Revision of the Intellectual Property Laws - Trademarks

Overview

The Directorate General of Intellectual Property Rights has prepared four draft Bills for Copyright, Patent, Mark, and Industrial Design as each of the current laws are considered to be no longer suitable for the purposes that they were originally enacted. The Directorate General has also been active in preparing a number of new pieces of legislation aimed at protecting Indonesia's rich cultural and traditional heritage.

 

Some of this legislation has become increasingly important after a number of recent spats with the Malaysian government over who has copyright in traditional Melayu songs and other creative expression. It is expected that this urgency will drive this legislation through parliament.

 

It is not expected that many members of the House of Representatives (DPR) are going to run the risk of sitting on this legislation. The simple reason for this is that the rhetoric that arose in the aftermath of the recent spat with Malaysia was quite nationalistic in nature and there was significant media play that suggested that there is a real risk that Malaysia will calmly and surely claim aspects of Melayu culture that Indonesians might justifiably claim originated within the borders of Indonesia and are significant parts of Indonesia's cultural and traditional heritage.

 

It is therefore expected that the majority of this Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) will pass relatively easily. But, this assumes that no intractable issues arise during the deliberation phase. As the recent Electoral Bill highlights special interests can override any general agreement that revisions or amendments are needed and consequently delay the passage of the bill.

 

The Marks Bill

The Bill on Marks, as it includes both trade and service marks, is now publicly available and it is best described as a working draft. The current draft is in effect primarily a reworking of the current legislation through reorganization of the various provisions into more relevant sections of the proposed law.

 

Nevertheless, the Articles that are no longer reflective or appropriate in terms of current developments in the field have been 'perfected'. The version attached to this ILD includes where the various Articles originated from in the current Law and includes notes where the relevant provisions are subject to further discussion or perfection. Therefore, this ILD will focus only on those provisions that are to be amended or that are noted as being subject to further discussion.

 

Three Dimensional Marks

Traditionally, marks have been registered presumably on the assumption that the mark is two dimensional. However, in the bill it is clear that a distinction is to be made between two and three dimensional marks. In the current Law on Marks (Law No. 15 of 2001) there is no mention of three dimensional marks. However, in the bill there is clear and specific reference to three dimensional marks and a note that these are to be included in other Articles of the bill. Unfortunately, any explicit further elaboration on three dimensional marks is not included.

 

Generally, a mark remains any sign in picture, name, word, letters, combination of colors, or any combination of the forms above that possess distinguishing features and are used in trade or the provision of services.

 

Announcement of Applications

This is the current Part Two of the Law. This part has now been moved and becomes Part Five in Chapter III of the bill. Article 16 in the bill is Article 21 of the Law and it has been amended to state that announcements of applications are to be made within 30 days in the Official Gazette of Marks. Currently this announcement is to be made within 10 days.

 

Rejected Marks

Chapter IV deals with the Registration of Marks. Part Three of this Chapter sets out the provisions for the rejection of a mark and some of these Articles have been perfected to amend the time frames for rejection and also to add additional clarification regarding the process.

 

Article 23 (current Article 18 of the Law) has been amended to clarify that the 30-day period for the Directorate General to conduct the substantive examination of the mark commences after the period to lodge any objection to the mark has expired and no objections have been received.

 

Finally, the period of time permitted to conduct this examination is to be reduced from nine months to six months.

 

Licensing

Articles 48 and 49 of the bill (Articles 47 and 48 of the Law) are currently in the same form as they are stated in the Law. However, the working draft clearly notes that these provisions are subject to further study and review. Unfortunately, the draft provides no insight as to what needs to the further studied or reviewed. Article 48 seems to be self-explanatory in dealing with the reasons for rejecting a licensing agreement. Similarly, Article 49 deals with, among others, royalty payments and in this regard also seems selfexplanatory.

 

Madrid Protocol

The bill permits for marks to be applied for through the use of the Madrid Protocol. However, the actual procedures and mechanisms for this are to be further regulated in a Government Regulation.

 

Geographical Indicators

The 'perfections' of the provisions in the section on geographical indicators are generally a re-ordering of the provisions and the separation of specific issues into independent Articles.

