The Constitutional Court has handed down its decision in the judicial review of the Capital Investment Law (Law No. 25 of 2007). The decision was reached on 17 March 2008 and read out in open court on 25 March 2008. The reading of the decision took more than four hours to complete.
The decision includes a Concurring Opinion and a Dissenting Opinion. The Court's decision grants part of the petition of the applicants as it relates to the phrase “sekaligus di muka ” which means the application for the various land use permits can be submitted 'one time upfront' for both the initial permit and an extension.
The decision runs to 285 pages however the essence of the decision is that with regards to Article 22(1), (2), and (4) are constitutionally invalid in so far as the use of the term “sekaligus di muka ” or “di muka sekaligus ” and therefore are not binding at law.
The use of this phrase meant that investors who were applying for various land use permits were able to obtain a permit for the total amount of time allowable through one application. However, it is clear for instance that the provisions for the 'right to use' land (Hak Pakai) allow for this type of permit to be issued for a period of 70 years. However, this is broken down into an initial period of 45 years and then an application to extend the permit must be submitted and where approved an additional 25-year period is granted.
However, the phrases, “sekaligus di muka ” and “di muka sekaligus”, that are contained in Article 22(1), (2), and (4) mean that the application for the initial period and the extension can be granted based on the one initial application that is submitted upfront. This is contrary to the intent of Article 33 of the 1945 Constitution and is also in conflict with other prevailing laws and regulations, specifically the Agrarian Law (Law No. 5 of 1960).
......