Healthy Markets - Healthy Citizens - Healthy Country

Overview

 

The Government has made the development of “healthy” districts and cities a priority in terms of reducing and eliminating the threats of rapidly spreading contagious diseases such as Avian Influenza, SARS, and even Cholera, among other potential contagious diseases. For the government, the potential threat seems to stem from traditional markets and the often less than hygienic manner in which these markets are managed and organized.

 

The government is seeking to rectify the perceived deficiencies in the regulatory framework through the issuing of Guidelines. These guidelines are contained in Minister of Health Decision No. 519/MENKES/SK/VI/2008. There are four basic objectives that the Guidelines endeavor to meet, namely: traditional markets that are clean, safe, secure, and healthy.

 

The Decision itself is short and in essence merely states that the Guidelines that are attached to the Decision are to serve as the framework for health officials that are tasked with ensuring that their respective local environments are healthy. The Decision also explicitly points out that the Guidelines are also intended to provide direction for market management and other stakeholders that are involved in ensuring that markets are healthy places for the conduct of business. The Guidelines make specific mention of traditional markets.

 

The concern is not primarily directed towards modern markets and shopping centers. Nevertheless, it would be remiss of modern markets and shopping centers not to consider the Guidelines as there have been known outbreaks of illnesses such as Legionnaire’s Disease (Legionella) that are traceable to the air conditioning systems of large modern markets and shopping centers.

 

The Decision has been in force since 6 June 2008.

 

The Guidelines

The Guidelines although directed more generally at any market format and this would be irrespective of whether that market was classified as modern or traditional, nevertheless seem specifically directed to Indonesia’s traditional markets which have traditionally been subject to much laxer regulatory enforcement.

 

The rationale is that the health of the nation is directly linked to the health of the locations where they undertake many of their activities. In this regard, the government contends that for the middle and lower classes, and these are the classes that make up the majority of the Indonesian population, find that the majority of their activities can be found to be undertaken in traditional markets.

 

World Health Organization and Others

As was noted earlier, World Health Organization studies have indicated that many outbreaks of infectious diseases with the potential to develop into pandemics originate in traditional markets. This has been the case in South and Latin America with respect of recent cholera outbreaks. It has also been the case for outbreaks of such illnesses as SARS and Avian Influenza in Asia.

 

More specifically, and particularly in the Indonesian context, the WHO, FAO, OIE, and the World Bank in a joint report from November 2005 have noted that in order to control the rapid spread of flu and avian flu then it is necessary to ensure that markets are healthy, this includes traditional markets.

 

Directorate General of Domestic Trade

The Directorate General of Domestic Trade at the Department of Trade states that as pf 2007 there were 13,450 traditional markets in Indonesia. At these markets there were some 12.625 million traders. The Directorate General then goes onto assume that each of these traders had a family unit of four. Therefore, the simple math of this is that more than 50 million Indonesians were in some way either directly or indirectly associated with a traditional market. This in turn means that almost a quarter of Indonesia’s population would be at immediate risk if there was to be an outbreak of contagious disease linked to a traditional market.

 

Nevertheless, the proportion of total markets that are traditional markets has been in steady, perhaps even rapid, decline since 1985. In 1985, traditional markets in Jakarta totaled 151 or 78% of the total number of markets in the capital. The remaining 22% were classified as modern markets. However, by 2006 traditional markets remained in 151 locations but accounted for a mere 25% of total markets. The modern markets had increased from 42 locations in 1985 to 449 locations in 2006. Modern markets now account for more than 75% of the market spaces in Jakarta.

 

Previous Regulatory Framework

The previous regulations in this area are deemed to be insufficient on many fronts. The Guidelines pay particular attention to issues such as bio-security and food security. Therefore, issues such as improving the level of food security from production through to consumption are regulated. Also regulated is education, specifically educating producers, traders, and consumers with regard to bio-security and standards of hygiene for optimal health. Within the Guidelines the term bio-security refers to the overall management of biological risk factors.

