Overview
The Government has regularly expressed a commitment to developing and implementing a regulatory and legal framework that will positively impact on Indonesia's ability to attract capital investment from both domestic and foreign sources. To this end there have been legislative developments with the enactment of a new Capital Investment Law, revisions to the Negative Investment List, an Interim Law on Free Trade and Port Zones, and now the Government is working on the Bill on Special Economic Zones.
The Bill on Special Economic Zones is part of the 2008 National Legislation Program (Program Legislasi Nasional / Prolegnas) and it is hoped that this bill will pass the House of Representatives (Dewan Perwakilan Rakyat / DPR) some time this year. To this end the Minister of Law and Human Rights has already met with the Legislative Agency of the DPR (Badan Legislasi DPR / Baleg DPR) and they have reached an 'in principal' agreement to try and complete passage of the bill this year through the DPR.
The basic premise of the bill is to attract investment. The Government believes that one of the best ways to attract investment is to provide areas that can be developed as 'special zones' that provide a high return on initial investment. To ensure that returns on investment are attractive and thereby ensuring that investments are made, the Government will offer special incentives and facilities to investors willing to part with some of their hard-earned money in a special economic zone.
Primarily these incentives and facilities will be in areas such as tax, customs, and employment. But it is expected that incentives and facilities in these areas will provide an investment environment that will permit rapid improvements and increases in industry, tourism, and trade. These improvements and increases will then form the basis of rapid economic growth and employment opportunities for the special economic zones.
Special Economic Zones
Special Economic Zones can be any one or combination of the following:
a. Export Processing Zone;
b. Bonded Warehousing Zone;
c. Industrial Zone;
d. Technology Development Zone;
e. Financial Services Zone; and
f. Other Economic Services Zone.
The (a), (d), (e), and (f) zones are to be created and established by the issue of a Government Regulation to that effect. There are several basic criteria a potential special economic zone must meet before it can be officially declared to be such, namely: the provincial, municipal, or city government must be capable of managing a special economic zone; that the special economic zone must be in accordance with any existing spatial plan and not be disruptive to the environment; the special economic zone must be strategically located and close to an international trade or shipping route; have some pre-existing infrastructure or the potential for infrastructure development; the availability of land; and possess a defined area.
The development of infrastructure can be undertaken from a number of funding sources. These sources include government funding, either Central or Regional; private; or public - private partnerships. The bill is clear that before a public - private partnership can be commenced there must be a feasibility analysis undertaken to determine whether the proposed partnership is sustainable.
The process confirming a special economic zone relies heavily on the Special Economic Zone National Authority (Dewan Nasional / DN). A special economic zone that fulfills the criteria noted above may be confirmed, amended, or rejected by the DN.
In addition to the criteria the recommendation must include:
· a map of the location and the size of the area;
· the type of special economic zone (multi-product, sole product, or services);
· statement of fulfillment of basic criteria;
· spatial plan for the proposed special economic zone;
· economic and financial feasibility study (investment, export, and labor targets);
· plan for funding sources;
· environmental impact studies; and
· recommendations from the relevant municipal / city government and from the provincial government.
Where a recommendation for a special economic zone is confirmed by the DN, then this zone must be operational within three years of the confirmation being announced.
However, if within this three-year period the special economic zone has not met or fulfilled the requirements then an application for an extension of time or an amendment to the confirmation may be requested. If the original applicant is not able to fulfill the requirements then the DN can appoint another entity to take over the management and administration of the special economic zone in accordance with prevailing laws and regulations.
Special Economic Zones - Institutions
The bill creates three distinct levels of authority in the administration and management of special economic zones, namely: The DN, the Zone Authority, and the Business Authority.
National Authority
The National Authority is to be chaired by the Minister responsible for the Government's economic affairs and is to have a membership comprising of Ministers and the Heads of both Government and Non-Government agencies. The DN answers directly to the President. The exact membership and the work procedures for the DN are to be contained in a Presidential Regulation (Peraturan Presiden / Perpres).
The primary functions of the DN are to undertake an analysis of areas recommended to become special economic zones. Then based on this analysis the DN will provide recommendations on the suitability of the proposed area to be classified as a special economic zone. Furthermore, the DN will provide policy and strategic mechanisms to expedite the creation of special economic zones. Finally, the DN will have responsibility in resolving problems that arise with regard to implementation of management and development policy for special economic zones.
Zone Authority
The Zone Authority (Dewan Kawasan / DK) is to be established through Presidential Decree (Keputusan Presiden / Keppres) based on a recommendation from the DN. The DK are to be established in every province where a special economic zone is established.
The membership of the DK is to originate from recommendations provided by both the Government and professional organizations. Any further provisions required with regard to the DK are to be in the form of Perpres.
The functions of the DK are to formulate and determine policy in the management of special economic zones within the framework of the general policy stipulated by the DN. The DK is also responsible for coordinating the activities of the Business Authority and the supervision and evaluation of activities within the special economic zone. Furthermore, the DK is to determine the strategic steps necessary to resolve any implementation problems relating to special economic zone activities within its jurisdiction. Finally, the DK must provide periodic and incidental reports to the DN.
Business Authority
The Business Authority (Badan Pengusahaan / BP) is to be established by the DK and a BP is to be established in every special economic zone. The BP is responsible to the DK and the composition and work procedures of the BP are to be stipulated by the DK.
