Overview
Aviation management in Indonesia has been suffering under the perception that it is ad hoc at best and at worst too lax even for a minimal standard that might be accepted internationally. The number of accidents that have occurred over the recent past has led to not only the European Union blacklisting Indonesian airlines from European skies but has seen the revocation of a number of aviation business permits in Indonesia by the Indonesian government. Another criticism of Indonesian airlines relates not to their safety but rather their consistency in customer service and their collective abilities to ensure listed flights take off on time and in some cases even take off at all.
For an archipelagic nation like Indonesia, it is one of those things that goes without saying and that is that as the world becomes increasingly competitive on a global scale then so does Indonesia’s ability to manage transport between its more than 17,000 islands become important, particularly air transport in these modern times. Indonesia’s shipping, both commercial and passenger, leaves a lot to be desired in terms of safety. However, that is another issue for a different ILD. This ILD will be focusing exclusively on Minister of Transport Regulation No. KM 25 of 2008 on Air Transport Management.
Air Transport Management had been regulated under Minister of Transport Decision No. KM 81 of 2004. However, the Department of Transport (DoT) has determined that the Regulation is no longer suitable to ensure effective and efficient air transport management in light of recent advances in the aviation sector. The DoT has also determined that the earlier Decision did not sufficiently address issues of customer service and support, particularly where airlines were at fault for delayed and canceled flights.
The new Regulation endeavors to rectify these deficiencies. This regulation came into force on 25 June 2008 and on doing so repealed the earlier Decision.
The basic legal framework for this Ministerial Regulation is the Law on Aviation (No. 15 of 1992) and Government Regulation on Air Transport (No. 40 of 1995 as amended by Government Regulation No. 3 of 2000).
Definitions
The basic definition for air transportation is the movement of people, cargo, or post by the use of aircraft for one or more journeys from one airport to another.
There are three types of air transport envisaged in the Regulation, namely: commercial (regular and charter), non-commercial, and pioneering. Commercial flights are classified as either regular or charter depending on whether they are scheduled or non-scheduled flights.
Commercial
A scheduled flight is one that is one that is flown on a determined route for a determined fee and is publicized. Generally, these are flights listed by aviation companies for ordinary passenger flights. A charter flight is any flight that takes place after an agreement has been reached between the provider and user of the flight service.
Non-Commercial
Non-commercial flights are generally not passenger flights and are not for public use.
Pioneering
Pioneering flight services are those flights that are of limited or no commercial value at the time the initial flights are made. These flights are designed to open up new routes to remote areas or areas that are not serviced by any other type of transportation.
Commercial Air Transport
Business Licenses
Commercial air transport may only be undertaken once the appropriate business license is obtained from the Director General responsible for the issuance of these licenses. The license issued will reflect whether the commercial air transport services provided are either scheduled or charter services.
Provided the holder of the business license continues its operations uninterrupted then the license is valid for a period of three years. At the expiration of the license an evaluation is required to determine that the holder has complied with all their obligations with respect to the license.
Requirements for a Business License
The basic requirements for a business license require that the company applying for a business license fill in the standard form that is attached as Attachment I and include the following documents:
a. deed of establishment as a limited liability company that has been legalized by the relevant Minister;
b. tax payer number;
c. a statement of domicile;
d. a statement letter of agreement from the Capital Investment Coordination Board (BKPM) or the Regional BKPM where the applicant is utilizing investment facilities;
e. a statement of deposited capital;
f. a bank guarantee; and
g. a business plan.
The business plan noted at (g) must include:
1. the type and number of planes to be operated;
2. the location of the operations base and the routes to be flown;
3. the expected or projected demand for the listed routes;
4. a list of human resources including technicians and flight staff;
5. a statement of operational readiness; and
6. an analysis and evaluation of current economic and financial aspects related to the business plan.
Each of the elements noted in the business plan above are then further enumerated in the Regulation and set out specific criteria that must be fulfilled in the application. For example, the type and number of planes required for a scheduled commercial operation is five planes. Two of these must be owned and a further three must be under the control of the applicant. For a charter operation, at least one plane must be owned and a further two must be under the control of the charter operation. For cargo companies the requirement is a minimum of two planes under the company’s control.
In respect of operational readiness, the Regulation demands that the business plan highlight:
a. a plan for the procurement of maintenance services for the aircraft;
b. a plan for the procurement of operational support facilities for the aircraft;
c. a plan for the procurement of passenger support services; and
d. a marketing plan for the air transport services that are to be provided.