 

Definitions

The basic definitions contained in the Guidelines are the following:

1.              traditional markets are permanent, managed, and generally include for sale and purchase everyday needs, simple facilities and infrastructure, with direct interaction between sellers and buyers;

2.              a healthy market is one where the market is clean, safe, secure, and health;

3.              stakeholders are those that have an interest in the operation of the market, including central government, regional or local government, market management, traders, market employees, and consumers, among others;

4.              infrastructure includes all infrastructure and equipment that the market relies on such as buildings, kiosks, transport, cleaning equipment, and other supporting equipment;

5.              market management are those responsible for the effective and efficient day-to-day operation of the market; and

6.              hygiene and sanitation promotion is an approach that is used to raise levels of awareness and knowledge within individuals, families, or the wider community about these issues.

 

The Guidelines then go on to list a series of benefits from the implementation of the provisions contained in the Guidelines. These benefits are listed categorically for: primary producers, traders, regional government, market management, local community, general community, and consumers. For example, the benefits that will be derived from the Guidelines for primary producers include; improvements in the quality of produce, increases in the sale value of produce, a growing market, and better economies of scale. For regional or local governments these benefits include; reduction in disease outbreaks, improvements in community nutrition levels, decreasing expenditure on health services, increases in the level of government income.

 

Policy and Strategy

Policy and strategy are covered in explicit detail within the Guidelines.

 

The policy aims are directed at developing a solid network of partners across the government (Central, Regional, and Local), private business, NGOs, and the community in the development of healthy markets.

 

The Guidelines list 12 components to the healthy market strategy. These include, among others, the development of healthy markets as part of an overall settlement spatial plan; socialization of the need for healthy markets; raising the level of professionalism of those associated with healthy markets; expanding available technology; and increased levels of supervision to ensure compliance with the ideals of a healthy market.

 

Management Steps

There are seven basic steps that are required to be implemented to ensure the effective and efficient management of healthy markets:

1.              Advocacy and Socialization - advocacy is specifically directed at the apparatus of government with the view of garnering support for the healthy market policy. In contrast, the socialization program is more broadly aimed at ensuring all healthy market stakeholders are on the same policy and strategy page;

2.              capacity building of human resources - the focus here is very much on “train the trainer” programs that are designed to build the numbers of locally available resources to train stakeholders in the value of healthy markets;

3.              Situational analysis - this is simply taking an initial survey of current conditions in order to develop a comprehensive and structured approach that is designed to allow for the goals of a healthy market to be achieved;

4.              Prioritized work plans - list in order the priorities to be worked through. This will generally be set out as the priority to be handled, the resources allocated to the priority, a work plan for the priority, and the roles of the various parties involved;

5.              Implementation of work plans - very simply the repair of infrastructure, improvements to operations, and a focus on hygiene and sanitation;

6.              Guidance and supervision - guidance and supervision in this context mandates that the stakeholders play a more intensive role in ensuring that short, medium and long-term healthy market goals are achieved. This will require that greater supervision be carried out. Generally, this supervision will be in the form of markets being monitored and evaluated based on a specified set of terms. These terms are contained in Attachment I to this Decision; and

7.              Reporting mechanisms - this is self-explanatory in the sense that once the report from the monitoring and evaluation process is complete then it is to be forwarded to the relevant authorities.

 

The Market Environment

The final part of the Guidelines deal with specific requirements to maintain a healthy market environment. The issues covered include; the location, the buildings, sanitation, clean and healthy behaviors, safety and security, and other facilities.

 

Location

Location - requires that the development of any market be in accordance with the relevant regional or local spatial plan. However, location also requires that consideration be given to whether the chosen location is susceptible to natural disasters. If it is then the market is to be built in some other location.

 

Buildings

Buildings - the provisions in this section deal with where various elements of the market are to be located and the proximity of one are to another. For example, there are explicit provisions with regard to the location within the market for the buying and selling of live animals, the slaughtering of animals, and the sale of dry goods.