 

For example, Article 58 of the bill deals with issues relating to the sphere of application as it relates to geographical indicators, which is the current Article 56 of the Law. However, Article 56 also dealt with reasons why a geographical indicator was to be rejected by the Directorate General. These provisions have now been spun-off into a separate Article, namely: Article 59.

 

The current Law contains only limited provisions on geographical indicators. The majority of the regulatory framework with regard to geographical indicators is contained in Government Regulation No. 51 of 2007 on Geographical Indicators. Many of these provisions are being incorporated into the bill.

 

The bill contains provisions on the work of the Geographical Indicators Commission that is tasked primarily with providing considerations and recommendations to the Directorate General with regards to matters such as the registration, rejection, amendment, cancellation, and / or the supervision of national geographic indicators.

 

Sanctions

The bill now includes sanctions of up to seven years imprisonment and IDR 1.5 billion in fines. This constitutes a significant increase on the current provisions which provide for maximum prison sentences of five years and fines of up to IDR 1 billion.

 

Transitional and Closing Provisions

All of the implementing regulations that have been issued under the provisions of the current Law are to remain in force in so far as they do not conflict with the provisions of the bill (once it is passed into law).

 

All mark applications that are in process at the time of enactment of the bill are to be dealt with under the provisions of the law at the time the application was lodged.

 

Once enacted this bill will repeal and replace Law No. 15 of 2001.

 

Conclusion

There are some important amendments in this bill such as the incorporation of provisions providing greater clarity on the procedures and mechanisms as they relate to geographical indicators.

 

Furthermore, the incorporation of recognition of filings made pursuant to the Madrid Protocol, although to be further regulated, in effect is designed to facilitate greater protections being afforded to international marks. Combined with stiffer penalties for breach of the provisions is an indication that the government is intending to take a much more serious approach to the violation of IPR in Indonesia.

 

As was noted earlier it is expected that the deliberation process will focus on ensuring that the provisions are complete and that the objective will be to pass this legislation quickly.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku

Overview

The Directorate General of Intellectual Property Rights has prepared four draft Bills for Copyright, Patent, Mark, and Industrial Design as each of the current laws are considered to be no longer suitable for the purposes that they were originally enacted. The Directorate General has also been active in preparing a number of new pieces of legislation aimed at protecting Indonesia's rich cultural and traditional heritage.

 

Some of this legislation has become increasingly important after a number of recent spats with the Malaysian government over who has copyright in traditional Melayu songs and other creative expression. It is expected that this urgency will drive this legislation through parliament.

 

It is not expected that many members of the House of Representatives (DPR) are going to run the risk of sitting on this legislation. The simple reason for this is that the rhetoric that arose in the aftermath of the recent spat with Malaysia was quite nationalistic in nature and there was significant media play that suggested that there is a real risk that Malaysia will calmly and surely claim aspects of Melayu culture that Indonesians might justifiably claim originated within the borders of Indonesia and are significant parts of Indonesia's cultural and traditional heritage.

 

It is therefore expected that the majority of this Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) will pass relatively easily. But, this assumes that no intractable issues arise during the deliberation phase. As the recent Electoral Bill highlights special interests can override any general agreement that revisions or amendments are needed and consequently delay the passage of the bill.

 

The Marks Bill

The Bill on Marks, as it includes both trade and service marks, is now publicly available and it is best described as a working draft. The current draft is in effect primarily a reworking of the current legislation through reorganization of the various provisions into more relevant sections of the proposed law.

 

Nevertheless, the Articles that are no longer reflective or appropriate in terms of current developments in the field have been 'perfected'. The version attached to this ILD includes where the various Articles originated from in the current Law and includes notes where the relevant provisions are subject to further discussion or perfection. Therefore, this ILD will focus only on those provisions that are to be amended or that are noted as being subject to further discussion.

