Ratification of the Charter of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations
Overview
The Indonesian Government has ratified the Charter of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations. The Bill that will accomplish this task of ratification is clearly not problematic, particularly as Indonesia is a member of the Association. The Charter was ratified on 21 October 2008.
The basic framework is that membership of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) reflects Indonesia’s commitment to a greater role in regional and international affairs and that this provides greater opportunities to face threats, challenges, and struggles whilst simultaneously promoting Indonesian political, social, security, and cultural interests.
The reality is that Indonesia has already signed the ASEAN Charter at the 13th ASEAN Conference in Singapore on 20 November 2007. Therefore, the bill is designed to give effect to that signature by incorporating into domestic law the ASEAN Charter. The bill is simple and merely states in two paragraphs that once enacted the bill represents the ratification of the ASEAN Charter and that it comes into force on the date of its enactment.
Nevertheless, Indonesia was the last of the ASEAN nations to ratify the Charter. The ASEAN nations are Brunei, Cambodia, Indonesia, Laos, Malaysia, Myanmar, the Philippines, Singapore, Thailand, and Viet Nam.
The purpose of the Charter is to commit the member nations to a wide ranging human rights protection framework and the creation of a free trade area by 2015. The human rights protections are to include the establishment of a human rights body that unfortunately has no real sanctioning power and as such this has led to charges that it is nothing more than a toothless tiger that might talk the good talk but will not be able to do anything more. Therefore, persistent human rights violators such as Myanmar will be able to thumb its nose at the body without fear of sanction. Yet, it would seem that the Charter does permit members to be suspended for violations of the Charter.
Indonesia points out in defense of the Charter that it is a work in progress and that the Charter itself allows for amendments, fine tuning, and tweaking to get the provisions right. Whether this should be interpreted as an intention at some future time to up the pressure on rogue states like Myanmar is still to be seen. It is worth noting that Myanmar is already under economic sanctions from both the European Union and the United States of America.
The Indonesian ratification is expected to lead to the subsequent formal adoption by ASEAN of the Charter before the end of 2008.
The Need for an ASEAN Charter
The Elucidations to the Bill are explicit in stating that ASEAN represents a corner stone of Indonesia’s foreign affairs politics, particularly because it is of strategic importance in terms of facing threats and challenges that are expected to the peace and stability of the region. For this reason it is imperative that Indonesia position itself to play an integral role in the development of regional cooperation.
ASEAN has committed itself to establishing an ASEAN community by 2015 that is based on three basic pillars, namely: politics, economy, and culture. Simply, if this is to be achieved then the transformation of ASEAN from its current form to the three pillars requires that there are clear organizational rules in place to facilitate the transformation.
The issues that are key to Indonesia’s participation are that any inter-state cooperation must be based on principles of mutual benefit, equality, and the respect of each other’s sovereignty.
It is the Indonesian Government’s view that under the umbrella of the ASEAN Charter these goals can be achieved and the basic principles noted above fulfilled with full respect.
The General Provisions of the Elucidations lists the principles more fully as:
-Respect of State independence;
-Sovereignty;
-Equality;
-Territorial integrity and national identity;
-Rejection of aggression;
-Free from external interference;
-Improved consultation and dialogue;
-Promotion of peaceful settlement of disputes;
-Respect of fundamental freedoms;
-Advancement and protection of human rights; and
-Respect of cultural, language, and religious differences.
The Purposes of the ASEAN Charter
There are fifteen purposes listed in the Charter. Primary among these are the need to maintain peace, security, and stability while strengthening the peace oriented values of the region. Another key purpose is to enhance regional resilience through the promotion of greater political, security, economic, and socio-cultural cooperation.
The purposes also reflect some over-arching goals such as a desire to keep Southeast Asia a nuclear weapon free zone and also free from all other weapons of mass destruction.
Furthermore, it is envisaged that the Charter will provide the framework for the creation of a single market and production base that is stable, prosperous, highly competitive and economically integrated. This single market is expected to provide enhanced trade and investment opportunities to member states by allowing for the free-flow of capital and labor.
ASEAN Human Rights Body
The Charter provides for the establishment of a human rights body. Presumably, this body will accept and adjudicate complaints related to human rights. However, the actual form of the body will be determined in Meetings of the ASEAN Foreign Ministers. Nevertheless, it is expected that the body will conform to prevailing international human rights norms. Indonesia insisted on as much before signing the Charter.