In addition the elements of the business plan in terms of economic and financial analysis and evaluation must include data on:
1. a five-year investment plan;
2. cash flow;
3. payback periods;
4. net present value;
5. profitability index; and
6. internal rates of return.
To facilitate compliance with this requirement the Regulation in Example 2 at Attachment I includes a standard form for the applicant to follow.
Once the applicant has submitted a complete application then the Director General is required to either grant or reject the application in writing and within 60 days of its submission. Once the license is granted, the applicant has a maximum of 12 months to commence operations. Furthermore, the onus is also on the license holder to notify the Director General if there is any change to the data on which the license was granted.
Routes
There are two basic type of routes covered in the Regulation, domestic and international. Nevertheless, these routes are then further classified in terms of demand into the following:
- very heavy;
- heavy;
- light; and
- very light.
A very heavy route would be one that caters for more than one million passengers per year and a very light route would be one that caters for less than 100,000 per year.
The routes that companies can fly will be noted in an attachment to their respective business licenses. However, if a company wants to expand the routes that they serve then they must submit the relevant data to the Director General for approval. The relevant data in this case would include, among other data, the intended days and times of flights; a slot time; and a valid Air Operator Certificate.
Obligations
One of the more significant changes from the previous Decision in this area and the current Regulation is the emphasis placed on the obligations that accrue to the business license holders in the air transport sector.
Delays and Cancellations
Article 36 lists five specific occurrences where the air transport service provider must provide a form of compensation to service users:
a. in the event of a delay of between 30 minutes and 90 minutes, the provider is required to provide light refreshments in the form of drinks and snacks;
b. in the event of a delay of between 90 minutes and 180 minutes, then the provider is required to provide light refreshments similar to those noted above. Additionally, the provider is to either provide lunch or dinner (depending on the time of day), move the passengers to the next available flight, or to the flight of another provider if the passenger so requests;
c. in the event of a delay exceeding 180 minutes the provider must provide all of the above. Where another flight is not available on that day, then the provider is required to provide accommodation to the affected passengers and facilitate a flight for these passengers on the following day;
d. in the event a flight is canceled, then the provider must endeavor to get the passenger onto an alternate flight either with the provider themselves or another provider. Where this cannot be arranged then accommodation must be provided and the passengers are to be directed to flights on the following day; and
e. in the event of a delay or cancellation where the passenger does not want to be directed to a later flight with the provider or a flight with another provider, then the cost of the ticket is to be refunded.
More specifically, when a flight is to be delayed then there is an obligation on the fight provider to make a public announcement at least 45 minutes in advance of the delay or as soon as the flight provider becomes aware of that delay. Where the delay is known some time in advance, then the flight provider is to contact the passenger by telephone, SMS, or some other form of electronic communication, and advise them of the delay.
Security Measures – Tickets and Boarding Passes
The Regulation also includes enhanced security measures with regards to tickets and boarding passes. For example, a ticket must include the following information:
- ticket number, place, and date of issue;
- name of the passenger and the name of the provider;
- place, date, and time of the flight;
- flight number;
- place of departure, place of arrival, and any stop-over locations in between; and
- a statement that prevailing laws and regulations apply.
With regard to boarding passes, the following apply:
- name of the passenger;
- route to be traveled;
- flight number, date, and time;
- seat number;
- gate number for waiting room; and
- boarding time.
International Routes
The Regulation includes specific provisions relating to domestic air transport providers operating international routes and international air transport providers flying into Indonesia.
For example, licenses will only be granted to foreign air transport providers wanting to service Indonesian destinations based on a bilateral or multilateral agreement and where the foreign air transport provider is in compliance with Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 129.
Compliance with the New Regulation
For those air transport providers holding licenses under the previous regulatory framework there is a 36 month grace period to come into compliance with the provisions contained in this Regulation. However, this simply means that as current air transport business licenses expire then the operators are going to be required to renew these licenses based on the new provisions.
Conclusion
It is clear that the intent of this Regulation is to not only ensure that there are more comprehensive regulatory provisions in place, but to also ensure that there is a greater ability to ensure that enforcement of the provisions occurs. Furthermore, it is clear that the government is trying to emphasize the obligations that air transport providers have towards their respective clients and the quality of the services that they provide.
The Regulation puts into place very specific obligations with regard to delays and cancellations and what air transport providers must do in the event a delay or cancellation occurs.
These provisions should ensure that the aviation industry and particularly those providing commercial and non-commercial air transport services do so at a much higher quality level.
Time will tell!......