Overview
The Minister of Health submitted a Bill on Hospitals to the Special Committee of Commission IX of the House of Representatives (DPR) on 2 July 2008. The primary purpose was for this Bill to be discussed, debated, and then enacted into law. The basic premise for this Bill is that the expansion in medical knowledge and technology combined with a concurrent push for globalization and decentralization and greater demands from the community that health services be open and transparent, has meant that the managing of a hospital has become increasingly complex and needs of a more comprehensive regulatory framework.
This complexity demands that there be strict regulations in place that are conducive to legal enforcement and thereby providing greater levels of community satisfaction and legal certainty. The government has clearly determined that the current regulatory framework of government regulations is insufficient for this purpose.
Ultimately, the Bill has been drafted to ensure that health services are promotive of good health, preventive, curative, and rehabilitative.
The Bill contains 15 Chapters and 58 Articles:
Chapter I – deals with the general definitions of the terms used;
Chapter II – states that the Bill is based on Pancasila whilst incorporating norms of humanity, benefits, justice, equality of rights and anti-discrimination, protection and safety of patients, and the social functions performed by hospitals;
Chapter III – states the functions and duties of hospitals;
Chapter IV – deals with the obligations of both the Central and Regional Governments with respect to providing hospitals to meet the basic needs of the surrounding communities, including the provision of medical services to the disadvantaged;
Chapter V – regulates the physical requirements of a hospital with regard to location, infrastructure, equipment, and pharmacy issues;
Chapter VI – regulates the types and classifications of hospitals;
Chapter VII – stipulates licensing requirements;
Chapter VIII – sets out the rights and obligations of both hospitals and their patients;
Chapter IX – addresses the issues relating to hospital management;
Chapter X – regulates matters with regard to hospital fees, funding, and subsidies;
Chapter XI – stipulates the provisions regarding the recording of data, reporting, and the obligation to use an information management system for this purpose;
Chapter XII – deals with matters relating to guidance and supervision of hospitals;
Chapter XIII – sets out the criminal provisions;
Chapter XIV and XV – deal with transitional and closing provision respectively.
All of the factions in the DPR have already agreed to proceed with discussion on the Bill. However, it is expected that this process may take some time in spite of the enthusiasm of the various factions to discuss it.
The responses of some of the factions indicates that there will be issues to be resolved such as whether hospitals should be left completely to market forces or if not what involvement should the government have. Or is the most natural mechanism to have a private and public hospital system catering to different parts of the community.
The Need for a Law
It is explicit in the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia (Constitution) that there is a mandate for the government to regulate medical services including hospitals. The Constitution in Article 28H(1) and Article 34(3) list the rights of citizens to have access to health services and the obligations on the government to provide health services that are fit for such a purpose.
The reality is that the current regulatory framework for hospitals is at the Ministerial level. The government has determined that there is a need for this to be upgraded to a level of statute. The belief is that with the enactment of a law there will be greater legal certainty for both hospitals and the communities that use them. This will be simultaneous with the need to provide direction and provide a basis for hospital management.
The other considerations that the government has had with regard to the need for a Law as opposed to continued Ministerial Regulation is that hospitals either public or private require considerable investment from both the perspective of start-up costs and operational costs once hospitals have been established.
Within the scope of national development hospitals play and will play a significant role. In addition to the need for infrastructure and equipment, national development will require healthy and working human resources that are the primary drivers of national development. Simply, no matter how much investment in infrastructure is made, without the human resources to work the investment the investment is of limited value.
The Bill stipulates that the Central and Regional Governments have a responsibility to provide, at least, minimal health services to the community. The community in this context is generally stated and pays no heed to race, ethnicity, social status, or religion.
However, the Bill also covers private hospitals and as such there is potential for long and drawn out discussion and debate during the process of enactment of this Bill, as private hospitals are an investment designed to derive a profit. This is in direct contrast to a public hospital which is designed to serve the needs of the local community.
Values & Functions
The Bill includes six basic values and a function. Those values are: humanity, benefit, fairness, equality, comprehensiveness, and protection. The function is a social one.