Dispute Settlement
Generally, Chapter VIII of the Charter provides for the peaceful settlement of disputes through good offices, conciliation, or mediation. In all other disputes where the mechanism of dispute resolution is defined, then the dispute is to be resolved in accordance with those provisions and utilizing the mechanisms stated.
If a dispute cannot be resolved then it is to be referred to the next ASEAN Summit for a resolution to be determined.
Working Language
The working language of ASEAN is English.
Amendments to the Charter
Any State can propose an amendment to the Charter through the ASEAN Coordinating Council who will make a consensus decision on the proposed amendments and then forward those amendments to the ASEAN Summit for a decision.
If the amendments are agreed at the ASEAN Summit, then all member States are under an obligation to ratify those amendments.
The idea of consensus decision making with regard to amendments is problematic, particularly if there is one member who will not agree to the proposed changes. Indonesia has suggested that an early amendment might relate to changing this provision from consensus decision making to one of simple majority.
Other Issues
ASEAN is to have a motto. That motto is “One Vision, One Identity, One Community”. Furthermore, ASEAN is to have a flag, an Emblem, and an Anthem.
ASEAN Day is 8 August and is to be observed. It remains to be seen whether this will become another public holiday in an already crowded Indonesian public holiday calendar.
Conclusion
The Charter now that it has been ratified by all member States is expected to be formally adopted before the end of the year.
The ASEAN Charter will have a significant and permanent impact on all member States as it requires the development of a free trade zone among member States by 2015. This provides some time for Indonesia to improve competitiveness in relation to other members. However, it is most likely that the biggest impact relates to the much freer movement of labor and professionals within the region.
The other significant element of the ASEAN Charter is the establishment of a human rights body. It is expected that the member States will use this body as a means of forcing more rapid change on Myanmar in an attempt to get Myanmar in some semblance of compliance with prevailing international human rights norms.
The ASEAN Charter is expected to require individual member States to produce and amend domestic legislation to facilitate compliance with the over-arching provisions of the Charter.
The Indonesian Government has ratified the Charter of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations. The Bill that will accomplish this task of ratification is clearly not problematic, particularly as Indonesia is a member of the Association. The Charter was ratified on 21 October 2008.
The basic framework is that membership of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) reflects Indonesia’s commitment to a greater role in regional and international affairs and that this provides greater opportunities to face threats, challenges, and struggles whilst simultaneously promoting Indonesian political, social, security, and cultural interests.
The reality is that Indonesia has already signed the ASEAN Charter at the 13th ASEAN Conference in Singapore on 20 November 2007. Therefore, the bill is designed to give effect to that signature by incorporating into domestic law the ASEAN Charter. The bill is simple and merely states in two paragraphs that once enacted the bill represents the ratification of the ASEAN Charter and that it comes into force on the date of its enactment.
Nevertheless, Indonesia was the last of the ASEAN nations to ratify the Charter. The ASEAN nations are Brunei, Cambodia, Indonesia, Laos, Malaysia, Myanmar, the Philippines, Singapore, Thailand, and Viet Nam.
The purpose of the Charter is to commit the member nations to a wide ranging human rights protection framework and the creation of a free trade area by 2015. The human rights protections are to include the establishment of a human rights body that unfortunately has no real sanctioning power and as such this has led to charges that it is nothing more than a toothless tiger that might talk the good talk but will not be able to do anything more. Therefore, persistent human rights violators such as Myanmar will be able to thumb its nose at the body without fear of sanction. Yet, it would seem that the Charter does permit members to be suspended for violations of the Charter.
Indonesia points out in defense of the Charter that it is a work in progress and that the Charter itself allows for amendments, fine tuning, and tweaking to get the provisions right. Whether this should be interpreted as an intention at some future time to up the pressure on rogue states like Myanmar is still to be seen. It is worth noting that Myanmar is already under economic sanctions from both the European Union and the United States of America.
The Indonesian ratification is expected to lead to the subsequent formal adoption by ASEAN of the Charter before the end of 2008.
