The Law on the Ombudsman of the Republic of Indonesia was enacted into law on 7 October 2008. The regulatory framework prior to the law was a Presidential Decree, No. 44 of 2000. The Law, in essence, supersedes the Decree and stipulates that the National Ombudsman Commission, the composition of the Commission, and all the Reporting functions must be in compliance with the provisions of the Law within one year of the Law’s enactment.
The overarching premise of the Law is to eradicate and prevent the maladministration of government that had lead to corruption, collusion, and nepotism. It is expected that the provisions of the new Law will provide the regulatory framework and mechanisms to ensure that the administration of state is effective and efficient, honest, clean, and open. It is also expected that these improvements will also lead to a reduction in the practices of corruption, collusion, and nepotism.
The Ombudsman of the Republic of Indonesia (the “Ombudsman”) has been designed to handle claims of maladministration from government or other public institutions and companies such as State and Regional Owned Enterprises but also complaints from the private sector or other entities that provide public services and where all or part of their respective funding is provided by the State or Regional government.
The focus of the Ombudsman is maladministration and the prevention of practices that negatively impact on the efficiency and effectiveness in the provision of public services. Maladministration is defined as any behavior or action that breaches the prevailing laws and regulations, exceeds the authority granted (ultra vires), and the use of granted authorities for purposes other than those that they were granted for. This may give rise to claims of negligence and omission in the performance of one’s duties and consequently result in both material and immaterial losses.
Generally, the Ombudsman will receive reports, either written or oral, from complainants upon which the Ombudsman will initiate an investigation. Nevertheless, the report must be of an act or omission that falls within the scope of maladministration.
Reporters or Complainants
The definition for who may make reports states that the “reporter” must be an Indonesian citizen or resident. The Elucidations to Article 1(5) and 23(1) do not provide any additional clarification on this. Therefore, resident must be concluded to mean any person legally resident in Indonesia. It is unclear whether this would include tourists who may be legally in Indonesia but would not generally be considered to be resident.
Power of Recommendation
Like most Ombudsman throughout the world, the Ombudsman of the Republic of Indonesia is empowered to make recommendations about what action must be taken to ensure that the maladministration that was the subject of the report and subsequent investigation is not repeated. These recommendations are to be made and framed within the context of good governance.
The Need for an Ombudsman
The background to the establishment and creation of an Ombudsman and the time taken to progress from Presidential Decree to law highlights a number of important issues. Primary among these would seemingly be some resistance to oversight in the provision of public services until such time as the post-Soeharto governments had made some headway on getting the provision of public services into some semblance of order.
After 32 years of rubber stamp administration and a general breakdown in the provision of public services would undoubtedly have seen the Ombudsman overwhelmed and the government unable to address the serious issues that the Ombudsman would have undoubtedly uncovered. The government has clearly made some headway on “cleaning-up” the provision of public services but admittedly there is a long way to go.
The “reformasi” period that followed the fall of the New Order mandated that the administration of State and government was based on democratic principles that improved prosperity while simultaneously creating a climate of justice and legal certainty as envisaged in the Constitution of 1945.
Internal and External Mechanisms
The government rationalizes the need for a law on the Ombudsman on the fact that the way the state and government was managed previously was colored by maladministration, particularly the practices of corruption, collusion, and nepotism. This runs counter to the hopes, desires, and demands of the broader community that would hope to benefit from the provision of public services that the provision of these services would be effective and efficient, honest, clean, open and free from corruption, collusion, and nepotism. The reality is that the best way of ensuring that the providers of these public services take this obligation and responsibility seriously is to put in place a mechanism that forces the development and application of best practices.
This mechanism must be external to the government and the providers of these services. Simply, the government cannot be relied on to supervise and then heal itself of any ills. This is not to suggest that internal oversight and supervision will not play any significant role, to the contrary the internal oversight and supervision mechanisms are to be supplemented by an external mechanism that will allow the general public to report their concerns to an independent non-partisan investigator, in this case, the Ombudsman.