 

Parking - a healthy market is required to have parking and loading facilities available for consumers and for those bringing live animals to market. The market is also required to provide some greenery to the parking lot.

 

Construction - this section deals with the physical construction of the market from the perspective of the roof, walls, and floors.

 

The other provisions of this section deal with stairways, ventilation, and lighting, and doorways.

 

Sanitation

Water - the sanitation provisions require that the market provide at least 40 litres of clean water per trader and that the quality of water be checked every six months.

 

Bathrooms and toilets - the provisions require that for markets with 25 traders or less then 1 bathroom and 1 toilet is required. Where a market contains 26 – 50 traders then 2 bathrooms and 2 toilets are required. Where there are 51 – 100 traders present there is a requirement that there be 3 bathrooms and 3 toilets. Finally, for the addition of every 40 – 100 traders there must be an additional bathroom and toilet added.

 

Pest Control - there are explicit provisions listed with respect to flies, cockroaches, mosquitoes, and rats. For example, mosquitoes cannot exceed 5% on the Container Index (CI) scale. For rats the tolerance level is zero.

 

Safety

There are two features to the safety provisions; healthy markets must have in place fire safety equipment and security posts.

 

Other Facilities

Prayer rooms - that are easily accessible, clean, and with appropriate ventilation and lighting.

 

Live animals - a location that is only for the buying and selling of live animals. This place is to be separate from the main market. This location will also include accredited facilities for the slaughter of animals.

 

Medical Facilities

All markets are required to have a medical post in place as a post of first treatment.

 

Conclusion

 

It is expected that all regional and local government will actively embrace these Guidelines and encourage other stakeholders to do the same. The reality is that if Indonesia does not take steps to ensure the cleanliness, safety, security, and healthiness of its traditional markets, then the possibility of an outbreak of infectious and contagious disease remains real.

 

Therefore, the need to put into place strict and enforceable guidelines for the management of markets generally and traditional markets specifically is a step in the direction of ensuring that an outbreak does not occur.

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku

Overview

 

The Government has made the development of “healthy” districts and cities a priority in terms of reducing and eliminating the threats of rapidly spreading contagious diseases such as Avian Influenza, SARS, and even Cholera, among other potential contagious diseases. For the government, the potential threat seems to stem from traditional markets and the often less than hygienic manner in which these markets are managed and organized.

 

The government is seeking to rectify the perceived deficiencies in the regulatory framework through the issuing of Guidelines. These guidelines are contained in Minister of Health Decision No. 519/MENKES/SK/VI/2008. There are four basic objectives that the Guidelines endeavor to meet, namely: traditional markets that are clean, safe, secure, and healthy.

 

The Decision itself is short and in essence merely states that the Guidelines that are attached to the Decision are to serve as the framework for health officials that are tasked with ensuring that their respective local environments are healthy. The Decision also explicitly points out that the Guidelines are also intended to provide direction for market management and other stakeholders that are involved in ensuring that markets are healthy places for the conduct of business. The Guidelines make specific mention of traditional markets.

 

The concern is not primarily directed towards modern markets and shopping centers. Nevertheless, it would be remiss of modern markets and shopping centers not to consider the Guidelines as there have been known outbreaks of illnesses such as Legionnaire’s Disease (Legionella) that are traceable to the air conditioning systems of large modern markets and shopping centers.

 

The Decision has been in force since 6 June 2008.

 

The Guidelines

The Guidelines although directed more generally at any market format and this would be irrespective of whether that market was classified as modern or traditional, nevertheless seem specifically directed to Indonesia’s traditional markets which have traditionally been subject to much laxer regulatory enforcement.

 

The rationale is that the health of the nation is directly linked to the health of the locations where they undertake many of their activities. In this regard, the government contends that for the middle and lower classes, and these are the classes that make up the majority of the Indonesian population, find that the majority of their activities can be found to be undertaken in traditional markets.

