Overview
The need for implementing regulations is an important feature of Indonesian legislation. Traditionally, primary laws are often general and state the big picture or the intent. This intent is then refined in subsidiary or implementing regulation. However, one of the biggest criticisms of this approach is that the implementing regulations are not drafted or enacted for considerable periods of time after the primary legislation. There are numerous examples of laws being passed where some provisions were unable to be implemented because the requisite implementing legislation had not been forthcoming.
This Regulation is an example of this particular system of primary and subsidiary legislation in action. After a somewhat long and tortuous journey the government has confirmed and enacted a Regulation on Ground Water. This Regulation is No. 43 of 2008. The Regulation has been in force since the date of its confirmation on 23 May 2008 (see ILB No. 650 for a discussion of the Draft Bill that was debated).
The need for this Regulation was that the following Articles from the Law on Water Resources (Law No. 7 of 2004) regulate the exploitation and management of ground water, specifically Articles 10, 12(3), 13(5), 37(3), 58(2), and 59. These provisions had been deemed to be ineffectively implemented and thus required specific subsidiary legislation to give the provisions the necessary legal effect that was envisaged when the original law was enacted.
The rationale for the Regulation is that ground water plays a critical role in the sustaining of life generally but more importantly is that it sustains the life of the broader community. The Regulation provides for the taking of an inventory of ground water resources while promoting conservation and sustainable management of the resource for the long-term.
Recent debate on the need to more strictly regulate ground water usage is that experts have stated that parts of Jakarta have sunk up to 1.5 meters over the last decade because of the unregulated pillaging of Jakarta’s ground water. It is expected that further subsidiary legislation at the regional and local levels will see an increase in fees and levies on those that use ground water as their primary water source. The increases and levies are expected to increase across the board but be weighted with respect to the usage expected for personal and commercial uses.
Ground water policy has a national, provincial, and municipal element in that each of the distinct government levels has a degree of policy control over the water resources. Nevertheless, it is clear that provincial and municipal policies will not be permitted to run counter to any national ground water policy determined by the Central Government.
Generally, ground water management will cover aspects of planning, implementation, monitoring, evaluation, conservation, and exploitation. The terms themselves are self-explanatory and need to be as some of them are only briefly regulated in the Regulation. However, other provisions are much more comprehensive such as the taking of an inventory of ground water resources which states that the inventory process will include mapping, examination, research, exploration, and evaluation of the data obtained.
The Regulation also stipulates licensing provisions; who needs a license, what licenses are to be granted, and the procedures for securing a license.
Definitions
Essentially, ground water is any water found in the layers of the earth and the stone and rock formations under the surface.
The rights to access, use, and exploit ground water resources are defined as are the licenses required in order to pursue these rights.
Ground Water Resources Management Policy
The basic policy is that the management of ground water resources must include directives that are going to ensure the conservation of ground water resources, the proper exploitation of the resources, control damage to the resources, and put in place an information system that facilitates the achievement of the above directives.
This will require additional Government Regulations to be issued to further stipulate the management policy.
Water basins, once identified, are to be confirmed in Presidential Decrees. This presupposes that there will need to be an inventory taken to determine available ground water resources. The criteria and procedures are contained in Articles 8 – 12 of this Regulation.
Management of Ground Water Resources
The basic premise of ground water resources management is to achieve balance between the need for conservation and the need for exploitation of the available water resources. In order to achieve this balance the Regulation provides for planning and inventories to be undertaken to ensure the objectives are met.
Planning
The planning component cannot be viewed independently from the taking of a water resources inventory. The planning component relies on the inventory of ground water resources as a means of determining areas that will become areas of water conservation.
Inventory
The inventory process requires that data and information be compiled that shows the quantity and quality of the ground water resources, the condition of the surrounding environment and the potential of that environment, water basins and any infrastructure, and the social economic conditions of the community that is connected to the ground water resources.
This inventory data will then be used to confirm conservation zones. These zones will then be noted as protected zones on all maps. However, any further legislation required on conservation zones will be in the form of a Ministerial Regulation.
Monitoring and Evaluation
The primary purpose of the monitoring and evaluation provisions is to ensure the suitability of the original ground water resources management plan and the subsequent implementation of that plan. And where the plan or the implementation is deficient, then adjustments can be made to ensure that the desired outcomes are achieved.
Monitoring is simply all activities that are related to the observation, documentation, recording, report examination, and direct review of the ground water resources themselves.
Evaluation is the analysis and assessment of the data and information that has been obtained during the monitoring phase.
Licensing
To obtain a license to use or exploit the ground water the applicant is required to submit a written application to either the Regent or the Mayor. This application is to be carbon copied to the Minister and the Governor.
The application must clearly set out the reason behind the need to use or exploit the ground water, any plans to bore or dig for ground water, and the requisite environmental impact, monitoring, and management statements.
The actual time frame for the issue of a license will be stipulated in an additional Ministerial Regulation. Nevertheless, once a license is issued it will be valid for a period of 3 years. This period can be extended.
Ground Water Information System
The Ground Water Information System is to be designed as a mechanism to assist in the management of ground water. Essentially, the information system is a centralized data management system that is to correlate all water resources information on a national, regional, district, and city level.
The data and information that will be correlated in this system includes, among others:
· configuration of existing water basins;
· hydro-geology;
· water resources potential;
· conservation;
· exploitation;
· condition or the water resources;
· control and supervision; and
· cultural, social, and economic, activities of the communities that are connected to the water resources.
Sanctions
The sanctions are administrative in nature and as a result include:
· written warnings;
· suspension of business activities; and
· cancellation of any licenses issued.
Closing Provisions
With the enactment of this Regulation, Government Regulation No. 22 of 1982 has been repealed. However, all implementing regulations that derive their legal authority from Regulation No. 22 remain in force so far as they do not conflict with provisions in the new Regulation.
Conclusion
It is clear that this is a Regulation that is long overdue. The delay has meant that the regulatory framework needed to prevent the pillaging of what are limited ground water reserves has meant that the original purpose of the law has not been implemented as it should have been. Although this is a national piece of legislation it is clear on a much more local front, Jakarta, the delay has served to exacerbate the problems of Indonesia’s capital city.
It is expected that the Regulation will provide a much more comprehensive regulatory framework that allows for a complete inventory of ground water resources to be taken and an appropriate ground water management policy to be formulated.
Ground water users should expect to pay more for their ground water usage in the future.
......