Overview
The Bill on State Secrets has been bouncing around for many years now with drafts coming and going intermittently. However, it has finally made its way from Commission I on Foreign Affairs, Defense, and Information of the House of Representatives (DPR) to the Department of Law and Human Rights.
The Bill is now expected to undergo a series of consultations to solicit both government and public opinion to the current draft of the Bill and once this is complete the Bill is then expected to be returned to the DPR for public hearings to be scheduled. The reality is that the Bill is so problematic that Commission I commenced secret deliberations on the Bill and when news of these deliberations became public knowledge the deliberations were put on ice.
It is the eternal optimist that envisages that this Bill is likely to pass the DPR in the near future. It is expected that there will be a very long list of issues in the problem inventory (Daftar Inventarisasi Masalah / DIM) to the Bill, which will require substantial time to complete. The Bill is not expected to pass this parliamentary term. It must be noted that the Bill has been subject to considerable debate to date and it is expected that this intensity will not subside in the near future.
The primary issue of concern is the broadness of the information that conceivably can be restricted in the name of state security and the national interest. Much of the Bill will be in conflict with other draft legislation that seeks to broaden access to information through the development of freedom of information ideals. A classic of diametrically opposed legislation destined to be subject to multiple judicial reviews as Articles are tested individually for their constitutional validity, assuming that these problems ever make it through the house.
There are similar problems with the Freedom of Information Bill where the government is insisting on the inclusion of criminal sanctions for the misuse of information provided under the provisions of the Bill. This insistence seems to be specifically targeting journalists and other investigators seeking to expose issues.
It is this contradiction in terms that is most likely to hinder the passage of both these Bills; State Secrets and Freedom of Information, as one seems intent on exemption rather than disclosure and the other seems intent on disclosure instead of exemption. It appears that the government will lobby hard that there are greater numbers of exemptions to the information that may be disclosed. This will hopefully put them into direct conflict with civil society which is likely to lobby equally hard for the idea that greater levels of democracy will be achieved with greater public access to information. It would seem business will be caught somewhere in the middle.
The Issues
Underlying Premise
The underlying premise of the Bill is to impose significant restrictions on information that may become available to the public by classifying this information as either 'secret' or 'top secret'. The basic elements of making a decision whether information will be given one of these classifications is what impact the release of the information would have on State sovereignty, the unity of the Republic, and public safety in the law and order sense. The language of the Bill is particularly nationalistic and refers to the protection of the motherland, and the prosperity and access to social justice for citizens. Although this is expected in a Bill of this nature there are many citizens already questioning whether the Bill is in fact in their respective best interests.
The Bill acknowledges that citizens have a right to access information but it goes on to say that this is not an unfettered right and that the State has a greater obligation based on what would seem an obligation to protect Indonesians from themselves. It would seem that broad access to information will lead to a dramatic increase in the misuse and abuse of information and this will have a significant negative impact on the administration of the State and the maintenance of sovereignty.
State Secrets
The definition of a State secret is overly broad and the passage of a definition as expansive as this one will ensure that the government has very broad discretion on the interpretation of information that it can classify as secret or top secret. This is problematic because without a clear and precise definition people that are in possession of information and use it are then conceivably liable to the stiff penalties that the Bill seeks to see imposed.
What makes the definition problematic is that information relating to public order can be classified and this is likely to be used by the central and regional governments as well as other government agencies and institutions to block access to administrative decisions information and data on State and Regional Owned Enterprises (Badan Usaha Milik Negara / BUMN and Badan Usaha Milik Daerah / BUMD). Therefore, it is altogether possible that officials will rely on this Bill should it pass into law as a means of obscuring administrative actions that may be controversial or subject to criticism in the event that they were to become public available under freedom of information.
Article 4 implies that the scope of the information, assets, and activities are limited to matters related to national defense and security, foreign affairs, law enforcement processes, maintenance of the national economy, State codes, national intelligence, and the security of vital assets. Nevertheless, although this appears to be a restrictive list the scope is considerably broad as a result of the generalness of the terms. For example, maintenance of the national economy can include just about any administrative action undertaken by an official at the central or regional government level.
Extra-Territoriality
Article 2 of the Bill stipulates that the Law is to apply to all persons either Indonesian or foreign that commit a criminal offence in the use of State secrets even where this offence is committed outside of Indonesia. The Elucidation to the Article only states that the Article is self-explanatory. Unfortunately, this leaves exactly how Indonesia intends to enforce its criminal jurisdiction outside of the territorial sovereignty of the Republic.
Consequently, there will be a need to put in place subsidiary agreements with other States to facilitate the respect for the provisions of the Bill but it is unlikely that these bilateral agreements will be easy to negotiate as the Bill seeks to criminalize a great deal of information that would be subject to freedom of information in most other jurisdictions.
Top Secret v. Secret
Top secret is the most secret of the classifications and is reserved for information that if released or obtained by an unauthorized party there is a risk that this information has the power to endanger national sovereignty, territorial integrity, and / or the safety of the nation. This information is to remain top secret and classified for a period of thirty years.
In contrast, secret is reserved for information that if obtained by an unauthorized party has the potential to interfere with the administration of the State, national resources, and / or public order. Secret information is to remain classified for a period of twenty years.
However, the Bill does also provide for lower categories of classification such as information at the government agency level, which is to be classified as confidential. Confidential information is to retain its confidentiality status for a period of five years.
State Secrets Council
The Bill creates a State Secrets Council. The State Secrets Council reports directly to the President and the Chairperson of the Council is the Minister of Defense and includes the Ministers of Home Affairs, Foreign Affairs, Law and Human Rights, Communication and Information, Attorney General, the Chiefs of the Armed Forces and Police, and the Head of the National Archives, among others.
The primary function of the Council is to formulate policy relating to State secrets.
The Council must be established no later than 12 months after the enactment of the Bill into Law.
Evidence
The evidence that may be adduced in court for the purposes of a prosecution has been expanded beyond what is permitted in the Criminal Procedure Code to include electronic evidence. This is a common-sense approach considering that the most likely means of communicating State secrets in this age of technology is by electronic means.
Criminal Sanctions
The criminal sanctions for breach of the provisions of the Bill are severe with fines of up to IDR 100 billion and terms of imprisonment up to life. The draconian nature of the applicable punishments means that any one thinking of using information that may be classified as either top secret or secret must be certain of their conviction in using that information because the threat of fines and imprisonment are not for the faint of heart.
Conclusion
The problematic nature of this Bill and the numerous conflicts between this Bill and the Bill on Freedom of Information means that the process to enactment is destined to be long and complicated.
......