The Need for an ASEAN Charter
The Elucidations to the Bill are explicit in stating that ASEAN represents a corner stone of Indonesia’s foreign affairs politics, particularly because it is of strategic importance in terms of facing threats and challenges that are expected to the peace and stability of the region. For this reason it is imperative that Indonesia position itself to play an integral role in the development of regional cooperation.
ASEAN has committed itself to establishing an ASEAN community by 2015 that is based on three basic pillars, namely: politics, economy, and culture. Simply, if this is to be achieved then the transformation of ASEAN from its current form to the three pillars requires that there are clear organizational rules in place to facilitate the transformation.
The issues that are key to Indonesia’s participation are that any inter-state cooperation must be based on principles of mutual benefit, equality, and the respect of each other’s sovereignty.
It is the Indonesian Government’s view that under the umbrella of the ASEAN Charter these goals can be achieved and the basic principles noted above fulfilled with full respect.
The General Provisions of the Elucidations lists the principles more fully as:
-Respect of State independence;
-Sovereignty;
-Equality;
-Territorial integrity and national identity;
-Rejection of aggression;
-Free from external interference;
-Improved consultation and dialogue;
-Promotion of peaceful settlement of disputes;
-Respect of fundamental freedoms;
-Advancement and protection of human rights; and
-Respect of cultural, language, and religious differences.
The Purposes of the ASEAN Charter
There are fifteen purposes listed in the Charter. Primary among these are the need to maintain peace, security, and stability while strengthening the peace oriented values of the region. Another key purpose is to enhance regional resilience through the promotion of greater political, security, economic, and socio-cultural cooperation.
The purposes also reflect some over-arching goals such as a desire to keep Southeast Asia a nuclear weapon free zone and also free from all other weapons of mass destruction.
Furthermore, it is envisaged that the Charter will provide the framework for the creation of a single market and production base that is stable, prosperous, highly competitive and economically integrated. This single market is expected to provide enhanced trade and investment opportunities to member states by allowing for the free-flow of capital and labor.
ASEAN Human Rights Body
The Charter provides for the establishment of a human rights body. Presumably, this body will accept and adjudicate complaints related to human rights. However, the actual form of the body will be determined in Meetings of the ASEAN Foreign Ministers. Nevertheless, it is expected that the body will conform to prevailing international human rights norms. Indonesia insisted on as much before signing the Charter.
Dispute Settlement
Generally, Chapter VIII of the Charter provides for the peaceful settlement of disputes through good offices, conciliation, or mediation. In all other disputes where the mechanism of dispute resolution is defined, then the dispute is to be resolved in accordance with those provisions and utilizing the mechanisms stated.
If a dispute cannot be resolved then it is to be referred to the next ASEAN Summit for a resolution to be determined.
Working Language
The working language of ASEAN is English.
Amendments to the Charter
Any State can propose an amendment to the Charter through the ASEAN Coordinating Council who will make a consensus decision on the proposed amendments and then forward those amendments to the ASEAN Summit for a decision.
If the amendments are agreed at the ASEAN Summit, then all member States are under an obligation to ratify those amendments.
The idea of consensus decision making with regard to amendments is problematic, particularly if there is one member who will not agree to the proposed changes. Indonesia has suggested that an early amendment might relate to changing this provision from consensus decision making to one of simple majority.
Other Issues
ASEAN is to have a motto. That motto is “One Vision, One Identity, One Community”. Furthermore, ASEAN is to have a flag, an Emblem, and an Anthem.
ASEAN Day is 8 August and is to be observed. It remains to be seen whether this will become another public holiday in an already crowded Indonesian public holiday calendar.
Conclusion
The Charter now that it has been ratified by all member States is expected to be formally adopted before the end of the year.
The ASEAN Charter will have a significant and permanent impact on all member States as it requires the development of a free trade zone among member States by 2015. This provides some time for Indonesia to improve competitiveness in relation to other members. However, it is most likely that the biggest impact relates to the much freer movement of labor and professionals within the region.
The other significant element of the ASEAN Charter is the establishment of a human rights body. It is expected that the member States will use this body as a means of forcing more rapid change on Myanmar in an attempt to get Myanmar in some semblance of compliance with prevailing international human rights norms.
The ASEAN Charter is expected to require individual member States to produce and amend domestic legislation to facilitate compliance with the over-arching provisions of the Charter.