citizens labor in the form of remittances.
Nevertheless, it is worth noting that Indonesian Migrant Workers also need protection through the recruitment process to ensure that they are not exploited before they are even placed overseas. This protection then must also be extended on the workers return. The exploitation that these workers suffer at the hands of officials and others on their return is infamous and notorious.
General Provisions
The General Provisions are in fact a list of defined terms that are used in the Regulation. In the complicated process of recruiting, placing, and ultimately repatriating migrant workers means that explicit definitions are a critical part of the enforcement puzzle for Indonesia.
Placement
Indonesian Migrant Labor (Tenaga Kerja Indonesia / TKI) are to be placed overseas by Private Indonesian Migrant Labor Placement Agencies (Pelaksana Penempatan Tenaga Kerja Indonesia Swasta / PPTKIS) who have already obtained Mobilization License (Surat Izin Pengerahan / SIP) from the Minister of Labor and Transmigration.
To obtain a SIP the PPTKIS must submit a written application to the Minister. The application must include:
-
A copy of the agreement between the PPTKIS and the user of the services provided;
-
Job order, employment order, demand letter;
-
Draft placement agreement; and
-
Draft work contract.
The above documents can be in Indonesian, English, or the language of the country of placement.
The SIP is to be issued in 1 working day once the completed application is received. The Sip can be cancelled where any of the parties involved encounters problems.
The SIP is to contain, among others the following information:
-
The number, type, and qualifications of the prospective TKI that is to be recruited;
-
The number and date of the demand letter;
-
The name of the prospective user or partner agency in the country of placement;
-
The type of work and position;
-
The length of validity of the SIP; and
-
The region in which recruitment is to take place.
Recruitment Procedures
Where a PPTKIS intends to recruit in a particular district or city then it must submit the original SIP and a draft placement agreement to the district or city authority. The recruitment process for prospective TKI is to be proceeded by the provision of information that includes at least, among other matters, the following:
-
Location and work environment;
-
Protection procedures for at risk TKI;
-
Requirements for the TKI;
-
Rights and obligations of the TKI; and
-
Fees to be borne by the TKI.
A prospective TKI must be at least 18 years of age except where the requirement is for the TKI to be at least 21 years of age. TKI must possess a statement letter from a doctor to say that they are not currently pregnant. The TKI will also need a letter of permission from their spouse, parents, or guardians as appropriate.
Education and Training
The education and training provisions of the Regulation are rudimentary in that they merely state that a prospective TKI must satisfy certain skill and competency levels. Once these levels have been achieved then the prospective TKI has a right to obtain a certificate stating the levels achieved and the skills held. However, the Regulation does state that the skills and competency levels required are to be stipulated in a Ministerial Regulation. Presumably, this Regulation will be issued in the near future.
Passports
To ensure that a prospective TKI who has satisfied all the requirements for placement can actually be placed overseas, then the prospective TKI is to be issued a recommendation letter in order to facilitate the process of gaining a passport.
Work Contracts
The provisions as they relate to work contracts contain standard features that one would expect to see in a work contract. The primary difference is that a TKI work contract must also gain the approval of the Indonesian Representative Mission in the country of placement. The provisions deal with matters such as extending the work contract, insurance, and fees, among others. However, it is unclear in the Regulation whether the work contract, even if signed by the ultimate employer, is valid in the country of placement in terms of being enforceable.
Therefore, it is questionable as to how much protection a contract such as this provides a TKI once they are placed. The common sense approach to this matter would be to include provisions that require the work contract to be registered with the requisite authorities in the country of placement. This would ensure that the work contract was structured in accordance with the prevailing laws in the country of placement and enforceable in that country as well.
Interestingly, the provisions in Article 29 are indicative of an attempt to ensure that the work contract is legal by demanding that the user (employer) legalize the extension. Unfortunately, it is unclear as to what this legalization means and it is also unclear as to how this is to be enforced in the country of placement.
Protection of TKI
The protection of TKI is in three parts; pre-departure, placement, and return.
The pre-departure protections are to ensure that the prospective TKI are not exploited in the recruitment and training phases prior to their departure to a placement. Generally, this protection is to be organized and administered by the government at the relevant level.
The placement phase protections are the responsibility of Indonesia’s Representative Missions in the respective country of placement. The protections afforded include:
-
Dispute resolution;
-
Legal aid;
-
Advocacy and support;
-
Consular assistance;
-
Diplomatic efforts; and
-
Insurance.
In theory this should ensure that TKI are protected or at least have access to the various protections noted. The reality is that not all TKI are able to freely move and their ability to contact the relevant representative mission is not always guaranteed. Indonesian newspapers have been littered with tragic accounts of abuse against TKI who were simply unable to avail themselves of these protections.
Each of the above noted protections are enumerated individually in the Regulation.
The protections afforded to TKI on their return to Indonesia are as critical, if not more so, as the other two phases. Once again, Indonesian newspapers and television news reports are littered with accounts of returning TKI being exploited on their arrival. Many of the exploitative activities revolve around illegal fees for services, such as transportation to the TKI’s home village or having to exchange foreign currency at non-market rates and with exorbitant fees.
Article 51 addresses each of these concerns.
Fees Borne By the TKI
It is not cheap to become a TKI and avail oneself of an overseas employment opportunity. Article 76(1)(a)-(c) provides that the TKI must bear the costs of organizing and obtaining all personal documents, medical and psychological tests, training and certification. This Regulation adds to that burden by stipulating that the TKI also bears responsibility for fees related to a work visa, accommodation and food prior to departure, air ticket, local transportation, company services, and insurance premiums.
When one considers that the prospective TKI is generally from a lower socio-economic background then the financial burden is quite severe. This burden is often taken as credit and paid back in installments, and sometimes at high interest rates.
Other Provisions
The Minister has within their discretion to blacklist certain countries where there are issues of security and protection of TKI. It is unclear as to what would trigger this discretion and how many “incidents” would be required before a country was blacklisted.
Conclusion
It is clear that the government is taking its responsibilities seriously with respect to protecting the large numbers of Indonesians who choose to head overseas in search of employment. The intentions of the Regulation are honorable. In most instances the provisions are not going to be problematic. However, it is worth noting that the mechanisms for ensuring enforcement of work contracts in the country of placement are not as clear as perhaps they need to be.
It is clear that Indonesian Representative Missions are to play an active role in facilitating protection of TKI and ensuring the enforceability of their rights.
It is expected that the enactment of this Regulation will usher in a new era of greater protection for Indonesian Migrant Workers.