 

World Health Organization and Others

As was noted earlier, World Health Organization studies have indicated that many outbreaks of infectious diseases with the potential to develop into pandemics originate in traditional markets. This has been the case in South and Latin America with respect of recent cholera outbreaks. It has also been the case for outbreaks of such illnesses as SARS and Avian Influenza in Asia.

 

More specifically, and particularly in the Indonesian context, the WHO, FAO, OIE, and the World Bank in a joint report from November 2005 have noted that in order to control the rapid spread of flu and avian flu then it is necessary to ensure that markets are healthy, this includes traditional markets.

 

Directorate General of Domestic Trade

The Directorate General of Domestic Trade at the Department of Trade states that as pf 2007 there were 13,450 traditional markets in Indonesia. At these markets there were some 12.625 million traders. The Directorate General then goes onto assume that each of these traders had a family unit of four. Therefore, the simple math of this is that more than 50 million Indonesians were in some way either directly or indirectly associated with a traditional market. This in turn means that almost a quarter of Indonesia’s population would be at immediate risk if there was to be an outbreak of contagious disease linked to a traditional market.

 

Nevertheless, the proportion of total markets that are traditional markets has been in steady, perhaps even rapid, decline since 1985. In 1985, traditional markets in Jakarta totaled 151 or 78% of the total number of markets in the capital. The remaining 22% were classified as modern markets. However, by 2006 traditional markets remained in 151 locations but accounted for a mere 25% of total markets. The modern markets had increased from 42 locations in 1985 to 449 locations in 2006. Modern markets now account for more than 75% of the market spaces in Jakarta.

 

Previous Regulatory Framework

The previous regulations in this area are deemed to be insufficient on many fronts. The Guidelines pay particular attention to issues such as bio-security and food security. Therefore, issues such as improving the level of food security from production through to consumption are regulated. Also regulated is education, specifically educating producers, traders, and consumers with regard to bio-security and standards of hygiene for optimal health. Within the Guidelines the term bio-security refers to the overall management of biological risk factors.

 

Definitions

The basic definitions contained in the Guidelines are the following:

1.              traditional markets are permanent, managed, and generally include for sale and purchase everyday needs, simple facilities and infrastructure, with direct interaction between sellers and buyers;

2.              a healthy market is one where the market is clean, safe, secure, and health;

3.              stakeholders are those that have an interest in the operation of the market, including central government, regional or local government, market management, traders, market employees, and consumers, among others;

4.              infrastructure includes all infrastructure and equipment that the market relies on such as buildings, kiosks, transport, cleaning equipment, and other supporting equipment;

5.              market management are those responsible for the effective and efficient day-to-day operation of the market; and

6.              hygiene and sanitation promotion is an approach that is used to raise levels of awareness and knowledge within individuals, families, or the wider community about these issues.

 

The Guidelines then go on to list a series of benefits from the implementation of the provisions contained in the Guidelines. These benefits are listed categorically for: primary producers, traders, regional government, market management, local community, general community, and consumers. For example, the benefits that will be derived from the Guidelines for primary producers include; improvements in the quality of produce, increases in the sale value of produce, a growing market, and better economies of scale. For regional or local governments these benefits include; reduction in disease outbreaks, improvements in community nutrition levels, decreasing expenditure on health services, increases in the level of government income.

 

Policy and Strategy

Policy and strategy are covered in explicit detail within the Guidelines.

 

The policy aims are directed at developing a solid network of partners across the government (Central, Regional, and Local), private business, NGOs, and the community in the development of healthy markets.

 

The Guidelines list 12 components to the healthy market strategy. These include, among others, the development of healthy markets as part of an overall settlement spatial plan; socialization of the need for healthy markets; raising the level of professionalism of those associated with healthy markets; expanding available technology; and increased levels of supervision to ensure compliance with the ideals of a healthy market.