The previous mechanism was completely unsatisfactory as the only recourse an individual had for reporting maladministration was to report to the institution where they received the poor service that they believed breached the prevailing provisions. The law would allow the individual to escalate a complaint to the courts, but for most the courts were notoriously corrupt and therefore aligned against them in terms of getting a decision in their favor. Consequently, must people accepted their fate and accepted the provision of poor quality public services. In a nutshell, the courts were expensive and the government had larger resources and the ability to string the process out thereby making the whole process even more costly.
From Presidential Decree to Law
Initially, the government issued Presidential Decree No. 44 of 2000 on the National Ombudsman Commission. The basic premise of this Decree was to provide a mechanism to confront the triple threats of corruption, collusion, and nepotism and with a comprehensive plan successfully prevent any further occurrences of these scourges in the provision of public services.
History shows us that this was not to be the case, however it must be noted that the undertaking was huge and was never likely to be completed in a short period of time. It took a much longer than a day or six months or a year to build the system of institutionalized corruption, collusion, and nepotism that was afflicting the nation and despite the euphoria of the fall of the repressive New Order it was also going to take a considerable time to dismantle these systems.
The need to codify the role, duties, and functions of the Ombudsman into law were recognized early. The Decree alludes to this, however the mandate for the establishment of the Ombudsman in a specific law can be found in the Decision of the People’s Consultative Council (Majelis Permusyawaratan Rakyat / MPR) No. VIII/MPR/2001.
Independence
The idea was that the Ombudsman would be an independent institution that was free from the interference of outside influence thereby making it impartial. When this is combined with the fact that to report an allegation of maladministration did not require the payment of any fees to lodge a complaint means that any person has the financial ability to lodge a complaint if they feel that the provision of public services have not been as they must be.
Investigation and Subpoena Power
The investigation that the Ombudsman can undertake permits it to call the reported parties to testify as well as witnesses to provide explanations and clarifications of what transpired in leading to the lodging of the report or complaint. This power to call includes a subpoena power. In essence, the Ombudsman can compel the reported parties and witnesses to present themselves in an investigation. This subpoena power relies on the assistance of the National Police Force of the Republic of Indonesia who will ultimately escort the reported parties and witnesses to any hearing if such action is required.
State and Regional Structure
The Ombudsman is to be located in Jakarta. Nevertheless, in order to facilitate access to the services of the Ombudsman, the Ombudsman may establish regional representative offices at the provincial, district, and city levels. Each regional office will have a head and a support structure that is the same as that noted for the Central Office of the Ombudsman.
Duties and Authorities
From the outset the provisions of the Law are very explicit that the Ombudsman is an institution of state that is independent and has no organic relationship with any other institution of government and it is to be free from interference in the performance of its functions and duties. These duties and authorities are to be based on, among other matters:
-Justice;
-Non-discrimination;
-Impartiality;
-Accountability; and
-Openness (transparency).
Periodic Reporting
The Ombudsman is required to submit periodic reports and annual reports to the DPR and the President. The purpose of these reports is to provide the necessary background to both the DPR and the President that would allow them to make policy decisions and where necessary to formulate policy that would codify improvements in the provision of public services within the framework of reaching an acceptable level of good governance and best practice in the provision of government services.
Criminal Provisions
The Law contains criminal provisions that provide for jail terms of up to two years or fines of up to IDR 1 billion for any person that seeks to obstruct any investigation being undertaken by the Ombudsman.
Conclusion
In conclusion, it is obvious that the basic objectives of the Ombudsman are to see that the rule of law prevails, that the administration of state is effective and efficient, that the services provided by the state are of the highest quality, and to provide assistance in creating a state that is free from maladministration and the triple threats of corruption, collusion, and nepotism.
It is expected that the Law will allow for dramatic improvements in the effective and efficient administration of state and government.