 

Three Dimensional Marks

Traditionally, marks have been registered presumably on the assumption that the mark is two dimensional. However, in the bill it is clear that a distinction is to be made between two and three dimensional marks. In the current Law on Marks (Law No. 15 of 2001) there is no mention of three dimensional marks. However, in the bill there is clear and specific reference to three dimensional marks and a note that these are to be included in other Articles of the bill. Unfortunately, any explicit further elaboration on three dimensional marks is not included.

 

Generally, a mark remains any sign in picture, name, word, letters, combination of colors, or any combination of the forms above that possess distinguishing features and are used in trade or the provision of services.

 

Announcement of Applications

This is the current Part Two of the Law. This part has now been moved and becomes Part Five in Chapter III of the bill. Article 16 in the bill is Article 21 of the Law and it has been amended to state that announcements of applications are to be made within 30 days in the Official Gazette of Marks. Currently this announcement is to be made within 10 days.

 

Rejected Marks

Chapter IV deals with the Registration of Marks. Part Three of this Chapter sets out the provisions for the rejection of a mark and some of these Articles have been perfected to amend the time frames for rejection and also to add additional clarification regarding the process.

 

Article 23 (current Article 18 of the Law) has been amended to clarify that the 30-day period for the Directorate General to conduct the substantive examination of the mark commences after the period to lodge any objection to the mark has expired and no objections have been received.

 

Finally, the period of time permitted to conduct this examination is to be reduced from nine months to six months.

 

Licensing

Articles 48 and 49 of the bill (Articles 47 and 48 of the Law) are currently in the same form as they are stated in the Law. However, the working draft clearly notes that these provisions are subject to further study and review. Unfortunately, the draft provides no insight as to what needs to the further studied or reviewed. Article 48 seems to be self-explanatory in dealing with the reasons for rejecting a licensing agreement. Similarly, Article 49 deals with, among others, royalty payments and in this regard also seems selfexplanatory.

 

Madrid Protocol

The bill permits for marks to be applied for through the use of the Madrid Protocol. However, the actual procedures and mechanisms for this are to be further regulated in a Government Regulation.

 

Geographical Indicators

The 'perfections' of the provisions in the section on geographical indicators are generally a re-ordering of the provisions and the separation of specific issues into independent Articles.

 

For example, Article 58 of the bill deals with issues relating to the sphere of application as it relates to geographical indicators, which is the current Article 56 of the Law. However, Article 56 also dealt with reasons why a geographical indicator was to be rejected by the Directorate General. These provisions have now been spun-off into a separate Article, namely: Article 59.

 

The current Law contains only limited provisions on geographical indicators. The majority of the regulatory framework with regard to geographical indicators is contained in Government Regulation No. 51 of 2007 on Geographical Indicators. Many of these provisions are being incorporated into the bill.

 

The bill contains provisions on the work of the Geographical Indicators Commission that is tasked primarily with providing considerations and recommendations to the Directorate General with regards to matters such as the registration, rejection, amendment, cancellation, and / or the supervision of national geographic indicators.

 

Sanctions

The bill now includes sanctions of up to seven years imprisonment and IDR 1.5 billion in fines. This constitutes a significant increase on the current provisions which provide for maximum prison sentences of five years and fines of up to IDR 1 billion.

 

Transitional and Closing Provisions

All of the implementing regulations that have been issued under the provisions of the current Law are to remain in force in so far as they do not conflict with the provisions of the bill (once it is passed into law).

 

All mark applications that are in process at the time of enactment of the bill are to be dealt with under the provisions of the law at the time the application was lodged.

 

Once enacted this bill will repeal and replace Law No. 15 of 2001.

 

Conclusion

There are some important amendments in this bill such as the incorporation of provisions providing greater clarity on the procedures and mechanisms as they relate to geographical indicators.

 

Furthermore, the incorporation of recognition of filings made pursuant to the Madrid Protocol, although to be further regulated, in effect is designed to facilitate greater protections being afforded to international marks. Combined with stiffer penalties for breach of the provisions is an indication that the government is intending to take a much more serious approach to the violation of IPR in Indonesia.

 

As was noted earlier it is expected that the deliberation process will focus on ensuring that the provisions are complete and that the objective will be to pass this legislation quickly.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku
2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info