 

Management Steps

There are seven basic steps that are required to be implemented to ensure the effective and efficient management of healthy markets:

1.              Advocacy and Socialization - advocacy is specifically directed at the apparatus of government with the view of garnering support for the healthy market policy. In contrast, the socialization program is more broadly aimed at ensuring all healthy market stakeholders are on the same policy and strategy page;

2.              capacity building of human resources - the focus here is very much on “train the trainer” programs that are designed to build the numbers of locally available resources to train stakeholders in the value of healthy markets;

3.              Situational analysis - this is simply taking an initial survey of current conditions in order to develop a comprehensive and structured approach that is designed to allow for the goals of a healthy market to be achieved;

4.              Prioritized work plans - list in order the priorities to be worked through. This will generally be set out as the priority to be handled, the resources allocated to the priority, a work plan for the priority, and the roles of the various parties involved;

5.              Implementation of work plans - very simply the repair of infrastructure, improvements to operations, and a focus on hygiene and sanitation;

6.              Guidance and supervision - guidance and supervision in this context mandates that the stakeholders play a more intensive role in ensuring that short, medium and long-term healthy market goals are achieved. This will require that greater supervision be carried out. Generally, this supervision will be in the form of markets being monitored and evaluated based on a specified set of terms. These terms are contained in Attachment I to this Decision; and

7.              Reporting mechanisms - this is self-explanatory in the sense that once the report from the monitoring and evaluation process is complete then it is to be forwarded to the relevant authorities.

 

The Market Environment

The final part of the Guidelines deal with specific requirements to maintain a healthy market environment. The issues covered include; the location, the buildings, sanitation, clean and healthy behaviors, safety and security, and other facilities.

 

Location

Location - requires that the development of any market be in accordance with the relevant regional or local spatial plan. However, location also requires that consideration be given to whether the chosen location is susceptible to natural disasters. If it is then the market is to be built in some other location.

 

Buildings

Buildings - the provisions in this section deal with where various elements of the market are to be located and the proximity of one are to another. For example, there are explicit provisions with regard to the location within the market for the buying and selling of live animals, the slaughtering of animals, and the sale of dry goods.

 

Parking - a healthy market is required to have parking and loading facilities available for consumers and for those bringing live animals to market. The market is also required to provide some greenery to the parking lot.

 

Construction - this section deals with the physical construction of the market from the perspective of the roof, walls, and floors.

 

The other provisions of this section deal with stairways, ventilation, and lighting, and doorways.

 

Sanitation

Water - the sanitation provisions require that the market provide at least 40 litres of clean water per trader and that the quality of water be checked every six months.

 

Bathrooms and toilets - the provisions require that for markets with 25 traders or less then 1 bathroom and 1 toilet is required. Where a market contains 26 – 50 traders then 2 bathrooms and 2 toilets are required. Where there are 51 – 100 traders present there is a requirement that there be 3 bathrooms and 3 toilets. Finally, for the addition of every 40 – 100 traders there must be an additional bathroom and toilet added.

 

Pest Control - there are explicit provisions listed with respect to flies, cockroaches, mosquitoes, and rats. For example, mosquitoes cannot exceed 5% on the Container Index (CI) scale. For rats the tolerance level is zero.

 

Safety

There are two features to the safety provisions; healthy markets must have in place fire safety equipment and security posts.

 

Other Facilities

Prayer rooms - that are easily accessible, clean, and with appropriate ventilation and lighting.

 

Live animals - a location that is only for the buying and selling of live animals. This place is to be separate from the main market. This location will also include accredited facilities for the slaughter of animals.

 

Medical Facilities

All markets are required to have a medical post in place as a post of first treatment.

 

Conclusion

 

It is expected that all regional and local government will actively embrace these Guidelines and encourage other stakeholders to do the same. The reality is that if Indonesia does not take steps to ensure the cleanliness, safety, security, and healthiness of its traditional markets, then the possibility of an outbreak of infectious and contagious disease remains real.

 

Therefore, the need to put into place strict and enforceable guidelines for the management of markets generally and traditional markets specifically is a step in the direction of ensuring that an outbreak does not occur.

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku
2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info