The Supreme Court (Mahkamah Agung / MA) has handed down a cassation decision that came on appeal from the Central Jakarta District Commercial Court involving the registration of the trade mark “Tasbih”. Tasbih was a specialized banking product that was to be used to secure savings and deposits that were destined to fund the Haj pilgrimage of those individuals depositing into the Tasbih accounts.
The registration of the mark was made by H. Elon Dachlan on behalf of Bank Surya. Bank Surya has since been liquidated and consequently is no longer in a position to offer banking services. The mark has since been used by PT. Banl Pembangunan Daerah Sumatera Selatan (South Sumateran Regional Development Bank / Bank Sumsel). Bank Sumsel has been successful in promoting this product and has managed to secure funds in excess of IDR 23 billion. Dachlan then sort to recover some of this money as money owed to him as the holder of the mark.
However, the Commercial Court did not find in his favor and Dachlan appealed to the MA. The MA has held in its decision that Dachlan has not evidenced that there was no law or factual errors, there were no errors in the application of the law, and the additional evidence was not of a kind that could be considered by the MA in a cassation matter.
Therefore, the MA rejected the grounds of the appeal and issued an order for costs against Dachlan.
The decision was handed down on 31 March 2008.
......