The Supreme Court has handed down its decision on 22 August 2008 in Case No. 719 K/Pdt/2008. The case pitted PT Timor Putra Nasional (TPN) against Bank Mandiri and others in the right to accounts held by TPN at Bank Mandiri.
The substance of the case stems from the then Indonesian Bank Restructuring Agency’s (IBRA) decision to sell TPN’s account receivables to a new creditor, PT Bella Vista Pratama (BVP). The agreement between IBRA and BVP was contained in an agreement to buy and sell account receivables. This agreement to all intents and purposes, in the Court’s mind, was a contract. The rules of contract are well set and therefore these rules must be complied with.
The Supreme Court in its decision held that the High Court had erred in the application of the law of contract and this in turn resulted in an incorrect decision at the High Court level. To rectify this error the Supreme Court simply cancelled the decision and then decided the case themselves. The Supreme Court has relied on the principle of pacta sunt servanda or the principle that contracts must be performed as agreed.
The Supreme Court also noted in its Decision that the role of the confidential correspondence between the Department of Finance and Bank Mandiri where the Department instructed Mandiri not to release the accounts of TPN as they were to be held as surety against TPN debts was not transparent and indicated a secret change in policy that would serve to decrease the amount of legal certainty of Indonesian citizens in their interactions with government and other institutions.
The Decision means that TPN will have access to the relevant accounts and also any interest that has accrued on those accounts. However, the Supreme Court rejected TPN’s claims for immaterial (punitive) losses as having no legal basis and because the losses were not proved by TPN.
This Decision does not expunge any debts still owed by TPN.
The Supreme Court has handed down its decision on 22 August 2008 in Case No. 719 K/Pdt/2008. The case pitted PT Timor Putra Nasional (TPN) against Bank Mandiri and others in the right to accounts held by TPN at Bank Mandiri.
The substance of the case stems from the then Indonesian Bank Restructuring Agency’s (IBRA) decision to sell TPN’s account receivables to a new creditor, PT Bella Vista Pratama (BVP). The agreement between IBRA and BVP was contained in an agreement to buy and sell account receivables. This agreement to all intents and purposes, in the Court’s mind, was a contract. The rules of contract are well set and therefore these rules must be complied with.
The Supreme Court in its decision held that the High Court had erred in the application of the law of contract and this in turn resulted in an incorrect decision at the High Court level. To rectify this error the Supreme Court simply cancelled the decision and then decided the case themselves. The Supreme Court has relied on the principle of pacta sunt servanda or the principle that contracts must be performed as agreed.
The Supreme Court also noted in its Decision that the role of the confidential correspondence between the Department of Finance and Bank Mandiri where the Department instructed Mandiri not to release the accounts of TPN as they were to be held as surety against TPN debts was not transparent and indicated a secret change in policy that would serve to decrease the amount of legal certainty of Indonesian citizens in their interactions with government and other institutions.
The Decision means that TPN will have access to the relevant accounts and also any interest that has accrued on those accounts. However, the Supreme Court rejected TPN’s claims for immaterial (punitive) losses as having no legal basis and because the losses were not proved by TPN.
This Decision does not expunge any debts still owed by TPN.