After a long and tortuous journey through the legislative process and a name change from the Anti-Pornography and Indecency Bill to its current title of the Pornography Bill, it seems that the House of Representatives (DPR) is set to pass the bill by the end of September 2008. The major changes to the bill are that the majority of the indecency provisions have been dropped in favour of focusing almost exclusively on pornography. However, some of the more pertinent indecency provisions have been incorporated into other provisions within the bill.
The biggest question relating to the pornography bill is whether or not specific pornography provisions were necessary. The majority of what is to be regulated in this bill is already regulated elsewhere. Specifically, pornography is regulated in both the Criminal Code and the recently enacted Information and Electronic Transactions Law.
There is little dispute that pornography needs to be regulated but once again the concerns relate to whether this is the most effective way of ensuring that those that need to be protected are in fact protected.
The definition of what constitutes pornography is very broad and in essence encompasses any material that is sexual in nature. However, the bill does include cultural, ritual, and artistic exceptions. Yet, it is worth noting that these exceptions are vaguely constructed and as such subject to considerable interpretation and discretion.
Another concern is the role of the community. If Article 21 is read by itself then the bill paints a picture of vigilante justice as the community can play a significant role in the prevention of pornography. However, Article 21 is specifically modified by Article 22 which limits what can be done by the community to things such as socialization with regards to educating the community to the dangers of pornography and commencing class actions. The provisions though in these two articles will require vigilance from the government to ensure that the role the community plays is properly policed as well.
Article 4 makes it an offence to store, among other things, pornography. Therefore, any organization, institution, or individual with images that would be deemed pornographic have one month after the enactment of the bill into law to destroy those images.
The key to how large an impact this bill will have will be determined by the commitment the government has in ensuring it is enforced.
......