The Law on the Ombudsman of the Republic of Indonesia was enacted into law on 7 October 2008. The regulatory framework prior to the law was a Presidential Decree, No. 44 of 2000. The Law, in essence, supersedes the Decree and stipulates that the National Ombudsman Commission, the composition of the Commission, and all the Reporting functions must be in compliance with the provisions of the Law within one year of the Law’s enactment.
The overarching premise of the Law is to eradicate and prevent the maladministration of government that had lead to corruption, collusion, and nepotism. It is expected that the provisions of the new Law will provide the regulatory framework and mechanisms to ensure that the administration of state is effective and efficient, honest, clean, and open. It is also expected that these improvements will also lead to a reduction in the practices of corruption, collusion, and nepotism.
The Ombudsman of the Republic of Indonesia (the “Ombudsman”) has been designed to handle claims of maladministration from government or other public institutions and companies such as State and Regional Owned Enterprises but also complaints from the private sector or other entities that provide public services and where all or part of their respective funding is provided by the State or Regional government.
The focus of the Ombudsman is maladministration and the prevention of practices that negatively impact on the efficiency and effectiveness in the provision of public services. Maladministration is defined as any behavior or action that breaches the prevailing laws and regulations, exceeds the authority granted (ultra vires), and the use of granted authorities for purposes other than those that they were granted for. This may give rise to claims of negligence and omission in the performance of one’s duties and consequently result in both material and immaterial losses.
Generally, the Ombudsman will receive reports, either written or oral, from complainants upon which the Ombudsman will initiate an investigation. Nevertheless, the report must be of an act or omission that falls within the scope of maladministration.
Reporters or Complainants
The definition for who may make reports states that the “reporter” must be an Indonesian citizen or resident. The Elucidations to Article 1(5) and 23(1) do not provide any additional clarification on this. Therefore, resident must be concluded to mean any person legally resident in Indonesia. It is unclear whether this would include tourists who may be legally in Indonesia but would not generally be considered to be resident.
Power of Recommendation
Like most Ombudsman throughout the world, the Ombudsman of the Republic of Indonesia is empowered to make recommendations about what action must be taken to ensure that the maladministration that was the subject of the report and subsequent investigation is not repeated. These recommendations are to be made and framed within the context of good governance.
The Need for an Ombudsman
The background to the establishment and creation of an Ombudsman and the time taken to progress from Presidential Decree to law highlights a number of important issues. Primary among these would seemingly be some resistance to oversight in the provision of public services until such time as the post-Soeharto governments had made some headway on getting the provision of public services into some semblance of order.
After 32 years of rubber stamp administration and a general breakdown in the provision of public services would undoubtedly have seen the Ombudsman overwhelmed and the government unable to address the serious issues that the Ombudsman would have undoubtedly uncovered. The government has clearly made some headway on “cleaning-up” the provision of public services but admittedly there is a long way to go.
The “reformasi” period that followed the fall of the New Order mandated that the administration of State and government was based on democratic principles that improved prosperity while simultaneously creating a climate of justice and legal certainty as envisaged in the Constitution of 1945.
Internal and External Mechanisms
The government rationalizes the need for a law on the Ombudsman on the fact that the way the state and government was managed previously was colored by maladministration, particularly the practices of corruption, collusion, and nepotism. This runs counter to the hopes, desires, and demands of the broader community that would hope to benefit from the provision of public services that the provision of these services would be effective and efficient, honest, clean, open and free from corruption, collusion, and nepotism. The reality is that the best way of ensuring that the providers of these public services take this obligation and responsibility seriously is to put in place a mechanism that forces the development and application of best practices.
This mechanism must be external to the government and the providers of these services. Simply, the government cannot be relied on to supervise and then heal itself of any ills. This is not to suggest that internal oversight and supervision will not play any significant role, to the contrary the internal oversight and supervision mechanisms are to be supplemented by an external mechanism that will allow the general public to report their concerns to an independent non-partisan investigator, in this case, the Ombudsman.
