There has been a great deal of controversy surrounding the passage of this bill through the House of Representatives (DPR). The issue that garnered most attention was the provisions that sort to raise the retirement age of judges from 65 years of age to 70 years of age.
Nevertheless, the issues going forward are going to relate to the manner of the passage of the bill into law. It is expected that there will be a constitutional challenge of the new law. The challenge will focus on whether or not the bill was properly drafted, debated, and passed within the framework of the Law on Legislation Drafting and the standing orders or procedures of the DPR itself.
The bill was passed at 21.30 on 18 December 2008. Acceptance of the bill was not universal and one of the factions that were present listed its objection to the passage of the bill in a mijnderheidsnota. This is an important piece of the puzzle as the constitutional challenge will most likely include data relating to the number of members present at the time the bill was passed.
The Indonesian Corruption Watch (ICW) is intending to base its constitutional challenge in part on breaches of Articles 205, 206, 208, 209, and 210 as contained in DPR Decision No. 08/DPR-RI/I/2005-2006.
The other primary concern of those who have stated their collective intention to challenge the constitutional validity of the law is that the drafting and debate or discussion phases were not conducted in accordance to the provisions stipulated in the Law on Legislation Drafting and specifically Article 53 which would envisage wide-ranging community participation.
The Indonesian President has no veto power to speak of and therefore the only way that this bill will not become law is if the proposed constitutional challenges find a sympathetic Constitutional Court.
There has been a great deal of controversy surrounding the passage of this bill through the House of Representatives (DPR). The issue that garnered most attention was the provisions that sort to raise the retirement age of judges from 65 years of age to 70 years of age.
Nevertheless, the issues going forward are going to relate to the manner of the passage of the bill into law. It is expected that there will be a constitutional challenge of the new law. The challenge will focus on whether or not the bill was properly drafted, debated, and passed within the framework of the Law on Legislation Drafting and the standing orders or procedures of the DPR itself.
The bill was passed at 21.30 on 18 December 2008. Acceptance of the bill was not universal and one of the factions that were present listed its objection to the passage of the bill in a mijnderheidsnota. This is an important piece of the puzzle as the constitutional challenge will most likely include data relating to the number of members present at the time the bill was passed.
The Indonesian Corruption Watch (ICW) is intending to base its constitutional challenge in part on breaches of Articles 205, 206, 208, 209, and 210 as contained in DPR Decision No. 08/DPR-RI/I/2005-2006.
The other primary concern of those who have stated their collective intention to challenge the constitutional validity of the law is that the drafting and debate or discussion phases were not conducted in accordance to the provisions stipulated in the Law on Legislation Drafting and specifically Article 53 which would envisage wide-ranging community participation.
The Indonesian President has no veto power to speak of and therefore the only way that this bill will not become law is if the proposed constitutional challenges find a sympathetic Constitutional Court.