These basic values and functions must be read in conjunction with other articles within the Bill that provide some scope for private hospitals to make a profit.
The reason is that one of the biggest criticisms of private hospitals is that by their very nature they are selective in the patients that have access to those services. It is a simple user pays system in that if you have the resources to pay for private medical or health care then the hospital will accept you as a patient. However, if you have limited or insufficient resources then a private hospital will turn you away as a patient as you cannot afford to pay.
The Bill attempts to rectify this disparity by stipulating that the tariff for any Class III hospital room is to be set by Government Regulation. This provision is sure to spark the interest of private hospital administrators and future investors as it would appear to mandate that every hospital, public or private, must have a Class III series of rooms that cater to the poor and those less able to afford health care. Even so, the practicality of this provision is that it would simply translate to long waiting lists at private hospitals for certain types of treatment.
In essence, the government’s attempt here is merely legislated ‘pro bono’ work for hospitals. This is a provision that requires further regulation and it is expected that this regulation will be in the form of government regulation.
Community Needs
The Bill demands that hospitals are to be established based on community needs. This means that the number of beds in any one hospital is to be in a ratio commensurate with the total population of the area where the hospital is to be built.
This must be read in conjunction with other articles as the community needs that are most prevalent are those living in the most marginalized communities of Indonesia and specifically those that are poor and unable to afford even the most basic of health care.
Hospitals
Hospitals must use staff that are certified or meet an accredited professional standard. The professional standards are based on four basic principles: capacity, knowledge, skill, and professional attitude. It is expected that these will be covered by existing professional standards applicable in the medical and health professions.
The Bill also sets out and defines pharmacies that are provided by hospitals. The Bill also defines and distinguishes health equipment.
The types of hospitals covered under the Bill include both public and private. There are specific types of hospitals within the public hospital sphere such as Special Public Hospitals. However, the critical point of the provisions in this regard is that public hospitals cannot be transferred to private or corporate entities. A public hospital is a not for profit institution and as such any transfer to a private entity will put this not for profit status in jeopardy.
There are specific provisions within the Bill that address issues such as medical records and their confidentiality. This confidentiality also extends to the idea that there is privilege between doctors and their patients.
Furthermore, the Bill also provides in the Elucidations that there are specific medical and health issues that hospitals are to pay attention to such as abortion and plastic surgery designed to disguise identity.
The Bill lists the need for hospitals to have bylaws with a view to achieving good corporate and clinical governance. These bylaws include hospital, corporate, and medical bylaws. It is expected that this will also address issues of clinical privilege.
Patient Safety
Historically, accidents can happen at hospitals that effect patient safety. The Bill characterizes these into three specific events: medical error, adverse event, and near miss.
A medical error is self-explanatory.
An adverse event is defined as something that occurs and that was unexpected. This may or may not be a consequence of medical error.
A near miss is self-explanatory. However, it may be a medical error that had the potential for a harmful outcome but that harmful outcome did not eventuate.
The Bill also addresses situations where the patient or the patient’s family refuses treatment or determines to end specific medical treatments that may sustain life. Nevertheless, this seems to be nothing more than simply stating that the hospital cannot be held liable where patients or their families refuse treatment. However, this does not mean that voluntary euthanasia is permissible.
The provisions also seek to protect hospitals from prosecution where the hospital has done everything within its power to preserve or save life.
Criminal Provisions
For individuals that breach the provisions of the Law will be subject to criminal penalties that range from six months of detention through to five years of imprisonment and fines ranging up to IDR 1 billion.
These breaches relate to the establishment of a hospital, licensing, and services.
Conclusion
It is clear that the government is attempting to strengthen the legal and regulatory framework of hospitals with the introduction of this Bill. Nevertheless, and as has been previously noted, despite the initial support for the introduction of the Bill, it is expected that the discussion and debate on the Bill is likely to intensify as more critical examination and analysis of the current provisions are undertaken.
However, this is also likely to be offset by the need for the regulatory framework to be strengthened.
......