In order to expedite the activities of the special economic zone the BP will be granted the authority to issue business and other licenses as required by entrepreneurs in the conduct of their respective businesses. Any delegation of authority is to be premised on the “one roof” system to ensure quality services.
Where the BP fails to perform its functions and duties or undertake activities counter to prevailing laws and regulations the DK can take control of the BP's functions for a period of 90 days. The DK at the end of the 90-day suspension the DK can dissolve the old BP and then establish a new BP.
The BP wherever possible is to be self-funded and may garner funds from the Central or Regional Government budgets. The financial management of the BP is to be to the standards of prevailing laws and regulations. This includes the annual auditing of BP books by a public accountant.
Movement of Goods and Quarantine
The prohibition against the movement of goods that are prohibited under Indonesian law or any international agreement are in effect in the special economic zones. However, goods that are subject to movement restrictions may still be moved into and out of special economic zones where the zone is an export processing zone of a bonded warehousing zone.
The prevailing laws and regulations in Indonesia with respect to the quarantining of people, animals, fish, and plants remain in force for special economic zones.
Facilities
As noted in the overview, the Government will provide facilities and incentives in order to encourage greater levels of capital investment into special economic zones. These facilities and incentives are to be in the areas of tax and customs, land, licensing, immigration, and investment.
Tax and Customs
For taxpayers that are limited liability companies or cooperatives who invest in special economic zones there are income tax facilities that can be taken advantage of. These facilities include, among others, reductions to net income; expedited depreciation and amortization schedules; 10% tax on dividends paid to foreign tax subjects or reduced tariffs based on any double taxation agreements that Indonesia is a party to; and compensation for losses beyond five years. Any additional regulations in this area are to be by way of Government Regulations.
Customs facilities on imported goods to a special economic zone will apply to value-added tax (VAT), Luxury Sales Goods Tax, and Article 22 income taxes. Exporters are also granted reductions in payable excise where the goods are process or manufactured in the special economic zone and destined for export.
Finally, special economic zones are to be granted regional tax and retribution incentives.
Land, Licensing, and Immigration
Land incentives specifically refer to the capital investment sector and particularly the Capital Investment Law (Law No. 25 of 2007) which provides for rights to land use for periods of up to 95 years.
Licensing is to be made easier through the provision of fiscal incentives for business, banking, capital, industry, trade, ports, and security activities.
The bill also provides for incentives and facilities in the immigration sector. These facilities seem likely to include self-contained immigration services within the special economic zone. Furthermore, there is an expectation that special rules will apply for investors with regards to provisions relating to membership of the Boards of Directors and Commissioners for foreigners.
The specifics of these facilities and incentives are to be contained in Ministerial Regulations.
Investment
The provision relating to investment facilities is a mere single sentence and simply states that regulations concerning business sectors closed to investment are not in force in special economic zones. This means that the recently enacted Perpres No. 111 of 2007 on the Negative Investment List will not be in force in special economic zones.
However, it remains to be seen whether this provision remains in the bill as it is likely to encounter opposition despite the good intention. The rationale is that opening up all sectors to investment must result in a corresponding increase in the total amount of investments made.
Nevertheless, this is good news for potential investors in sectors that are currently closed totally to all investment, assuming these sectors are opened too. Yet, the opposition is likely to arise from domestic capital investors who stand in line to lose exclusive access to the sectors that are closed only to foreign investment, which presumably would become an investment free-for-all under the current formulation of Article 28 in the bill.
Industrial Relations Issues
The bill is explicit that a tripartite body is to be established with representatives from the Government, unions, and businesses. The tripartite body is tasked with the duties or providing a forum for communication and consultation to overcome employment issues and to detect potential labor problems and head them off before they become real issues.
Interestingly, the bill is explicit that for the purposes of representing labor interests and aspirations only one labor union may be established and that membership is voluntary. This provision is also likely to encounter plenty of opposition from labor organizations as the mandating of a single union seems to run counter to the idea of freedom of association.
The bill also provides for the establishment of a Special Economic Zone Wage Council. The functions of the Wage Council are the same as those for all other regions. The Wage Council provides a forum to discuss wage related issues and to provide inputs with respect to the setting of wage levels.
Transitional Provisions
For Bonded Warehousing Zones and Industrial Zones in existence before this bill is enacted into law and that are subsequently anointed as a special economic zone then there is a three-year grace period for those zones to come into compliance with the provisions of this bill.
Conclusion
The bill is a clear acknowledgement by the Government that it can better exploit its vast archipelagic nature through the creation and establishment of special economic zones. One of the primary concerns of investors has always been legal certainty and this bill certainly endeavors to provide enhanced legal certainty. However, as is the case with most of Indonesia's primary legislation it is general and relies heavily on subsidiary regulations to give effect to many of its provisions. Therefore, any delay in the subsidiary or implementing legislation will result in a reduction of the goals that the bill sets for itself.
The bill is not problem free and there a number of issues that are likely to be subject to considerable debate, a number of which were noted. Particularly relevant are the provisions relating to the Negative Investment List and industrial relations. Both of these issues will also have a large impact on whether the bill not only passes the DPR but once it passes whether it can be successfully implemented.
Simply, aside from providing an improved and increased level of investment opportunity there will also be an immediate need for human resources and consequently there needs to be a fair and workable labor regime in place within the primary and subsidiary legislation.
The expectation is that the bill will pass in 2008. However, this is dependent on the amount of time required to work through any issues that arise during the Commission process.
......