The previous mechanism was completely unsatisfactory as the only recourse an individual had for reporting maladministration was to report to the institution where they received the poor service that they believed breached the prevailing provisions. The law would allow the individual to escalate a complaint to the courts, but for most the courts were notoriously corrupt and therefore aligned against them in terms of getting a decision in their favor. Consequently, must people accepted their fate and accepted the provision of poor quality public services. In a nutshell, the courts were expensive and the government had larger resources and the ability to string the process out thereby making the whole process even more costly.
From Presidential Decree to Law
Initially, the government issued Presidential Decree No. 44 of 2000 on the National Ombudsman Commission. The basic premise of this Decree was to provide a mechanism to confront the triple threats of corruption, collusion, and nepotism and with a comprehensive plan successfully prevent any further occurrences of these scourges in the provision of public services.
History shows us that this was not to be the case, however it must be noted that the undertaking was huge and was never likely to be completed in a short period of time. It took a much longer than a day or six months or a year to build the system of institutionalized corruption, collusion, and nepotism that was afflicting the nation and despite the euphoria of the fall of the repressive New Order it was also going to take a considerable time to dismantle these systems.
The need to codify the role, duties, and functions of the Ombudsman into law were recognized early. The Decree alludes to this, however the mandate for the establishment of the Ombudsman in a specific law can be found in the Decision of the People’s Consultative Council (Majelis Permusyawaratan Rakyat / MPR) No. VIII/MPR/2001.
Independence
The idea was that the Ombudsman would be an independent institution that was free from the interference of outside influence thereby making it impartial. When this is combined with the fact that to report an allegation of maladministration did not require the payment of any fees to lodge a complaint means that any person has the financial ability to lodge a complaint if they feel that the provision of public services have not been as they must be.
Investigation and Subpoena Power
The investigation that the Ombudsman can undertake permits it to call the reported parties to testify as well as witnesses to provide explanations and clarifications of what transpired in leading to the lodging of the report or complaint. This power to call includes a subpoena power. In essence, the Ombudsman can compel the reported parties and witnesses to present themselves in an investigation. This subpoena power relies on the assistance of the National Police Force of the Republic of Indonesia who will ultimately escort the reported parties and witnesses to any hearing if such action is required.
State and Regional Structure
The Ombudsman is to be located in Jakarta. Nevertheless, in order to facilitate access to the services of the Ombudsman, the Ombudsman may establish regional representative offices at the provincial, district, and city levels. Each regional office will have a head and a support structure that is the same as that noted for the Central Office of the Ombudsman.
Duties and Authorities
From the outset the provisions of the Law are very explicit that the Ombudsman is an institution of state that is independent and has no organic relationship with any other institution of government and it is to be free from interference in the performance of its functions and duties. These duties and authorities are to be based on, among other matters:
-Justice;
-Non-discrimination;
-Impartiality;
-Accountability; and
-Openness (transparency).
Periodic Reporting
The Ombudsman is required to submit periodic reports and annual reports to the DPR and the President. The purpose of these reports is to provide the necessary background to both the DPR and the President that would allow them to make policy decisions and where necessary to formulate policy that would codify improvements in the provision of public services within the framework of reaching an acceptable level of good governance and best practice in the provision of government services.
Criminal Provisions
The Law contains criminal provisions that provide for jail terms of up to two years or fines of up to IDR 1 billion for any person that seeks to obstruct any investigation being undertaken by the Ombudsman.
Conclusion
In conclusion, it is obvious that the basic objectives of the Ombudsman are to see that the rule of law prevails, that the administration of state is effective and efficient, that the services provided by the state are of the highest quality, and to provide assistance in creating a state that is free from maladministration and the triple threats of corruption, collusion, and nepotism.
It is expected that the Law will allow for dramatic improvements in the effective and efficient administration of state and government.